10 Greatest TV Shows Of 2014

A vintage year for the small screen.

By Michael Gordon /

2014 saw the current 'Golden Age Of Television' continue unabated, with a number of truly wonderful new shows making their bows throughout the year. Television is now the premier medium for gifted writers to tell long-form stories and this year saw the beginnings of quite a few that will be around for many years to come, if there's any justice at least. As well as these quality newcomers, audiences were also treated to brilliant seasons of returning favourites, and the likes of Netflix and Amazon Prime Instant Video continued to cement their reputations as destinations for many viewers to binge watch entire seasons of the best shows, as well as putting out their own incredibly popular shows. In 2014, the distinction between movie talent and TV talent continued to disappear, with many established film stars taking on their own shows, spurred on by the benefits of shorter seasons on cable shows coupled with the abundance of brilliant and innovative writing. Shows like Game Of Thrones and The Walking Dead continued their quests for world domination; both are now cultural touchstones with ever-increasing fan-bases. On UK TV, fans were treated to Peter Capaldi's new Doctor Who and also the second season of Belfast-set serial killer drama The Fall. 2014 also brought the curtain down on a few popular shows such as Aaron Sorkin's The Newsroom and Kurt Sutter's biker epic Sons Of Anarchy (which, with some judicious cutting, would have made our top ten list, but alas). That they didn't indicates exactly how good a year the small screen had...

10. Silicon Valley (HBO)

HBO's Silicon Valley made its bow on April 6th in the States and a few months later the 8 episode first season was shown on Sky Atlantic in the UK. Given that HBO are known for being purveyors of some of the highest quality television, well, ever, it should have come as no surprise that this followed suit. Created by Mike Judge, of Beavis And Butthead and King Of The Hill fame, along with John Altschuler and Dave Krinsky, the show chronicles the fortunes of a group of young tech whizzes who found a start-up company in 'Silicon Valley', in the San Francisco Bay Area. The show is part sitcom and part satire of the computer and technology industry but crucially, it is very, very funny. The group, led by Thomas Middleditch as the constantly nervous and horrifyingly out of his depth Richard Hendricks, all bring something different to the table. T.J. Miller as Erlich Bachman stands out as leaning closest to caricature, but he is talented enough to tread the fine line very carefully, making Bachman's overblown and clueless bravado consistently hilarious. However, the best just might be Zach Woods as Jared, who brings an odd, disarmingly earnest and yet simultaneously ridiculous energy all his own to the character.

9. Brooklyn Nine-Nine (Fox)

Arguably the best comedy on television these days, Brooklyn Nine-Nine is every bit as good as long-running current sitcoms like Modern Family. It has one of the best casts in comedy, and the quality of each episode continued to rise in its second season, which began airing in September. Following the day to day misadventures of a group of detectives and their Captain in the fictional 99th Precinct of the New York City Police Department, Brooklyn Nine-Nine expertly weaves together slapstick humour with clever wordplay, only occasionally veering too far into 'silly' territory. Somewhat miraculously, the creative team generally leave the viewer with the feeling that these characters are actually good police officers more often than not, which is pretty incredible when you consider some of the truly dumb and ludicrous shenanigans that occur on the show. Andy Samberg has grown considerably as the lead, Jake Peralta, and his chemistry with female co-stars Melissa Fumero and Stephanie Beatriz (who both also bring plenty of funny) is excellent. Andre Braugher as Captain Raymond Holt is undoubtedly the crown jewel of Brooklyn Nine-Nine, however. What could have been a one-note joke (the stern, humourless captain) has instead been transformed in the hands of Braugher. Yes, Holt is stern and humourless, but that is precisely why he is gut-bustingly hilarious. His monotone, deadpan delivery makes pretty much every sentence a hoot, and the highlights of most episodes can often be boiled down to Holt quotes.

