10 Best Lost Plot Twists

From shock deaths to big reveals, flash back to Lost’s greatest plot twists.

By Tim Hand /

Few shows have featured as many gripping twists and turns as Lost, which had legions of fans on the edge of their seats thanks to its compelling characters and thrilling plot. While the show’s ending may have been rather disappointing, Lost was unmissable when it was at the top of its game, showcasing superb scripts, performances and direction.

Advertisement

Given that mysteries and secrets played such an important role in Lost’s appeal and success, it’s hardly surprising that some of the show’s best moments were centred on rug-pull plot twists that sent the story and characters in captivating new directions. Some of these revealed shocking information about the nature of the Island, while others gave startling insights into key players, or subverted expectations by breaking the show’s usual “rules”.

A few of the developments resulting from these twists may not have lived up to the promise of the initial moments themselves, but these game-changing events in Lost's history still represent incredible storytelling triumphs, which helped to secure Lost's place as one of the greatest TV shows of all time.

So, grab a seat on the DHARMA van, and let’s begin…

10. The Others' Home

Lost worked hard to conceal the Others’ true nature and power during its first two seasons. By depicting them as lacking in technology, dressed in tattered clothes and living in tents, it encouraged viewers to believe that the Others led a primitive existence, and were therefore fairly evenly matched against the castaways.

Advertisement

There were hints that there might be more to the Others than met the eye, such as the discovery of Tom’s fake beard in the Staff station, and Walt’s warning that they were “pretending” in a flashback. But none of these were sufficient preparation for the first glimpse of the Others’ true home: a luxurious compound complete with electricity, homemade muffins and a book club, in which Juliet was introduced going about a seemingly everyday life back in the “real” world.

The appearance of Ben and the sight of Oceanic 815 disintegrating in the sky revealed that Juliet and her neighbours were actually the Others, confounding expectations and raising numerous questions about the nature of their civilisation.

This revelation that the Others were in fact miles ahead of the castaways in terms of resources heightened the threat they posed, getting Season Three off to a great start and contributing towards the build-up to all-out war at the season’s conclusion.

9. Alex's Death

From his initial masquerade as Henry Gale, to his ability to weasel out of imprisonment in Locke’s camp, Ben Linus had a lie, excuse or plan for every occasion. Thanks to his thorough knowledge of the Kahana’s crew and their agenda, it seemed that he would be able to outwit and frustrate their attempts to capture him. So it was both shocking and heartbreaking when Ben was finally confronted with a situation that he couldn’t manipulate, as his adopted (or rather abducted) daughter Alex was captured by Martin Keamy’s mercenary team, and Ben was given ten seconds to surrender if he wanted her to live.

Advertisement

True to form, Ben attempted to bluff his way out, claiming that Alex was merely a pawn and meant nothing to him, rounding off by stating that if Keamy wanted to kill Alex, he should “go ahead and do it” - to which Keamy responded by simply shooting Alex in the head.

Ben’s stunned, horrified response showed very clearly that he had once again been lying, and would never be able to take back the cruel words that were his daughter’s last memory.

Alex’s death would be a defining event for Ben, leaving him with dreadful guilt and a thirst for vengeance that would have huge ramifications. It also further humanised one of Lost’s most unsympathetic and untrustworthy characters in a way that would previously have been unthinkable.

8. Locke's Wheelchair

Walkabout, one of the first season’s best episodes, began to shed light on John Locke’s past, and consolidated his position as one of Lost’s most intriguing characters. Through teases and uses of misdirection, such as the case of knives and the “Colonel Locke” phone call, the episode left viewers eager to find out more about the man capable of adapting swiftly to life on the Island, and who had survived an encounter with the Monster. But nothing could have prepared anyone for the shocking reveal that Locke was a wheelchair user before his arrival on the Island, which was cunningly concealed during the flashbacks by means such as having him sitting or lying down.

Advertisement

The twist highlighted just how intelligent and intricate Lost’s scripts were, and demonstrated the Island’s otherworldly power in an unforgettable way. From this point onwards, it was clear that the show was unafraid to take bold creative risks, and that nothing could be taken for granted.

