10 Best Columbo Episodes
"Just one more thing."
Columbo was a ground-breaking series founded by Richard Levinson and William Link.
Having its roots in stage work (and a failed attempt to lure Bing Crosby into the lead role), the show originated through two pilot episodes in 1968 and 1971 respectively and was a formative effort that inverted the entire mystery movie mystique by unusually revealing the identity of the murderer to the audience at the beginning of each episode (most of the time).
Columbo then slyly began pulling at the loose threads of each suspect's alibi throughout, before exposing what had revealed the criminal in a climactic resolution sequence that was more akin to the accepted Agatha Christie style of exposing the murderer at the end of the story.
That said, not every episode of the series is an instant classic and, as it progressed, the show had its own fair share of continuity errors, rushed conclusions, and questionable logic.
Nevertheless, here is a list of what may be considered to be the 10 best episodes of the show.
10. A Bird In The Hand
This 1992 mini-movie episode of the series inverts the accepted Columbo format.
For the majority of the episode, we follow Greg Evigan's Harold McCain, who has been plotting the demise of his football team-owning uncle, Big Fred (Steve Forrest) with a car bomb before Big Fred is surprisingly mown down in a hit and run accident. Harold tries to remove the bomb, only for it to explode when the McCain family's gardener tries to move Big Fred's Rolls Royce. Around three quarters of the way through the episode, Harold realizes that Big Fred's own wife, Dolores (Tyne Daly) was driving the gardener's truck that killed her husband, and he then proceeds to blackmail her. This leads Dolores to then murder Harold as well, before Columbo arrests her for both crimes.
Aside from the canny tinkering with the show's format, the thing that makes this a fantastic episode is, quite simply, the great Tyne Daly, whose Dolores seems at first to just be Big Fred's ditzy lush of a wife, before transforming into a cunning mastermind after his death, using her drinking as nothing more than a smokescreen to conceal her devious side.
Her closing line, said to her gobsmacked lawyer, who simply stands by whilst Columbo reveals the evidence of her guilt, is also one of the best in the entire show: "Thanks Bertie. I don't know what I would've done without you!"
9. Caution: Murder Can Be Hazardous To Your Health
George Hamilton was already an alumnus of Columbo's golden age (having portrayed the murderer in A Deadly State of Mind in 1975) when, in his first screen role after The Godfather Part III, he played Wade Anders, the host of a Crimewatch-style programme whose name had become a household word. When he is blackmailed by an envious, chain-smoking colleague (played by Peter Haskell, who famously fell victim to the killer doll, Chucky, in the very same year that this episode aired), Anders conspires to murder his oppressor with a poisoned cigarette.
What makes this a fascinating episode of Columbo is that it deals almost entirely in the politics of the media, with nods to late 1980s and early 1990s culture that helped to distinguish the later episodes of Columbo from its original 1970s run.
There is also a brilliant sequence in which Columbo's battered Peugeot 403 Cabriolet collides with Anders's pristine Mercedes-Benz. An irritated Anders inspects the damage and, upon seeing Columbo's Peugeot, which has certainly seen better days, asks "This didn't just all happen, did it?"
The evidence used to prove Anders's guilt also takes a cue from a key piece of evidence featured in Alfred Hitchcock's 1954 film, Rear Window, demonstrating the show's fondness for the classics.
8. A Trace Of Murder
Another of the later entries in the series which dared to challenge the traditional Columbo format, 1997's A Trace of Murder sees Cathleen Calvert (portrayed by Peter Falk's real-life wife, Shera Danese) conspiring with her forensic expert lover, Patrick Kinsley (played by David Rasche) to get rid of her overbearing husband, Clifford Calvert (Barry Corbin) by murdering an innocent man who is currently engaged in a legal battle with Clifford. The aim is to therefore avoid Cathleen from being suspected of the crime, as a third party will be dead, rather than her husband.
One of the big things that sets this episode apart, other than its tweaking of the format, is Corbin's performance as the boisterous, but curiously likeable Clifford.
We can understand why Cathleen wants rid of him, but he's just too funny to dislike! Additionally, when all is said and done, Clifford unwittingly goes one better on Cathleen and gets rid of her instead when her plan eventually falls apart.
Another interesting thing about this episode is that it delves a bit deeper into Columbo's uncanny observation of human nature, which plays a key part in his ability to expose Cathleen and Patrick. Slightly less convincing is the manner in which the joint killers turn on each other with nothing more than a few simple words from Columbo. Still, an almost-perfect episode!
