10 Criminally Underrated Doctor Who Stories
They may not be seen as classics, but these undervalued masterpieces are worth a second look.
Every Doctor Who fan has a list of their favourite episodes, but it’s usually the same dozen or so stories that recur time and time again as universally-agreed-upon classics. Of course, there are a number of standout episodes that deserve all the praise they get, but with so many stories to choose from, there are bound to be some hidden gems that belong in the Hall of Fame which have sadly been denied entry at the door.
One of the best things about Doctor Who is that every episode has merit, and even the ones you really dislike could be somebody’s favourite. With that in mind, it’s worth giving stories that you previously weren’t so keen on another watch. Many episodes that fans rarely discuss actually contain buried treasures that make them worth appreciating: intricate layers of complex metaphors, excellent production values, or just a funny one-liner that catapults the episode into greatness.
These are the revival-era stories that deserve more recognition. Some of them are unjustly hated, others are simply overlooked. Either way, they’re miles better than the Whovian consensus would suggest, and they’re definitely worthy of your time (and space).
10. Tooth And Claw
This early 10th Doctor story was very well-regarded when it first aired, but nowadays it’s sadly seldom talked about. It’s a lupine lark that cements David Tennant in the role by giving him an action-packed chase through a gothic house stalked by a ferocious werewolf – an entirely CGI creation which holds up surprisingly well despite being a little long in the tooth.
Perhaps the most memorable aspect of this story is that it’s the only time Tennant uses his natural Scottish accent in the show, making for some amusing scenes as he spars with Queen Victoria. More importantly, this episode also sets up the Torchwood Institute, which plays a key role in the Series 2 finale and of course formed the foundation of the Torchwood spin-off.
Accompanied by a fantastic musical score, this gripping episode is superbly made, with taut editing and inventive cinematography. It may not be the most complex story, but it deserves to be remembered for its slick action and haunting atmosphere. Give it a watch next time there’s a full moon. It’s hair-raisingly good.
9. Last Christmas
This dark Christmas special is essentially Ridley Scott’s Alien mixed with Steven Moffat’s take on Christopher Nolan’s Inception, and if that’s not high-concept sci-fi enough for you, I don’t know what is.
The Doctor and Clara venture to the North Pole, where a scientific research base is studying alien creatures known ominously as the Dream Crabs. Or is it? As it turns out, the research base is actually a dream… within a dream, as caused by the Dream Crabs latching on to the Doctor and Clara’s brains and essentially causing them to hallucinate a Doctor Who episode into existence. This is Doctor Who at its most self-aware, with a slew of meta-commentary on the Doctor, the show, and the concept of Christmas itself.
The multiple layers of dreams lend this episode a surreal quality amplified by the reality-warping presence of Father Christmas, played by the legendary Nick Frost. He plays a sarcastic Santa worthy of Peter Capaldi’s gruff Doctor, and the two bounce off each other brilliantly. This festive offering tends to fly under the radar compared to other more eventful Christmas specials, but if you pay attention to its complexities you’ll be rewarded with a delightfully dark treat.
8. Journey To The Centre Of The TARDIS
This story was so hyped up prior to its airing that it was bound to disappoint on first viewing. The title alone is so tantalising that it sets the mind of an eager Whovian racing with possibilities. We get to see more of the TARDIS! What marvels lie in wait? What horrors lurk within? Does the TARDIS have a garage? A bathroom? A hidden vault full of Doctor Who action figures?
The reality was perhaps mildly disappointing: a brief glimpse of the swimming pool, a quick look at the library, and a copious collection of metal corridors. Yay?
But despite the disappointing selection of iconic locations, this episode still has a lot to offer, particularly on re-watch. There are some incredible visuals: we get to see the Eye of Harmony at the heart of the TARDIS, as well as some fantastic sci-fi concepts such as the self-replicating artificial tree that creates any machine you desire.
The script is smarter than it seems, with the setting of the TARDIS interior used to great effect to create a timey-wimey storyline that provides a series of clever twists and, thanks to the tongue-in-cheek-tone, remains believable (as long as you don’t think about it too much). This episode is an important lesson in overhype, demonstrating that a story which initially underwhelms can still be enjoyable if you give it a second chance.
