10 Darkest Doctor Who Moments
Devilish deaths and horrifying transformations you'll need a night on Darillium to recover from.
TV campaigner Mary Whitehouse – who was displeased with violent moments in several classic Doctor Who serials – would've had a field day with modern Doctor Who.
There are often things written in the media or on forums about whether Doctor Who is too scary for children, but it would make for a decidedly dull show if all we watched was the Doctor and their companions sunning it up in Marbella in 1989. And as the Tenth Doctor said to Donna:
"You need a good death. Without death, there'd only be comedies. Dying gives us size."
So, prepare to be supersized, because there's quite a heavy dose of death coming up.
From characters being killed in some truly horrifying ways, to certain lines of dialogue that hit harder than the TARDIS flying at full pelt, modern Doctor Who has had some memorably dark moments over the years.
This show thrives on 'hide behind the sofa' horror, giving the kids a fun scare on a Saturday night before the Doctor swoops in and saves the day. But there are some moments likely to give even the adults nightmares...
10. The Boneless' Murals (Flatline)
The Boneless were belligerent beings from a two-dimensional universe, who caused the Twelfth Doctor all sorts of problems by shrinking the TARDIS exterior while he was inside it.
They eventually converted into surreal-looking 3D monsters that could've come straight out of a Salvador Dali painting. Now there's a killer episode concept.
Terrifying though they were emerging from the ground and giving chase in a suitably dark tunnel, the Boneless were at their most sinister in 2D. The pre-credits sequence shows a frightened man on the phone to the police, saying "I can't speak up, they might hear me... they are everywhere", before being snatched from underneath, and ending up on the wall as a screaming mural.
Later, PC Forrest is also muralised as she searches a missing person's room. The Boneless slither towards her, then brutally pull her into the floor. Barely a second goes by when Clara and Rigsy burst into the room after hearing PC Forrest's screams, only to discover her nervous system graphically displayed on the wall like a twisted art piece.
The episode's writer Jamie Mathieson believed that Doctor Who should be "utterly terrifying and filled with body horror". Stringing out people's innards was certainly one way to make that statement, demonstrating that the Boneless were savage creatures who could not be bargained with.
9. Using Humans For Parts (The Girl In The Fireplace)
The fourth Tardisode (remember those?) depicts the SS Madame de Pompadour sustaining severe damage in an ion storm. In the aftermath, it shows a member of the injured crew relieved to see something mechanical-sounding approaching her – but in an instant, that relief turns to terror as she is killed off-camera.
We're all familiar with the story of the Doctor going back and forth through the 18th century French fireplace to see/snog Reinette (aka Madame de Pompadour), while Rose and Mickey search the 51st century ship equipped with "ice guns". They come across something truly disturbing, even for 51st century standards: a human eye and a beating human heart, both wired into the machinery of the ship itself.
Turns out that the Clockworks Droids were programmed to repair the ship by any means necessary – including harvesting the "parts" from the 50-strong crew, and believing that Reinette's brain would be compatible to replace the ship's broken command circuit.
We get an idea of the grisly ordeal the crew went through when Rose and Mickey are tied down and threatened by a Droid's mini circular saw – presumably, the entire crew was butchered alive.
8. Daleks Murdering A Family (The Stolen Earth)
The Daleks really embodied Terry Nation's alien fascist creation during Russell T Davies' first showrunning era.
We had a single Dalek exterminating its way through Henry van Statten's bunker; the Reality Bomb test on a group of unlucky people; and one other, which we'll get to later on. Apart from the excellent Asylum of the Daleks and the Dalek Reconnaissance Scout in Resolution, they haven't reached that consistent level of fear since those Ninth and Tenth Doctor days.
The Stolen Earth/Journey's End sees the Daleks at the height of their devastating power, invading the Earth and subjugating humanity. One man makes a fatal mistake by telling his family to get back inside their house, before throwing a brick at a Dalek and yelling, "Get back in the sky, get back where you came from!"
