10 Doctor Who Episodes NOBODY Was Ready For

In the words of the Tenth Doctor... WHAT?!

By Millie Hinchliffe /

We never know what we’re going to get when we tune in for a new episode of Doctor Who. Sometimes, it can be your simple monster-of-the-week story. Other times, we get a history lesson, or a high-concept thrillride. Sometimes, it's everything at once!

Every now and then though, an episode comes along that is so good, so surprising, or so... well, nutty, that it catches you completely off guard.

Advertisement

We aren’t focusing on plot twists or cliffhangers in this list (though some will be mentioned), but rather those overall episodes that were unique, subversive, shocking, or took fans by surprise in one way or another.

For a show that’s been going for nearly 60 years, it’s wonderful that it’s still able to grip the attention of fans and come up with new and refreshing ideas. Doctor Who has always played by its own rules, which is one of the reasons why it's able to pull such unique episodes out of the bag in the first place.

You almost certainly weren't prepared for these episodes for one reason or another, and if you say you were, then you're misremembering. Or lying.

10. The Night Of The Doctor

To commemorate the show’s 50th anniversary, Doctor Who put out a minisode called The Night of the Doctor, which brought back Paul McGann as the Eighth Doctor - his first live-action appearance in the role since the 1996 TV movie.

When the show returned with Christopher Eccleston in 2005, we never knew why the Doctor had regenerated from the Eighth to the Ninth. However, it was implied in Eccleston's first appearance that the regeneration was recent, as the Ninth Doctor didn’t know what he looked like until he saw himself in a mirror.

But instead of regenerating into Eccleston’s Doctor, this minisode showed us that Eight had instead regenerated into the War Doctor first, answering a few questions that fans had after The Name of the Doctor’s shocking cliffhanger.

The Night of the Doctor was a well-kept secret, and as a result, nobody was expecting McGann to return as the Doctor in this way. We're glad he did though, because he was wonderful in the few brief minutes he had here.

Let's hope he gets more to do in the future, eh?

9. Fugitive Of The Judoon

Fugitive of the Judoon saw the introduction of a new incarnation of the Doctor - an incarnation that no fan had seen (or heard of) until this point.

Neither of these Doctors can remember living the life of the other, which was both a confusing and intriguing development. However, this new Fugitive Doctor did possess her own police box TARDIS, indicating that she came after William Hartnell's First Doctor. It's still unclear.

To quote Tom Baker's Curator in The Day of the Doctor, "Who knows?"

Advertisement

As if this revelation wasn’t shocking enough, fans were also treated to the return of the beloved Captain Jack Harkness. Like the Fugitive Doctor, this reveal was kept completely under wraps, making for a jaw-dropping surprise when the cheeky Time Agent's voice was first heard talking to a rather confused Graham O'Brien.

It was expected that this episode would be a standard mid-series romp focused on the Judoon (who, despite the title, are basically a subplot in their own story). Absolutely nobody expected it to change the very fabric of Doctor Who as we knew it - and bring back Captain Jack to boot.

8. Asylum Of The Daleks

After the announcement that Karen Gillan and Arthur Darvill would be making way for Jenna Coleman as the new companion, it was expected that we'd first meet her after the Ponds had left the show.

However, during Asylum of the Daleks, we meet Oswin Oswald (Coleman) living her rather odd day-to-day life, trapped in the Dalek Asylum after crashing there a year prior. Fans would be forgiven for thinking that the Doctor was going to save Oswin and have her join the TARDIS crew - but that wasn’t the case at all.

It turns out that Oswin never escaped from the Daleks after the crash and she became a Dalek herself, but the truth was too much for her to handle, so she created a world inside her head, and was waiting for someone else to come and rescue her.

In simpler terms: Oswin Oswald had died.

It begged the question, "How could Oswin have died if Jenna Coleman was announced to be the next companion?" and though fans would eventually find out that there were multiple versions of Clara/Oswin scattered throughout the Doctor’s life, nobody expected her to be introduced in the way that she was.

7. The Power Of The Doctor

Where do we even begin with this one? From its earliest bits of marketing, fans could tell that they were in for a treat, with favourites like Ace, Tegan, and Kate Stewart confirmed to return.

But none of us were truly prepared for the sheer volume of surprises that The Power of the Doctor had in store.

Advertisement

For one thing, this episode was never promoted as a multi-Doctor special, so seeing the return of Doctors One, Five, Six, Seven, and Eight was a joyful surprise for all Who fans. Watching the Fifth and Seventh Doctors have a heartfelt chat with their respective companions was the icing on the cake, gaining closure for things said and done in the past.

There was also the companion support group at the very end of the episode, which brought back characters like Mel Bush, Jo Grant, and Ian Chesterton, much to the surprise (and delight) of classic Who lovers.

However, it was the ending that had fans truly shocked - at least, those who aren't on Twitter all day.

As we said our final goodbyes to the Thirteenth Doctor, plenty of people expected Ncuti Gatwa to appear onscreen, due to him being announced as the next Doctor several months prior. Instead, we got none other than David Tennant, reprising the role onscreen for the first time since 2013.

Alright then, we'll say it... "WHAT?!"

6. Sleep No More

Mark Gatiss’ Sleep No More is one of the most divisive episodes in the show. At the time, it had the lowest viewing figures of any episode of the revival, but with a decent 61% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, it also has its fans.

