8 Ups & 2 Downs From Star Trek: Discovery 5.7 - Erigah
Star Trek goes big, green, and Breen; T'Rina translates a triumph; Betazoid brings a clue.
Before we get into what is my (second ever) Ups & Downs for the seventh episode of Star Trek: Discovery's fifth season, just a quick reminder that these are very much in addition to Seán's video each week. I won't put an Erigah on you if you start with that one, but I hope you remember to check out the article too!
I'd say season five just keeps getting better and better. Erigah continues on with the bold and thoroughly captivating storytelling, at times ramping up the tension to the loftiest of zeniths, accompanied by a truly majestic score, and then releasing it as only Star Trek can with round table discussion and diplomacy.
This season has also been historic for its highly creative and beautifully executed additions to Trek lore. Who thought going in that we'd be learning so much about the Breen? Not me, that's for sure, but I'm loving it, even as I am furiously noting every detail! In that, Erigah does not disappoint, telling us yet more about the Breen, whilst managing not to beat us over the (bucket) head about it.
Properly and to the point, Erigah's a lot to do with it in Erigah. When Uncle Ruhn and co. come knocking to claim the bounty on L'ak and Moll's heads and double face, a dramatic stand-off erupts between Breen forces on one side and the Federation on the other. All the while, Stamets, Tilly, and Adira must continue to work to solve the clue from tower five, as Culber gets a little chilly!
11. UP — The Good Fortune Of Barzan Badassery
As this season of Star Trek: Discovery edges inevitably towards its finale, we will have to find more and more reasons to console ourselves that it is the series' last. Filming on season five began nearly two years ago now. Then, in the interim of 2023, Discovery was cancelled, and additional scenes — a coda — were shot.
Aside from going out on a high (consolation number one), and getting the addendum (consolation number two), it does feel somehow like this season was always planned to be the last, even though it wasn't. As Discovery showrunner Michelle Paradise told a panel at the SXSW conference in Texas in March 2024 (via TrekCore),
We didn't have to go back and chop up episodes and change a bunch of things. […] I think people who don't know that we didn't know going in that it would be our last season will have no idea that we didn't know. I think it will have felt planned.
That is some sort of consolation (number three), or, as actress behind the Tilly-isms Mary Wiseman told Mick Joest at CinemaBlend, a "kind of kismet".
Such serendipity, like lightning (contrary to popular belief), can strike in the same place more than once. Commander Nhan, of Barzan badassery, only appeared in one episode of Discovery's fourth season (Rubicon). Discovery could have been cancelled, season five could have happened without her, and we might never have seen the character again.
It is our extra good fortune, therefore, that Nhan makes a re-appearance in Erigah, (re-)introduced with much merited visual theatricality as the camera pans over the Discovery and down through a window to reveal both she and Captain Burnham on a walk-and-talk, reminding us of similar camera moves in the season two episode Brother, as Burnham and Saru walk down a corridor to the transporter room where they meet Nhan for the first time.
Nhan also comes out swinging in Erigah — figuratively — at Book. The sardonic jibes fly. "Oh, lots of trust there!" Nhan retorts. "The last time I saw you, also a personal situation, you fired on Discovery […]." The Commander does have a point, and she expresses it gloriously! Book's attempt to see Moll (as she is about to be beamed in) was a little presumptuous! Later, the badass Barzan comes in most literally swinging in hand-to-hand combat with Moll.
10. UP — Breens' Gor-lore
"It's the whole faceless-helmet vibe. Truncheons. Jackboots. Where's the nuance?" ~ Commander Reno on the Breen
Well, Reno does have a point. The Breen are about as subtle as a Ferengi mating dance. No offense Nog! Nevertheless, nuance is exactly what we do get for the Breen in Erigah. Some of the finer detail about the species is finally revealed, and it is most definitely an UP! This episode was a veritable cornucopia of Breen — in number and lore.
Long back in the days of the Dominion War (from our 32nd century vantage point), it was a Thot named Gor who led the Breen side of the 'let's conquer the galaxy together' talks with the Female Changeling. Gor then became the face behind the mask of the Breen/Dominion alliance.
