10 Dropped Doctor Who Plot Threads We'll Never Get Answers To

Rose has a TARDIS. Did everyone just forget that?!

By Danny Meegan /

Considering that Doctor Who is almost sixty years old, it's really not surprising that a vast amount of story has been left by the wayside throughout its run.

Advertisement

After all, writers, producers and showrunners eventually move on, actors leave - often taking their associated plot points with them - and audience reaction can dictate what does and doesn't appear in the show, creating even more abandoned narrative threads.

And when you factor in the standalone nature of most episodes - as well as the time travel element, which can easily overwrite and change certain things - it's pretty much inevitable that some stories will just become lost within the huge, all-consuming time vortex of wibbly-wobbly doom... otherwise known as Doctor Who history.

Bearing that in mind then, here are some storyline setups, character arcs and plot ideas that we still haven't revisited - and probably never will. While some of these may have resurfaced in comic books, novels and audio dramas, the main TV show is the central pillar of Doctor Who canon, and in this area, we've been left in the dark.

10. The Truth Behind The Midnight Entity

One of the most chilling episodes in Doctor Who history, Series 4's Midnight pits the Doctor against a terrifying, powerful - and most importantly - unseen enemy.

Advertisement

The Midnight entity approaches the Doctor (and a group of citizens) while he's trapped inside a broken-down tour bus, and is somehow able to enter said bus without any of its passengers noticing, and without leaving a single trace of damage. It then stealthily possesses people, never showing its true form.

While the entity is seemingly vanquished at the end of the episode - and even that isn't a sure thing - it remains one of the only monsters in the universe that the Doctor knows nothing about, and we haven't seen it in another episode since Series 4 aired.

So what exactly is the Midnight entity? What does it look like? Are there more?

While there have been plenty of theories suggested by fans, we don't know the answers to any of these questions, which is unusual because Doctor Who, normally, does at least do some explaining about its bad guys.

That being said, the episode was clearly deliberately designed to reveal as little information as possible, and the lack of details about the entity only enhances the suspense. So it wouldn't be a total tragedy if it went unexplained permanently.

9. The TARDIS Adventures Of Me

At the end of Series 9, Clara Oswald jets off (in her very own TARDIS) to see the universe, with her immortal friend Me in tow. But this trip can't last forever.

Advertisement

Why? Because - technically speaking - Clara is dead. She's only alive at this point because the Doctor plucked her from her timeline mere moments before her death. Eventually, she'll have to re-enter said timeline, and accept her demise.

And so, when this happens, Me - a character who can never die, never age, and has a proven track record of causing mischief and mayhem - will be left in sole control of the TARDIS, without Clara's kinder and more positive moral compass to guide her.

As a result, Me could easily wreak untold havoc throughout the universe. It's a potential recipe for disaster, but it's something that the show hasn't yet addressed.

And in the end, it probably never will. With Series 9 showrunner Steven Moffat having left Doctor Who and Maisie Williams ruling out a return as Me, it just isn't realistic to expect the character to appear ever again.

8. The Silurians Sharing The Earth

Series 5's Chris Chibnall-penned two-parter The Hungry Earth and Cold Blood brought the Silurians back to Doctor Who, in a story revolving around an enormous Silurian civilization living beneath the surface of the Earth.

Advertisement

However, they're not entirely satisfied with their current housing conditions. The Silurians want to move above ground and live on the actual surface of the planet, rather than underneath it. As such, Cold Blood includes a plotline about the humans and the Silurians trying to work out an agreement that will allow the two species to share the Earth. But in the end, this situation proves too difficult to resolve.

And so, the Doctor proposes a solution: the Silurians will go into hibernation for 1,000 years, and afterwards, they will emerge, and the human race must be ready to share the planet with them. This is where the story ends, but in the ten years since Series 5 aired, we haven't yet revisited exactly what happened when the Silurians woke up.

And this has left many questions dangling. Were the humans ready to accept the Silurians? Were they not ready? Was there a war? There's a bit of narration at the start of Cold Blood that hints at a peaceful co-existence, but the finer, far more interesting details of this storyline are still frustratingly unclear.

