10 Doctor Who Plot Holes You Didn't Realise Were Actually Solved
Did The Timeless Children completely break River Song's character? Not exactly...
Any long running science-fiction or fantasy series is bound to run into plot holes sooner or later. When you have multiple writers all working in a completely fictional universe, wires get crossed, narrative details get forgotten, and stories end up contradicting each other (or themselves) at one point or another.
And all of these things are twice as likely when a show is as long-running and has as chaotic an attitude to its lore as Doctor Who. Sometimes new stories change established details out of the blue; sometimes, completely unrelated narrative threads collide in unpredictable ways; and sometimes, events that should be permanently world-changing have to be downplayed just to keep everything relatable to the average audience.
Occasionally, an episode will even end up contradicting itself, whether due to details getting lost between script drafts, or overly-enthusiastic editing.
And yet for all the chaos, complexity, and contradiction, Doctor Who isn't quite as careless with its lore as people sometimes think. From seemingly insignificant lines of dialogue that massively shift the status quo, to years-later explanations of older episodes, here are 10 Doctor Who plot holes you didn't realise were actually solved...
10. Why Doesn't The Wall Reset In Heaven Sent?
Steven Moffat has always had a knack for intricately-constructed stories that play with time travel, with episodes like The Girl in the Fireplace, Blink, and The Big Bang all garnering huge acclaim.
His timey-wimiest though has to be Heaven Sent, where the Doctor is trapped and endlessly reliving the same experiences for billions of years. It’s such an interesting and well-executed premise that it’s really no surprise that it was immediately recognised as an all-time classic upon its release.
And yet for such a tightly-wound script, there’s one large detail fans have pondered over since broadcast: if everything in the Confession Dial constantly resets, how is the Doctor able to (very slowly) punch his way through the diamond wall? Shouldn’t it reset too, along with everything else?
The answer, it turns out, is a rather straightforward one. As Moffat himself points out in an interview, the diamond wall isn’t inside the confession dial at all; it’s the exterior wall. It doesn’t reset because it’s the container inside which the resetting happens.
This also gives an indication as to why the Time Lords considered a metres-thick wall of solid diamond a reasonable investment. If they want the Doctor to remain trapped inside their torture dimension you might as well make its walls out of something he could never break through.
After all, who’d be crazy enough to spend infinite lifetimes punching diamonds with their bare hands?
9. Where Did Fifteen Get The Whistle?
At the climax of Empire of Death, all seems lost: Sutekh has won, and life has been all-but eradicated from the universe. But the Doctor always has one last trick up his sleeve, and this time it's... a whistle that can control the TARDIS remotely, that he randomly picked up earlier in the episode with next to no explanation? Eh?
This understandably left fans asking questions. Questions such as: "What is happening?" and... well, mainly just that first one really.
Turns out that Ruby Sunday also asked that exact question in a (slightly bafflingly) deleted scene from Empire of Death. In the scene, it turns out that the Doctor himself creates something of a bootstrap paradox, passing the whistle back to his younger self through the floor of his TARDIS after using it to defeat Sutekh.
It might not be the most satisfying of answers, but when the stakes are so high in a series finale, it's 30 seconds or so that would probably have been worth keeping, to give the Doctor’s victory a little more foundation than a whistle falling out of a ceiling panel.
Especially in an episode that spends five minutes on a lady and a spoon...
8. Why Didn't The TARDIS Translate The Pope?
One of the TARDIS’s many handy features is that it can instinctively translate any known language and telepathically transmit the results to its passengers. No matter how far you travel in either time or space you should be able to converse with pretty much anybody you meet. In fact, it’s translation matrix is so advanced that when it's unable to translate text in The Impossible Planet, the Doctor immediately takes that as a very, very bad sign.
But for some reason it can't translate the Pope?
Admittedly the Pope of all people inadvertently ruining Bill’s date works so much better if he’s babbling incoherently in Italian. But at the end of the day it's still a human speaking a common Earth language – you’d think the TARDIS wouldn’t have much of an issue with that.
This seeming plot inconsistency is once again addressed in a deleted scene, with Steven Moffat explaining in an interview with Radio Times that:
"I did write in the Doctor saying he didn’t really need the translation, and Nardole suggesting that he play along out of courtesy – but it glitched the scene, so I lost it in the edit. In fairness, the Doctor’s translation ability has wobbled before, so it’s just having another off moment."
That said, there is also another potential explanation in the episode as broadcast: this isn’t the real Pope or the real TARDIS. Almost the entirety of Extremis takes place in a simulated universe created by the Monks – a simulation that is shown multiple times to not be 100% accurate to the real world.