Advertisement

This divisiveness largely stemmed from the unexpected nature of the episode, which took a big swing that some would argue didn’t pay off.

Playing out like a found-footage horror film, Sleep No More was a radical departure from your typical Doctor Who fare, even forgoing the show’s classic opening credits sequence in favour of a custom title card.

It was also a standalone episode in a series that had consisted entirely of two-parters up to this point, another reason why it feels like an oddball not just in Series 9, but in all of modern Who. And for some extra WTF points, it also ends on an unresolved cliffhanger, which left millions of viewers feeling suitably jarred.

5. The Girl Who Waited

The second half of Series 6 got off to a rocky start with episodes like Let's Kill Hitler and Night Terrors, but out of nowhere came The Girl Who Waited.

Similarly to Amy’s Choice, the relationship between Amy and Rory was front and centre in this episode, while the Doctor’s recklessness and morals (particularly where his companions are concerned) were also brought into question.

The Doctor, Amy, and Rory land on the resort planet of Apalapucia, where Amy soon finds herself alone in a different timeline, left behind to fend for herself as she waits for the Doctor to come and save her.

Rory then finds an older, bitter version of Amy, who tells him she’s been waiting for 36 years. The episode switches between old and young Amy, finally bringing them together when the Doctor promises Rory that the TARDIS can hold both versions at once.

Rule one: the Doctor lies.

Coming from the guy whose only previous Doctor Who credit was the mediocre Rise of the Cybermen/The Age of Steel, few were expecting The Girl Who Waited to be such a tour-de-force of writing, direction, and acting, with Gillan delivering her best performance (actually, two of her best performances) as Amy.

Advertisement

Writer Tom MacRae has referred to this episode as his "most accomplished piece of plotting ever" - high praise that The Girl Who Waited more than earns.

4. Blink

After the disastrous Love & Monsters, an episode that doesn't feature the Doctor was a concerning prospect - but Blink made that concern disappear almost instantly.

After finding out that the Doctor and Martha have been sent back in time without the TARDIS, a woman named Sally Sparrow (brilliantly played by Carey Mulligan), finds herself stuck in the middle of helping the Doctor, and running away from the creepy Weeping Angels who are stalking her.

A mixture of great writing, acting, and the introduction of the scariest Doctor Who monster of all time is what made this episode successful. Despite the absence of the Doctor, the episode just worked, with Sally Sparrow being a strong enough protagonist to carry the episode almost single-handedly.

That's not to forget Larry, of course - we love that guy!

After The Empty Child, The Doctor Dances, and The Girl in the Fireplace, it was expected that Steven Moffat would deliver the goods with his next episode. But was it expected that he'd deliver one of the best Doctor Who stories and villains of all time, in an episode that barely features the Doctor? No. No it was not.

Advertisement

3. The Timeless Children

Love it or hate it, you can't deny that nobody expected the game-changing twists featured in The Timeless Children.

Both the Doctor (and the audience) had the shock of finding out that the character isn't who they thought they were. We believed that the Doctor was a Time Lord from Gallifrey, and while they still technically are, it was revealed that the Doctor was originally found on another planet, and was the source of the regenerative powers that created Time Lord society as we know it.

This reveal didn’t go down very well with countless fans of the show, as it completely messed with everything we thought we knew about the Doctor’s past. It was a bold move on Chris Chibnall's part, but that doesn't make it good.

Either way, Doctor Who fandom was completely and utterly stunned by the events of this episode. We knew that something big was coming, but nobody had "Completely rewrite the Doctor's backstory" on their Series 12 finale bingo card.

Advertisement

2. Rose

After going on a 16-year hiatus, Doctor Who announced that it was going to be returning in 2005, with Christopher Eccleston as the Doctor, and Billie Piper as his companion. Before the episode aired, fans criticised the new logo and the changing of the TARDIS, with some going so far as to send hate mail to the production team.

Due to the ongoing criticism and previous behind-the-scenes drama that caused the show to be cancelled in the first place, there was a lot of skepticism that the 2005 revival was actually going to work.

Spoiler alert: It did.

The first episode, Rose, peaked at 10.81 million viewers when it aired, making it one of the most-viewed NuWho episodes to this day.

The episode had the massive job of introducing the Doctor to both an old and new audience, and despite making the risky move of focusing the episode more on the companion, the show made the good decision of bringing back an old monster, the Autons, to satiate some of that classic demand.

In short, the whole thing worked wonderfully - even in the face of all the doubt that led up to it.

Advertisement

1. The Name Of The Doctor

Excitement for Doctor Who’s 50th anniversary was at an all-time high when this episode aired a few months prior to the big day.

Fans all around the world were speculating about who would be returning in the 50th, and what the overall story was going to be about. But introducing a previously unseen incarnation of the Doctor, played by the legendary John Hurt, no less? Yeah - nobody saw that coming.

The Name of the Doctor dropped this bomb as a tantalising lead-in to the 50th, with the words “Introducing John Hurt as the Doctor” sending Whovians into a frenzy of excitement, confusion, and tons of speculation.

Advertisement

The reveal changed any and all theories people had about the 50th anniversary, with it now being clear that Moffat was planning something much bigger than we'd anticipated.

This moment changed Doctor Who forever, and fortunately, the actual 50th episode - The Day of the Doctor - was a roaring success, cementing Hurt's War Doctor as a crucial incarnation in the Doctor's life.

Advertisement