10 Celebrity Guests Who Should've Stayed In South Park

Brief cameos which could've been turned into extended residencies...

By Daniel Wylie /

Celebrities passing through cartoon locales is one of the hallmarks of Adult Animation. For much of its early run The Simpsons was an example of cameos done well. However, in later seasons, guest stars were used to generate easy publicity. Many point to an over-reliance on such cameos as a key reason for the show’s steep decline. The infamous Lisa Goes Gaga is a damning indictment of this.

Advertisement

South Park has a different approach to celebrity cameos. As they rarely involve the person being lampooned, Trey Parker and Matt Stone do not have the hardship of having a celebrity ego to flatter, and are free to create a fully realised satire of the person’s public image. The celebrities often fit into South Park so well that they could become regular characters, in a similar vein to Adam West being Mayor of Quahog in Family Guy.

Tom Cruise and Al Gore have had successful multiple episode arcs in South Park. However, there are many more characters in the South Park Hall of Shame who could become series regulars.

Note: Appearances as background characters with little added to a character's in-world story arc have been omitted for length.

10. Malcolm McDowell

Episode(s) appeared in: Pip (Season 4, Episode 14)

Advertisement

Malcolm McDowell was the narrator of what many fans consider to be the worst episode of South Park. The only regular character featured was Pip. Shortly after this episode he was relegated to a background character with Butters stepping in his place to serve a similar role.

The episode Pip was an adaptation of Charles Dickens’ Great Expectations, with Pip playing the character who inspired his name. Regardless of anything else, McDowell as a narrator was perfect, lending both an authority and a wry humour to the episode.

Malcolm McDowell, like most successful British actors of a certain age, is a talented narrator. His voice could add class to even the crassest goings on in South Park. McDowell deserves to narrate a more memorable script. As the man who brought to life one of literature and cinema’s most terrifying characters (Alex in A Clockwork Orange) he would be the perfect narrator for Halloween episodes, adding some horror credentials to the humour. McDowell’s guest appearances are diverse: CSI: Miami, Fallout 3, and Slipknot’s Snuff music video, to name a small sample of his work.

9. Sinéad O'Connor

Episode(s) appeared in: Taming Strange (Season 17, Episode 5)

Advertisement

To parody Miley Cyrus’ transition from a Disney child star to asserting her maturity with sexualised and exhibitionist stunts, Foofa from Yo Gabba Gabba! was used as a stand-in. Foofa concluded she needed to start playing to older audiences and must be edgier and sexier to do so. Mocking the singer’s real-life unsolicited advice to Cyrus, Foofa’s castmates brought Sinéad O'Connor to talk to Foofa. O’Connor implored Foofa not to “sell [her] strange to those corporate b*****ds” and joined the rest of the Yo Gabba Gabba! cast in singing a song entitled Don’t Show Your Strange on TV.

In the age of cancel culture, O’Connor’s controversial photo tearing antics, once shocking, is now the perfect parody. Also, South Park O’Connor would be the perfect antagonist for President Garrison. After converting to Islam, O’Connor used Twitter to refer to non-Muslims as “disgusting” and expressed that she no longer wished to spend time with “white people”. Trey and Matt have proven adept at both questioning Islam and mocking celebrities who hijack belief systems and movements for clout. Fun Fact: O’Connor even managed to provoke Prince into a fist fight.

8. Michael Dorn

Episode(s) appeared in: Fun with Veal (Season 6, Episode 4)

Advertisement

Actor Michael Dorn is best known as Lieutenant Commander Worf in Star Trek: The Next Generation and Star Trek: Deep Space Nine. Straddling the line between the real actor and his fictional character, Michael Dorn appeared on South Park in full Klingon make-up while wearing a Pasadena City College sweater, Dorn’s real-life alma mater.

When the boys kidnapped baby cows, the FBI were forced to negotiate with them. Cartman added to the list of demands that he wanted "the guy who plays Worf on Star Trek" to drive their getaway vehicle. The FBI bowed to their demands. Dorn drove the vehicle and seethed quietly as Cartman requested that Dorn refer to him as “captain”.

