10 Buffy The Vampire Slayer Episodes That Changed Everything

TV would never be the same again.

By Jay Anderson /

It was a show that never should have worked, with a ludicrous premise and a name that almost no one could take seriously. And it was based on a failed motion picture. Despite that, Buffy accomplished a lot in seven years. While it was never a ratings juggernaut, the cult hit had such a dedicated fan following that when it was up for renewal, a bidding war between networks erupted, and the show jumped from the WB to the then-fledgling network UPN for $2.3 million per episode, more than twice what the WB had paid for Buffy. At the time of its airing, Buffy was hugely influential in the world of television, and that hasn't changed even to this day. It was so influential that a Slate poll from 2012 found it to be the television show most studied by Academics, and there have been entire courses built around it, not to mention countless essays, and even several published works about the series and its influence. Not to mention plenty of shows following in its footsteps. With all that in mind, it's worthwhile to examine cases where Buffy the Vampire Slayer wasn't just a great show - but where it changed, well, everything for the television landscape.

10. Welcome To The Hellmouth

It's hard not to include mention of Buffy's very first episode, Welcome to the Hellmouth, when talking about how the show changed everything. The launch of Buffy was notable for a couple reasons: what it became (a cult hit) and where it came from - after all, Buffy the Vampire Slayer had already been a failed feature film featuring Kristie Swanson and Donald Sutherland. It also brought with it a new-found passion for pop culture references, something which, to that point, was nearly unheard of in prime time television. Buffy's unleashing changed all that, and many shows would follow suit in the coming years. Buffy, however, was the catalyst.

9. Passion

The killing of a main, or beloved, character is nothing new in the post Game of Thrones landscape. And to be fair, Game of Thrones (which is mostly following the source material) isn't the first show to kill off a key character - it just seems to take a certain amount of glee in it, or George R.R. Martin does anyway. In any case, the world of Buffy seemed somewhat secure as far as main characters and key supporting cast members went, at least until Passion came along in the second season. In the episode, Angel, Buffy's love interest in the early years, kills the popular Sunnydale High computer teacher Jenny Calendar, lover of Rupert Giles. Or more accurately, his evil side, Angelus does. Either way, the character, beloved by fans at that point, wound up dead, and suddenly Buffy had announced that it was a take no prisoners sort of show. Afterwards, all bets were off. To that point, "teen" dramas had stayed away from carnage that dark (Angelus goes so far as to place Calendar's body in Giles' apartment, surrounded by flower petals as if for a romantic evening, to torture the man further). Buffy proved that "teen" dramas (though whether it really counts as one is debatable) were capable of being as twisted as anything else on television. And it proved that it was no longer just for teens.

8. New Moon Rising

It's hard to pinpoint just when and where Willow and Tara became a thing, but we're giving credit to New Moon Rising for really changing things: on the show, and in the television landscape. To that point, gay couples had been one note stereotypes, or comic relief, when it came to network television. However, in the fourth season of Buffy the Vampire Slayer, after her werewolf musician boyfriend Oz (Seth Green) left town to try and cure his condition, Willow embarked on a romantic journey with fellow U.C. Sunnydale student (and witch) Tara. In New Moon Rising, Oz returns to Sunnydale, having learned to control his monthly transformation - yet Willow is full on in love with Tara by then, and chooses her over her ex. While many would point to this episode as key because it marked one of Seth Green's final appearances on the show (he would be in just one more, Restless, at the end of the season), the real reason it changed everything was that for perhaps the first time on a major show, a character was forced to choose between a same-sex love interest and an old flame of the opposite sex - and validated the hope the LGBT community had placed in the character when she was first portrayed as gay.

7. Touched

Speaking of impact when it comes to the portrayal of gay characters on television, it wasn't until Buffy's seventh and final season that the show portrayed a full-blown lesbian sex scene. Network television's first lesbian love scene (though cable beat them to the punch) took place during during Touched, and featured newcomer Kennedy taking the lead with Willow, whose original love interest, Tara, had perished the previous season. While episodes like Once More, With Feeling hinted at this, Touched was the first to openly show love-making between a same-sex couple, and while it seems unthinkable today, with the proliferation of HBO and other cable networks more than willing to push boundaries, the episode caused quite a stir when it aired back in 2003. The first lesbian sex scene on network television: another Buffy first.

6. Restless

Beyond bizarre, in a format that should not have worked on television - that's the best way to describe season four's finale, Restless. "You think you know what's to come, what you are. You haven't even begun." That quote, care of Tara in a dream of Buffy's, is just one of many hidden references foreshadowing the coming years of Buffy the Vampire Slayer. In fact, the entire episode, which features the dreams of each of the show's main characters, is riddled with clues to the future of the Slayer and her pals. Plus a guy who keeps showing up with cheese. It's almost unheard of that a television show would plan episodes that far ahead, especially on network TV where the axe of cancellation can swing swiftly down at any given moment, but Buffy did just that - plan plot points years in advance. Restless also features a clock alluding to Buffy's death the following season, and the line "Be back before Dawn" - a reference to the arrival of her sister, which had been planned since at least the third season (as had Buffy's death). It featured additional references to happenings as late as the seventh season, however - and set the bar for foreshadowing and plotting in advance for all shows.

