10 Greatest TV Bottle Episodes

One location, few actors, no problem.

By Josh Mills /

NBC

The bottle episode was created for purely practical purposes. A term coined by writer Leslie Stevens - as in a genie from a bottle, i.e creating something out of nothing - the bottle episode was a money saving device. One location, a handful of actors, and you’ve got a chunk of telly on the cheap.

Advertisement

Over time, though, the discipline and limitations of small scale episodes have proven popular with fans. Bottle episodes are a great opportunity to try something different, to rely on character interaction and performances rather than larger scale flashiness.

TV budgets have skyrocketed since Stevens’ day, but the often quieter and more reflective nature of modern bottle episodes still serve a key purpose, adding texture and shade to a show, making those wild and expensive episodes stand out all the more.

When used and written correctly, bottle episodes can take a show to places it hasn’t previously been, exploring different dynamics, putting its characters into unfamiliar situations and seeing how they’ll react. The budgets may be smaller, but the impact can be as great as anything the show has ever done.

10. Breaking Bad - 4 Days Out

Breaking Bad’s more famous bottle episode is season three’s “The Fly”, in which Walt and Jesse hunt a pesky insect trapped in the drug lab. The better episode, though, is the previous season’s “4 Days Out”. The claustrophobia of the lab is replaced by the vast isolation of the New Mexico desert, but in marooning the two leads together for the duration of an episode, Breaking Bad had its greatest hour to date.

Advertisement

The relationship between Walt and Jesse - hotheaded, bitter genius chemist and slacker doofus - was inherently comic, but the partnership turns a corner here. The two wind each other up something fierce, but faced with their own mortality, they’re able to connect on a level deeper than a lucrative drug manufacturing business.

The actors play off each other magnificently. From here they embark on entirely different paths - Jesse becoming a better man, Walt descending into true villainy. This may be the last moment they find themselves on the same level.

“4 Days Out” was the moment the show transcended its catchy teacher-turns-dealer hook and caught up to its ambitions to become one of the best and weightiest dramas of our times.

9. It’s Always Sunny In Philadelphia - CharDee Mac Dennis

A show with few if any boundaries, It’s Always Sunny made its name with brash and daring comedy, an unpredictable focus and the ability to place its characters into basically any situation. With such freewheeling energy, it’s all the more impressive that one of its finest episodes sees the gang play a board game for 20 minutes.

Advertisement

Being It’s Always Sunny, of course, they’re not playing Monopoly. The titular game, devised by the characters, doesn’t so much devolve into chaos as starts off chaotic and gets worse. The rules are simple: cheating is encouraged (as long as you don’t get caught); booze, naturally, is flowing freely, and the aim of the game is to hurt and humiliate your opponents.

The stakes are low but the nonsense of the game, coupled with the increasing inebriation of the characters, makes for one of the liveliest and most memorable episodes in the show’s run as every character gets a moment in the spotlight,

It’s Always Sunny knows how to do a lot with a low budget, but they embrace their limitations here to create glorious pandemonium out of five drunk idiots playing a made up game.

8. Red Dwarf - Marooned

For a show based on a pretty grim premise - the entirety of humanity bar one slob is wiped out - Red Dwarf rarely chose to dwell on the melancholic. Lacing the comedy with something more serious, however, made for some of the show’s best episodes, like season three’s “Marooned”.

Advertisement

The episode is all Craig Charles and Chris Barrie. Lister and Rimmer find themselves stranded on an ice planet. As is their wont, they instantly get on one another’s nerves - but when the situation becomes truly bleak, they drop the facade. The bickering pair open up - it’s a revealing episode for actors and characters alike.

Barrie’s performance was consistently one of the best things about Red Dwarf - he plays Rimmer like a coiled spring. Here, though, he’s substantially softer, dropping his cloak of officiousness as he learns more about Dave Lister, the man with whom he is doomed to spend the rest of time.

With its tiny cast, Red Dwarf was always a show that thrived within its own limits, but in concocting something akin to a two person mini-play, they push the claustrophobic vibes as far as they ever have, and it works a charm.

7. Girls - One Man’s Trash

Lena Dunham’s divisive comedy drama managed to be especially divisive in its season two bottle episode “One Man’s Trash”. Co-starring Fargo’s Patrick Wilson, the loose plot sees lead character Hannah shack up with a rich older man for a weekend tryst and a voyage of self discovery.

Advertisement

The show’s dissenters dismissed this as self obsessed, an episode written by and for Dunham to hog the limelight. But the episode actually intricately skewers the character of Hannah, bursts her protective bubble of Brooklyn hipness and digs into the heart of what she really wants out of life.

Girls expertly rode a bittersweet line throughout its run - these characters are supposed to be making the most of their youth, having the time of their lives, but instead they’re stuck in bad relationships, apartments, and jobs. Patrick Wilson’s wealthy doctor lives in the lap of luxury - it’s a way of life Hannah turns her nose up at, but secretly envies, too.

The actors’ chemistry is impressive even if the meet-cute of it all is a little unlikely. Those who had already written off Girls were never going to enjoy it, but for fans, it was one of the series’ highlights thus far.

6. Star Trek - The Enemy Within

Gene Roddenberry’s space opera was one of the first shows to utilise bottle episodes for their most practical of purposes: cut costs for one episode and you’ll have more money to spend down the line. Early instalment The Enemy Within takes this notion to its logical extreme, having William Shatner double down as good and evil Captain Kirks.