7. Any Old Port In A Storm
"An exciting meal has been ruined by the presence of this LIQUID FILTH!"
What a great way to avoid paying the bill in a restaurant!
Even though he was largely regarded as a character actor rather than a leading man, you can't deny that Donald Pleasence always brought his A-game to each and every role that he took on. A good five years away from portraying Dr. Sam Loomis in John Carpenter's Halloween here, Pleasence plays an obsessive British-Italian winery manager named Adrian Carsini who murders his brother, Enrico, when Enrico threatens to sell the winery to some competitors. Settling upon an outlandish scheme to make it appear that he was on a buying trip in New York City when Enrico apparently died in a diving accident off the coast of Los Angeles, Adrian makes a vital mistake that ultimately costs him not only his freedom, but also his precious winery, and his priceless collection of antique wine as well.
This is one of those episodes where the resolution to the case is clearly rushed - after all, why would the manager of a winery need to throw bottles of spoiled wine off of a cliff when there must have been a perfectly viable means of discreetly disposing of the bottles at the winery itself? Nevertheless, the thing that helps to sell this episode is the very clear chemistry between Peter Falk and Donald Pleasence throughout the entire episode. Pleasence's Carsini appears to develop a genuine fondness for Falk's Lieutenant Columbo (and vice versa) as they discuss the case over many a glass of fine wine, and this truly pays off at the climax. Clearly empathising with Adrian, Columbo even goes so far as to buy him a dessert wine, as if to say that he genuinely regrets having to arrest him.
After watching this episode, you definitely feel that, putting its faults aside, you have seen something very special.
This entry also features Julie Harris (best known for her starring role in 1963's The Haunting) as Adrian's adoring and increasingly manipulative secretary, Karen Fielding.
6. Lovely But Lethal
The episode immediately that aired immediately prior to Any Old Port in a Storm, 1973's Lovely but Lethal is another highlight of the show.
Vera Miles is a highly underrated actress who is perhaps still best known for portraying Janet Leigh's determined sister, Lila Crane in Alfred Hitchcock's 1960 film, Psycho. Here, she appears as cosmetics industry mogul, Viveca Scott whose company, Beauty Mark is desperate for a big success. Imagine her relief when one of her chief chemists develops a cream named Miracle that can literally smooth away wrinkles, and imagine her anger when that formula is stolen by her one-time lover, Karl Lessing (played by Martin Sheen). Killing Lessing in a fit of rage and stealing the formula back, Viveca is in a race against time to save her company and outwit Columbo...if she can.
One of the highlights of this episode is the brief but memorable presence of horror icon, Vincent Price as David Lang, Viveca's hated rival. Miles and Price spit venom at each other, and Price also shares an amusing scene with Peter Falk before vanishing completely from the proceedings. It is a fascinating little insight into Price's acting abilities and it is indeed a shame that he did not return to portray a murderer in the series himself.
The episode is also notable for having been directed by Jeannot Szwarc, who went on to helm the highly anticipated 1978 film, Jaws 2. Szwarc makes good use of a distracting plot device here in which Columbo believes that he has come into contact with poison ivy, whereas Viveca fears that the itches that both she and Columbo are suffering may actually be induced by the same beauty cream that she needs to save her company.
With the police closing in on her, Viveca is forced to hurl the last container of Miracle out of a window and into the sea - therefore losing the formula, perhaps forever - in a vain effort to try and preserve her freedom. With this comes the realisation that all of her efforts, including two murders, have been for nothing.
5. Murder By The Book
Technically the first episode of Columbo (if you discount the television movie pilot episodes), 1971's Murder By The Book also has the distinction of being one of Steven Spielberg's earliest widely-available works and, indeed, the only episode of the series that he directed.
It is a very engrossing, character-driven episode, dealing with Ken Franklin (played by David Cassidy's father, Jack Cassidy) killing his writing partner, Jim Ferris (Martin Milner) for the insurance money. Together, they are believed to collaborate on a series of Miss Marple-style mystery novels but, in truth, Ferris does all the writing work and Franklin purely sells the novels.
Having become tired of doing all the hard work and wanting to go it alone, Ferris unwittingly sets himself up as a victim, since Franklin lives a hedonistic lifestyle and desperately needs the cash. As with many a Columbo episode, it is the method of the murder that is ingenious, as Franklin drives Ferris to his isolated cabin retreat before murdering him, and then transports the corpse back to Los Angeles, dumping it on his own front lawn to make it look like a gangland warning. From there, however, Franklin's plot has to go downhill so that he may be captured and, indeed, as Columbo observes, Franklin goes on to commit a second very "sloppy" murder.
