14 Dumbest Things In Star Trek Nemesis
Nemesis is often considered the worst Next Generation film, but it's not just bad, it's dumb.
Commonly criticized for being little more than an inflated two-part TV episode, Star Trek Insurrection failed to excite critics or make a dent at the box office. Given this, fans could be forgiven for hoping for the best when it was announced that Oscar-nominated editor turned director Stuart Baird was to helm the next film from a script by one of the Oscar-nominated writers of Ridley Scott’s Gladiator: John Logan.
Sadly for audiences and the franchise, the result was Star Trek Nemesis, a joyless dud with uninspired direction and a script barely better than fan fiction. The film was met with a series low at the box office and a collective shrug from most critics. As a result, Star Trek, once a crown jewel of Paramount, would disappear from movie theaters for seven years.
But just what was wrong with the script, beyond its poor characterization, unfocused plot, ham-fisted twins theme, and wall-to-wall illogic? You guessed it — or the title gave it away — it’s one of the dumbest Star Trek movies ever. How dumb? Let me count the ways.
14. B-4 Contrivances
Everything about Data’s double, B-4, is utter rubbish. The degree of contrivance employed is mind-boggling. The audience is expected to believe:
1) Shinzon’s minions (now there’s a title) conveniently “found” (his word) a Soong-built android that looks identical to a trusted officer of Picard’s and 2) despite having no similar positronic technology, modify it, then 3) drop it in pieces on some remote planet that Shinzon somehow knows the Enterprise will be within range to detect while en-route from the Riker-Troi wedding to planet Betazed, and 4) that nobody will be suspicious that this deactivated and disassembled twin is transmitting positronic signatures that stay on when disassembled, then 5) is certain not only that the Enterprise will detect it, but divert to track it down, and 6) assume that they’re going to assemble this unknown right away and that they’ll trust it enough for it to be used for subterfuge.
Finally, 7) Shinzon’s counting on Starfleet to send Picard specifically to Romulus. Mind you, cameo Janeway doesn’t indicate that Picard or the Enterprise was requested for, so Shinzon’s assuming all his machinations will get Starfleet to do exactly what he wants. Any one of these would be far-fetched, but to pile them on this deep is to insult the intelligence of the audience.
13. Remans In The Twilight Zone
Presented for your consideration. Aliens who look like the titular creature from Nosteratu, fangs included, and who shrink from bright light.
A point is made that the Remans are creatures of darkness who are highly sensitive to light. As such, their ship interiors are dimly lit. Yet this apparently provides them with zero tactical advantage even on their home turf, as Picard easily outguns them both when escaping from and reboarding their kill-o-zap spaceship, the Scimitar.
Later, when the Reman Viceroy and his goons board the Enterprise, the for-whatever-reason-the-lights-are-at-Reman-ready-10-watts on Deck 29 similarly affords them no advantage whatsoever. Riker knows they dislike bright lights, so why not try calling for it even if it ends up the ship’s damage won’t allow it? Did no one think to bring bright lights? Flashbulbs? Flares? Also, shouldn’t the battle-hardened Remans know that Federation ships are usually as brightly lit at a hotel? Why don’t they come aboard wearing photo-adaptive sunglasses? The only concession to this bright light sensitivity is when Riker yanks some fiber optic cables loose and shines them in the Vicerory’s eyes, but that really doesn’t do much at all.
The problem, as usual, is they made up a plot point and — say it with me — immediately forgot about it.
12. The Dune Buggy Directive
The story technobabbles up a convenient reason (blah blah ion storm blah blah) the Enterprise crew can’t use the transporter to visit the planet where B-4 is found, so they go down by shuttle instead. The indigenous society is said to be composed of “isolated pockets of humanoids” and “an early industrial-age civilization.” The industrialization needed to manufacture motor vehicles and produce the fuels and lubricants necessary to run them requires an infrastructure of the sort “scattered pockets” would be unlikely to have.
