As anyone this side of Skaro knows, Doctor Who will soon be back on our screens with a brand new face; that of The Thick of It actor Peter Capaldi. It seems that Peter and the production team are keen to differentiate his incarnation from the previous two very well-loved Doctors, as the main thrust of the pre-series advertising campaign has been to paint Doctor Number Twelve (let's not get started on the numbering controversy) as the darkest Doctor yet. "Am I a good man?" he asks his companion Clara in all the trailers, well it seems the answer will have to wait until the series premieres next Saturday. However, can Capaldi really be the darkest Doctor ever? Yes, the Doctor may be the main character in a largely cheerful family series but he is also an ancient being with buckets of regret and a fierce sense of justice that he often upholds at the cost of bloodshed. Not exactly Winnie the Pooh, is he? In fact, right through his many lives the Doctor has had a number of incredibly dark moments that have really pushed the character - right from his beginnings as the curmudgeonly William Hartnell to the usually cuddly Matt Smith. So, unless Peter Capaldi's plan for the role is to don a hockey mask and a chainsaw, Number Twelve might find himself hard pressed to produce darker moments than the following ten.
10. The Tenth Doctor Causes Pompeii's Destruction
The Series Four episode Fires of Pompeii introduced the idea of fixed points in time and space. For years, it had been a mystery for fans why sometimes the Doctor could merrily dance his way through a period in time and space pouncing on any butterflies he felt like, whereas other times he was sworn not to interfere. Here it was revealed that certain moments cannot be changed. Much to his sadness, one such moment was the destruction of Pompeii. The Doctor is racked with guilt upon arriving and ignores his companion Donna's insistence that he must save the people of the city. Things only get worse when the time travellers realise it is them who cause the eruption of Mount Vesuvius, as a means to destroy the evil alien Pyroviles who wish to claim the Earth for their own. It's Pompeii or the world and unfortunately there is only one answer. Although the Doctor does eventually save some people - including a man played by Peter Capaldi, who apparently repays the Doctor by giving him his face - the moment in the TARDIS where we think the Doctor really will run away and leave everyone to die is as dark as the show has ever got. It's a terrible glimpse into the responsibility that the Doctor faces every time he travels somewhere. He isn't called a Time Lord for nothing.
9. The Ninth Doctor Tortures A Dalek
When the show came back in 2005, it came with a new brooding version of the Doctor. Lacking the eccentric fashions or received pronunciation of his predecessors, Christopher Eccleston's Ninth Doctor was a stripped-back hero haunted by the actions of his past. Many are expecting Capaldi to be more on Eccleston's side of the spectrum but it is hard to imagine any other Doctor reacting with such searing venom when meeting his old enemy, the Dalek. Believing that the Daleks had all been wiped out in the Time War that killed his people, the Doctor is angry and terrified that just one survived. Laughing madly to hide his rage, the Doctor decides what he has to do - 'exterminate.' He proceeds to electrocute the Dalek - despite it's cries for mercy - and would have killed it too if not for the soldiers of the Dalek's owner, Van Statten, stopping him. It's a famous moment for fans and perhaps the greatest demonstration of the Doctor's hatred for his greatest enemy ever seen in the show. Seeing as the Doctor can't have the quite the same hostility towards them now that the Time Lords are (sort of) safe, it is unlikely that the Twelfth Doctor will deal with the Daleks with the same level of vitriol when he meets them for the first time later this year.
8. The Eleventh Doctor Is Without Mercy
When considering the Eleventh Doctor, we think of bow ties and fezzes and puppy dog tails and things that good Time Lords are made of. However, let's not forget that Number Eleven was the oldest of the Doctors and so had the weight of all those many centuries behind him. Sometimes then, like any old man his patience would occasionally wear thin. One time this occurred was back in the ol' wild west, in a town - ironically - called Mercy which was being stormed by an alien cyborg. Sick of people needlessly dying for his pacifist nature, the Doctor goes against his normal rules and straight out points a gun at the offending alien. It takes the words of wisdom of his companion Amy to bring him back to reality. While we've seen the Doctor grab a gun before in moments of dire danger, this must be the only time he does so as a knee-jerk reaction, rather than use his trademark wits to save the day. Given the rarity of this, we don't expect to see Peter Capaldi swapping his sonic screwdriver for something with more a little more firepower...