8. Banshee (Cinemax)

Banshee is a criminally underseen show, and that needs to be rectified. If you like crime stories featuring damaged lead characters with shady pasts, existing in heightened worlds full of dangerous femme fatales and brutal gangsters, then Banshee is for you. The show follows an ex-con, played by Antony Starr, who assumes the identity of Lucas Hood, the new sheriff of the titular small town. He tangles with Mr Rabbit, the terrifying Ukrainian gangster who he has been hiding from and also Kai Proctor, the local crime kingpin. Perhaps due to its airing on the Cinemax channel in the US, a station which has only recently entered the business of making its own original content, Banshee has remained something of a cult hit. Its second series aired in 2014, and the jump in quality from season one was noticeable. The actors all became more comfortable in their characters, with performances improving across the board. The production value increased noticeably and the direction and writing of the series was superb, with Banshee becoming the place to go for cinematic quality action scenes and fight choreography. They even transcended their pulp roots a number of times, with the season showcasing an increased ambition towards telling emotionally affecting stories in amongst all the gloriously gratuitous violence.

7. The Knick (Cinemax)

Speaking of Cinemax, The Knick is another of their original series and couldn't be more different from Banshee. Starring Clive Owen as Dr John Thackery, a brilliant but tortured surgeon working at the Knickerbocker Hospital in New York City in the year 1900, it is a medical drama with a difference. Acclaimed director Steven Soderbergh was at the helm of every episode of the first season, and he predictably imbued the show with his own uniquely cinematic style. The brilliance of this show is in its setting. At the turn of the century, the world was advancing at an incredible rate, with new discoveries in medicine and technology leading to breakthroughs that would have been impossible even a decade earlier. In many ways these years led to the birth of the modern world, and The Knick wonderfully captures the essence of invention and relentless innovation that Dr Thackery works within. Clive Owen is brilliant, portraying an incredibly forward thinking man in many ways, taking the viewer along with him as 'Thack' experiments with new methods of conducting surgeries but also with cocaine and opium. However, he is also a product of his time in other ways, as he initially refuses to interact with Dr Algernon Edwards (Andre Holland), the other lead of the show, a black doctor who has to battle for respect in the all-white hospital and in the racially segregated city as a whole.

6. True Detective (HBO)

What more is there to say about the cultural phenomenon that was True Detective's first season? The subject of countless articles written when the series was in the midst of its run, dissecting every aspect of the scripts and performances, and countless more column inches when the dust had settled on the finale. Social media went crazy after every episode, with fans theorizing about everything from the true nature of Matthew McConaughey's eloquent nihilist Rust Cohle to the identity of the Yellow King; from the meaning of Carcosa to just what the hell Woody Harrelson was actually saying through that sometimes impenetrable drawl. The fact that True Detective made such a breakthrough into the mainstream is an impressive feat considering the somewhat art-house leanings of the show. Produced by HBO, on the surface it was a story about two Louisiana State detectives hunting a serial killer, but it merely used that somewhat generic description as a launching pad for much meatier, esoteric material. Created by novelist Nic Pizzolatto, the series takes a very literary approach, with the story being told at a leisurely pace through rich, provocative dialogue and a sense of mounting dread that permeates nearly every scene. True Detective was decidedly non-commercial, eschewing the traditional approach at every turn and yet it burrowed its way deep into the recesses of viewers brains with surgical skill. There's no doubt that the casting of McConaughey and Harrelson, two highly successful film actors, brought more curious eyes to the show but that wouldn't have counted for much in the long run had it not been so stunningly written and directed by Cary Joji Fukunaga. Will season two, starring Colin Farrell, Vince Vaughn and Rachel McAdams, scale the lofty heights of season one? Only time will tell.

5. Arrow (The CW)

The continued critical and commercial success of Arrow has been quite the pleasant surprise. Produced by The CW network, a channel most often associated with programming aimed at teenagers, Arrow debuted in October 2012 to high ratings and mostly complimentary reviews. After half a season of finding its feet, the show blossomed quite considerably and has gone from strength to strength in its subsequent seasons. All the more impressive when you consider it is based on Green Arrow, a DC Comics character with a dedicated cult following but, prior to the show, very little mainstream recognition. 2014 in the world of Arrow included the second half of season two and then the first nine episodes of the third season, which kicked off on October 8th. Season two was consistently superb, with the latter half being particularly good. The show made wonderful use of the source material, cannily realising that the use of characters from the Batman mythos would add immeasurably to the on-screen world. Manu Bennett made a formidable villain as Deathstroke and the show became a massive favourite among comic book fans but also just as popular with viewers who simply enjoyed the top notch action and tangled inter-personal relationships. Season three has had a strong start as well, building to a particularly shocking and daring cliffhanger at the close of its mid-season finale. Fans are now excited to see Ras Al Ghul as Arrow's newest nemesis, and his introduction was a clever move by the producers considering the character has a certain recognition factor after being used in Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight Trilogy.