7. Nikola Tesla’s Night Of Terror
Hidden in the middle of the extremely polarising Series 12 lies Nikola Tesla’s Night of Terror, an electrifying episode which never really gets the attention it deserves. The plot is nothing to write home about, concerning an alien invasion of scavenger scorpions known as the Skithra, but it’s solid, simple Doctor Who, and sometimes that’s just what you need.
This episode stands out because of its excellent production values. The recreation of Gilded Age New York is remarkable, with immersive sets and fantastic costume design selling the illusion and giving the episode a premium quality. The script is tightly written too, managing to juggle the Doctor and her three companions as well as a number of side characters.
But Goran Višnjić is the highlight here. His pitch-perfect performance honours the real-life Tesla and ensures that he stands out as an actual character rather than merely a caricature like some other historical figures in Doctor Who. His bitter rivalry with Thomas Edison makes for some sparky scenes, and his camaraderie with fellow inventor The Doctor really lets Jodie Whittaker demonstrate her acting chops. Perhaps, like Tesla himself, this episode will receive its well-earned recognition in years to come.
6. Boom Town
This is that episode. You know the one. That one episode in almost every series of Doctor Who that’s clearly a hasty addition designed to save as much money as possible because the budget’s running dry. The Doctor, Rose, and Captain Jack Harkness arrive in the harsh alien landscape of… Cardiff… to take a break from their travels while the TARDIS recharges. Riveting.
That is, until they discover that an escaped Slitheen has gone undercover as the Mayor and has rigged the new nuclear power plant to detonate right on top of the Cardiff spacetime rift (one of Cardiff’s many natural wonders), letting her surf the temporal blast right back to Raxacoricofallapatorius.
When the Doctor learns of this peculiar plan, he quickly captures the Slitheen and takes her prisoner… and also out for dinner. This leads to a disarmingly brilliant dialogue scene, as this low-budget comedy episode transforms into an analysis of the Doctor’s character and how he reacts when an enemy treats him as an equal. Russell T Davies’ ability to create such an interesting story on such a small budget is testament to his impeccable skill as a writer.
5. Into The Dalek
Into the Dalek is Peter Capaldi’s second episode as the Doctor, and it’s a crowd-pleasing blockbuster helmed by respected film director Ben Wheatley, in which the Doctor is miniaturised and must journey into the inner workings of his greatest enemy. This episode is generally seen as solid if unremarkable, but beneath its amusing premise hides a complex metaphor that sheds light on the Doctor’s character.
Capaldi is wonderfully acerbic here. His searing, sarcastic dialogue gives him an abrasive presence compared to the other Doctors, and this notion of our hero seemingly turning bad is perfectly paralleled by the idea of a Dalek that has malfunctioned and turned “good”. At the episode’s climax, the Doctor and the Dalek merge their minds together, allowing the Doctor to channel his thoughts into the creature, further cementing the thematic parallels between them.
The Doctor hopes that this will make the Dalek see peace and kindness, but what he actually sees in the Doctor is hatred: hatred for the Daleks. After proclaiming “Daleks must be exterminated!” the Dalek destroys his allies to satiate his burning hatred caused by the Doctor’s mind-merge. The Doctor realises that there is no such thing as a good Dalek, and the Dalek retorts: “You are a good Dalek”. Not only is this an excellent callback to the 9th Doctor’s initial Dalek encounter, it’s also an encapsulation of the episode’s themes, and a catalyst for the 12th Doctor’s character arc that transforms his outlook from apathy to empathy.
4. A Town Called Mercy
Saddle up for a wild ride, pardner! In this episode, the Doctor goes to the Wild West for a rootin’-tootin’ cowboy caper. Or so you might think. At first glance it might seem like you’re in for a cheesy charmer of an episode here, but in fact A Town Called Mercy is surprisingly subdued and contemplative, offering fascinating insight into The Doctor’s character.
Sure, it has plenty of fun playing with the Western genre, but at its core this is a tense slow-burner of a story focused on a moral dilemma. The Gunslinger, a cybernetically-augmented warrior created by alien scientist Kahler Jex, arrives in the town of Mercy to hunt down his creator and take revenge. The Gunslinger has established a patrol boundary around the town, preventing anyone from entering or leaving, so its populace are slowly starving.