7. The Seventh Doctor's Treatment Of Ace
Pointing a gun at the bad guys may still be a dark moment for the Doctor but that's nothing compared to making your companion's life hell. Ace is a troubled young woman with a history of arson and a difficult relationship with her mother. Travelling around the universe with the wise old Doctor on an eye-opening journey of self-discovery should have been the perfect thing to put her on the right track in life. Instead of showing her kindness though, the Doctor makes Ace face all her greatest fears. A house that terrorised her as a girl, her irrational fear of clowns (which probably isn't helped when she meets evil robot ones) and even her mother. Blimey, that last one's worse than making her face the Daleks. You might think the Doctor is just being cruel to be kind and has her best interests at heart. However, in the penultimate episode of the classic series it is revealed that Ace has been an unwitting pawn of the evil entity Fenric, something the Doctor was not only aware of it, but it was the reason he took her own board in the first place. Although he might be a tad grumpy, the Twelfth Doctor will surely treat Clara better than his earlier self did Ace.
6. The Tenth Doctor Makes Sure The Family Live Forever
There's a strong theme in two-parter Human Nature/The Family of Blood of the differences between the Doctor and human beings. Transformed into an ordinary man, with no knowledge of his true identity, the Doctor - or rather John Smith - enjoys a happy life as a boarding school teacher in 1913. Until he is forced to give it all up so the Doctor can come back and defeat the fiendish Family of Blood who are seeking immortality. It is then that we get one of the most vengeful moments in the Doctor's life. Narrated to us by one of the Family - Harry Lloyd's Son of Mine - we are set against the Doctor and encouraged to see him from his enemy's point of view: a terrifying avenger with a black heart. "We wanted to live forever," we are told "So the Doctor made sure that we did." The cruel and unusual punishments the Doctor dishes out include launching one into a supernova, keeping one in suspended animation as a scarecrow and banishing the little daughter of the family into a mirror. We are used to the Doctor killing the enemy as a last attempt but the fury he unleashes here is near unheard of. It is also the expression that David Tennant pulls, a look of resignation, as if to say "I try to stop myself doing this, but you made me" that makes this moment truly chilling. That fury is the true difference between the Doctor and human beings.
5. The Eleventh Doctor Punishes Solomon
However, it's not just the Tenth Doctor that dishes out the dodgy punishments. Whereas the Eleventh Doctor only threatened to kill his enemy in A Town Called Mercy, in the preceding - otherwise light-hearted - adventure Dinosaurs on a Spaceship, he actually went through with it and executed the episode's villain. With missiles heading to the spaceship filled with himself, his friends and a cargo of dinosaurs, the Doctor tricks the missiles into targeting the spacecraft of David Bradley's despicable space pirate Solomon - with Solomon still inside. The Doctor ignores the man's cries for mercy and leaves him to be destroyed. It's a shocking moment for an episode whose mission statement seemed to be 'family fun', to then end with the Doctor committing cold-blooded murder. It's the total control over who lives and who dies that the Doctor exhibits in this moment that make it such a dark one. Surely Number Twelve, having been gifted with saving his own people from the Time War in his previous incarnation, wouldn't chose to take a life like this again? We'll have to wait and see.
4. The War Doctor Plans To End The Time War
Speaking of the Time War, there can be no darker point in the Doctor's entire life than when he fought in that great battle between his own people and the Daleks. For a man who prides himself on helping others, to be part of such a devastating conflict must have crushed him. And it did, as we found out in 50th anniversary special The Day of the Doctor. Having finally had enough of the endless suffering, the Doctor (or whatever he called himself in the Time War, maybe it was Dave) decides to end it the only way he can - by detonating the Moment, a weapon of mass destruction that would obliterate Gallifrey. When you think about it, the show's birthday bash is an odd place to feature the main character contemplating double genocide. Of course though, we all know that thanks to his future selves the Doctor does not destroy his fellow Time Lords, but the fact remains that he almost did - at the lowest part of his long, long life. Surely the Doctor can't have a darker, more personally devastating moment ever again?
