10 Doctor Who Characters That Should Return
In a show about time travel, surely it's possible to bring characters back from the past?
As of 23 November 2020, Doctor Who is now 57 years old. In all of those years, many characters have come and gone. Some good. Some not so good. As for the very best in the show's long history, it's kind of hard not to have that niggling feeling. You know the one I mean. Were you basically pine to see a certain character return to our screens.
Whether it be because they're simply your favourite. Maybe you'd like to see how this character would interact with a different Doctor. Sometimes it's the case that we just haven't seen them in a bloody long time, and a return seems appropriate. In some cases, a character needs to make a comeback because they're story was never really resolved, or more could be done with that character if they were given the case to rematerialize on screen.
In many ways, it's me being a whiny Whovian demanding for nostalgia. But at the same time it's nice to have a blast from the past, especially if it means progressing the ongoing narrative. Plus, a bit of fan service is a good thing from time to time. Not too much. Just enough to get us excited, before moving on with the current plotline. However, considering that Captain Jack Harkness has recently been announced to return for the festive special, Revolution of the Daleks, it seems to be me that anything is possible. Also, I can dream can't I?
10. Susan Foreman
I know. This one is an obvious choice, given her importance to The Doctor's character. Susan is The Doctor's granddaughter at the end of the day, and was his original companion all the way back at the very beginning. More than that, she was essentially the lure into the mysteries world of her grandfather, being this strange, alien-like being that peaked Ian and Barbara's interests, which inevitably began their adventurous journey aboard the TARDIS.
At the end of the day, she hasn't been a recurring companion since The Dalek Invasion of Earth, where The Doctor decided to leave her behind to find a new life for herself. Her last on screen appearance was during The Five Doctors. That's a long time ago!
Naturally, Big Finish have delved into her character, and explored what happened after she was left behind. Though, if you've listened to To the Death, you'll know it didn't with her being on particularly good terms with The Doctor, which is something worth exploring in the future. I haven't listened to Susan's War as of yet, but it is interesting knowing she became involved within the Time War, so of course, you want to explore how this changed her further, and how much more damage was put on her relationship with her grandfather.
Furthermore, in context with the current storyline, it'd certainly be fascinating seeing how Susan's character is explored. Was she even aware of The Doctor being the Timeless Child? Chances are she was just as much in the dark as was her grandfather (and everyone else for that matter), so it'd probably come as a shock to her to discover that Time Lord society all revolved around The Doctor. Would this change her dynamic with her grandfather?
Heck, is she even The Doctor's granddaughter? I mean, their dialogue in An Unearthly Child seems to indicate they were running away from the Time Lords for a reason, so was it simply because The Doctor stole a TARDIS? Could there be more to the mystery that could neatly be explored nearly sixty years after the show's very beginning?
9. Ohila
Perhaps an odd choice to some, but I feel Ohila's character warrants a return, considering her importance to The Doctor's character. Her first appearance back in 2013 saw her present for the Eighth Doctor's regeneration. Ohila was the one who finally pushed the Time Lord over the edge, forcing him to finally step properly into the Time War, despite his best efforts to stay out of it, and remain a healer.
Ohila made a couple of returns in Series 9, and was present for one of The Doctor's lowest moments. The events of Hell Bent caused the Time Lord to spiral out of control, becoming the infamous Hybrid, all for his desperate attempts to save Clara from death. There also seemed to be a history between them, beyond what we'd seen, and it would've been nice to see that explored further.
Like a lot of things from Hell Bent, they were completely brushed aside come Series 10. Sure, not all of the ideas in that final were handled well, but in terms of Gallifrey's return, and the Sisterhood of Karn, these are elements that shouldn't have been left abandoned. Now that Gallifrey has been destroyed by The Master, I feel we've lost a lot of potential storytelling, so we need to see what became of Ohila, and how she could become a part of the ongoing narrative, alongside the Sisterhood of Karn, given their strange relationship with the Time Lords.
8. The General
Again, another strange choice, but The General is another character who became important within The Doctor's life during the Moffat era. His first appearance in The Day of the Doctor placed him at the heart of crucial events, leading to The Doctor announcing his new plans to save Gallifrey, ultimately re-writing his own history.
Naturally, he came back during the events of Hell Bent, and once again became an integral element in The Doctor's narrative, given that he discarded his loyalty for Rassilon and sided with The Doctor during his rebellion against the insane, ancient Time Lord. Sadly, The Doctor in his Hybrid state certainly dicked over The General (which I still think is one of the most insulting scenes in Doctor Who history) but they ultimately regenerated and lived on.
So, it makes me wonder what happened to them. Did they perish with the rest of the Time Lords on Gallifrey during The Master's onslaught. It'd be nice to shed some light on how The Master ultimately destroyed the Time Lords (considering he presumably did it by himself). What if The General somehow survived, and actually helped the innocent bystanders caught in the middle of this brutal skirmish survive, and they escaped off-world to rebuild Time Lord society in some shape or form. Also, The General recently reappeared in Big Finish, so clearly their character hasn't been forgotten, and this means there's every chance they could return on screen one day.
