10 Failed TV Shows That Became Cult Classics

Firefly, we hardly knew ye.

By Jack Pooley /

Fox

As complicated as the world of filmmaking is, the machinations of TV are even more chaotic and difficult to understand.

Advertisement

With most shows operating on a season-by-season basis for their survival, it's sadly all too common for beloved shows to get the chop long before they've had a chance to live out their natural creative lives.

The annals of TV history are littered with great shows that struggled to find an audience, for one reason or another, and consequently were no longer a viable property for their respective network.

Advertisement

While there are tales of passionate fan campaigns bringing shows back from the dead - Arrested Development being perhaps the most famous case - this is of course a rare exception, and most of the time, "failed" shows tend to just stay dead.

But the premature cancellation generally only fuelled fans' dedicated enthusiasm, and thanks to the posterity of DVD and streaming, many of these shows have found a greater posthumous fandom than they ever did while they were on the air.

Advertisement

It's in many ways a shame that some of these shows weren't saved for the streaming era, because one suspects they might've fared much better outside of the traditional, rigid network TV model.

Whether felled by poor ratings or middling reviews (or both), each of these shows has nevertheless become a cult smash after the fact, and continues to live on years, even decades later...

Advertisement

10. Freaks & Geeks

NBC

Paul Feig and Judd Apatow's coming-of-age dramedy Freaks and Geeks is arguably the most perceptive and boundary-smashing TV show about growing up that the medium has ever produced.

Advertisement

And so, it's an utter travesty that NBC summarily cancelled it after an 18-episode first season, citing poor ratings, with it averaging "only" 7 million viewers compared to the 14 million scored by the network's flagship shows Frasier and Friends. Shocking, that.

Between those lofty expectations, spotty scheduling and the show's producers bristling with NBC executives - who wanted the teenagers to be "cool" rather than realistic misfits - it never really stood a chance.

Advertisement

Nevertheless, Freaks and Geeks scored three Emmy nominations during its brief run, launched the careers of James Franco, Seth Rogen, Jason Segel, Busy Philipps, Martin Starr and Linda Cardellini, and endures 20 years later as a brave, almost uncomfortably realistic look at the anxieties of high school life.

While most similarly-themed shows would've featured conventionally gorgeous actors in their mid-20s playing the focal teens, Freaks and Geeks boasted an uncommon authenticity among its cast while presenting social issues far ahead of its time.

Advertisement

After all, how many other high school shows have ever been brave enough to feature a subplot about a hermaphroditic student, and not turned it into a cheap joke no less?

9. Dollhouse

Fox

You've been pre-warned: Fox is going to show up on this list quite a few times.

Advertisement

Years after Fox binned off Firefly - which we'll get to later - the network extended an olive branch to Joss Whedon by committing to a 13-episode first season order for his new sci-fi show Dollhouse, and even allowing him to forego the usual path of making a pilot episode first.

The show certainly got off to a rough start regardless, though. Despite an inspired premise - protagonist Echo (Eliza Dushku) is a blank slate "doll" who has a new persona implanted each episode for whatever her mission requires - the first half of season one was a real slog, unaided by the WGA strike of 2007-2008, which left Whedon with just two months to prep the entire season.

Advertisement

Furthermore, Fox's meddlesome tendencies soon enough resurfaced, ditching the season's first episode yet still considering it part of a 13-episode order, requiring Whedon to beg the network to allow him to create a true 13th episode on a lower budget.

Though the first season certainly picked up near the end, it received generally middling reviews and pulled mediocre viewing figures, so a surprise it was that Fox actually renewed it for a second run. Firefly guilt, perhaps?

Advertisement

Season two was considered a vast improvement by fans who stuck with it, even if most prominent critics had already abandoned the show by this point.

With viewing figures dropping below 2 million, Fox cancelled Dollhouse near the end of its second season, breaking the hearts of fans who felt the show and lead actress Dushku - whose season one performance was admittedly pretty iffy - had just found its stride.

Advertisement

Dollhouse never had the chance to become a great Whedon show like Buffy or Firefly, but it nevertheless lives on as an intriguing experiment with a legion of devoted fans.

8. Constantine

NBC

After Hollywood served up a stylish yet unconvincing adaptation of the beloved Hellblazer comics - starring Keanu Reeves with neither blonde hair nor a Scouse accent - fans' prayers seemed to be answered with NBC's TV adaptation, co-developed by David S. Goyer (Blade, The Dark Knight, Man of Steel).

Advertisement

Though Matt Ryan's take on the character wasn't shown smoking (due to network regulations) and he chose to speak with a more ambiguous "regional" accent, Ryan nevertheless gave fans a decidedly more accurate portrayal of John Constantine, signature trench coat and all.

After a slightly wonky start, the show quickly picked up thanks to a combination of Ryan's performance, stylish visuals and a creatively grim tone befitting the source material.

