10 Best Actor Replacements On TV Shows

These tricky actor replacements worked out better than anyone expected.

By Jack Pooley /

TV shows are tough enough to make without having to deal with the colossal headache of replacing an actor mid-production, which at worst can threaten to derail a series entirely.

Advertisement

Replacing an actor for one of many reasons - their quitting, firing, or death - requires delicate consideration from those in charge, to ensure that whoever's drafted in to take over fits the bill and won't alienate the fanbase.

And so, inspired by this recent Reddit thread on the very subject, these 10 actor replacements just might be the finest that TV has ever seen.

Now to be clear, actor replacements aren't strictly limited to mere recastings - in some cases a departing actor was replaced with another performer who played a new, typically similar character intended to fill the void left in their wake.

Despite considerable skepticism in most of these instances, everything ultimately worked out for the best, with the replacement actor either matching or even exceeding the efforts of their predecessor.

And so, the next time you get ready to pitch a fit about an actor replacement in your favourite TV show, remember that it can work out for the best...

10. Jerry Stiller Replaced John Randolph - Seinfeld

It's incredibly easy to forget that this replacement even happened.

Advertisement

In Seinfeld, George Costanza's (Jason Alexander) father Frank was introduced in the late season four episode "The Handicap Spot", where he was portrayed by veteran character actor John Randolph.

But when the decision was made to make Frank a regular character starting with season five, it was also decided that Randolph's more restrained acting style wasn't quite the right fit for the show.

And so, the part was recast with the great Jerry Stiller coming in to play a more larger-than-life, exaggerated version of Frank.

Randolph gives a totally solid performance in his single episode, yet it's also tough to picture him delivering the more outlandish Frank performed by Stiller from that point.

Despite Randolph's tenure lasting just one episode, two years later his scenes in said episode were re-shot with Stiller, to ensure consistency during syndicated TV airings.

Watching the two very different renditions of Frank side-by-side is quite the fascinating, surreal experience. As fine an actor as Randolph was, Stiller made the part his own in ways that Randolph never would've been able to.

9. Rose McGowan Replaced Shannen Doherty - Charmed

Hit fantasy drama series Charmed faced a major challenge when one of its three leads, Shannen Doherty, decided to depart the show after its third season due to an apparent overabundance of "drama" on the set.

Advertisement

After toying with replacing Doherty with the likes of Soleil Moon Frye, Denise Richards, Tiffani Thiessen, and Jennifer Love Hewitt, the decision was made to kill Doherty's character, Prue Haliwell, at the start of season four.

At this point, she was replaced with a long-lost younger half-sister character, Paige Matthews, played by Rose McGowan.

On paper it certainly seemed like anything but a smooth transition, and even accepting that the show was simply never as good as in its first three seasons, McGowan made for an impressively seamless casting replacement.

A big part of the reason that Paige's introduction works is that the showrunners didn't simply attempt to make her Prue 2.0, but develop her as a character with her own personality and agency.

Furthermore, her arrival ended up reshuffling the dynamic between the three sisters, what with Piper (Holly Marie Combs) now nudged into the oldest sister role.

Plus, given how frosty the interplay between Doherty and screen sister Alyssa Milano was throughout those first three seasons, McGowan certainly helped make things a little warmer.

All in all, for a personnel change that sounds laughably desperate on paper, it actually ended up working out fantastically well under the circumstances.

8. Jonathan Banks Replaced Chevy Chase - Community

Chevy Chase was fired from cult sitcom Community during production of its fourth season after allegedly using a racial slur on set.

Advertisement

This led to Chase's character, Pierce Hawthorne, being revealed to have died early on in season five in a bizarre dehydration incident.

In an attempt to compensate for his conspicuous absence, another old white guy was drafted in, with Breaking Bad's Jonathan Banks brought aboard to portray surly criminology professor Buzz Hickey.

And while Chase's contributions to the show can't be denied, Banks was an extremely capable and entertaining replacement, shaking up the established dynamic with his take-no-prisoners demeanour. However, his gruff exterior nevertheless belied a deep humanity percolating underneath.