Gor and other Breen on Cardassia Prime were also famously the subject of conjecture by one Weyoun (8) and Damar in The Changing Face of Evil. The Breen homeworld wasn't a "frozen wasteland," contrary to popular belief, Weyoun conjectured. So, why did they wear "refrigeration suits"? asked Damar.
Breen biology still remains largely a mystery for Starfleet and the Federation in the 32nd century. What was that vital organ on L'ak's medical scans, for example? In Erigah, however, Doctor Culber did reveal a few fascinating fact from his investigations into the Dominion War era. For one, Culber confirmed that the Breen do indeed use "refrigeration units".
Reason being, as the Doctor went on to explain, was that "some evidence" showed that the Breen were "capable of somatic cell regeneration in extreme cold". Culber's subsequent sub-zero gas treatment for L'ak did, in fact, start to work, all by "[promoting] a strong immune response unique to the Breen".
That was a seriously clever solution to this particular Breen biological mystery. It neatly resolved, and merged, both sides of the decades- (and centuries-) long speculation into one. The Breen don't have to be cold, but the cold is beneficial to them. They're basically the ice bath champions of the galaxy!
9. UP — That's No Space Station…
… although it is practically a mini-moon. I'm a bit late to the May 4th mixed media franchise messages but live long and lightsabers or something!
In my article '10 Things We Now Know About The Breen,' I mistook the Breen locale of Moll's flashbacks in Mirrors to be a space station. In fact, it was a ship — one so absolutely ginormous, that, in Erigah, it cast an ominous, encompassing shadow over the corridors of Discovery as it warped into Federation HQ! This was a dreadnought, in Captain Burnham's words, "the most powerful warship class in the entire Breen Imperium".
In an interview for TrekMovie, Star Trek: Discovery season five writer/story editor Carlos Cisco confirmed the vessel's enormous proportions, and that we'd seen the space station imposter before,
Yep, that big honking thing next to Federation HQ [in Face the Strange] is the Breen ship. It's not a space station, it's a ship. […] This thing was just a behemoth. Like a Discovery-sized ship could fly into its shuttle bay.
An UP for sheer size and scale alone — go big, green, and Breen or go home! — but equally for the gorgeous visual effects. The Dreadnought simply dominated the screen in this episode, most notably towards the end in the eerie beauty of an exterior shot as four Federation ships warp in, only to pale into insignificance in the shadow of the Breen giant.
8. UP — Tilly-isms, Part Two
At the risk of sounding repetitive, although that is half the point, this is only my second ever Ups & Downs and already my second UP to Tilly and her -isms. The brilliant one-liners and Tilly brilliance more generally continue, however.
In last week's episode, Whistlespeak, Tilly was focused on the wellbeing of one of her students in particular; this week, in Erigah, her imperative is the protection of all her cadets from the Breen. With the Dreadnought on the way, Tilly, phaser in hand, sets off to Federation HQ before Commander Stamets stops her and convinces her to stay. Tilly's skills are needed aboard Discovery to help decipher the current clue from the aptly named Betazoid (Doctor MARINA [!] Derex). In general, it's also a great episode for Stamets this week. He plays the needed role of gentle reminder(er) of the importance of the main mission within all the Breen brouhaha.
A little later, and whilst we could have done without another mention of Adira's over-egged time bug woes — not your fault, let's move on — I couldn't help but appreciate the very Tilly-ness of the advice and encouragement she gives them as both work on the quandary of the Betazoid book: "You're really finding your way, and you shouldn't be afraid to take on more…," Tilly tells Adira. "You have it in you." Tilly really is a teacher through and through!!
We also got more 'hilariously sarcastic Tilly(-isms)' this week. Of particular note, towards the end of the CV conversation with Commander Reno:
Adira to Reno: "You really got around. Oh, not like that."
Reno: "Oh yeah! Like that!"
Tilly: "Well, story for another time."
Maybe that's what the coda is really all about!
