10 Best Performances In Scrubs

Scrubs: Ranking the ten best actor performances at Sacred Heart.

By Aidan Whatman /

Like all great sitcoms, Scrubs is all about the character, and how each of them change with the show and tackle the often heavy themes thrown their way. The show was a perfect blend of comedy and drama, and though much of that is down to the remarkable writing, none of the show's strongest moments would have been as successful without its wonderful acting talent.

Advertisement

From the core group to supporting characters who helped fill-out the world of Sacred Heart Hospital, Scrubs was bursting with some truly brilliant performances. Whether bringing the comedy full-throttle or keeping the show grounded with some thoughtful musings about life and the everyday, each star brought passion and likeability to their roles.

The following list will take a look at the show's best performers, from the actors who barely stuck around but made one hell of an impression, to the core cast that kept the show moving through its funniest and darkest days. From the motor-mouthed doctor with a heart of gold to the scheming janitor out to cause some chaos, here are the 10 best performances in Scrubs.

10. Brendan Fraser

Brendan Fraser was around only briefly, but his short tenure as Ben Sullivan was enough to make him a fan favourite and the focus of one of Scrubs' most emotionally devastating storylines. Fraser appeared in two episodes during the show's first season, and once more in the third season, where his time on the show was cut brutally short.

Advertisement

But over only three episodes, Fraser proved to be a god-send. Not only did he sell the goofy, lovable nature of photographer Ben, but he also worked wonders alongside John C. McGinley's more intense and brooding Dr Cox.

Ben was a character who loved life, aimed to make people love him and never worried about where he was going or what he was doing. He represented a part of everyone at home, who wanted to cut loose and have some fun, and Fraser sold every second of his goof-ball antics and laidback nature. To see him taken so suddenly will never not hurt.

9. Christa Miller

Though Jordan Sullivan (sister of Ben and ex-wife of Dr Cox) was merely a brief recurring player in the first season, it soon became apparent just how great a character the writers had on their hands, and her role grew with the show.

Advertisement

Christa Miller was the perfect actress to bring Jordan to life. Tough, loyal, honest and blunt, she was a source of great comedy and often acted as a mini-antagonist to the core gang. But under her hard exterior and seemingly unflappable nature, there was always something tragic and moving about the character, and Miller was the master of showing this vulnerability when she needed to.

Jordan's relationship with Perry also gave Miller a chance to stretch her legs and play several roles at once - she was the voice of reason, the brutally honest best friend, the doting mother and the cold enemy. Miller owned every aspect of the character, and Jordan today is rightfully seen as a fan favourite.

8. Michael J. Fox

It took two episodes, but sitcom veteran and all-round Hollywood legend Michael J. Fox didn't need long to prove his salt as a worthy addition to Scrubs. He played Dr Kevin Casey, a brilliant doctor and surgeon who struggled with severe OCD and spent a short while working at Sacred Heart.

Advertisement

In the role, Fox was at first incredibly funny, with the OCD played for laughs, with his one-sided rivalries with Cox and Turk also bringing some solid laughs. But in a shock twist, the whole thing was turned on its head, and JD finds Casey two hours after his last surgery, repeatedly washing his hands and breaking down over his life-changing condition.

It's a powerful turn, switching Casey's easy comedy chops for one of the most impressive scenes in the entire show. In his final episode on the show, he tries to face his fears of using an outside toilet, and once more Fox brings the humour without fault. He may not have been around for long, but he left quite the impression.

7. Sarah Chalke

Though Elliot Reid is quite a divisive character in the Scrubs fandom, there can be no denying that Sarah Chalke was able to bring a great amount of empathy and complexity to the role. Elliot was worried, intense, hopeful, imperfect, even annoying, and beside balancing all her strengths and weaknesses, Chalke also found a way to make Elliot endearing.

Advertisement

Elliot went through a lot on the show, falling in and out of love several times and struggling to find her place at Sacred Heart, and due to this uncertainty and indecisiveness Chalke was able to look under Elliot's worse habits and find a relatable and ultimately human character.

Chalke had a tough job, and there were certainly moments where Elliot was far from likable or out of the loop with the core plot of the show, but Chalke's commitment to crafting a complicated but realistic character deserves to be commended.

6. Neil Flynn

Neil Flynn was a great addition to the show. Whilst J.D, Turk, Cox, Elliot and Carla all had the tough job of balancing humour with drama, Flynn had to play the Janitor as almost pure comedy. In a lot of ways, this was a harder job than the actors that surrounded him, since he had to keep the drama of the show grounded with a never-ending stream of strange and wonderfully odd shenanigans.