Beyond its wider implications, the wheelchair twist in itself gave considerable emotional depth to Locke’s character, and his reaction to being able to feel and move his legs again was truly moving. This combination of sharp plotting and powerful character work would prove fundamental to Lost’s success.

7. Michael Is Ben's Spy

Given that Ben was able to earn some freedom by divulging the identity of his agent on Widmore’s freighter, and that the confession took place offscreen, it was almost certain that the spy would be a familiar face. Sure enough, the unveiling of the spy’s identity proved to be another memorable twist, as Sayid and Desmond encountered Kevin the deckhand, a man revealed to be none other than Michael, who hadn’t been seen since he departed from the Island having betrayed his friends at the end of Season Two.

Advertisement

Due to Michael’s long absence and the legacy of his treacherous behaviour, his return to Lost was a massive moment and left questions in the air regarding why he had continued to work for Ben, not to mention how his fellow castaways would respond to him. Michael’s journey in Season Four delivered on the promise of his reappearance, following his attempt to atone for his sins by saving his fellow survivors from Widmore’s mercenaries, and culminating in his death while delaying the explosion of Keamy’s bomb.

Michael had been one of Lost’s most complex characters, and his surprise return brought additional emotional weight to the freighter storyline, as well as providing further evidence of Ben’s calculating intelligence.

6. Ethan Is An Other

While the concept of the Others had been previously introduced, they had been depicted as a distant threat, lurking in the jungle. But the shocking conclusion of Raised by Another revealed that the danger was far closer to home.

Advertisement

While Claire’s “nightmares” of being attacked may have brought the Others to mind, the episode cunningly encouraged viewers to believe that her assailant was external, by having Hurley interview the castaways (including the seemingly innocuous Ethan) to create a census. The revelation that Ethan’s name wasn’t on the flight manifest, and that he therefore hadn’t been on the plane, was an absolutely chilling moment, particularly as it was immediately followed by Charlie and Claire’s cliffhanger encounter with the undercover Other (who was at that point sporting one of the creepiest facial expressions in television history).

Raised by Another’s gripping ending demonstrated just how devious and dangerous the Others were, particularly since it led into Claire’s abduction and the attempted murder of Charlie. It also established in memorable fashion that the survivors’ relationship with the Others would be defined by conflict and deceit, thus escalating what would prove to be one of Lost’s most riveting storylines.

5. Desmond Crashed Oceanic 815

It takes a truly great twist to answer not one but two of a show’s biggest unanswered questions. For the entirety of its second season, Lost teased viewers with the question of the Swan button’s purpose, which took on greater weight after Ben claimed that he had failed to push the button in time to no effect. The expedition to the Pearl station seemed to prove that the button was merely part of a psychological experiment, prompting Locke and Desmond to try and ensure that the countdown ran down to zero.

Advertisement

However, Desmond’s examination of the log printout from the Pearl led him to a chilling discovery, as he realised that the occasion when he had previously failed to press the button within the time limit coincided with the crash of Oceanic 815.

The precise cause of the plane crash had been shrouded in mystery since the very beginning, and the discovery that the Swan station’s electromagnetism was responsible represented a massive landmark in Lost’s mythos. It also raised the stakes of Season Two’s finale to apocalyptic levels, by proving that pushing the button was anything but a futile exercise, and that Locke’s attempt to let the clock run down could have lethal consequences for the entire planet.

4. Michael's Killings

The fact that Michael’s reappearance towards the end of Season Two was too good to be true was hardly a surprise. But who could have predicted that the caring father would go so far as to murder Ana Lucia in cold blood in order to free the captured Ben? And just when it seemed as if things couldn’t get any worse, poor Libby arrived at the scene of the murder to fetch some blankets for her picnic with Hurley, earning herself two bullets from Michael in the process.

Advertisement

This horrifying moment revealed just how morally compromised Michael had become in his quest to protect his son, and made it clear that he’d sold his soul while a prisoner of the Others. In the long term, Michael’s guilt would prove to be one of his defining characteristics until (and after) his own death, driving him to suicide attempts and poisoning his relationship with Walt. The survivors’ responses to the deaths were deeply poignant, particularly Hurley’s last moments with the mortally wounded Libby and his eulogy at her grave.

