10 Best Episodes That Make Bad TV Seasons Worth Watching
These ten episodes represent the best of a (very, very, very) bad bunch.
The only thing worse than stubbing your toe is when good shows go bad. You’ve been watching for years, built up a strong connection with the characters, you’re excited to see what they do next, then it’s just... bad.
Sometimes it’s motivated by a crucial character leaving, or a departure behind the scenes. Other times, you realise on a rewatch that the first season is garbage compared to what came after, while other shows either fumble the ending or just don’t know how to end full stop.
Whatever the reason for a great show going off the boil though, there’s often still a redeeming quality. Something from whatever made it great still remains, and when that all comes together for one brilliant episode, it’s magical. A bright spot in the darkness.
These episodes are precisely those bright spots. Overall, these shows are fantastic, but they’ve all had a least one dud year; in some cases, more than one. They’re worth powering through just to get to these gems though, as they can remind you of what the show can do when it fires on all cylinders, even if the episodes around it let it down.
10. Dwight Christmas - The Office (Season 9)
The Office Season Nine really has four great episodes, but seeing as the final three are all really one big finale, Dwight Christmas is the one true standout of the standalones.
Shows typically bring (or try to bring) their A-game to finales, so this list largely steers clear of them. There is one which just couldn’t be missed out, but The Office doesn’t need cheap nostalgia in Season Nine to show that even when it’s bad, it can still pull off one last trick.
Dwight Christmas, as the name suggests, is the season’s Christmas episode, and, um, centres around Dwight.
Season Two’s Christmas episode, Christmas Party, is considered one of the most important to The Office’s popularity and success, so these seasonal episodes typically hold a dear place in fans’ hearts. It’s probably not as good as Christmas Party, nor Classy Christmas or Secret Santa, but it’s still head and shoulders above the rest of Season Nine.
Dwight is the office’s Santa, except he’s actually Belsnickel, a German Christmas character who hits naughty people with a stick. Or rather, impish people, as Belsnickel checks who’s impish or admirable, rather than naughty or nice.
9. The Lost Art Of Forehead Sweat - The X-Files (Season 11)
There’s a few seasons which could qualify as ‘bad’ for The X-Files. The first seven Mulder & Scully series are solid, but after that it gets trickier to tell. Season Eight was worse for Mulder’s absence, but Robert Patrick’s John Doggett fills in well and there’re too many good episodes there to isolate on a list like this.
Season Nine, on the other hand, is average to poor throughout with no major standouts. Season 10 was finding its feet after a long hiatus, so it falls to Season 11 to prove things were back to their best - or not, as it happened. The second of the comeback seasons proved that they were never going to capture the glory days, and stumbled its way to cancellation.
When picking out a truly bad season then, Nine and Eleven seem the obvious candidates. Where Nine is fairly bland, Eleven at least has The Lost Art Of Forehead Sweat.
It was written by Darin Morgan, the man behind legendary X-Files episodes Jose Chung, Coprophages and Clyde Bruckman, as well as Season 10’s best, Were-Monster. Like most of Morgan’s stuff, it’s as funny as it is creepy, dealing with the Mandela effect and fake news. It also takes a meta examination of The X-Files themselves. A must watch for sci-fi fans.
8. That ‘70s Finale - That ‘70s Show (Season 8)
That ‘70s Finale is the one and only finale on the list, simply because it’s too good an episode to leave out and Season Eight of the show was so inescapably bad. As mentioned in The Office’s entry, including a finale does feel a tad cheap, but when it’s head and shoulders above the rest of the season, it’s really unavoidable.
One of the huge problems with the season was the departure of Topher Grace and Ashton Kutcher as Eric Foreman and Michael Kelso respectively. With such a tight dynamic, losing just one of the main stars would have been tough to recover from. But two? It was practically a death sentence.
The strange plot of Jackie & Fez’s romance plus the unpopular addition of Josh Meyer’s Randy didn’t help either.
In the finale though, suitably set on New Year’s Eve, 1979, those issues were forgotten. For one, Randy is hardly in it, but it also brings Kelso and Eric back, reuniting the gang as they should be, one last time. It’s as funny as it is somber, and while it’s certainly helped by the added nostalgia of being a finale, it’s pretty much the only Season Eight episode worth watching.
7. Kiksuya - Westworld (Season 2)
It might be slightly harsh to call Westworld’s second season ‘bad’. By most standards of TV, it’s pretty good. Compared to Westworld’s first season though, most fans agree it was a massive nosedive.
Season Two was far too concerned with tricking its viewers and keeping up confusion, running multiple timelines and constantly attempting to trip fans up. Characterisation, world building and even plot seemed to be put on the back burner in exchange for making the show as convoluted as possible.
All that is, except for Kiksuya. The runaway fan favourite and critical darling of the season reminds you exactly why you fell in love with Westworld in the first place, just as you started having doubts.
It follows the tale of Akecheta, a character who had so far been pushed so deep in the background he was basically set dressing, or occasionally a one note obstacle/plot device. With Kiksuya though, we not only see his deep ties to Maeve and William, but to the consciousness at the heart of Westworld itself.
Almost the entirety of Kiksuya is in Lakota, a native Sioux language. Like all of Westworld, it demands you pay attention, but unlike most of Season Two it doesn’t pull the rug from you.
6. No Way Out - The Walking Dead (Season 6)
The harshest of critics will claim that The Walking Dead has been bad since the end of Season One. While it’s true that it’s never been as tight as Frank Darabont’s original first season, it probably did take a few more years to go truly off the boil.
By Season Six though, the rot had well and truly set in. There were some bright sparks along the way, with Danai Gurira’s Michonne freshening things up, but all in all fans were starting to wonder exactly what had gone wrong.