Composer, Billy Goldenberg scored a handful of the original episodes of the series and imbues this particular entry with a soundtrack that makes use of the clacking keys of a typewriter for its central theme, which is both memorable and unsettling. Spielberg and Goldenberg later collaborated on Spielberg's pre-Jaws television movie, Duel, in the same year as this episode was aired.
Also memorable is the presence of Barbara Colby as the effusive (and toothy) convenience store owner, Lilly La Sanka, who is seemingly smitten with Franklin. Sadly, several years after appearing in this episode, Colby was gunned down with a colleague in a parking garage in Venice, California whilst they were on their way home from teaching an acting class, which makes her memorable turn here seem all the more tragic.
Anchoring the entire affair, however, is Rosemary Forsyth, who portrays Ferris's down-to-earth widow, Joanna, whom Columbo takes great pity on.
4. The Greenhouse Jungle
Especially in its earlier days, Columbo had the distinction of relying upon the Universal contract system to ensure that A-list stars appeared in the show. Ray Milland was just one of those big name stars, appearing not only as the victim's husband in the first season episode, Death Lends a Hand, but later as the killer in the second season's The Greenhouse Jungle. His second (and final) appearance may be the better of the two, but it's a very close call.
Playing Jarvis Goodland, an irritable old businessman with a fondness for orchids, Milland (complete with a toupee) schemes with his character's nephew, Tony (portrayed by Bradford Dillman) to fake Tony's kidnapping and collect on a ransom paid from Tony's trust fund. Those orchids don't come cheap, you know!) What Tony does not know is that the plan also involves Tony's murder, which Jarvis plans to frame on Tony's unfaithful wife, Cathy (Sandra Smith).
Milland steals the show as the scenery-chewing Jarvis Goodland and his barbs to and about Columbo are likely to make you chuckle at the very least ("I had to be sure we weren't being followed by that Neanderthal policeman!"). Ray Milland and Bradford Dillman would go on to co-star (and have another fictional family connection) in the Roger Moore vehicle, Gold, two years after this entry into the Columbo canon.
The episode also introduces us to Sergeant Frederic Wilson, played by Bob Dishy, who is one of Columbo's more memorable colleagues. Dishy returned to the role four years later in the 1976 episode, Now You See Him (in which his character is curiously credited as Sergeant John J. Wilson), but he was far more effective here, introducing Columbo to a whole collection of gadgets to assist in solving crime, none of which the lieutenant shows much interest in.
Dishy's Wilson also unwittingly sets up one of the show's best bloopers, which was so good that it remained in the final episode. Finding Tony's crashed Jaguar E-Type at the base of a cliff, Wilson guides Columbo down the quickest (and steepest) way down, whereupon the lieutenant loses his footing and tumbles down the rest of the way. In true Columbo style, Falk took the error in his stride, telling Dishy that it certainly was the quickest way down, before taking the longer way back up the cliff when they are done.
Arlene Martel also makes her first appearance in the show here, portraying Tony Goodland's former secretary and suspected lover, Gloria West. She went on to feature in the following season's Double Exposure as Tanya Baker and as an alluring salesgirl in the 1974 episode, A Friend in Deed.
3. Blueprint For Murder
When Peter Falk agreed to play Lieutenant Columbo for Universal, one of his conditions was that he also be able to direct some of the show's episodes. The story goes that, during the first season, he started to become so discontented with not being given any episodes to direct that he threatened to quit the role.
Realising that they had a ratings success on their hands, Universal did not wish to risk giving creative control over to the show's star, nor did they want to lose him. Therefore, in order to satisfy Falk and to suit their own aims, they allocated him one of the most technical and complicated episodes of the entire series to direct.
Successful architect, Elliot Markham (Patrick O'Neal) has got his hooks into Jennifer Williamson (Pamela Austin), the young wife of stereotypical Texan magnate, Bo Williamson (Forrest Tucker). When Bo learns that Markham has talked his wife into building Williamson City with Bo's money, he flies into a rage, and Markham quickly bumps Bo off, making it appear that he has simply gone travelling instead. However, Bo's former wife, the forthright Goldie (Janis Paige) is not convinced and, as he looks into matters further, neither is Columbo. Both soon become very interested in the foundations of a new skyscraper that Markham is erecting in Century City, Los Angeles...