More than likely this was just a glitch in the matrix. Or the Monks thought it would be funny if the Pope wasn't translated. Either or.
7. How Does Humanity Keep Forgetting All The Alien Invasions?
One of the most regularly-occurring plot holes in Doctor Who history has been the human race’s general obliviousness to the constant alien invasions happening in contemporary Britain.
You’d think a world that has seen Cybermen climbing out of manhole covers at St Paul’s cathedral, dinosaurs walking the streets of London, Daleks transporting the Earth halfway across the universe, and dummies murdering innocent shoppers two separate times would have evolved into a society quite a bit different to ours. Yet no matter what, modern-day London (almost) always looks pretty much as you’d expect.
There have been some token efforts to clear this up over the years, usually involving implications that UNIT (and later Torchwood) are covering up any traces of alien activity to keep our knowledge of extraterrestrial life a secret, but these have never been particularly robust. There’s even a moment in Remembrance of the Daleks where the Doctor lampshades this, commenting on humanity’s “most amazing capacity for self-deception.”
It also doesn’t help that the show can be occasionally inconsistent with who remembers what – most modern day companions have never heard of a Dalek, but their invasion in The Stolen Earth forms an important part of Adelaide Brooke’s backstory in The Waters of Mars.
It wasn’t until Series 5 that we finally got an explanation that stood up under any amount of scrutiny, when the Doctor attributes humanity’s convenient recurring amnesia to the all-consuming cracks in time. It’s an easy explanation granted, but when you’re trying to explain away the world’s population forgetting ghosts turning into Cybermen and a giant metal robot stomping about the place, the fabric of time and space being fundamentally fractured feels a bit more appropriate than “the military hid the evidence and claimed it was a gas leak.”
6. How Doesn't The Doctor Know Which Osgood Survived?
Ever since their first appearance in 1975, the Zygons have had clearly established powers. They can shapeshift into the form of a humanoid creature with near-perfect accuracy, but they need to have a living host to copy. If the host either dies or is rescued, the Zygon cannot retain its shape and will revert back to a “big red rubbery thing covered in suckers,” as the Tenth Doctor so eloquently put it.
This has left some fans slightly confused about the Doctor’s confusion as to which version of Osgood was killed by Missy in Death in Heaven, and which one survived. After all, if the human Osgood had died, the Zygon version wouldn’t be able to remain looking like Osgood. So it must have been the Zygon that was killed.
But as we discover in Series 9’s Zygon two-parter, things are no longer that simple, with Osgood describing the commonly understood system as “the old rules.” It turns out at some point before these episodes, the Zygons underwent a slight upgrade, and are now capable of shapeshifting into the form of anybody they’ve already scanned. Osgood says:
"Those were the old rules, before Zygons could pluck loved ones from your memory and wear their faces. Zygons only need to keep the original alive if they need more information from them. If the interrogation is over, then the original can die."
As if the Zygons weren’t terrifying enough already...
5. How Did Skaro Come Back After Remembrance Of The Daleks?
Remembrance of the Daleks is notable for being one of the few times the Doctor begins an episode with a fully thought-out plan. Setting the tone for the rest of his incarnation, Remembrance shows the Seventh Doctor playing two warring Dalek factions against each other, getting one to wipe out the other before manipulating the victors into unintentionally destroying Skaro with the hand of Omega.
It’s a huge moment in the series’ history with the Doctor finally taking matters into his own hands and actively attempting to wipe out his greatest foe, arguably firing the first shot of the Time War in the process. It was therefore a bit of a shock to long-time fans when Skaro was mentioned as being very much intact in the TV Movie, even more so when it showed up pretty much back to its old self in Asylum of the Daleks, and later The Magician’s Apprentice/The Witch’s Familiar.
This has, however, been addressed multiple times in the Doctor Who expanded universe, and the answer is rather obvious in retrospect: it was a Time War, and the Daleks meddled with time. Wibbly-wobbly, timey-wimey, etc.
Really, this one only appears to be a plot hole because it’s easy to forget the absolutely immense scale Doctor Who can sometimes operate on. A sun going supernova and wiping out a planet might seem like a big deal on the face of it, but in a series where two time-travelling species are having the war-to-end-all-wars across all of time and space, resurrecting a planet isn’t really that infeasible a task.
For an even simpler explanation, as Missy puts it: “They’ve brought it back.” It's not a stretch to imagine the Daleks rebuilding Skaro – after all they must've built it in the first place!
4. Why Are Cybermen From Different Universes So Similar?
When Doctor Who returned in 2005 its writers were faced with the unenviable task of reintroducing the series’ various monsters and aliens to a new generation who were largely unfamiliar with them. This happened slowly over the course of multiple years, with each villain usually arriving with a vague pre-existing relationship to the Doctor.