No Way Out reminded us all why we were still tuning in.
The mid season premiere came out all guns blazing in every sense of the phrase. With the walkers inside Alexandria safe house and the (as yet unseen) influence of Negan beginning to be felt, this is the most high octane, claustrophobic episode in years.
We see some classic comic moments like the death of Jessie and her sons and Carl losing his eye to round it off too. Pretty much every area of fan service is covered, but it’s a shame the rest of Season Six couldn’t live up to it.
5. Switch The Flip - Family Guy (Season 16)
Family Guy has long been seen as the rival or contemporary (or both) of The Simpsons, but its fall from grace has been far less publicised. People will still tell you it’s rubbish now, but their voices tend to be quieter, the cut off point for vintage quality less clear cut.
Some would say Season Seven, but there’s definitely a claim to be made for both earlier and later.
However, by Season 16 it’s clear Family Guy ain’t what it used to be. Tuning in week to week, you have to cross your fingers that you’re getting a good one. Most recently, You Can’t Handle The Booth scored an eye watering 3.7 out of 10 on IMDb.
With Switch The Flip though, Season 16 delivered quality many fans thought the show had lost touch with a decade earlier.
The episode involves one of Stewie’s contraptions, and offers up one of the best body switching episodes on television (though somehow only the second best of its kind on this list). Stewie swaps with Peter, Brian with Chris and to go into everything that happens would ruin the experience. Let's just say that Stewie as Peter on a sexual retreat with Lois is genius.
4. Basic Human Anatomy - Community (Season 4)
The other body switching episode.
Season Four of Community, nicknamed the gas leak season, was made without creator Dan Harmon and had a fair few misfires, out of character behaviours, emotional moments with poor delivery and a few botched concept episodes. However, its biggest shining light is Basic Human Anatomy, which feels more in tune with the other, less gas leaky seasons of the show.
It involves Troy pretending to switch bodies with Abed, in order for Abed (acting as Troy) to be the one to go on his date with Britta, and break up with her. Thus ends the least popular romantic relationship in the show’s history.
The side plot of the Dean acting like he’s switched bodies with Jeff is absolutely hilarious too. Jim Rash, Donald Glover and Danny Pudi all play different parts to their usual characters here, and each demonstrate their range brilliantly.
Though Season 4 does reach for emotional moments fairly often, Troy and Abed each working through Troy’s break up while playing each other is one of the only times they get it right. The balance between goofy and genuine emotion is perfect, and it’s all done in Community’s typical off kilter style.
3. A Knight Of The Seven Kingdoms - Game Of Thrones (Season 8)
Game Of Thrones’ final season was a car crash of epic proportions. The first episode dragged and failed to understand the characters, while the much anticipated Night King battle in episode three was poorly lit, anticlimactic and seemingly at odds with the tropes and plot of the previous seven seasons.
Then we had a nothing burger follow up with more out of character moments in episode four, a ridiculous twist with no set up for episode five, and a truly disastrous finale.
Episode Two was an example of what could have been. The whole time is spent within Winterfell, exploring the characters and their motivations, exploring what makes them fight and forging even deeper connections than before.
It seemed to be setting up some hard goodbyes and closing arcs off expertly. It’s a shame that the rest of the season ruined what it had built, but in isolation it’s fantastic.
We see different yet realistic sides to a lot of players in the game of thrones, but the clear standout is when Jaime knights Brienne in front of a delighted Tormund and Pod, who’s absolutely bursting with pride. His rendition of Jenny’s Song completes the scene perfectly.
2. Black Maps & Motel Rooms - True Detective (Season 2)
With True Detective being an anthology show, each of the three seasons are distinctly different from each other. Season One is still viewed as the apex and Season Three put in a solid showing to remind us all what the show could do.
Season Two, however, was a garbled mess which seemed bereft of ideas or identity. In the penultimate episode, Black Maps & Motel Rooms, it finally delivered, but by then it was far too late to save the season. If you ever go in for a rewatch though, you’ll be glad it’s there to look forward to.
Most of Season Two feels like it’s grasping at what it thinks made Season One great. There’s a lot of slow, whiskey soaked melancholy monologues and whispered conversations, but it’s missing what actually made Season One great: tension and dynamics.
Until Black Maps, all the characters felt too distant, too desperate to get in their ‘time is a flat circle’ quote. Black Maps finally remembers that this is a cop drama at heart.
Paul (Taylor Kitsch) actually does something plot worthy, Ani (Rachel McAdams) and Ray (Colin Farrell) are on the run, an actual conspiracy starts to unfold and eventually, we might actually care.
1. Halloween Of Horror - The Simpsons (Season 27)
The Simpsons could have filled every spot on this list, quite literally. Whether you take the bad Simpsons seasons to be post 9, post 11 or even a generous post 24, there’s still a lot of contenders. When it comes to The Simpsons, being bad is relative to its glory years.
Though the Golden Era is a long way back in the rear view mirror, The Simpsons still puts out an absolutely great episode once every couple of seasons.
Brick Like Me, Eternal Moonshine Of The Simpson Mind, The Squirt & The Whale, The Town and Eeny Teeny Maya Moe all could have been here as gems in their respective seasons. However, Halloween Of Horror from Season 27 is the pick of the bunch.
It breaks free of the usual Treehouse segments to tell a more down to Earth Halloween story, with Lisa traumatised after a visit to Krusty’s Halloween exhibit.
What follows is a Homer and Lisa story in the vein of classics like Lisa The Vegetarian, Lisa’s Substitute and HOMR. Not as good as them, perhaps, but one of the few modern episodes to capture the original, relatable father-daughter dynamic.