What's missing from the equasion is a little thing called the Prime Directive. It’s never even alluded to. They’re risking cultural contamination on the pretext of a scavenger hunt. That Picard, Worf, and Data are aliens is bad enough, but the shuttle and dune buggy are clearly tech beyond the locals. So even though they don’t get caught, what are the locals to think they just saw?
Worse, the phaser cannon Worf employs in self-defense results in two pursuing vehicles ending in rollover crashes. So our heroes are likely causing injury or even death to the natives as part of their merry little field trip. How is that justifiable? How is any of this justifiable? This isn’t just violating the prime directive, it’s trampling it with cleats and grinding it into the dirt with their heels…or wheels.
11. Shinzon's Pathological Procrastination
Shinzon’s dying. That’s D Y I N G dead if he can’t suck the marrow out of Picard or whatever. At the top of the story he’s literally days from certain doom. So, what does he do once the Enterprise delivers Picard right to his doorstep? He dawdles. He waits SEVENTEEN FLIPPING HOURS before initiating contact.
Then, with the clock ticking, and with Picard onboard his Scimitar, Shinzon just has a chat with the captain and Senior staff and LETS PICARD GO BACK TO THE ENTERPRISE, only to have him back “tomorrow” for a tête-à-tête dinner (possibly upwards of a day!), and then LETS HIM GO AGAIN.
Only then, after much complaining on the part of his Viceroy, and being warned that he has literally run out the clock, does he finally consent to kidnapping Picard.
Sure, one expects a flair for the dramatic in a villain. But this is a flair for the idiotic.
10. Sensitive Data
Data’s “brother” B-4 claims to have no memories of his life before he was on the planet where the Enterprise found him. To help B-4 realize his potential, Data chooses to copy his memory engrams into him. He does this with Picard’s blessing, even as LaForge warns that B-4 would have all Data’s memories as well, adding, “Maybe he's not supposed to be like you, Data. Maybe he's supposed to be exactly the way he is.” Data’s rationalization, “That might be so, but I believe he should have the opportunity to explore his potential,” is troubling.
While that unilateral decision is questionable enough, what’s dumb is that both Data and Picard are okay with this memory copy at all. Data’s memories include personal interactions and information about his friends and colleagues they might not consent to share, and decades of memories about his Starfleet service, including metric tons of sensitive data about Starfleet, starships, and missions covert and otherwise. How’s that a good idea? And how could anyone think it was appropriate?
And, sure enough, B-4 accesses the ship’s computers to try to get information to assist in Shinzon’s evil plans. Could he have done this had not Picard approved this literal Data Dump?
LAFORGE: I still can't believe the Captain went along with a memory download.
Neither can we, Geordi. Neither. Can. We.
9. Violations
Related to Shinzon’s dawdling, rather than play coy to make sure Picard doesn’t smell a Womp Rat (whoops, wrong franchise) and raise shields or warp away, he mentally assaults Troi.
Okay, sure, he’s damaged goods in every way imaginable, but how does he think this is a good idea? Shinzon’s simultaneously trying to woo Picard and mentally violating one of his key aides? Does he think Picard’s not going to find out about this? He’s smart enough to stage this whole elaborate coup and yet stupid enough to risk it all because he finally sees a woman without pointed ears and bowl-cut.
And assuming he’s really that stupid, what about his Reman Viceroy, the one who enables the attack? Where’s the “Yo, Praetor, this is a really bad idea. It’s gonna show our hand and risk everything. Show some impulse control for a few minutes at least til — ya know — we’ve grabbed Picard and done the Nosferatu thing and bled him dry.”
And it could have been worse. As scripted, the violation happened just before Picard's dinner with Shinzon, and was followed by a second attack — filmed but deleted — right after the dinner.