3. The Tenth Doctor Becomes The Time Lord Victorious
Yes, that's three times he's appeared on this list. The Tenth Doctor definitely was a dark one. When the show was revived for 21st century audiences, it developed the character of the Doctor considerably, moving him on in his life, adding new backstory and also giving him extra subtext; namely recurring references to him being a god, or at least an all-powerful cosmic being. Oh, wait, that's still a god. This came to a head in David Tennant's penultimate episode in the role as, in a thematic sequel to Fires of Pompeii, the Tenth Doctor comes across another fixed point in time - the deaths of the crew of Bowie Base One on Mars. Why are fixed points never nice things? It wouldn't be so bad if the Doctor had to make sure a picnic had to happen. However, the Doctor decrees he is not about to stand by and do nothing and declares that because he is the last Time Lord he can do whatever he likes. To feed his own arrogance rather than to do the right thing, the Doctor breaks the laws of time and brings the crew back to Earth. It's a terrifying moment because - with a manic glint in his eye and talk of being an omnipotent 'Time Lord Victorious' - the Doctor becomes the exact opposite of what we love about him; a power-mad tyrant, undeterred by the effect his actions will have on the universe. In short, he becomes the Master. While some have said that Capaldi would have made a good Master instead of Doctor, we don't see him playing both characters at the same time.
2. The First Doctor Nearly Kills A Caveman
It's a fact that the character of the Doctor has changed a lot over the years. As is only natural for a character who has been portrayed by twelve/thirteen different actors (do we count Peter Cushing?). Fans unfamiliar with the character's first incarnation - the original, you might say - might be surprised to find out just how different he was. In the first ever Doctor Who story - An Unearthly Child - the Doctor, his granddaughter Susan and their new travelling companions Ian and Barbara (whom the Doctor kidnapped) arrive on a Prehistoric Earth. Sometime in their adventure they are held up by a caveman. How does the Doctor deal with the situation, with his brilliant mind and kind two hearts? He goes to bash the caveman over the head with a rock of course, until Ian prevents him. As stated previously in this article, the Doctor may resort to killing his enemies if there is no other means of holding the peace or, on occasion, he may go a bit wacky and kill them anyway. However, attempting to kill an innocent - a human being, as well, his favourite species - is something he never does. This is a moment Peter Capaldi's Doctor simply cannot do again as it is a product of this younger, more alien Doctor who is yet to establish the set of morals that we now come to think of as at the core of his character.
1. The Sixth Doctor Strangles Peri
Of all the moments on this list there is one that sticks out as so shocking, so against the show's traditional code of conduct, that it cannot be beaten on the darkness factor. The moment in question is no doubt the scene where the Doctor tries to strangle his companion, Peri. A newly-regenerated Sixth Doctor (whose predecessor was so lovely he wouldn't strangle a fly) is feeling a bit under the weather after his rebirth - by which we mean he has gone stark raving bonkers. Growing paranoid, the Doctor starts to believe that his companion is an alien spy. "Well, we all know the fate of alien spies", he says before attempting to strangle Peri. Only his own reflection in the mirror makes him come to his senses. There is some parallel between Peter Capaldi and Colin Baker's Doctors, as it seems both will be the reckless, unpredictable incarnations who are meant to be a bit hard to like. However, you can imagine that the production team will learn from the mistakes of the show's past and never include as dark an introduction to the new Doctor as this one. To conclude, the 'Is he a good man or isn't he?' campaign is a good attempt to get people excited - and perhaps get the fans a little worried - about the new Doctor, but in truth it's not really needed. Peter Capaldi's Twelfth Doctor will in fact be just like all the great Doctors before him. A man at once weary of his old life and raring for adventure, someone full of kindness but also great fury. In short, he won't be the 'dark' Doctor, he'll be the Doctor. And that's enough to get excited about. Are there other dark moments of the Doctor's past that we've forgotten? Do you actually think Capaldi will hit a caveman over the head with a rock? Materialise your thoughts in the comments section below!