10 Best True Crime Documentaries On Netflix

Extremely wicked, shockingly evil and vile...

By Jamie Kennedy /

Netflix

Whether you're into serial killers (“into” might not be the best wording there, admittedly!), murder mysteries, in-depth analysis on the human psyche, or a combination of all three, Netflix has you covered. There are loads of true crime documentaries that explore some of the grittiest real dramas of all time on the service.

Advertisement

What's really worth your time though? That's the question.

Not everything on this list is strictly new. There are docs and series from yesteryear on here, and there's a simple reason behind that: the Netflix audience has grown exponentially over the past decade, so it'd be remiss not to include some gems you may have missed out on. Don't be fooled by their age; just like the stories they tell, they're the kind of timeless and gripping psychological mindf*cks you're probably after.

Advertisement

You'll find yourself binging a lot too. It's probably just as well some of these films are presented in small, easily-digestible doses, because they're thick on depth. The trick is that many are worth watching more than once. Any good crime story has minor details you'll gloss over on first viewing.

Time to get stuck in.

Advertisement

10. The Staircase

netflix

Unless you've been living under a rock for the past year, you'll have heard at least something about Jean-Xavier de Lestrade's deep dive on loss, secrets and murder mystery. The series was actually launched in 2004, but made its way to Netflix in 2018. Anyone who watched will attest it's been worth the wait.

Advertisement

There's a humanity to The Staircase that's missing from most of the other documentaries included here. That's what sets it apart.

Michael Peterson's tearful and distressed 911 call to emergency services in 2001 after his wife had fallen down the stairs is affecting to hear. This is real human tragedy laced with an undercurrent of whodunit, and it all comes together in an engaging way.

Advertisement

Though Staircase is a bit slow during the early hours, it picks up about halfway through and doesn't let up until all 13 episodes are done. That's the sign of a winning story, even if it does come with a pang of sadness over what happened to Kathleen.

9. Interview With A Serial Killer

Netflix

Before he later died in prison, serial killer Arthur Shawcross agreed to an interview in which he'd lay out the gruesome details of his crimes. This 44-minute horror show is a masochistic ride through the mind of the man who'd become known as the 'Genesee River Killer'.

Advertisement

It's depressingly grim, but then you would've already guessed that.

One of the more fascinating parts comes when Shawcross describes his troublesome childhood. The amazing thing here is that his family maintain his upbringing was normal, and they suggest his ramblings are the result of delusion. That's downright scary, especially when Arthur then seems to lean on his behavioural problems as a child for his murders.

Advertisement

In total, the man killed between 12-15 people, some of whom were children. This, as bleak as it is, is an essential watch for anyone studying psychological patterns or analysing how one's adolescence (right or wrong) forms adulthood.

8. The Confession Tapes

Netflix

If you're one for playing detective, then you'll lose yourself in 2017's The Confession Tapes.

Advertisement

Twists and turns are the order of the day here. There's a brain-teasing mix of false evidence, misdirections and hard, solid evidence to keep things interesting across seven episodes and six unique murder cases. The bizarre 1994 murder of Atif Rafay's family, and the mystery behind it, is a red-hot way to open things up.

Later episodes look at everything from house fires and burglaries to retracted confessions, rapes and automobile slayings. Throughout, Confession Tapes is an addictive look into genuine drama that skips glamourisation in favour of showing how harrowing human life can be behind closed doors.

Advertisement

If you enjoyed The Keepers (another worthwhile series that just failed to land a spot on the list), then you'll go all in on this one. The zippy pace and multiple-case format keeps things moving along; it's impossible to be bored.

7. Out Of Thin Air

Netflix

Shocking, thrilling and puzzling. Those are all words that could be used to perfectly describe what Out Of Thin Air is all about. Prepare to scratch your head along with Icelandic police as they attempt to piece together what happened to two separate men in the span on 10 months in 1974.

Advertisement

When both Guðmundur Einarsson and Geirfinnur Einarsson (no relation) mysteriously disappeared, police were put under pressure to find the culprit(s). Their intense digging and prodding resulted in six different young men confessing to the crimes despite being unable to recall them happening.

Spooky.

Advertisement

There's a thread of injustice about this doc. It shows, more than 40 years on from the unexplained disappearances, why confessions aren't always the be all and end all of crime. Anyone looking for a unique twist on typical mystery will find a lot to love.

6. The Innocent Man

Netflix

Anyone looking for a unique twist on typical mystery will find a lot to love.

Advertisement

We might as well repeat that sentence for this entry, because the tale of ex-baseball player Ronald Keith Williamson's incarceration is intense. He was arrested and charged with the rape and murder of Debra Carter in 1988, then released from prison more than a decade later in 1999.

Based on the non-fiction book by writer John Grisham, The Innocent Man is an often-thought provoking snapshot look at how police corruption and the need to tag a felon can lead to disaster. In some respects, this is a commentary on how the entire law system is flawed, and it makes one feel for Williamson.