Chibnall even revisited the Silurians in Series 7's Dinosaurs on a Spaceship, but he chose not to reference the events of Cold Blood. In all likelihood, that piece of narration is all we're going to hear on the matter.

7. Ace's Ambiguous Ending

When Doctor Who was dropped by the BBC in 1989, many things came to an abrupt end. Sylvester McCoy's time as the Doctor was suddenly over, as was John Nathan-Turner's lengthy tenure as producer.

Advertisement

In addition, this cancellation also claimed another notable victim: the Doctor's companion, Ace, whose fate has never been properly addressed in the show.

While McCoy's Doctor did return to regenerate in the 1996 TV movie, Ace wasn't with him, which is rather odd, considering that the end of Survival - the final serial of the classic era - sees the pair walking off into the distance, with the Doctor saying "Come on Ace, we've got work to do!" hinting that they will continue travelling together.

That final scene was full of hope and optimism, so then... what happened to Ace after this point, and why wasn't she with the Doctor in the TV movie?

While the character has been given a lot of love in novels and Big Finish audio dramas since 1989 (and we do know that, if the show hadn't been cancelled, there were plans to bring her to Gallifrey and turn her into a Time Lord), Ace was basically just dropped, and actress Sophie Aldred didn't get a definitive onscreen ending like McCoy did.

6. The Whereabouts Of The Kovarian Chapter

Madame Kovarian was the big overarching villain of Series 6, and along with the Kovarian Chapter, she was responsible for turning River Song into a murderous psychopath, resulting in the Doctor's "death" on the shores of Lake Silencio.

Advertisement

In finale episode The Wedding of River Song, Kovarian was killed by Amy Pond in an act of revenge, which seemed to put an end to her once and for all. But then, the events of this story were wiped from continuity when the timeline was aborted, meaning that Kovarian (and, presumably, some of her Kovarian Chapter followers) is still running around out there in the Whoniverse, possibly plotting another evil scheme.

Now sure, villains get abandoned all the time in Doctor Who, but Kovarian had such a raw, unbridled hatred for the Doctor that it's really hard to believe that she'd just leave him alone, especially after discovering that he was still alive.

However, Kovarian was a Steven Moffat creation, and since he's no longer with Doctor Who, it's highly unlikely that we'll ever see her return. Not that other writers can't reuse villains, but Kovarian was so intrinsically tied to Moffat's Series 6 arc that it would feel really weird to have someone else try and pick this thread back up.

5. The Alliance Of Villains

While this isn't an abandoned plot thread exactly, it's still an abandoned and untapped story idea, one that we'll probably never see more of.

Advertisement

In the first half of the Series 5 finale, the Doctor is captured and sealed inside the Pandorica, an inescapable prison that was specifically built to contain him. And which villain was responsible for this ultimate victory? Well... all of them.

This "Pandorica plan" was engineered by a group known as The Alliance, a league of bad guys that combined forces to achieve one mutually-beneficial goal: stopping the Doctor. Despite consistently failing as individuals, they were successful as a team, and for a brief time, the Doctor had been unequivocally defeated.

So why has The Alliance never been formed again since? The Daleks, the Cybermen, the Sontarans, the Judoon, the Autons... together, they managed to defeat their greatest foe, so it does seem strange that they've never again considered putting aside their squabbles to focus on the one being who actually threatens them all.

Sure, the events of The Big Bang mean that the members of The Alliance won't remember their Pandorica victory, but regardless, they must know that they'll stand a better chance against the Doctor as a unit. However, the topic of villainous team-ups - at least, on the scale of The Alliance - hasn't been broached in the decade since Series 5 aired. Realistically, we'll never see an evil league like this again.

4. Sleep No More's Cliffhanger Ending

Sleep No More is a standalone episode in a series that's stuffed with two-parters, so it's actually quite funny that it concludes with a cliffhanger.

Advertisement

At the very end of the story, it's revealed that narrator Rassmussen is actually one of the Sandmen, villains that are made up of that crusty stuff you find in your eyes after a long sleep. Yes, really. Turns out that Rassmussen edited the whole episode together himself, found footage style, embedding a signal within the video that will convert anyone who watches it into a Sandman too.