The exception to this was the Cybermen. Instead of bringing back the Doctor’s second-most iconic alien foes as they were in the classic series, the show gave us a whole new origin story for them, sending the TARDIS team to a parallel universe where they witness the completely different genesis of a completely different race of Cybermen.
And yet despite having a unique origin to our universe’s Cybermen, the Cybus Industries Cybermen from Pete’s World are conveniently, incredibly similar to their Mondasian counterparts. This issue gets further muddled as the series goes on and the Cybus branding is phased out of the Cyberman design, as it becomes increasingly unclear which universe’s Cybermen are appearing.
This was all eventually cleared up in World Enough and Time/The Doctor Falls, where we get to witness a third Cyberman origin on board a Mondasian colony ship. Here, the Doctor proposes the theory of “parallel evolution”, positing that Cybermen are, in a sense, a form of evolutionary inevitability (try saying that ten times fast), with multiple species across space and time all turning themselves into somewhat similar versions of the iconic man-machine hybrids.
3. How Can River Regenerate After The Timeless Children?
The Timeless Child had a monumental influence on the Doctor Who universe, with its revelations about the true source of the Time Lords’ regenerative abilities creating endless questions, conflicts, and confusion.
As if Doctor Who needed more complications to its lore.
One of the most glaring questions it throws up is that of River Song, who grew up to have Time Lord regeneration powers despite being the child of Amy and Rory, two humans.
In Series 6 it’s implied that she gains these powers as a result of being conceived while the TARDIS is mid-flight in the time vortex, but The Timeless Child reveals that the Time Lords’ abilities are not a natural phenomenon, but something genetically engineered into them. So how did River gain her powers in the first place?
The answer is laid out in the very same episode that first revealed River’s true identity, A Good Man Goes to War. While everybody remembers the point about River being conceived in the TARDIS, this is actually only one piece of the puzzle. As Vastra says to the Doctor, that was merely "a head start", and the Silence then had to work very hard to morph River's DNA further to get the result they wanted.
In other words, no, being conceived in the time vortex still isn't enough to suddenly cook yourself a Time Lord – there's still more work to be done!
Considering this, if anything The Timeless Children actually makes River’s backstory make more sense, giving a potential explanation for how the Silence were able to genetically alter her. We literally see Tecteun conducting all sorts of genetic experiments with regeneration in The Timeless Children, so who's to say the Silence didn't do something similar with their own adopted child?
2. Hasn't The Doctor Been That Far Out Before?
Wild Blue Yonder makes a very big deal of sending the Doctor out farther than he’s ever been before, stranding him and Donna at the very edge of the universe.
It is a dark, lonely place – similar to Leeds – with the Doctor repeatedly reinforcing to Donna the implications of how far they’ve gone.
But the thing is, this isn’t really new for the Doctor. He’s been to the edge of the universe, the end of the universe, different universes, and even outside the universe altogether. So what makes Wild Blue Yonder different? Why is the Fourteenth Doctor so scared?
The answer here is context. The Doctor isn’t just scared because of where they are, but because of how exposed they are to it.
This is made much more clear in a deleted scene from the episode's script, where the Doctor explains to Donna that he’s thus far ventured so far out "only inside magnificent Timeships." But being there without protection is not only something he hasn’t done before, but that "No one ever has."
It's another moment that again is so brief that you have to wonder why it was cut in the first place, because it also adds new depth to the Doctor's reaction at where he and Donna end up at the start of the episode.
1. How Did The Daleks Survive Journey's End?
The Daleks being defeated by the Doctor only to return the very next series is about as guaranteed as the sun rising in the morning, or water being incredibly wet.
That said, there are some Dalek defeats that are a bit more “final” than others, and there’s arguably none more final than their highly explosive and thorough destruction by the Metacrisis Doctor at the climax of Journey’s End.
It may seem a little odd then that the Daleks almost immediately show back up in Series 5’s Victory of the Daleks. And there’s no use chalking it up to time-travel shenanigans – these Daleks are explicitly shown to be the last of the army from Series 4’s finale. So what gives?
The solution
to this is actually briefly visible in Journey's End. When the Metacrisis Doctor “maximises the
Dalekanium power feeds”, the episode cuts to show the Dalek fleet
exploding in space. But if you look very
closely, you can actually see a single ship slipping off out of the shot. This ship is confirmed by RTD to be the same
one that reappears in Victory of the Daleks!
With RTD on the way out of Doctor Who he decided to extend a Dalek-shaped hand to his successor Steven Moffat, to give him a built-in reason why the pepper pots could survive. Wasn't that nice?