Banks' stint on the show lasted only a single season - before he was replaced himself by Keith David - but given the massive chasm that Chase's departure left, he filled it with laudable ease.

7. Bruce Greenwood Replaced Frank Langella - The Fall Of The House Of Usher

Netflix's The Fall of the House of Usher is a unique case on this list because it's the only one where the replacement happened before the show even premiered.

Advertisement

Frank Langella was originally cast to portray protagonist Roderick Usher - the ageing patriarch of the Usher family and corrupt CEO of a massive pharmaceutical company.

Yet mid-way through shooting, Langella was fired due to allegations of inappropriate conduct on set, at which point he was replaced with terrific character actor Bruce Greenwood.

And watching Mike Flanagan's dramatic horror series, it's extremely difficult to picture Langella bringing quite the same loquacious charm to the table that Greenwood does, his gravelly vocal tenor bringing enormous pathos to so many of Roderick Usher's poetic monologues.

Given that Roderick Usher is depicted as a charming man and plausible father to six young-to-middle-aged children, in pure number terms the 67-year-old Greenwood also simply fit the bill better than the 85-year-old Langella.

While it's often easy to lament a mid-production actor switch, in this case it's almost impossible to feel anything bad about it at all, because Greenwood simply should've been the actor cast in the first place.

6. Jeri Ryan Replaced Jennifer Lien - Star Trek: Voyager

Jennifer Lien portrayed telepathic alien Kes throughout the first three seasons of Star Trek: Voyager, yet she was promptly written out of the show early in season four due to Lien suffering with unspecified personal issues which prevented her from performing.

Advertisement

This resulted in a new female character, former Borg drone Seven of Nine (Jeri Ryan), being introduced at the start of the season, effectively serving as Kes' replacement.

Many fans decried Kes' departure given the intriguing potential of her character, and initially felt that the tightly-dressed Seven of Nine was overtly sexualised in an insultingly pandering fashion.

Yet to Voyager's credit, they worked hard to make Seven a nuanced and compelling character beyond the obvious superficial appeal, while also revising her attire to be less revealing.

This, combined with Jeri Ryan's terrific performance in the role, allowed Seven to graduate into a fan-favourite character.

Given that Kes had a limited lifespan anyway - with the Ocampa species only living an average of nine years - it's tough to decry the replacement much, especially as Ryan's performance is ultimately so much more commanding and memorable than Lien's.

5. Liam McIntre Replaced Andy Whitfield - Spartacus

Starz's Spartacus series faced a devastating nightmare of a situation when lead actor Andy Whitfield was diagnosed with early-stage non-Hodgkin lymphoma following completion of the show's first season.

Advertisement

While he recuperated, a prequel mini-series, Spartacus: Gods of the Arena, went into production, yet Whitfield's cancer ended up recurring, sadly leading to his death in 2011.

Rather than end the show, however, the network decided to recast Spartacus at Whitfield's own insistence, with Australian actor Liam McIntyre playing the part for the second and third seasons.

Though there was much upfront resistance to the recast due to Whitfield's acclaimed performance, McIntyre worked hard to win fans over, and by the time the show wrapped up, most felt that he'd earned his place.

More to the point, the showrunners evidently made the best of a horrible situation - continuing the ongoing story without invaliding Whitfield's sublime work in role, but rather honouring it.

To most fans Whitfield is still the Spartacus, but as replacements go under deeply upsetting circumstances, McIntyre absolutely crushed it in his own right.

4. Lamorne Morris Replaced Damon Wayans Jr. - New Girl

The pilot episode for Fox's sitcom New Girl counted among its ensemble cast Damon Wayans Jr., who played one of protagonist Jess' (Zooey Deschanel) roommates, Coach.

Advertisement

However, when Fox decided to take the show to series, Wayans' other sitcom project, Happy Endings, had already been renewed for a second season, and so Wayans made the decision not to return in a full-time capacity.