Klingons are one of the most visually recognisable and iconic races in the whole sci-fi canon, close enough to human for an audience to relate but odd enough to stand out. Dorn’s appearance finds humour in the juxtaposition of Worf outside of the show's setting. This could’ve turned into a running gag. However, the time may have passed. Since the character’s appearance on South Park, Dorn has lent his voice to two episodes of former rival show Family Guy.

7. Yoko Ono

Episode(s) appeared in: World Wide Recorder Concert (Season 3, Episode 17)

Advertisement

Yoko Ono, John Lennon’s widow and celebrated artist in her own right, appeared as the special guest conductor for “the musical event of the millennium”. Along with multi-instrumentalist Kenny G, she planned to lead four million third grade students in playing America (My Country, ‘Tis of Thee) on the recorder.

Throughout the episode Yoko largely spoke gibberish and became more aggressive as the combined incompetence of millions of children grew. The event was ruined when The Boys discovered the brown noise (92ȼ below the lowest E-flat) and accidently caused everybody on Earth to “crap their pants”. Some to death.

Yoko Ono is better known today as a conceptual artist. Conceptual art and South Park are almost opposites. The creation and appreciation of conceptual art is the kind of thinking South Park lacerates with its blunt, yet still creative, parodies. Just because the little mountain town lacks culture, doesn’t mean its residents would be thankful for it being gifted to them. How would the town react to her displaying painted ladders and blurred photographs of her assassinated husband as fine art?

6. Christopher Reeve

Episode(s) appeared in: Krazy Kripples (Season 7, Episode 2)

Advertisement

The former Superman actor appeared in South Park to advocate for stem cell research, however, his ghoulish interpretation of the science involved him consuming foetuses by ripping off their heads and sucking out the “juices”.

In classic South Park fashion, political correctness, and a dose of patronisation, had the town’s population hail Reeve as an inspiration. Reeve soon becomes the antithesis of ‘The Man of Steel’ when his consumption of foetuses not only returns his body to full health, but also gives him supervillain ambitions. After knocking up a Legion of Doom lair quicker than Chinese efficiency can build a hospital, it is left to Gene Hackman, the Lex Luthor opposite Reeve’s Superman, to put an end to his foe’s “foetus sucking days”.

Though Reeve passed away in 2004, South Park’s supervillain version had the curative power of aborted foetuses. Reeve could live on in South Park taking advantage of his status as an “inspiration” to mask all kinds of evil. Butters as Professor Chaos does his best to provide a supervillain antagonist to The Coon and Friends, however, he lacks direction. Reeve would be an ideal mentor for the budding supervillain.

5. Oprah

Episode(s) appeared in: A Million Different Fibres (Season 10, Episode 5)

Advertisement

When a celebrity’s South Park interpretation is the most bizarre aspect of an episode also featuring an anthropomorphic stoner towel, it’s evident that Matt and Trey have took the parody to a unique place. In-world Oprah wrestled with some unique body issues.

Mingey, her vagina, and Gary, her anus, both gained sentience and British accents somewhere along the way. The duo bemoaned that Oprah, distracted by her career, paid them no attention. When their plot to derail Oprah’s success failed, Mingey pulled a gun on a crowd, shooting a police officer in the process. In the chaos, Gary was hit by a sniper, and Mingey took their own life in grief.

Oprah’s depiction was bizarre even by the show’s own standards. The addition of Mingey and Gary was a leftfield joke at the expense of Oprah’s busy schedule, the type only Trey and Matt could pull off, or would even dream up in the first place. Call me curious, but I want to know more about the origins of Mingey and Gary. Also how does a person cope in the wake of the suicide of their genitals in response to their anus’ death by police shooting?

4. Robert Smith

Episode(s) appeared in: Mecha-Streisand (Season 1 Episode 12)

Advertisement

In one of the show's early successes with celebrity cameos, Mecha-Streisand, a giant robotic dinosaur incarnation of singer Barbara Streisand, threatened to destroy the little mountain town. When both film critic/historian Leonard Maltin, in giant robot form, and distinguished actor Sidney Poitier, transformed into a giant turtle, failed to take down Mecha-Streisand, all hope appeared lost.