8. Scorpion Silliness
When Picard and Data steal one of the “Scorpion-class attack fliers” from the Scimitar hangar, just how does Picard know the route through the ship that will take them to the one room with the big window perfect for escaping? Data’s been snooping around the Scimitar playing B-4, so sure, maybe he’s learned the layout, but there’s nothing in the film to suggest he’s backseat driving.
When the Enterprise rams the Scimitar later, it’s obvious the hangar is lower on the ship than the window through which the Scorpion escaped. Did it fly up some grand staircase we missed, or did it just take some giant turbolift?
Finally, about the Scorpion fliers, they’re yet another example of Trek movies introducing something for expediency but which factors into the story not one whit. You know what would’ve been a surprise? Introducing these earlier in the story — maybe escorting the Enterprise into orbit — so when Picard and Data find themselves desperate for a way off the ship, have them surprise us by absconding with one and flying through the ship to a place they can get out. Or, hey, have Data use it later to get back onto the Scimitar. Setup and payoff is something the TNG movies were absolutely crap at.
7. Targeted Transporters
So, just how is it that the Remans are able to lock onto and beam Picard over to their ship? It’s not like he’s on the bridge and yapping with them on the viewscreen, or wearing a homing beacon. He’s talking to Troi in sickbay when abducted, and there’s no indication the Viceroy is intruding into her mind to get a bearing. Is it just that easy to pinpoint a specific human on the Enterprise? Does the Scimitar possess sensors that can differentiate individuals on another ship based on DNA or something? If so, how does the Enterprise crew not detect such invasion snooping?
And how does the single-use transporter used to save Picard's bacon a the climax know to deposit Picard on the Enterprise bridge in a spot clear of any obstructions or passing crew?
These movies are full of this stuff, where events happen because they’re convenient and capabilities are established in one scene and immediately forgotten in another. Dumb da dumb dumb.
6. The Earth-Centric Universe
Shinzon’s very existence, his ticking down lifeclock (he might as well have a red crystal in his palm a la Logan’s Run), and all the pain and suffering he’s endured was the doing of the Romulans. So, once he stages and coup, seizes power, and commands the baddest battle wagon around with its planet-killing Medusa Radiation, what does he reveal his master plan to be?
Attack Earth. Kill every living thing on it.
Why is it always the Earth? The Star Trek movies became obsessed with it. Earth is directly endangered in The Motion Picture, The Voyage Home, First Contact, and Star Trek 2009. Sure, V’ger originated from Earth, the whale probe is looking for missing Humpbacks, and the Borg are attempting a re-do of their first attempt on Earth. But Shinzon? What’s his motivation? The Romulans wrecked his life and practically ensured his death, but hey, who needs revenge on them when he can kill the planetary home of his unwitting DNA donor?
Yeah yeah… he’s this dumb movie’s dumb villain with dumb motivations.
5. Once More Into The Briar Patch
Okay, sure, admittedly the "Briar Patch" per se was in the previous movie. But here we have yet another mandatory space anomaly (a nebula by any other name smells just as cliché). This one’s a glowing green cloud thingus called the Bassen Rift, through which all long-range comms don’t work… but short-range comms are fine so all the local ships can yap with one another.
And, get this, the Enterprise — with the crew’s knowledge that Shinzon’s undetectable ship is likely right on their arse — flies directly into the damned thing. Did no one look for hazards en route? Even Data doesn’t think to caution against this, only realizing the danger at the moment they first have a comm flicker.
Why would the Starfleet ships assemble to support the Enterprise on the far side of this thing and just sit there as shown on the chart? Why wouldn’t they aim for a position where they could see beyond it, and have the Enterprise bear towards the same spot, so there’d be no chance of comm signal disruption? And why is it only when they enter the damned thing does this vulnerability conveniently come up?
4. Crash Test Dummy Shinzon
Picard’s decision to ram the Enterprise into the Scimitar only works because this is modern Star Trek, where ships always sit nose-to-nose despite transporters having ranges of tens of thousands of kilometers. Upon seeing what Picard is doing, what does ever-dawdling Shinzon order, and much too late? “Hard to port!” Only long after the crash does he have the presence of mind to order “Divert all power to engines! ...Full reverse.”