In that moment, you know exactly what's going to happen next.
Three Daleks immediately move into an attack formation at the front of the house, and the music builds as if to serve as a warning of the horror that's about to unfold: maximum, explosive extermination of a husband, a wife, and their young son.
7. Donna Helps Miss Evangelista (Silence In The Library)
Technology can be a wonderful thing in Doctor Who, such as River Song's sonic screwdriver being fitted with equipment that allowed the Doctor to save her.
It can also be a freakish thing, as we saw with Miss Evangelista.
The sight of her remarkably clean skeleton (you've got to hand it to the Vashta Nerada, they're very efficient) is in itself a very dark moment, but it's what happens next that gets this moment a slot on the list.
With everyone gathered round Miss Evangelista's remains, they suddenly hear her voice politely asking "Sorry, where am I?". River explains to a distressed Donna that it's a Data Ghost – the communicator on Miss Evangelista's spacesuit held an impression of her living consciousness for a short period after she died.
The Doctor tries to comfort Donna by putting it poetically that the Data Ghost is a "footprint on the beach, and the tide's coming in".
Miss Evangelista asks for the nice woman – our very own brilliant Donna, who acted kindly towards her previously. Donna comforts Evangelista as she slowly fades away. It's a haunting sequence, the sort of thing that stays with you long after it's over.
6. Creation Of The Peg Dolls (Night Terrors)
The eerie, eyeless, singsong wooden Peg Dolls were brought to life as part of eight-year-old George's pantophobia – a crippling fear of absolutely everything.
Anything he found scary was sealed in his bedroom cupboard: a dolls house, the sound of the lift, and even his kindly old neighbour Mrs. Rossiter.
Not merely content with chasing Amy and Rory around the dolls house while emitting the sound of creepy childish laughter, the Peg Dolls also possessed the ability to transform people into more of their kind, a fate suffered by Amy and the landlord Purcell.
These transformations are the stuff of nightmares, and were horrifyingly realised onscreen. The sounds are a mixture of wood creaking and bone cracking, and the CGI of the hair emerging from the top of the heads is still impressive today.
Maybe you're better off getting the Barbie Dreamhouse instead.
Arguably no other episode in the modern era has conveyed a sense of childlike horror better than Night Terrors did, and these Peg Doll scenes will no doubt freak out the adults as well.
5. Floor Zero Massacre (The Parting Of The Ways)
"The Daleks will enter the station at Floor 494, and as far as I can tell, they'll head up, not down. But that's not a promise."
Captain Jack was right not to promise the rest of the people on Floor Zero that they'd be safe. But hey, no doubt fueled by his win on the Weakest Link, at least Rodrick was extremely confident that the Daleks no longer existed.
However, as soon as they blow up the Anne-Droid on Floor 495, the Daleks descend the elevator shaft – much to Lynda's horror, who's observing events on a monitor.
A lot of people die in Doctor Who, but it's usually people involved in the story directly – it's rarely a massive group of innocent people, and it's rarely as chilling as this.
The slow, processional manner in which the Daleks move provides a devastating contrast to the mass panic of the helplessly huddled humans, all of which comes to a conclusion in a cacophony of "Exterminate!", screaming, Dalek gunfire, and Lynda's reaction to what's she's just witnessed.
4. Breaking The Emotional Inhibitor (The Age Of Steel)
While the Daleks started NuWho as the more menacing monsters, the Cybermen have stomped back strongly with some terrifying turns in Series 10 and Series 12.
Notwithstanding the gruesome scene where we see people being upgraded in a whirl of saws and scissors, John Lumic's Cyberman design was too robotic – you sometimes forgot that these machines were once living, breathing people. Then again, perhaps that was the point – to make scenes like this one all the more affecting.
After the Doctor and Mrs Moore successfully navigate their way through the cooling tunnels underneath the Cyber-conversion factory, Moore takes out a Cyberman with an electromagnetic bomb. The Doctor begins examining it by removing the front plate to reveal its inner workings, but in doing so, he realises that its emotional inhibitor is broken.