Until the arrival of The Cure frontman Robert Smith, metamorphosed into a giant moth. He defeated Mecha-Streisand with a punch to her weak spot, her nose. The show heaped praise on Smith. Kyle declared “Disintegration is the best album ever”, Cartman acknowledged that “Robert Smith kicks ass”, and Jesus Christ gave him the ultimate accolade of “Our Saviour”

Robert Smith is in the exclusive club of celebrities depicted positively in South Park. He is idolised in the mountain town. Smith deserves to live in a place where even ten-year-olds appreciate The Cure. Likewise, The Goth Kids deserve to meet the king of gothic rock and be gifted with a genuine moment of happiness. Not that it would require any extra facial animations. Also, we don’t have enough characters in western animation that can turn into giant monsters.

3. R. Kelly

Episode(s) appeared in: Trapped in the Closet (Season 9, Episode 12)

Advertisement

After Stan was hailed as the second coming of Scientology founder L. Ron Hubbard, his words carried weight with the celebrity members of the church/cult/possible practical joke. When Stan revealed he didn’t care for Tom Cruise as an actor, the Mission Impossible star locked himself inside Stan’s bedroom closet. R. Kelly was drafted in to persuade Cruise to come out. He sang his lines and was brandishing a gun in a parody of his rap-opera Trapped in the Closet. R. Kelly quickly found himself in the closet too.

When he was depicted in the 2005-episode, R. Kelly was spared much mockery, even though at the time he had been indicted on child pornography charges. Also, an alleged video of him urinating on a girl had surfaced. Since R. Kelly’s appearance in South Park his life has taken an even darker turn. R. Kelly is currently incarcerated for a litany of sex crimes, exposed in depth by the docu-series Surviving R. Kelly.

Trey and Matt are notable for their dark humour and R. Kelly deserves a skewering. Plus, the in-world R. Kelly communicates in song form, whilst Matt and Trey have proven themselves as talented musical writers, with The Book of Mormon being a glaring example.

2. Vince McMahon

Episode(s) appeared in: WFT (Season 13, Episode 10)

Advertisement

After WWE Live rolled into South Park, the boys decided their futures lie in professional wrestling. After an awkward mistake led them to their school wrestling club, they set up their own backyard wrestling promotion – Wrestling Takedown Federation. Their outrageous storylines and their acting ability, rather than any athletic talent, lured Vince McMahon, the owner of the world’s largest wrestling promotion to South Park.

After the shunned wrestling teacher failed to assassinate McMahon with a rocket launcher, he won the crowd over with an impassioned rant about the boys taking his job. Thinking this was part of the show, McMahon hired the wrestling coach, deciding he had more wrestling talent than the boys.

Vince McMahon was depicted as a generic businessman with an off-brand Irish lilt. In reality, Vince is closer to a real-life Eric Cartman. He uses his “authoritah” to bully and humiliate his employees, including his own family. He also gets involved in convoluted schemes such as faking his own death, discovering he fathered a leprechaun, and being the anonymous leader of a Satanic cult. McMahon also loves childish, bodily humour, often dubbing it “good s**t”. The worlds of WWE and South Park are not too far apart.

1. Kayne West

Episode(s) appeared in: Fishsticks (Season 13, Episode 5), The Hobbit (Season 17, Episode 10)

Advertisement

Kanye West burst into town with fury, ego, and a lot of confusion. When South Park’s resident comedian Jimmy Valmer made a viral gag about people who like fishsticks being “gay fish”, only the self-proclaimed genius Kanye West doesn’t understand the joke. He is enraged and believes people are spreading rumours that he is a gay fish.

After a violent hunt for the person behind the joke, Kanye eventually comes to terms with his true self and begins life as a gay fish. Kanye is forced to return to South Park to defend his love life when his fiancée Kim Kardashian is accused of being a hobbit who uses Photoshop to look attractive. He again must come to terms with another bizarre attraction.

Kanye West exists to be satirised. He is a wealth of wackiness. His unique view on the world and mind-melting logic beg to be sent up. Less than twenty-four hours at the time of writing, Kanye has launched his campaign for US President with his suggestion that women should be given $1m when they have a baby to deter them from abortions. Though he may appear too easy a target for Trey and Matt, they always find a spot on the punching bag that hasn’t yet been struck.

Advertisement