Despite initial plans to recast Coach and reshoot the pilot, it was eventually decided to simply have Coach duck out in the very next episode, where it was also revealed that he was only subletting the apartment from the real roomie, Winston (Lamorne Morris).

The transition was basically butter-smooth, with Lamorne Morris giving an uproariously funny performance as Winston while quickly cementing his superior chemistry with the rest of the cast.

But in something of a happy ending for everyone, Wayans did return to play Coach as a series regular throughout the third and fourth seasons once Happy Endings was cancelled, alongside other periodic appearances.

Ultimately Coach was simply better suited to being a supporting character while Winston truly felt like he belonged front-and-center for the long haul.

3. Robert Llewellyn Replaced David Ross - Red Dwarf

When Red Dwarf's iconic service droid Krysten was first introduced in the legendary sitcom's second series, he was originally intended to be a one-off character as played by David Ross.

Advertisement

But Kryten's popularity led creators Rob Grant and Doug Naylor to bring the character back as a mainstay member of the Red Dwarf crew in series three, and with scheduling conflicts preventing Ross' return, he was swapped out for Robert Llewellyn.

And Kryten more-or-less felt like a totally different character in Llewellyn's hands - less snippy and instead more goofy and earnest, as made him such a brilliant contrast to the likes of Lister (Craig Charles) and Rimmer (Chris Barrie).

This isn't to disparage Ross' performance in his single episode whatsoever - his work was perfect for that single outing, but long-term it absolutely made sense to replace him with an actor whose personality better suited a Kryten who would be sticking around.

Ross' Red Dwarf tenure didn't quite end there, though - he also provided the voice for Talkie Toaster in the show's fourth and twelfth seasons.

2. Rob Lowe & Adam Scott Replaced Paul Schneider - Parks & Recreation

Parks and Recreation certainly suffered through rough patches in the early going, and one of the toughest aspects of those first two seasons in particular? How poorly the character of Mark Brendanawicz (Paul Schneider) gelled with the rest of the cast.

Advertisement

Mark was placed in the show as the clear "straight man" to his more outlandish co-workers, yet between Paul Schneider's palpable lack of chemistry with both love interests - Leslie Knope (Amy Poehler) and Ann Perkins (Rashida Jones) - and the character's generally dull presence, he just didn't work.

Schneider's proven himself a perfectly solid actor elsewhere, but he just wasn't working for this part, and so for a variety of stated reasons - such as Schneider's film career blowing up - he and the show's creators mutually agreed on his exit at the end of season two.

The third season kicked off with Mark being replaced by not one but two new characters - Ben Wyatt (Adam Scott) and Chris Traeger (Rob Lowe), each serving as a love interest for Leslie and Ann respectively.

Where to even begin here? Beyond Ben and Chris simply being more interesting characters from the outset, both actors had effortlessly superior chemistry with the wider ensemble cast, and without them, Parks and Rec likely wouldn't have enjoyed all the success it did.

1. Woody Harrelson Replaced Nicholas Colasanto - Cheers

Cheers was forced to make a sad pivot when Nicholas Colasanto, who played fan favourite bartender Coach Ernie Pantusso, passed away following production of the sitcom's third season.

Advertisement

Rather than recast Coach, the show's creators had him die from unexplained causes within the series itself, and in the season four premiere his replacement was ushered in - Woody Boyd (Woody Harrelson).

Woody was introduced as Coach's pen pal - as in, they literally traded pens through the mail - and quickly filled the open bartender role.

As contrived as it might seem in theory, Woody slotted quite effortlessly into the ensemble cast, in large part due to Woody Harrelson's infectiously charming performance.

And while the two characters had some obvious similarities, Woody was also different enough to not feel like a mere young imitation.

Even to this very day there's still no clear fan consensus on which is the superior character, which is perhaps the finest compliment you could give the creators, for finding a pitch-perfect substitute who didn't just erase Coach from memory.

Advertisement