5. The Gift

Killing off characters, sure - but killing off a main character? Now that's breaking new ground. Buffy's eventual death was foretold as early as the show's third season (and that's discounting the fact that she technically drowned in the show's first season, though as she would later put it, only for a minute!). In that season's finale, Graduation Day Part 2, Faith would tell the Slayer (in a shared dream) "Miles to go, little Miss Muffet, counting down from 7-3-0" in response to Buffy saying there was something she had to be doing. What was it she had to be doing? Dying. "Miles to go" of course is from Frost's Stopping By The Woods On A Snowy Evening, and the full line (miles to go before I sleep - which had appeared in Buffy at least once before) is commonly thought to refer to death. Little Miss Muffet represents Buffy herself, of course, and 730? Well, that happens to be the number of days in two years - and it was 730 days later when Buffy actually did die on the show, in the fifth season finale The Gift. It was at that point that the show would switch networks, arguably at its peak (the fifth season is generally the show's most beloved).

4. Buffy Vs. Dracula

Retconning (basically the process of changing the established history of a work of fiction) is a familiar term in the comic book world, but in television circles, it wasn't normally done - at least not until Buffy was given a sister who was treated as if she had been on the show all along, despite only turning up in the fifth season. Fans were left in the dark as to who Dawn was (other than Buffy's sister) and just why she was there, with no explanation immediately given. It was simply presented as established fact: Buffy had a sister. Buffy vs. Dracula marks her first appearance, though the season's second episode is her real introduction. Either way, it was an addition that really did change everything, and moving forward, shows were much more willing to take risks with continuity (Fringe being a great example).

3. Hush

You don't realize how much episodic television is dialog driven until all that chatter is gone. Season four's brilliant Hush took away speech, and left the characters of the show to rely solely on emotion, facial expression, hand gestures, and occasionally, the written word to communicate - both with one another, and with the audience watching. And it worked fantastically, to the point that it is recognized as one of the best episodes of the series. It's also recognized as a spectacular feat of storytelling. It earned Buffy an Emmy nomination for Best Writing, despite an almost total lack of dialog - now that's impressive.

2. The Body

Death is never easy. It's also - normally - not very realistically portrayed on TV, especially in action-based shows. Almost never does it have any real impact. Someone is shot, loved ones mourn, tune in next week. Rarely does a show dwell on death - on a particular death - for long. Certainly not for an entire episode, yet that's exactly what Buffy did with The Body, creating in the process one of the most realistic, genuine portrayals of the most inevitable conclusion to life: death. Buffy's discovery of her mother's body - dead not from the forces of evil, but from an aneurysm following brain surgery - changed the makeup of the show completely. And it changed how a lot of fans viewed death. With a younger audience, few Buffy viewers had been confronted with the reality of a body, the body of a loved one, in their home. How time slows (as it often does in an emergency), how even the most seasoned veterans can fail to act. And how when it's all said and done, the mundane details are still there, the papers to be filled out, the well-meaning but ultimately inconsequential condolences to be accepted. The choice to eliminate the usual score, and go forward with just dialog and the odd sound effect, hammered the reality of the situation home. Somehow, a zany show about vampires managed to portray one of the most accurate examinations of death seen on television.

1. Once More, With Feeling

A TV show doing a musical, where all the characters sing? You mean Glee, right? No, Buffy did the musical thing long before a show was dedicated to it. Now, to be fair, Buffy wasn't the first show to try it: The Simpsons did it (of course they did), though it was more musical numbers in regular episodes; That 70s Show did it the year before Buffy. Ally McBeal beat Joss Whedon to the punch a full three years earlier. Several shows had tried it through the decades. Yet when Buffy did it, it was a momentous occasion, for a number of reasons: For starters, the cast of the show did all their own singing (and dancing, in some cases). And several of them (Anthony Stewart Head, James Marsters, Amber Benson) were actually quite good. For another, the show's creator, Joss Whedon, wrote and composed the entire episode - all original numbers. Even then, if that was the only standout quality of the episode, it might not rank as an episode where Buffy "changed everything" - but the episode was actually really, incredibly good, in terms of plot, and in the way it moved the storyline of the season forward. Read: it wasn't just a gimmick. In fact, it was key - and the way music was used, as something of a curse where characters bared their souls, was ingenious. In perhaps the most important moment of the season, Buffy admits to her friends that they did not save her from hell when they brought her back from the dead, but rather ripped her out of heaven - then breaks into song with "give me something to sing about!" to hammer the point home. Countless shows have tried to go the musical route since, no doubt inspired by the cult following this episode created (which included Rocky Horror like public viewings with audience interaction, and a soundtrack album) but none have come close to equaling it. It opened the door for them to try, however.