Advertisement

The first season was reviewed broadly well, but NBC cancelled the show a few months after it aired, citing poor "live" viewership (where most ad revenue is made) and the expensive costs of production.

Though Warner Bros. Television attempted to shop it around to other networks, nobody bit, causing the cast and crew to be released from their contracts, effectively killing it dead.

Advertisement

Fans were vocal in their desire for the show to find a new home regardless, showing just how much its more source-accurate depiction of the title character meant to them.

And while those efforts haven't panned out yet, Ryan's Constantine has appeared extensively in CW's Arrowverse (especially Legends of Tomorrow), while voicing the character in both the animated film Justice League Dark and animated web-series Constantine: City of Demons.

Advertisement

Rumours have swirled in recent months that Warner Bros. is interesting in reviving the show with Ryan, but it's probably best not to get your hopes up. What a win for fans and their dedicated campaigning that would be, though.

7. Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles

Fox

With Terminator 3 being received rather tepidly by fans, it made all the sense in the world for the property to leap to the TV medium, and so Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles was born.

Advertisement

Now, the show certainly had some early stumbles: the first few episodes weren't great nor barely even good, and this being a Fox show, it couldn't offer up the R-rated brutality of the three prior movies (yes, even the third one).

But what really kept the show chugging along during those growing pains was the cast, especially a typically brilliant Lena Headey as Sarah Connor and Summer Glau as benevolent Terminator Cameron. Over the course of the show, Thomas Dekker also became a decidedly more interesting and likeable John Connor.

Advertisement

With a reliably terrific supporting cast including Garret Dillahunt, Dean Winters, Brian Austin Green and eventually even Garbage front-woman Shirley Manson, it certainly didn't want for talent.

The first season performed well as a mid-season replacement, though things quickly took a bad turn in season two, tumbling from the first season's ratings low of 7.12 million to a brutal 2.96 million.

Advertisement

A mere three days before the release of Terminator Salvation, Fox announced the show's cancellation, to the frustration of fans who had seen the series grow in scope and nuance over its 31 aired episodes.

Making matters worse was ending the show on a tantalising - and ultimately, frustrating - cliffhanger, and the show's increasing lack of relevance within the extremely muddy Terminator continuity.

Advertisement

Still, given the sorry state the Terminator franchise has been in as of late, it's no wonder fans are still pining for a continuation - one that's definitely never happening.

6. Jericho

CBS

Jericho was a post-apocalyptic drama series taking place in the fictional titular Kansas city following a devastating nuclear attack on U.S. soil, and certainly suffered from expectations that it would be "the new Lost."

Advertisement

Reviews for the 22-episode first season were heavily mixed, citing a slow pace and over-reliance on genre tropes, but it nevertheless found a passionate cabal of fans for its more low-key cast and lesser emphasis on spectacle compared to other similar shows.

Nevertheless, CBS cancelled Jericho after a single season, only to grant fans a shortened, 7-episode second season after fans collectively sent 20 tons of nuts to CBS HQ, referring to a famous quote from the first season's finale.

Advertisement

Reviews for season two enjoyed a steady uptick, but sadly the ratings continued to drop, and CBS subsequently canned the show for a second time. As a small sliver of solace, the story was continued in comic book form for two more "seasons."

In recent years Jericho creator Stephen Chbosky attempted to shop the show to Netflix, and despite the streaming platform reportedly being receptive, CBS ultimately refused to sign off on it.

Advertisement

More than a decade after the show ended, fans still remain optimistic that it might one day get the Deadwood treatment and earn a belated revival, be it a new series or a TV movie.

5. Wayward Pines

Fox

Wayward Pines had one hell of a hook: a Twin Peaks-style mystery show with a pilot episode directed by M. Night Shyamalan, who also served as an executive producer.

Advertisement

That's not to forget a stupid-good ensemble cast, including Matt Dillon, Carla Gugino, Toby Jones, Juliette Lewis, Melissa Leo, Terrence Howard, Jason Patric, Hope Davis, Djimon Hounsou and many more.

And though some criticised the show feeling a little too much like a Peaks clone, its entrancing mystery and brilliant acting proved undeniable catnip to those seeking some David Lynch-lite entertainment.

Advertisement

Season one was broadly well-reviewed and performed decently in ratings, but season two was beset by a number of issues, namely the departure of showrunner Chad Hodge, and its last-minute renewal meaning many actors had already moved onto other projects.

Under new showrunner Mark Friedman, the show scored wildly mixed reviews, with many citing its lack of necessity, given that the first season adapted all the existing novels and was as such intended to be a one-off.

Advertisement

The ratings promptly dropped off throughout season two, though Fox cruelly didn't officially cancel the show for more than 18 months after the season finale aired.

Given that season two ended on a cliffhanger and actually had a baked-in set-up for a third season to focus on a new cast, fans are still hoping that the show might end up revived at some point. So far no dice, though.