7. UP — Reno's Résumé
When Adira asks Zora to scan through the personnel files to find anyone with expertise on ancient manuscripts to help with the latest Progenitors' clue, they are a bit surprised by the result. But of course, it's Jett Reno, the match for "rare and antiquarian bookseller" on the "curriculum vitae"! No further questions needed. Let's go find the Commander!
By her own admission, Reno's résumé has more padding than a Ferengi tax return, particularly regarding the bookseller gig. Nonetheless, back in those 23rd century days, Reno did, it seems, "move hard to find folios for a shady antiquarian archivist." "Try saying that one five times fast," Reno adds to Tilly and Adira in the corridor as she, ever the engineer, prepares Discovery for the imminent arrival of the Breen. Perhaps you can give that tongue twister another go, too, when you've had a few of Reno's "Seven of Limes"!!
Reno is and was already one of Star Trek(:Discovery)'s most delightfully colourful and engaging characters, although not without her own dose of tragedy in the loss of her wife during the Federation-Klingon War. You simply can't help but fall for Tig Notaro's deadpan comedic twists and turns in the role. The extra backstory for Reno in Erigah was as glorious as it was hilarious.
Her other odd jobs on the reams of résumé — to be taken, no doubt, with the same pinch of salt before a 'Seven of Lime' — were "VIP shuttle pilot," "deep mercury welder," and "bartender at a cosy little dive on Aschelan IV" (now there's an Easter egg! See: Cetacean Observations). Reno even joked (?) that she had a guest shift Red's Lounge aboard Discovery that very evening. Reno's conversation with Adira and Tilly is cut short by the very large Breen ship entering overhead, but not before she has provided them with some vital information towards solving the clue.
6. LATINUM UP — T'Rina's Terrific Diplomacy With(out) The Tribbles
Masterclass in writing, masterclass in diplomacy, masterclass in acting. No, I'm not being hyperbolic with the trifecta. It really was that good. In Erigah, President Rillak (who would have undoubtedly done just as fine a job) is away at a diplomatic summit on Tellar Prime, and so President T'Rina takes on negotiations with the Breen "in her stead". Don't be fooled by what you might have heard in the past! Vulcans, certainly this Vulcan, can bluff with the best of them!
I really cannot heap enough praise on the simply outstanding President T'Rina of Ni'Var this week, performed to perfection by Tara Rosling. Her one-liners alone deserve to go down with the greats of Star Trek history, and probably preserved for posterity in a diplomacy textbook or two. One of the best of the best was surely: "Do not equate a desire for understanding with a lack of nerve," as T'Rina quipped to a dubious Commander Rayner as they prepared for the Breen's arrival.
Vulcan or no, T'Rina's steadfast resolve when faced with a hoard of Breen in the round at Federation HQ (and their Dreadnaught looming outside) was a sight to behold. Primarch Ruhn's belligerent opening gambit was simply to insist, "There will be no negotiation. The fugitives! Immediately!" but T'Rina held her ground. From her bag of diplomatic tricks, T'Rina pulled the paperwork of an extradition order to counter him. "It seemed preferable to claims of a Tribble infestation," she noted to Captain Burnham afterwards, proving (once more) that Vulcans can tell jokes far better than, let's say, Tuvok's "It occurs to me that he could also have eaten the 'Sundays'".
In an episode that also marked a set of firsts for the Breen language, translated in real time out-loud into Federation Standard by the computer, T'Rina proved her diplomatic might once more. By correcting Primarch Ruhn's interpreter on their translation, T'Rina showed she had an impressive knowledge of Breen!
5. DOWN — Rayner's Raison D'Être
By now, we're all pretty used to Commander Rayner's grumpiness and foot-in-mouthisms in front of his superiors. Typically harmless, or at least well-intentioned, and at times even rather endearing, this week Rayner's more acerbic nature could have gone either way in our appreciation, but for a few oddities in the revelations about his past.
Rayner does certainly need to rein in the constant questioning of the higher-ups in particular. In the round table meeting with Admiral Vance, President T'Rina, and Captain Burnham, Rayner is more than just forthright with his opinions, he is downright hot-headed, dismissive, and even overtly insulting. He outwardly states that "All Breen are the same," that "The word diplomacy is not even in their vocabulary," and calls T'Rina's definition of it "a pipe dream".