Blueprint For Murder must have been something of a logistical nightmare for Falk, as it required a lot of location filming, mainly in a real-life construction site. This meant that scenes needed to be shot quickly, efficiently, and accurately, as there would be no chance to do re-shoots once construction on the site had resumed. Universal's approach in putting Falk in his place may be considered to be either justified or quite unfair, depending on how you look at it.
Either way, it is hard to deny that it led to an outstanding episode, enlivened by great performances from both Forrest Tucker and Janis Paige. As the episode reaches its conclusion, Falk also brings great tension to a sequence in which Markham, transporting Bo's body in the trunk of his car to the construction site under the cover of night, gets a flat tire and is confronted by a traffic cop. It certainly is a shame that Falk did not direct any more entries in the series.
Patrick O'Neal later went on to have a rather thankless supporting role as a television station executive in one of the last of the original run of Columbo episodes, Make Me a Perfect Murder in 1978.
2. Try And Catch Me
Columbo (or at least the programme) seemed to have a fascination with mystery writers. Perhaps this isn't surprising, as its creators later went on to make Murder, She Wrote, which sort of replaced Columbo for most of the 1980s and beyond.
In a loose remake of Any Old Port in a Storm, Abigail Mitchell (played by the delightful Academy Award winner, Ruth Gordon) is one of the most successful and respected mystery novelists in the business; indeed, she seems to have been inspired by Dame Agatha Christie. Unfortunately, she has a nephew-by-marriage, Edmund Galvin (Charles Frank) who not only seems to be hanging around seeking to inherit her fortune, but whom she also believes to have murdered her beloved niece. Locking Edmund in her walk-in safe, Abigail jets off to New York City. In the meantime, her secretary, Veronica (Mariette Hartley) opens the safe and finds Edmund suffocated. Everyone is led to believe that Edmund was trying to steal from Abigail when he was accidentally locked in the safe (either by his own hand or otherwise), but Veronica is not convinced, and neither is Columbo.
The byplay between Peter Falk and Ruth Gordon is what makes this episode so endearing. There is a sort of friendly rivalry between Columbo and Abigail for most of the episode, during which she even throws his "just one more thing" catchphrase right back at him. This instalment also experiments with several darker scenes to demonstrate Columbo's involved thought processes. However, the most poignant sequence comes right at the end of the episode, where Columbo exposes the flaws in Abigail's plan and is faced with the prospect of arresting her. Although unrepentant at her murder of Edmund, Abigail notes that, had Columbo been assigned the task of investigating her niece's disappearance, there would never have been a need for him to then investigate Edmund's murder. That is perhaps the finest compliment that Columbo has ever received, especially from a murderer.
It is also worth noting that Mariette Hartley had previously co-starred in the 1974 episode, Publish or Perish as publishing specialist, Eileen McRae.
1. Ransom For A Dead Man
Prescription: Murder, the 1968 pilot for Columbo, had been something of a muddled affair: overlong, unremarkable and, worst of all, a dull characterization of the lieutenant himself. Columbo returned for a second pilot in 1971, Ransom for a Dead Man, and it was here that the series struck gold: striking visuals; what we might now call distinctively Columbo-style music from Billy Goldenberg, and a scruffy, seemingly absent-minded Columbo. The irony in all of this is that both pilots had starred Peter Falk and both had been directed by Richard Irving.
High-flying lawyer (and we mean that literally) Leslie Williams, played by Lee Grant, is bored with her practically perfect attorney husband, who has dared to stand up to her and so, wanting money from him one way or another, she kills him. Dumping his body where it may not be found for a while, she stages a phony kidnapping, fooling the FBI into believing her ruse, but failing to mislead Lieutenant Columbo. She also fails to deceive her stepdaughter, Margaret (Patricia Mattick), who proceeds to raise merry hell in the Williams household as she and Columbo start to unravel Leslie's plot.
Ransom for a Dead Man was the first episode (well, technically, it's a mini-movie like the episodes of the late 1980s to 2003) to give us the version of Lieutenant Columbo that we recognize today, and it's an important transformation that has kept Columbo memorable and entertaining as a character. However, when you think about it, we supposedly learn an awful lot about his family during the course of the show without ever meeting them or even learning if Columbo is telling the truth.
The episode also boasted several gripping aerial sequences, using the larger budget of a TV movie to its advantage without allowing that to overshadow the mystery and emotional tension that characterizes this particular entry.
And just one more thing about this episode: it was the first one to feature Columbo's favourite chilli restaurant, Barney's Beanery.