He finishes by saying that he's going to broadcast the episode to the whole solar system, meaning that billions of people could potentially watch the footage, transforming them into Sandmen and basically destroying the Earth as a result.

So what happened after this point? Did Rassmussen's plan work? Was the entire solar system turned into a Sandman playground? We just don't know.

At one point, writer Mark Gatiss was planning to do a sequel to this episode in Series 10, indicating that he had a bigger story planned. However, he ended up writing Empress of Mars instead, leaving Sleep No More's ending unresolved.

3. The Mystery Of The Valeyard

The Trial of a Time Lord - Colin Baker's final series - introduced the mysterious Valeyard, a Time Lord prosecutor who, according to the Master, is a sinister future incarnation of the Doctor, a physical manifestation of his darkest impulses.

Advertisement

Considering how important this reveal was in relation to Doctor Who canon, the Valeyard seemed primed to become a recurring character in the Whoniverse (perhaps like the Master) allowing the show to fill in some of the blanks that his brief stint left wide open: how was he created? Where, specifically, does he stem from in the Doctor's timeline? Heck, when we last saw him onscreen at the end of Trial of a Time Lord, he was laughing right into the camera, hinting at more villainous antics to come.

But nope. We haven't seen him since.

The Valeyard is one of those characters who's brought up every single time a new Doctor Who series is about to be broadcast, with people saying that he should be the new overarching villain, and many theories being posited about how he could return.

But at this point - over 30 years after his last appearance - it just feels like the creators don't care about the Valeyard as much as the fans do.

2. The Curious Absence Of The Reapers

In the Series 1 episode Father's Day, Rose alters a fixed point in time when she stops her father, Pete, from dying in a car accident.

Advertisement

In response to her meddling, a group of winged creatures - Reapers - appear in the sky and start attacking people at random. The Doctor describes these creatures as bacteria being drawn to a wound, indicating that the Reapers are attracted to fixed points in time that have been messed with or changed in some way.

So isn't it pretty odd that we haven't seen the Reapers since this episode? The Doctor and his companions have tampered with fixed points in time on countless occasions since Father's Day, and yet, the Reapers haven't shown up to play.

There are plenty of theories as to why this might be - some speculate that the incident in Father's Day was unique, while others think that the Reapers themselves are rare beings who can't attend to every single crack in the universe's timeline.

But if we're being honest, the real reason why we've only seen them in one episode - and the reason why we'll probably never see them in another - is because it just isn't feasible (from a production or scriptwriting standpoint) to have to bring back the same monster over and over again whenever a story involves some time-meddling.

1. Rose And The Meta-Crisis Doctor's TARDIS Adventures

While this plot thread was kicked off in a deleted scene, former showrunner Russell T Davies has said that he considers it a part of the show, and plus, it's just a really interesting idea to think about.

Advertisement

After Rose Tyler helps the Doctor defeat the Daleks in the Series 4 finale, she has to return to her own universe, but this time, she has the Meta-Crisis Doctor (a clone of the Tenth Doctor created in a prior episode) with her.

In the final, broadcast version of this scene, the real Doctor leaves the couple on a beach and flies off, but there's an additional deleted moment where he gives the Meta-Crisis Doctor a piece of the TARDIS and tells him to "grow your own".

As a result, Rose and her knock-off Doctor are in possession of their own TARDIS, meaning that they're probably having their own weird and wonderful adventures in space and time, all within their own parallel universe.

While it's nice to think that Rose and a version of the Tenth Doctor are still out there somewhere, journeying through the cosmos, this plot thread will likely never be revisited, for several reasons.

For one thing, it was started in a deleted scene, but the main sticking point is that it would require David Tennant and Billie Piper to return to the show - not impossible for Doctor Who, sure, but a scenario that seems like a fanboy pipe dream at best.

-

Got any other dropped story points in Doctor Who that we'll probably never get to revisit? Let us know in the comments section!

Advertisement