It's not just a (rather epic) nod to canon, then, but very much a dressing down when T'Rina calls Rayner out for his "xenophobic comments," i.e. his mention of the Romulan saying "never turn your back on a Breen". Burnham, having already ordered Rayner to wait outside, is equally curt with him after the meeting has ended, expressing her concern about his ability to handle the situation. "Dismissed," Burnham concludes.
All of this was bordering on a) insubordination and b) one step forward, several light-years back in terms of character development for the Commander, but, given what we do learn about him in Erigah, we can probably forgive him a little forthright grumpiness. What clinches this as a DOWN, however, is not the substance of his backstory but the fact that Burnham was seemingly unaware of it in the first place.
During a one-on-one chat with Burnham later in the episode, we find out that Rayner's homeworld, Kellerun, was once conquered and occupied by the Breen, used as a staging area in one of their wars. Rayner was the only member of his family to have survived the brutal period.
The scene is profoundly touching, but we wondered if all of the information Rayner revealed, as personal as it was, should have already been available in some form in his Starfleet records? Furthermore, in Mirrors, for example, Burnham had been reading up on Kellerun culture enough to use that knowledge as a distress signal. You'd think, therefore, that the Breen occupation of the planet wouldn't have come as such… news!
4. UP — (Bang) Their Bucket Heads Together
This is a multifaceted UP, rather fitting for the Breen given what we now know about them. In addition to the additions to the species lore, and the Crocodile Dundee effect made manifest on their starships, Erigah presented us with a multitude of visually striking moments with the bucket heads. And if you thought getting blood from a Breen was hard enough (jury's still out on that one), try asking them for information!
In Erigah, we got more looks at the new Breen suits (which I love!) than you can shake one of those extended Breen weapon-bangy-stick things at. Before beaming in with his minions, Uncle Primarch Ruhn first appears as giant holo-head right in the centre of the round of Federation HQ. The 'negotiations' that follow are made ever more tense by the sublime framing of the scene — Breen firmly on one side of Fed HQ's Command Centre (upper level), Starfleet and the Federation firmly on the other, neither moving much more than a muscle at first. Later, at around 37 or so minutes in, there is also a brilliant shot of Ruhn in a face-to-face (or bucket-head-to-bucket-head) discussion with one of his fellow Breen.
I've given an UP to T'Rina's diplomatic flair; I must give one to Burnham's equally impressive handling of the situation. Burnham's knack for extracting information from the tight-lipped L'ak simply through the persistence of asking pertinent questions would be scary if it weren't just utterly brilliant.
In general, it is once more a delight to see Burnham fully assume the confidence of Captain. Burnham continues her steadfast determination when facing down the rest of the band of stubborn Breen, not flinching even for an instant (outwardly anyway) when she shows Ruhn Starfleet's upper hand — "because we have a spore drive."
3. DOWN — Booker's Prize
We all love Book, but the hook or by crook — nudge the Grudge — of the what of the plot, is now not the best look. Sorry, I still appear to be rhyming after last week's episode. Season five would be poorer without him — his interactions with Doctor Culber have already provided a particular highlight — but, as Seán has previously mentioned in his Ups & Downs, writing Book in has required walking a fine line of credibility. At times in Erigah, I felt this credibility was stretched just a little too thin.
What was arguably a great moment for Nhan, was more pointedly a 'Last time/season on Star Trek: Discovery' for Book. It's no doubt not a good sign that they had to re-justify Book's presence aboard in such a way in the opening few minutes, brightly spotlighted by Burnham's "Book has been instrumental in this mission so far". Credit where credit is due, Book does prove her point correct by assisting Stamets with his half of the clue, and by convincing Moll to cease her escape attempt and return to L'ak's side.