7. Luke Smith
Although not strictly a Doctor Who character, Luke Smith has still made a massive impact on the show through his relationship to beloved ex-companion Sarah Jane Smith. Luke Smith made his debut back in 2007 during the premiere episode (Invasion of the Bane) of the newly established spin-off series, The Sarah Jane Adventures, were he eventually became Sarah Jane's adoptive son after being rescued by his creators, the Bane.
He would then make his way onto Doctor Who during the Series 4 finale, The Stolen Earth/Journey's End, were each of Russell T Davies' Whoniverse properties crossed over, before making one more small cameo during The End of Time. Luke remained on the spin-off as a regular until the Series 4 opener, The Nightmare Man, were he went off to college, returning then for sporadic appearances.
Sadly after the tragic death of Elisabeth Sladen, the spin-off show was put to rest and Luke Smith remained absent ever since. Of course, with Doctor Who Lockdown produced the beautiful epilogue story, Farewell, Sarah Jane, we now know a little bit more of what Luke has gotten up to since The Man Who Never Was, as well as the fact that Sarah Jane has passed away in canon (or maybe not, depending how you interpret the story).
Either way, now seems like a good time to bring Luke back in order to pay homage to Sarah Jane's legacy, and allowing further closure for the iconic character through her son's appearance, and perhaps him following in her footsteps and becoming The Doctor's companion. Heck, him just being a recurring character on Doctor Who would be a lovely way to pay tribute to our beloved Sarah Jane Smith.
6. K9
K9 is such a beloved character. I mean, he's a robot dog for crying out loud. What's not to love? Plus he became such a staple of the Fourth Doctor's run, next to jelly babies, and a long multi-coloured scarf. It's just saddening that the robot dog hasn't made too many comebacks since his final recurring appearance in Warrior's Gate.
He had a failed spin-off attempt, before having minimal screen time in his reappearances in both The Five Doctors, and School Reunion. Even when The Sarah Jane Adventures came along he wasn't made a recurring character until Series 3, but was disappointingly sent away with Luke Smith when he went off to college at the start of Series 4. Also, the less said about his second spin-off the better.
Considering K9 has already had four models, it's an easy assumption that K9 Mark V could easily be introduced down the line. Either The Doctor encounters this latest model, or he just randomly decides to build it himself. It'd just be really nice having K9 aboard the TARDIS as a companion again, and hearing John Leeson's voice once more. Perhaps you could see the return of K9 Mark IV, who'd perform a similar service as Luke coming back, thus paying tribute to Sarah Jane Smith through the inclusion of her loyal robot dog.
Or, going back to my original suggestion of introducing K9 Mark V, wouldn't it be poetic if Sarah Jane sent The Doctor this latest model, similar to how the Time Lord originally did the same for her in K9 and Company. It could be a final gift from her in order to remember her by, as well as saying thank you for all The Doctor had done for her. That would be beautiful.
5. Kate Stewart
I'm just going to say it. Kate Stewart was wasted by Steven Moffat. Her arrival in The Power of Three showed such promise for the future of the show. Not only was it a reminder of the UNIT days of the Third Doctor's tenure, but also a lovely tribute to The Brigadier, with Kate Stewart carrying on his legacy.
Sadly, I found Moffat's writing of the character was less to be desired, and she fell from grace time and time again, as he depicted her not as a scientist leading UNIT into a better age of problem solving, but just someone who was stricken by the militaristic mindset of blowing things up. Honestly, her father would be ashamed of her. I know he had a tendency of wanting to do things in a blunt military manner, but he gradually learnt from The Doctor and tried different horizons in solving the situation in front of him.
On top of that, we knew from Kate in The Power of Three that The Brigadier had taught her in the ways of The Doctor, so why was she constantly resorting to such extreme, callous methods of defeating her enemy, thus doing something that would make The Doctor (and her father) disappointed?
From what I can gather, she is used much better in Big Finish, and I'm glad that is the case, and that her character can be explored in a way that's faithful to her initial establishing, and that also pays tribute to The Brigadier. Honestly, I feel Chris Chibnall needs to give her another tackle, as he wrote her right originally, and it would also allow UNIT to return (as opposed to being shut down for the sake of a dumb Brexit joke).
4. Ace
Ace is just awesome. Plain and simple. Companions had a certain stereotype prior to Ace's arrival, one that indeed gave them a bad rep. Once Ace came into the picture things radically altered. From the companion being more head strong. Them being able to take care of themselves. The companion feeling more three dimensional in their characterisation. To actually having clear definitive development as a character. And, of course, holding a more personal connection with The Doctor.
Undoubtedly, Ace became the archetype for the modern-day companion. Beyond all that obvious stuff, Ace was just a breath of fresh air, and delivered a character model unheard of in Doctor Who at that point. She was a street kid who was rough around the edges, carried baseball bats, and even made her own explosives. But she was also inquisitive, and loyal, whilst also having the ability to stand up for herself (despite feeling vulnerable at times through her own fears and doubts), and even challenged The Doctor when she felt he was keeping things from her.
