10 Buffy Actors Who Went On To Great Things

The Buffyverse has some very successful alumni.

By Jay Anderson /

Buffy the Vampire Slayer was known for tight writing full of witticisms, in jokes, and pop culture references, to the point that the show has been dissected and taught on college campuses and remains a huge influence on modern television. Yet its acting talent has been sorely overlooked over the years. The cast were tasked with delivering some clever yet difficult dialogue, and had to ensure that viewers bought into the serious, dramatic nature of the show regardless of the ridiculously unreal events unfolding on screen - and at that they were quite successful. The fact that they succeeded in making a show with such a ludicrous title and premise a hit that both entertained viewers and tugged at their heartstrings is an outstanding achievement, and a testament to their skill, which continues to be seen, in many cases, today. While series star Sarah Michelle Gellar never quite reached the same heights, with her most notable appearances since Buffy ended being in the Scooby-Doo franchise and the Grudge movies, others have fared much better. From guest stars to regular cast members, Buffy in many cases served as a breeding ground for acting talent. Now lets take a at ten Buffy actors (fine, fine, one is technically from the spin-off Angel) who excelled after the show came to an end.

10. Kal Penn

You probably didn't notice Kal Penn on Buffy the Vampire Slayer. He appeared as a guest star - basically an unknown one, at the time - in the fourth season episode Beer Bad. That's the one where Buffy takes to drinking beer just a little too fondly, only to turn into a cave-woman version of herself - and her fellow bar patrons cavemen - when a warlock spikes their brew of choice. That wasn't Penn's only tour of duty in the Buffyverse. He also turned up on Angel, in the 2001 episode That Vision Thing, playing a mystic keeping a rather icky secret under his hat (his exposed brain). Since then, of course, Penn turned up in Van Wilder as Taj (which resulted in him taking a starring role in its sequel, subtitled The Rise of Taj), House, and, of course, was Kumar in the Harold and Kumar trilogy. That would be a pretty solid career to date even if you chose to overlook the fact that for a time, Penn quit acting to join the Obama administration as an Associate Director in the White House Office of Public Engagement. After leaving that role, he was later appointed (in 2013) to the President's Committee on the Arts and Humanities. Not bad for a guy who started out playing drunks and stoners.

9. Jeremy Renner

Jeremy Renner did not appear on Buffy. He did, however, appear as a guest star in spin-off series Angel, as Penn, a former protege of the show's titular character. That puts him squarely in the Buffy universe (or Buffyverse, if you will). You'll find that episode, Somnambulist, way back in 2000. At the time, he was a complete unknown. That makes him a Joss Whedon guy, and Joss Whedon takes care of his guys. So when Whedon took the helm of The Avengers franchise for the first two films in the series, it was no surprise when Renner was cast as Hawkeye. That said, Renner has done more that just tag along with the creative genius that is Whedon. Between working on Angel and re-teaming with Whedon, he appeared in 28 Weeks Later, and the award winning The Hurt Locker. More recently, he has also held his own in the Mission: Impossible series alongside Tom Cruise, and stepped into the Bourne franchise.

8. Charisma Carpenter

Main cast on Buffy, and leading lady on its spin-off Angel, Charisma Carpenter has done quite well for herself over the years. Her character growth as Cordelia Chase was the most pronounced of any character in the Buffyverse during her run on the two shows, making her beloved to fans. After leaving Angel following the show's fourth season (though she did turn up for season five's Thank You), Carpenter went on to take a role in another popular series on the CW, Veronica Mars. Though it lasted just a few seasons, Veronica Mars made enough of an impact to be resurrected via a Kickstarter campaign thanks to fan interest, which spawned a big screen outing. Carpenter also appeared in the Expendables franchise, alongside Jason Statham.

7. Pedro Pascal

Another season four alum from Buffy the Vampire Slayer. If you don't know the name Pedro Pascal, you might be better acquainted with him as Oberyn Martell, who takes up the sword to defend Tyrion Lannister in trial by combat, and take on The Mountain to avenge his sister's death in HBO's Game of Thrones. Pascal is frankly unrecognizable in The Freshman, the very first episode of Buffy's fourth year, which sees the Slayer transitioning to college. He plays a fellow student, Eddie, who feels as lost as Buffy herself, and who keeps the novel Of Human Bondage near him at all times as a security blanket. Soon enough, he's vampire fodder - and becomes one himself. Since Buffy, Pascal (who was credited as Pedro Balmaceda) has had recurring roles in The Good Wife, Graceland, The Mentalist, Narcos, and, of course, Game of Thrones - making him very successful in series television.