Advertisement

The Innocent Man might have been higher on the list had it not relied on an opening that makes it seem like HBO's next big series. That's a rare downside in a six-parter which gets one's brain ticking with a sense of cruel malpractice from police.

5. I Am A Killer

Netflix

Arguably the only downside to I Am A Killer is that you'll need a US Netflix account to see it. Currently, it's unavailable in the UK, unless you have a Sky, BT or Virgin TV package and happen to have the Crime & Investigation channel. Even then, you'd have missed the boat by now.

Advertisement

That's a shame, because the show is one of the single best true crime series to ever air.

Interviews are the name of the game here. Death row inmates are quizzed on their crimes, and asked to give their thoughts on why they did what they did. Most make no attempt to cover their tracks, save face or protest their innocence, and the result is some eye-opening insight into detained criminals about to pay the ultimate penalty.

Advertisement

The stories, whilst disturbing and terrifying, are engrossing. Killers like Kenneth Foster, Charles Victor Thompson (who contributes to the 'Between The Bars' blog from solitary confinement on death row) and Wayne Doty go under the microscope, amongst others, in the series 10 episodes. If you can find it, or whenever Netflix bring it to the UK, it's a must-watch.

4. Evil Genius

Netflix

Evil Genius only lasts for four episodes and has a total runtime of approx three hours, so it's the ideal binge-watch for anyone interested in crime. The cool thing about the mini-series is that it doesn't become bogged down with telling what happened to Brian Wells' in 2003. Instead, it puts keen focus on the case and surrounding circumstances instead.

Advertisement

That's welcome considering the four-parter's relatively short length.

It also means the filmmakers can concentrate more on the 'why' rather than the 'what happened'. The attention shifts to the motivations of those who carried out the bank heist Wells ended up being caught in the crossfire of, and that helps it move along at a searing speed.

Advertisement

Some have opined that Evil Genius would have been better had it slowed down, protracted each minor detail's examination and maybe added a few more episodes so the directors didn't rush. That's a fair point, but they do a fine job of telling the story in a condensed, almost-movie like way.

3. Abducted In Plain Sight

Netflix

Before describing what Abducted In Plain Sight is, here's a little test: take 30 seconds to think of the most bizarre 'growing up' story you can. Got one? Good. Now, scrap that and bow in awe of what actress Jan Broberg went through in her childhood. It, for lack of a better term, was absolutely incredible.

Advertisement

As a bright-eyed young kid, Broberg was abducted and sexually abused by her adult neighbour more than once. Making things even more horrific, her parents kinda' had a sense for what was going on, but even their criminally absent parenting can't prepare viewers for what happens next.

There's religion, there's talk of aliens, and there's outright kidnapping, and that's just the start.

Advertisement

Hearing Jan's father Bob say, “I tell you, I don’t know how we could have been so gullible when there were so many red flags”, is infuriating. Abducted is the kind of documentary that'll either have you bawling your eyes out at how horrible the world is or punching the TV.

2. The Ted Bundy Tapes

Netflix

The upcoming movie based on Ted Bundy's life (starring Zac Efron) will either be a smartly-scripted classic or an insensitive train wreck. If Hollywood's upcoming glitzy take on one of the world's most viciously cold serial killers doesn't sound informative enough for you, then check out Conversations With A Killer: The Ted Bundy Tapes on Netflix.

Advertisement

Why not? Everyone else is, and they're finding a stomach-churning yarn is waiting for them.

Bundy's murder-fuelled romp through Idaho, Utah, Colorado and Florida is the stuff of nightmares. His 30+ murders (all of young women) are one thing, but it's the trial period that'll really have you reaching for the sick bag. Throughout, Ted's sickening charm and delusions of self-grandeur are nauseating.

Advertisement

The way he escaped prison, manipulated the law system and generally got away with behaving like a real-life Joker for years is terrifying. These Tapes take viewers through Bundy's murders, his arrests, his trial and (eventually) his death row fate.

1. Making A Murderer

Netflix

We've left the longest until last.

Advertisement

Making A Murderer crosses two seasons. The first caused such a stir when it launched in late-2015 that a follow-up was perhaps inevitable, assuming the filmmakers could find enough material. Thankfully for them, the life of Steven Avery is busy and controversial enough that they could probably produce a third if they so wished.

Almost everyone perusing through this list will know a few things about Avery's story. His 18-year stay in prison for supposed attempted murder and sexual assault dips into the same kind of judicial corruption as earlier examples Out Of Thin Air and The Innocent Man, but it goes even deeper than both. Seriously, Making is immersive, so brace yourself to dedicate some time if you want to squeeze the most out of it.

Advertisement

His re-arrest between 2005-2007 is similarly interesting, and the second series' focus on appeals against Avery's incarceration give the story yet more life. This is simply one of the greatest and most exhaustive true crime docs out there.

What other true crime docs on Netflix would you recommend? Let us know down in the comments section below!

Advertisement