If he’d had the presence of mind to order full reverse the moment the Enterprise started its verrrrrrry sllllllloooooooowww ramming maneuver it’d have at least diminished the impact force, and maybe provided an opportunity for some evasive action.
Or, hey! What about launching all those armed Scorpion fliers and letting them try to damage the Enterprise’s impulse engines? Oh, wait, those only exist for Picard to steal one.
3. The Nuke On The Bridge
So, let’s see, this ginormous Scimitar badass ship is possessed of all sorts of overly complicated rotating and unfurling emitters and layered bat-wings for releasing this deadly Thaleron radiation, but the Tootsie Roll center of this space plutonium Tootsie Pop is in a compartment just off the bridge.
Not only is a critical doohickus of this turns-everyone-to-pumice Medusa Radiation within spitting distance of everyone in the main control room, but the most important dudes on the ship... like Praetor Shinzon. What possible sense does this make? Why is it anywhere near there, instead of buried at the core of the ship surrounded by shielding? Looking at the device, is there even a forcefield? As far as we can see, it’s unshielded by transparent aluminum, a see-through shower curtain, or even a peekaboo nightie. Shinzon's knife gets destroyed in it, but was that a shield or the energy itself?
An early draft of the script featured a different yet equally dumb premise: that multiple warp cores passed through the bridge. That's as logical as a nuclear reactor just off the bridge of a modern supercarrier.
2. Action Picard
After Picard is captured, he and Data fight to escape the Scimitar, with Picard doing most of the shooting. Again, at the climax, the script contrives to make Jean-Luc beam to the Scimitar, alone, an exercitus unius (a one-man army).
Surprise! Or, rather, no surprise. You didn’t really think the Dune Buggy scene fulfilled the Action Picard quotient for this film, did you? Of course not. Since Sir Patrick Stewart’s name is at the top of the cast list, Jean-Luc has to go in guns blazing.
It’s preposterous. A point is made that Remans have the reputation of being formidable warriors, used as assault troops in the most violent encounters. With that established you’d expect them to be tough opponents, but Action Picard just mows them down on their own home turf.
Furthermore, by the end, Picard is acting as irresponsibly as Shinzon. He lets it get personal when the lives of his entire crew are on the line, refusing to let Data go in his place. Data, who’s stronger, indefatigable, and knows the layout of the enemy ship, is more likely to succeed than anyone else.
Action Picard is dumb. He should be drummed out of the service. At least the dismal box office ensured he'd not appear in another movie.
1. Dumb-Way Trip
When Data first rescues Picard to prevent him from being bled out by Shinzon’s minions, he produces a heretofore unseen rabbit out of his hat: an itsy bitsy teeny weeny prototype Emergency Transport Unit capable of beaming one person. It’s not used then, but at the end of the film, he slaps this onto Picard and sends him back to the Enterprise while he gets himself blowed up real good.
Why does the Enterprise have such a prototype, and why just one? Is Geordi just so good that he invented something so useful yet Starfleet’s R&D never came up with such a thing? It’s just another tech thing invented to conveniently allow a specific story beat.
The book The Physics of Star Trek posited that the energy necessary to convert a light adult human being into energy would be equivalent to a hundred 1-megaton hydrogen bombs. Sure, we see phasers do this, but those weapons only have to do the disassembly, not project that energy stream to another place along with all the information for reassembling it, and, you know, actually reassemble it.
When Picard arrives on the Enterprise bridge the gizmo is still stuck to his shirt, which means it beamed itself. How? Does it turn itself into energy and while in an energy state still functions to put both itself and Picard back together? It sure wasn’t the Enterprise transporters doing the reassembly, as Geordi said they went down the moment after he beamed Picard to the Scimitar.
The transporter has always been magic, but this is beyond the pale, even for it.