The Cyberman reacts by saying "Why am I cold?", and goes on to explain that her name is Sally Phelan, and that she was going to get married to Gareth the following day. Even with a Cyber-voice, you can hear the anguish, the pain.
It's one of those rare moments that brings humanity to the Cybermen, and truly makes you realise how horrifying it is that there's a lost, terrified soul somewhere inside that cold metal shell.
3. Gas Mask Transformation (The Empty Child)
You knew this was coming. It may not be the darkest moment on this list, but it's undoubtedly the most iconic.
The entire scene with Christopher Eccleston's Ninth Doctor and Richard Wilson's Dr Constantine is crafted with incredible intrigue and tension, thanks to Steven Moffat's writing and Murray Gold's unsettling score.
Constantine's coughing and spluttering makes you sense something bad is about to happen, and as the Doctor's examination of the gas mask-wearing patients draws the same impossible conclusion – that they've all got the same injuries, right down to the scarring on the back of their hands – the camera cuts to Constantine's own hand, which bears the exact same mark.
His coughing intensifies and before long, he utters those four famous words: "Are... you... my... mummy?" The Doctor can only look on, helpless to intervene, as Constantine's face morphs into a gas mask.
We all needed our mummies after witnessing that.
This scene was originally even darker too, with producer Phil Collinson noting that the sound of Constantine's skull cracking was edited from the final broadcast. Probably the right decision – it's not like it needed to be more scary, let's be honest.
2. Don't Cremate Me (Dark Water)
Following Danny Pink's shock death, the Doctor and Clara end up at the 3W Institute in an effort to track him down. Inside, both are welcomed (the Doctor in particular) by Missy, who calls Dr Chang. Chang asks the Doctor and Clara, "Is there a particular dead person you want to talk to?"
The BBC received over 100 complaints for the scene that follows. It's not visually vicious like many others on this list, but it's quite possibly the most psychologically traumatising.
In Chang's office, the Doctor and Clara ask what 3W means. Chang replies, "The three words", and braces them for a shocking revelation. He tells them that 3W's founder, Dr Skarosa, played white noise through a translation machine and recorded a babble of voices, which he believed were from the recently deceased. Skarosa managed to isolate some of the voices, and Chang warns of the bone-chilling words they're about to hear:
"Don't cremate me. Don't cremate me!"
In other words, the dead are still conscious, and are aware of what's happening to their bodies. Feeling cold? You're probably still in a mortuary fridge. Screaming in agony? Choosing Burn Baby Burn for your committal song doesn't seem quite as funny now.
The BBC defended this plotline, reminding everyone that the Doctor dismisses it as a con and a racket (which it was). Still, remember that a lot of people's minds were uploaded to the Nethersphere, and most would've been put down as a "burner" by default.
1. Scooti's Devilish Demise (The Impossible Planet)
Russell T Davies mentions in The Writer's Tale how much he loves The Impossible Planet/The Satan Pit, and we agree – it's one of the best stories in modern Doctor Who, and the best of Series 2 to boot.
This is mainly down to how scarily the Beast is portrayed, via Will Thorp's possessed Toby Zed, Gabriel Woolf's demonic vocals, and an impressive-looking CGI Beast. There are also plenty of 'hide behind the sofa' moments that will give the grown-ups a few nightmares, never mind the children. But the one that tops them all is Scooti's death scene in The Impossible Planet.
After hearing from the base's computer that someone has gone out onto the planet's inhospitable surface without a spacesuit, Scooti wanders over to a window and watches in disbelief as Toby "bathes in the black sun". Toby turns around, an evil grin on his face, and tries to tempt her to join him, before slowly breaking the glass protecting Scooti from the endless depths of space.
From the unsettling red eyes and ancient text plastered across Toby's face, to Scooti pleading for her life as she realises what's happening, it's disturbing stuff, as is the sight of her corpse floating towards the black hole a few minutes later.