Nevertheless, it does feel like Book has been given an awful amount of privileged access to go running around ship — one that he'd fired on last season (warning shots or no). When Moll escapes the confines of the confinement field, Discovery is put on "lockdown protocol," and Book proceeds to ask Zora "What's going on?" Zora then spills security information to him more readily than Ensign DeSeve after a couple of glasses of Romulan ale. How much clearance does Book have? Later, Book's reaction to Moll's departure, whilst completely understandable, was also arguably a bit out of line.
2. UP — L'ak, The Silly Scion, and Moll's Most Married Escape
First of all, I'm evidently not upping the fact that L'ak died! I'm not a monster (on weekdays anyway), and besides, that would be a huge down (and downer) for a character we've already come to love, in spite of his occasionally a-little-quick-on-the-poison dealings. We all have our rebellious phases! Plus, L'ak is also only 'Star Trek dead' at the moment. It ain't over until it's Progenitors tech and over, and until Reno sings during her shift at Red's!
In Erigah, we did learn quite a few things about L'ak (Burnham's power of persuasion is impossible to resist), notably the real reason he's been avoiding his uncle for a bit. As Burnham deduces, and L'ak sheepishly confirms, Primarch Ruhn's not after him to fulfil the Erigah by death — although some of the details are still a little fuzzy and contradictory — nor is he angry he wasn't invited to the wedding (quite the opposite!). In fact, Ruhn needs L'ak to succeed to power because L'ak is, as it happens, "Scion of the Breen Imperium," the "direct descendant of the emperor".
Beyond the politics, the bloodlines, and the power play, there is Moll, and she is the only thing that matters to L'ak in the entire galaxy. Safe to say the feeling's mutual! Their 'love story above all odds' is most definitely one of the highlights of the season. Even L'ak's accidental overdose on tricordrazine was all in an attempt to allow Moll to escape, it would seem.
Oh, and that deathbed scene with L'ak and Moll! Let's just take a moment to note how beautifully played the moment was on the part of Eve Harlow and Elias Toufexis. I'm not crying, my, err, refrigeration suit is leaking!
Even if our invitation to their nuptials also apparently got lost in subspace, we have to give credit to Moll's bold reveal of her and L'ak's wedded-status-by-matching-branding to the Primarch. Though extremely dangerous, it was equally an extremely smart move given the circumstances. Ruhn called the union "an abomination," but Moll knew he was obliged to take her — along with L'ak's body — with him under Breen tradition. Telling Ruhn about the Progenitors' tech also helped! Starfleet and the Federation had little choice but to let Moll go.
1. CETACEAN OBSERVATIONS
Quite the week for Easter eggs, and otherwise noddily nods to Trek lore! We got everything Breen and in-between — from Tribbles to Tellar Prime — and a bit of Betazoid too. Seán will still cover them all most comprehensively, but here are a few to whet your appetite:
- Cause of L'ak's death tricordrazine, a cordrazine derivative, was first mentioned on screen by Doctor Pulaski in that episode, Shades of Gray.
- Commander Rayner's "My suggestion: We install thoron emitters on the hull, used with duranium shadows" was a direct reference to similar trickery employed in Emissary, and then most definitely not in Way of the Warrior.
- Doctor Culber's research into "The Dominion War era" was a doff of the cap and a tip of the dermal regenerator to… well, the Dominion War era…
- … and did anyone think Flotter (Adventures of…) and/or Trevis when Commander Reno made a comparison to a "holodeck adventure for the littles"?
Speaking of Commander Reno, she had a few more Easter eggs in her arsenal. In fact, if her CV is anything to go by, she probably used to make them too! For this Star Trek: Voyager fan and obsessive, one particular part of Reno's work experience section caught my attention — "bartender at a cosy little dive on Aschelan IV."
Aschelan V was the Cardassian target that B'Elanna Torres had reprogrammed into missile Dreadnought before it then mysteriously disappeared in the Badlands (sound familiar?). Dreadnought had, in fact, been scooped up by the Caretaker, who left it for Voyager (and mostly B'Elanna) to deal with in the Delta Quadrant. In the TrekCulture Infinity Room, we did joke that perhaps Reno meant to say Rakosa V instead! No more 'Seven of Limes' for us!