6. Amy Adams

Amy Adams made her film debut in 1999's Drop Dead Gorgeous, so she wasn't exactly unknown when she appeared on Buffy the Vampire Slayer the following year - but she wasn't really known, either. She was, basically, an actress with a couple of decent credits who filled a role - that of Beth, Tara's cruel, self-serving cousin in the season five episode Family. Adams would go on to acclaim in the film Catch Me If You Can alongside Leonardo DiCaprio following Buffy and other T.V. work. She would then appear in Tenacious D and the Pick of Destiny, Talladega Nights: The Ballad of Ricky Bobby, and this little film called Man of Steel, where she portrayed Lois Lane. She'll be in Batman vs. Superman next, and has pulled double duty as a singer as well, contributing songs to several soundtracks. Oh, and four Oscar nominations are nothing to sneeze at either!

5. Nathan Fillion

Including Nathan Fillion feels like a cheat, since he appeared on Firefly first, but Fillion was very much a part of Buffy's world as the dark priest Caleb in the seventh and final season of the show. Fillion was strong as the minion of the First Evil - but of course not as strong as Buffy and her gang in the end. Fillion was a known name after starring alongside Ryan Reynolds in Two Guys, a Girl, and a Pizza Place (later renamed to Two Guys and a Girl) prior to working with Whedon, but he has still had a great deal of success since his Buffy and Firefly days, with a recurring role on Desperate Housewives, the role of Captain Hammer in Dr. Horrible's Sing-A-Long Blog (the best thing Whedon has ever done) - and, of course, the starring role in ABC's Castle. And there's always hope among the Browncoats for another Firefly resurrection.

4. Danny Strong

Danny Strong played the geeky Sunnydale high school student (and later, a well-meaning sometimes super-villain) Jonathan for six seasons on Buffy the Vampire Slayer (he did not appear in any of the first season episodes, but was in the unaired pilot). Originally having auditioned for the role of Xander, while he didn't land the part, Joss Whedon and the folks at Mutant Enemy liked him enough to keep him around in a smaller role. These days, Strong is double fisting Emmy awards and writing the final Hunger Games movies. See, great things doesn't always have to mean on-screen success. While he did go on to a recurring role on Gilmore Girls after Buffy, Strong has had much more success behind the scenes. He wrote screenplays for both Mockingjay movies, and is co-creator of the Fox show Empire. His dual Emmy wins, meanwhile, came from the HBO film Game Change, which picked up Outstanding Miniseries or Movie, and Outstanding Writing for a Miniseries or Movie awards. You go, Jonathan!

3. Clea DuVall

It was easy to miss Clea DuVall on Buffy in the first season episode Out of Sight, Out of Mind - after all, she was the girl that turned invisible, complete with Marty McFly-esque special effects. That brief appearance was one of DuVall's first acting credits. Since the 1997 episode, she appeared in the cult horror/sci-fi flick The Faculty, the teen hit Can't Hardly Wait, the acclaimed Girl, Interrupted, and starred in series like HBO's Carnivale, Heroes, American Horror Story, and recently turned up in Better Call Saul. Interestingly, while she has stayed close to her genre roots, she has been one of those rare actors not pigeonholed into the horror/sci-fi realm, and does great work both inside and outside of it.

2. David Boreanaz

When Angel came to an end, you had to wonder whether David Boreanaz would be type-cast as his vampire alter-ego forever. After taking the lead in Valentine's Day, a corny horror outing, while still on the show, and appearing in a bad Crow sequel afterwards, it seemed like that might be the case. Then along came Bones, and Boreanaz's role as Special Agent Booth. He has now played the part, to much fanfare, for over ten years, taking the odd project on the side as well. At this point, Boreanaz is better known for Booth than he is for Angel, despite all the love for everything Whedon and Buffy. That's quite the feat!

1. Alyson Hannigan

Alyson Hannigan was already breaking out as a star while on Buffy, thanks to appearing in American Pie (you know the line, we don't need to say it... okay, this one time, at band camp!). So it's no surprise that she would go on to another hit show, along with some successful side trips along the way. After Buffy ended in 2003, Hannigan would reprise her role of Willow for the animated series that sadly never got off the ground. She continued appearing in the American Pie movies, and even turned up alongside Charisma Carpenter over on Veronica Mars. Of course, her biggest achievement would be How I Met Your Mother, which is now the show she is arguably better known for than Buffy. Now that How I Met Your Mother has come to an end, maybe it's time Whedon and Hannigan teamed up again? Just a thought...