Ultimately, it's a simple answer of it'd be ace to see her come back. Not only because Ace is a badass character, but also so we can see see how she's grown since her last appearance. If the Cartmel Masterplan was anything to go by (alongside spin-off medias such as novels, comics, and Big Finish) then Ace was to be sent to Gallifrey to become a Time Lord, after The Doctor made her ready throughout their adventures together.
Of course, that begs the question of what happened to her during the Time War. Did she survive? It'd simply be nice to shed some light on the mystery of what became of Ace, and to see how she would react to the current events happening on the show.
3. Leela
Like Ace, Leela was another massive departure from the typical companion archetype, given she was a warrior who could battle her enemies. Sure, Leela wasn't the brightest of companions, but she was certainly loyal, and held so many strengths (both physically and mentally). Unfortunately, her departure was extremely forced, in that she fell in love with Andred out of the blue during the events of The Invasion of Time.
However, this has led to her character being heavily explored in Big Finish due to her association to Gallifrey, pairing her up with Romana in order to protect the Time Lord's home-world from many different threats. Inevitably, this forced her onto the frontlines of the Time War, as she aided the Time Lords in trying to defeat the might of the Daleks.
Though I haven't listened to the Gallifrey range as of yet, I have listened to her appearances during the War Doctor boxset, Casualties of War, and it is so depressing. Leela got struck by a time weapon and for a while lost her identity, as she experienced her infinite realities all at once, before inevitably being brought back from the brink by the War Doctor after years of torment.
As of yet, we do not know her fate. My hopes are that she did survive the Time War, and continued to help Gallifrey, perhaps even aiding them against the Master's onslaught, and maybe helped to get some of the civilians off world. Plus, it'd be nice to see how she could be incorporated into the ongoing events, as the Thirteenth Doctor explores the deceit of the past, which perhaps changes Leela's perspective on how she views the Time Lords as a whole.
2. Romana
Again, another example of a companion breaking the usual mould of how a companion is perceived. In many ways, Romana was like having a Female Doctor, before a Female Doctor was even a thing. She was very much just as brilliant, smart, witty, and heroic as The Doctor was. Honestly, her pairing with the Fourth Doctor was one of the best, with the two of them always feeling on equal grounds. It also felt refreshing that The Doctor was showing the wonders of the universe to one of his own people, thus desensitising her from the rudimentary, and duel ways of their society.
In the end, Romana refused to return home upon being recalled, and wanted to continue having a purpose out there in the universe, and so decided to remain in E-Space. Eventually, she returned to Gallifrey to become Lord President, which Big Finish explored within spin-off series, Gallifrey. I'm not too familiar with this range, but from what I've looked up it's clear Romana faced many trials. From maintaining order, to incriminating scandals, to her eventual departure as Lord President.
Romana then went on to work for the Celestial Intervention Agency, which is where she found herself facing perilous odds when trying to prevent the start of the Time War. In the end, history unravelled as it was intended, and the Time Lords were forced to go to war, with Romana edged into making even more difficult decisions in the name of victory (even consulting The Master for help on an important mission).
As of yet, we still don't know Romana's fate in the Time War. Perhaps Big Finish will shed some light on this come Gallifrey: Time War Volume 4. Either way, Romana is another character who would benefit from returning, and would help elevate the ongoing narrative. Perhaps she knew something of the Timeless Child deceit, having had access to the Matrix during her presidential years. It would add much to the ongoing discovery behind the Time Lord's origins, and corruption, and how their society could move forward should there be survivors like Romana.
1. The Eighth Doctor
Paul McGann certainly had a poor experience on Doctor Who, given his backdoor pilot (The TV Movie) ultimately failed in landing his incarnation a full American series with FOX. Sure, some could argue that this was for the best. However, it meant that the Eighth Doctor was left in the dark, with The TV Movie being his only physical appearance. Since Russell T Davies chose to start the New Series with a clean slate, it seemed like Paul McGann would never return on screen.
Luckily, he was finally graced the opportunity to shine once more for the mini-episode, The Night of the Doctor. Since then fans have been pinning for his return, given how seamlessly he slipped back into the role, as if he'd never been away. Then again, an argument could be made as to why he didn't feature in The Day of the Doctor. But I digress.
One of the main reasons I delved deep into Big Finish was because I wanted to explore the Eighth Doctor's journey. From his Main Range outings, the Eighth Doctor Adventures, his Time War range, The War Master, Susan's War, The Diary of River Song, to even The Legacy of Time (amongst many other appearances). Paul McGann has used the audio format to translate his version of the iconic character into an actual entity that we can follow and fall in love with. For me at least, he has become one of my favourite Doctor's next to Tom Baker and Matt Smith's incarnations.
Personally, I'd love to see Paul McGann given some well earned screen time, allowing him to channel all the hard work he's put in over the years with Big Finish. It worked perfectly for The Night of the Doctor, so why can't it work in a full episode, or even a series of episodes? Heck, why not have him around for an entire series, where the plotline revolves around the dimensions of time folding in on themselves, and the Thirteenth Doctor and the Eighth Doctor's timelines converge, forcing them to work together to solve the catastrophe. Or, at the very least, make sure he has a massive role in the 60th Anniversary Special.