Advertisement

4. Dead Like Me

Showtime

Dead Like Me was the brainchild of prolific TV vet Bryan Fuller (Pushing Daisies, Hannibal), a ludicrously entertaining black comedy-drama series following 18-year-old Georgia Lass (Ellen Muth), who is killed in the show's pilot episode and subsequently becomes a grim reaper, tasked with shepherding the dead into the afterlife.

Advertisement

It boasted a superbly unique premise and a cracking cast, centred around Muth's chemistry with her mentor Rube Sofer (a brilliant Mandy Patinkin), while balancing its tone quite perfectly between light and dark.

Sadly, Fuller departed the show after just five episodes, citing creative differences with MGM Television, though the series continued for a total of 29 episodes across two seasons, until Showtime cancelled it due to both declining ratings and unspecified production issues.

Advertisement

A direct-to-video follow-up was released over four years later to a relatively mixed response, providing a capper to show that never really got its fair due, especially with Fuller taken out of the frame so quickly.

Still, for its mere two seasons, Dead Like Me enjoyed solid reviews and charmed its way into the hearts of many fans.

Advertisement

3. Carnivàle

HBO

HBO's Carnivàle was another rich addition to the network's growing cachet of sumptuous, premium drama shows in the early 2000s, taking place in America's Dust Bowl during the Great Depression and following the colourful roster of a travelling carnival.

Advertisement

Brilliantly melding the authentic bleakness of the era with more surreal mythological musings, Carnivale also benefited from a ludicrously talented ensemble cast, led by Nick Stahl and Clancy Brown.

Despite receiving 15 Emmy nominations over its two seasons, all in crafts categories (and winning five), the show consistently received tepid reviews from critics, many of whom took umbrage with its vague, ambiguous approach, while some compared it negatively to Twin Peaks.

Advertisement

But the show quickly won a dedicated fanbase, given that it was quite unlike anything else on TV at the time and boasted stonking production values, with a $4 million budget per episode.

For a comparison, Game of Thrones' first season boasted a $6 million-per-episode price tag, though also benefited from a huge built-in audience from its immensely popular source material.

Advertisement

Despite debuting to the strongest ratings for any new HBO series at the time, the show's viewership quickly dropped off to less than 1.5 million in some second season episodes, prompting the network to give it the chop after 24 episodes on the air.

Much like Deadwood, the show to which it's most often likened, Carnivàle concluded without a satisfying resolution to ongoing storylines, though unlike David Milch's masterful western series, there's not much hope for the show to be revived.

Advertisement

2. Firefly

Fox

Perhaps no TV show in history was cancelled in as heartbreaking fashion as Firefly, the brilliantly inventive sci-fi western brainchild of Joss Whedon.

Advertisement

Between its absurd production values, superb cast and arguably career-best world-building from Whedon, the series won itself a loyal band of fans (who, of course, call themselves "Browncoats").

Unfortunately, Fox really didn't do the show any favours right out of the gate: they aired the episodes out of order, occasionally pre-empted airings for sports and marketed it more as a wacky comedy series than the grittier black comedy it actually was.

Advertisement

Citing low ratings after 11 episodes had aired, Fox cancelled Firefly and burned off the remaining three over six months later, showing just how little they cared about giving the show even the vaguest chance of building an audience.

Fans were heartbroken and campaigned extensively for Firefly to be renewed or picked up by another network, but to no avail.

Advertisement

A feature film did eventually materialise, with 2005's quite brilliant Serenity, but due to it tanking at the box office, the property has only been able to continue in comic book form since.

Fans are still crossing their fingers that, one day, a billionaire with too much money might write Joss Whedon a fat cheque and let him make another season, because this world and these characters are too damn great to produce such little content. It is the quintessential TV cult classic.

Advertisement

1. Party Down

Starz

Perhaps more than any other show on this list, Party Down really had all the ingredients to enjoy a long life as a comedy mainstay: a top-drawer cast, wickedly funny writing that subverted genre cliches and strong critical acclaim to boot.

Advertisement

But the one big thorn in the side of this show about a group of aspiring actors and writers working as caterers in Los Angeles? It aired on Starz.

It's extremely easy to imagine how a show starring Adam Scott, Ken Marino, Lizzy Caplan and Martin Starr would've absolutely slayed as a low-key smash on a more prominent network, but it was pretty much sent out to die on Starz, scoring less than 70,000 U.S. viewers near the end of its second season.

Advertisement

Between the low ratings and the departure of Adam Scott and Jane Lynch for Parks and Rec and Glee respectively, Starz decided to end the show after two seasons, killing a cult gem in the process.

Pretty much all the main cast members have done well off the back of the show, so that's a plus, but one suspects with a cannier treatment from the outset - namely a network with the business nous to market and mount the show appropriately - it could've gone on for many more seasons.

Advertisement