Lost had already proven on multiple occasions that key characters could die in brutal, tragic circumstances. But to kill two at once, particularly as neither had managed to fully achieve closure or happiness, was a particularly shocking move, which stands as one of the show’s most memorably upsetting twists.

3. "Sawyer's My Name Too."

There were few characters in Lost as repugnantly unsympathetic as Anthony Cooper. Responsible for stealing Locke’s kidney and throwing him out of a window, the unscrupulous conman had blighted his son’s life before the Island. But despite Cooper’s utter lack of repentance, Locke still found himself unable to kill his father, even though it prevented him from taking his place among the Others. Fortunately for Locke, he wasn’t the only person on the Island who wanted Cooper dead…

Advertisement

On the basis of information received from a helpful Richard, Locke lured Sawyer to the Black Rock under the pretence of having captured Ben. Once Sawyer had been trapped with Cooper in the ship’s brig, the two began to talk, leading to the jaw-dropping revelation that Cooper had been “Tom Sawyer”, the conman responsible for depriving Sawyer of his parents.

While Lost’s twists were almost always memorable, few carried such personal implications for its characters. The following scene, in which Sawyer gave a callous Cooper the letter that he’d been carrying since his childhood, and finally took his vengeance, represented a huge turning point for both Sawyer and Locke, and was an unforgettably intense piece of television.

2. Locke Was Never Resurrected

Even before Locke’s body was shown in the casket at the funeral home, Lost’s writers hinted that his story might not be over. Through Ben’s insistence that the body be taken back to the Island, and the general unlikelihood of such a pivotal character being killed offscreen, an impression was conveyed that Locke might rise again. Sure enough, the story of Locke’s quest to gather the Oceanic Six, and his eventual death at the hands of a treacherous Ben, was bookended by scenes of a supposedly resurrected Locke on the Island.

Advertisement

It seemed that Locke had finally achieved his destiny, and triumphed over his insecurities and trauma. But the writers had been playing a crafty game, and had a monumental shock in store.

The Season Five finale quickly established that there was something dreadful in the crate recovered from Ajira 316’s hold, thanks to Frank’s memorable reaction to its opening. Even so, it was truly chilling to discover that the crate contained Locke’s body, meaning that Locke had never been resurrected, and that something else had been masquerading as him on the Island. This twist raised the already considerable tension surrounding “Locke” and Ben’s fateful meeting with Jacob to fever-pitch, and gave far greater poignancy to the events of The Life and Death of Jeremy Bentham, by showing that Locke’s tragic, lonely end had not been undone, and that dead really was dead.

1. "We Have To Go Back!"

Through the Looking Glass’ scenes set on the Island represented one of Jack Shephard’s finest hours, as he led a mass exodus from the beach, triumphed over Ben, and finally gave the castaways a chance of getting home by making contact with the freighter. In contrast, the “flashes” depicted Jack living with a substance use disorder and attempting suicide. Thanks to the flashback structure normally featured in Lost, viewers were encouraged to believe that Jack had moved on from this period of despair to become a heroic leader.

Advertisement

Throughout the flashes, Jack had been attempting to get in touch with someone, and arranged a meeting at the start of the final flash. Jack’s mystery contact arrived… and was revealed to be none other than Kate. Lost had brilliantly subverted its usual flashback formula and concealed the fact that the scenes set off-Island were in fact flashforwards, through means such as Jack discussing his father as if he were still alive.

The implications were immense. It showed that the castaways’ efforts to escape from the Island had succeeded, but that this hadn’t represented a happy ending by any means, and left huge questions concerning whether Jack, Kate, and whoever else had managed to leave would indeed “go back.” The realisation that Jack’s mental health had deteriorated to such an extent was devastating, and represented a crucial moment in his painful journey to find peace. This exceptional twist showcased Lost at its best, mixing magnificent plotting with complex, heartfelt character drama.

Advertisement