Jex, meanwhile, has integrated himself into the town and is helping the townsfolk by treating their ailments and providing useful technology. Once the Doctor learns all this, he is conflicted: does he allow the tortured Gunslinger to take revenge against Jex? Jex fashioned dozens of his own species into weapons against their will, but he now seems repentant and is helping innocent people. Does the Doctor show mercy, knowing that Jex may have learned nothing and may simply default back to his evil deeds? A fascinating conundrum, and one which makes this episode one of the most introspective stories in the show’s history.
3. Victory Of The Daleks
When it first aired, this episode received a lot of backlash thanks to the gaudy new multicoloured Dalek design it debuted. But to dismiss this episode entirely based on one design misfire would be unfair, as this Mark Gatiss script has plenty of bold ideas up its sleeve.
Victory of the Daleks does something quite unique: it takes two staple episode formats and er… staples them together. There are dozens of Dalek-focused episodes, and plenty of episodes that centre on a famous historical figure, but this is the only story to combine the two concepts and it works surprisingly well.
Here, the Daleks meet Winston Churchill, and in an unexpected setup, they’re working for him. Churchill wishes to use the unmatched power of the Daleks – which he believes his chief scientist Bracewell invented – to win the war. This is a deliciously ironic premise, allowing for some iconic jokes (Daleks offering people cups of tea is the most quintessentially British thing ever) and some excellent acting from Matt Smith as he faces his arch enemy at their most devious. As if that wasn’t enough, as foreshadowed by the episode’s title, this is one of the only times the Daleks actually win. Seek, Locate, and Appreciate this episode by giving it a re-watch next time you’re in a Who mood.
2. Time Heist
An early offering from the 12th Doctor’s run, this ambitious instalment is supremely smart and endlessly rewatchable. One of Doctor Who’s greatest strengths is that it can mould itself into any genre, and this particular story takes the form of a heist movie with a time travel twist.
At the start of the episode, the Doctor and Clara wake up in a room with their memories wiped and a mission briefing from a mysterious overseer: to rob the Bank of Karabraxos. Two mercenaries - shape-changing mutant Saibra and cyborg hacker Psi – will assist them in the heist. This intriguing setup paves the way for a tense adventure filled with sci-fi hijinks.
Standing in the way of the Doctor and co. is the alien security system that protects the bank, known as The Teller. This telepathic terror is one of the most memorable alien designs ever to appear on Doctor Who. It’s not only a formidable monster with the unnerving ability to melt people’s brains, it’s also crucial to the central mystery of the story. The fact that this creature is accomplished with prosthetics and animatronics rather than CGI makes it even more impressive.
So many aspects of this episode are expertly executed: the stylish cinematography, the snappy editing, the tightly-written narrative, the beautiful costume design, the incredible sets, the awesome visual effects, the star turn from guest star Keeley Hawes, and best of all the immensely clever and uplifting ending. If you’re looking for a story that pays its debts, you can always bank on Time Heist.
1. The Sontaran Stratagem/The Poison Sky
Overshadowed by the other outstanding offerings in Series 4, this terrific two-parter is packed with everything you could possibly want from a Doctor Who story, whether you’re a full-on fan or a more casual viewer.
For dedicated lifelong fans, this episode emulates the feel of a classic Jon Pertwee story, with the Doctor working alongside UNIT to thwart an alien invasion of Earth by the Sontarans, a classic-era foe who return to the series with a brilliant updated design and their thirst for war intact. There’s plenty of continuity for newer fans too, with a surprise companion comeback in the form of Martha Jones, cheeky references to beloved revival-era episodes (“are you my mummy?”) and other returning elements such as the Valiant, UNIT’s suspiciously helicarrier-esque airborne vessel.
Despite the generous amount of gleeful geekery involved, this two-parter is surprisingly accessible for casual viewers. It doesn’t take itself too seriously, with a fun tongue-in-cheek atmosphere and heaps of great gags (“We have an intruder!” “How did he get in, in-tru-der window?”).
However, it still knows how to amp up the tension when needed: The Tenth Doctor’s swaggering arrogance comes to the fore as he is matched against multiple clashing personalities, making for climactic confrontations with UNIT, the Sontarans, and smug teen genius Luke Rattigan.
If that wasn’t enough, this story also features plenty of well-directed action scenes, some spooky moments involving Martha’s clone, clever concepts such as the ATMOS sat-nav system which takes control of cars, and a satisfying resolution that ties it all together. This high-stakes episode is a low-key classic with universal appeal, and it deserves to be remembered alongside the greats.