Advertisement

According to showrunner Bill Lawrence, Flynn was a master of the ad-lib, and would often make up his own lines on set in order to create a more naturalistic environment for the Janitor's humour to thrive.

Though the Janitor was almost always the most consistent source of comedy in the show, there were moments where Flynn was able to tap into the character's more human side, showing a man who was a bit of a bully, but also a bit of a loner who loved being a part of the hospital. Scrubs wouldn't have been the same without him.

5. Donald Faison

As the best friend of J.D, Turk could quite easily have been the charming sidekick to Zach Braff's awkward protagonist. Whilst this is still very much what Turk is a lot of the time, with Donald Faison behind the character, Turk became a deeply compelling and great leading man in his own right. He appears in more episodes than any other character (joint with Dr Cox).

Advertisement

A brilliant and committed surgeon, Turk was boisterous, confident and cool, but also compassionate and sensitive. Unlike other surgeons, he liked to connect with his patients whenever possible.

Turk's relationships are when Faison best got to show off his talents as both a dramatic and comedic actor. For starters, there's his friendship with J.D, which is goofy, funny, and genuinely sweet. Then there's his romance with Carla, which has its ups and downs and allows for some truly striking moments of well-handled drama. Faison could do it all.

4. Ken Jenkins

I'm going to go out on a limb and say something really bold about Ken Jenkins: He had the toughest job on the show. The reason for this is simple - he was the bad guy. Dr Kelso was cold, cruel, occasionally crass and indifferent to those around him. But he was still somehow hilarious, and it was clear from the get-go there was more to him than met the eye.

Advertisement

Kelso had the hardest job in the hospital, too. Though the other characters didn't like his decisions a lot of the time, as the show wore on it became clear he was always doing everything in his power to keep the hospital to its highest standard. Even if that meant stabbing some people in the back along the way.

The Chief of Medicine was a complex beast, but was clearly a good person underneath his bitter and cynical shell. Jenkins made for a great antagonist, but still played Kelso as a good man at heart. A tough balancing act, but one the actor executed with no issues.

3. Judy Reyes

Carla Espinosa was the backbone of Scrubs throughout her eight-season stint on the show. The head nurse, she was everyone's mentor, and during their times as interns she coached J.D, Turk and Elliot through the hardships of their jobs. She was also one of the few people able to see through Cox's hard exterior, and acted as his voice of reason.

Advertisement

Without Carla, many of the core characters wouldn't have made it very far, and without Judy Reyes, Carla wouldn't have been such a fantastic presence on the show. She was great at her job, loyal to a fault, honest, loving and, yes, often made mistakes.

But Reyes balanced every part of the character with ease, creating a nurse as tough as she was sometimes insecure, and as funny as she was necessary to the lives of those around her. Like Jenkins, she had a hard job, but had no problems knocking it out of the park. One of season nine's many issues was that she was never around.

2. Zach Braff

Speaking of tough jobs, Zach Braff's was certainly no picnic. Not only was J.D the narrator of the show, giving valuable life lessons at the end of each episode and filling in the various plot-points, but he was also the oddest character of the main gang. He daydreamed constantly, was socially awkward, and constantly put his foot in his mouth.

Advertisement

But thanks to Braff's delivery, innocent appearance and general likability, J.D was never too much to handle. His humour was strange, but it was also sharp and lighthearted; and his awkwardness was just part of his charm.

Within the bursts of surreal humour and philosophical musings, J.D also had the best arc on the show. He started the show inexperienced, on edge and out of his element, and soon became the hospital's best doctor. Braff's ability to counter J.D's weird mannerisms with his heartfelt and often tragic arc is astounding to see play-out, making it clear why he received so much praise in the role.

1. John C. McGinley

Faison, Jenkins, Reyes, Braff - they're all amazing in their respective roles, but none quite as great as John C. McGinley. As Dr Perry Cox, McGinley was at once the funniest guy on screen, and the most complicated. A veteran doctor deeply invested in his job, Cox was caged up with his demons and unable to really tap into his true feelings.

Advertisement

McGinley's most iconic trait as Cox was the super-fast delivery of his always hysterical rants and ravings. He could speed through monologues like no one else on the show, but under the bravado had no issues reminding the audience just how vulnerable he really was.

The reason why McGinley never received an Emmy or Golden Globe nomination for his work as Dr Cox will be a mystery until the end of time, but even without the accolades there can be no denying McGinley gave the best performance on the show.

Advertisement