Advertisement

The majority of the action here takes place in the confines of the Enterprise, and is based on the somewhat unlikely notion that Shatner is able to convincingly act two distinct characters at once. Needless to say, he goes for broke as Kirk’s evil doppelganger: it’s a frenzied, scenery chewing performance even by Shatner’s standards, and it’s great fun.

This was the fifth ever episode of Star Trek, and it’s bold move: to fully enjoy it requires a decent knowledge of the players, who we’ve really just met. The Enemy Within does a great job of fleshing out what would become iconic TV characters, though, from Kirk on down.

Star Trek would return to the bottle episode well repeatedly in its various iterations, but The Enemy Within was the first classic bottle they managed, and perhaps the first classic episode full stop. It’s a great way to bring new viewers into the franchise.

5. Parks And Recreation - Leslie And Ron

Parks And Recreation is a show about a community. In carefully building the town of Pawnee, the writers gave themselves an endless supply of weird and wacky characters to drop in for a laugh as needed. The show’s core, though, was the relationship between Leslie Knope and Ron Swanson, and in isolating the two for a full episode, they produced a highlight in the late stages of the show.

Advertisement

The characters are chalk and cheese, a Big Government optimist and a cynical libertarian, but Leslie and Ron tended to find common ground, until a season seven falling out. The episode sees the two of them locked away by their friends in order to sort through their issues, and what starts as the usual ideological bickering turns into something far more profound.

As played by Amy Poehler and Nick Offerman, the characters have always been funny and charming, but the dramatic swerve taken by this episode is met with aplomb by both actors. They know their characters and the relationship brilliantly by this point, and give you a strictly platonic connection worth rooting for.

4. Frasier - Dinner Party

The beauty of Frasier is that, in Kelsey Grammer and David Hyde Pierce, you have two of the funniest sitcom actors ever to grace the screen. As such, you need but the flimsiest premice, the slightest reason to stick them together, and you’re almost guaranteed a great episode of TV.

Advertisement

The stakes don’t get much lower than this: Frasier and Niles are co-hosting a dinner party, and they cannot agree on any of the details. The episode - played out in real time - derives its laughs from how ludicrously invested the ever-highly strung brothers become in the organisation of the bash.

That the episode manages to create a fast paced comedy about two men not throwing a dinner party and carry out a thoughtful and heartfelt interrogation of said men’s weird relationship is a testament to the economy of the script. Nothing happens, per se, but the character beats are perfect.

Couple the writing with the high octane performances of two actors who know their characters and each other so well and you get something akin to a dance, as they verbally spar for 20 minutes. At its best, Frasier elevated the sitcom to something balletic.

3. Community - Remedial Chaos Theory

In its capacity as the most meta show on telly, Community dedicated a whole episode to the deconstruction of the bottle episode. Season two episode “Cooperative Calligraphy” is a love letter to the concept - but they raised the stakes significantly for the following year’s “Remedial Chaos Theory”.

Advertisement

While the entirety of the action takes place in Troy and Abed’s apartment, the episode breaks the mould with its brilliantly original structure. A simple game of chance - a dice being rolled to determine who has to go and fetch the pizza delivery - leads to seven separate timelines, the course of history varying sharply depending on who’s not present.

It’s one of the smartest instalments of a show functioning at the top of its game, but it’s not just artifice: over 20 minutes, they manage to set up important stories for the rest of the season and even series: Annie moving in to the apartment, Troy and Britta’s relationship, Jeff’s increasing distance from the gang.

In creating what amounts to seven bottle episodes in one, this was a reminder that Community was operating on a level above most sitcoms at the time. It’s a daring episode which pays off in spades.

2. Mad Men - The Suitcase

Don Draper is nothing if not a ladies’ man, but his most important relationship ends up being with his colleague and mentee, Peggy Olsen. One of the acclaimed drama’s finest episodes, “The Suitcase” solidifies their connection as a late night at the office turns into the formation of a deep understanding.

Advertisement

Elizabeth Moss and Jon Hamm are staggeringly good in this episode, running the gamut from throwaway humour to hard hitting revelations. They argue and throw hurtful comments around, but ultimately they open up to one another, with Draper letting his finely tailored armour slip, his true identity seeping out.

Mad Men was never afraid of upsetting the status quo, and the bond formed here can’t last in the cold light of day. Still, Don and Peggy see one another in a new light following a night shut in the office.

It’s one of the most complex relationships portrayed on TV, neither romantic nor platonic nor professional, and the scenes in “The Suitcase” are the most important for understanding it. Mad Men was always about a lot more than the advertising industry, and this episode is about a lot more than a campaign for Samsonite.

1. The Sopranos - Pine Barrens

The Sopranos is one of the greatest examples of a single story told over a long time, but it was capable of brilliant one-off episodes, too. “Pine Barrens”, one of the best loved episodes in the show’s run, is built around characters we’ve known for years, but its plot is so tight and fun that it could work as the basis for a standalone movie.

Advertisement

The plot is a simple one: gangsters Chris and Paulie botch a money collection job and end up marching a Russian acquaintance to his death in the deep New Jersey woods. The Russian gives the pair the slip, and they wind up stranded in the wilderness.

The Sopranos always had a knack for comedy, but rarely did they go so full throttle with the laughs as they do here. Paulie and Chris in turn bicker, threaten, and comfort one another, two tough wiseguys completely out of their elements and frightened for their lives.

While “Pine Barrens” isn’t a traditional bottle episode in that it takes place in the vast expanses of nature, its focus on just two characters out of a sprawling cast allows for greater exploration of creations with real depth. It’s one of the best and most fun hours of TV ever made.

Advertisement