4. Boardwalk Empire (HBO)

Boardwalk Empire was always a very good show with more than its share of fans and no shortage of awards nominations. However, there is no doubt that it never really reached the level of intense critical adoration bestowed upon the likes of Breaking Bad and The Wire, nor the level of fan devotion given to Sons Of Anarchy, for example. This is something of a shame, as it was often just as good as these shows, with a truly superb cast and wonderful period production value. Its final season, which wrapped up in October of this year, was arguably its best, ending the series on a high note with more buzz than it had seen in years. At a condensed eight episodes (all the previous seasons had clocked in at 12), Boardwalk's fifth season made the interesting choice of jumping forward in time, beginning seven years after the end of season four, in 1931. The writers also made use of flashbacks to Nucky Thompson's (Steve Buscemi) childhood for the first time and these added a wonderful emotional melancholy, illuminating important people and moments in his life that made him the complicated man he was for all of the show's run. A criticism that could have been levelled at previous seasons was the sometimes extremely slow pace, but this was rectified by the smaller episode count in season five. The creative team just didn't have the extra room for middling sub-plots this time and so each episode was crammed with all the great Prohibition-era exploits that fans loved to see. Show creator Terence Winter and his team managed to craft a fitting conclusion to their gangster epic, with particularly brilliant writing given to the excellent Michael Kenneth Williams as Chalky White, the explosive Stephen Graham as Al Capone and the oddly hilarious Michael Shannon as Agent Van Alden.

3. Penny Dreadful (Showtime)

Horror is a very big deal on TV these days, with an abundance of shows vying for the attention of the discerning gore-hound. These shows all vary wildly in tone, story and quality, but with the likes of The Walking Dead, American Horror Story, The Strain and Hannibal all on the air, the options are plentiful. However, in our estimation, Penny Dreadful is the pick of the bunch. Co-produced by Showtime and Sky Atlantic, Penny Dreadful was created by John Logan, acclaimed writer of Skyfall, who acts as executive producer along with Sam Mendes (American Beauty). Starring Josh Hartnett, Eva Green and Timothy Dalton, it features an intelligent mixture of monsters from turn of the century literature such as Victor Frankenstein and his monster from Mary Shelley's masterwork, Dorian Gray from Oscar Wilde's writing and Mina Harker and Abraham Van Helsing from Bram Stoker's Dracula. These characters all exist in turn of the century London alongside Hartnett's mysterious Ethan Chandler, Green's haunted Vanessa Ives and Dalton's explorer, Sir Malcolm Murray. Penny Dreadful is a sumptuous watch for any horror fan, featuring a plethora of blood and guts alongside terrifying supernatural elements and dramatic, graceful writing from Logan. It tugs at the heartstrings as much as it turns the stomach and features some outstanding acting, particularly from Eva Green, who should win all the awards going for her multi-faceted and layered portrayal of Vanessa.

2. The Flash (The CW)

The Flash has very quickly established itself as a confident, effervescent superhero show, one that has been firing on all cylinders right from episode one. A spin-off from Arrow, the show has only aired nine episodes thus far, but they have been nine of the most enjoyable comic book adventures yet committed to celluloid. Currently holding a 96% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes, The Flash hit the ground running and shows no signs of letting up. Given that The Flash is made by the same production team as Arrow, it is obvious that they learned from any teething problems that it experienced in its early days and made sure they would not be repeated with this show. In its early episodes, Arrow sometimes struggled to balance its tone, veering awkwardly from attempts at gritty realism to sub-par teen romance. The Flash has, thus far, experienced none of this and actually has one of the best tones of any comic book adaptation yet produced. It is fun and enjoyable, a light-hearted romp in many ways, but also manages to pull things back with more serious elements that somehow don't feeling jarring or tacked on. A lot of credit has to go to the cast, who are uniformly excellent. Grant Gustin has an innate likeability as Barry Allen, a boyish charm that is offset by his capable handling of the more dramatic elements. His relationship with Jesse L. Martin's Detective Joe West is played to perfection. The chemistry between the two actors is brilliant, making what could have been a cliched 'father figure who doles out sage wisdom' character into a fully realised person; their interactions feel entirely real. The show also benefits from some top special effects and magnificent production design. Pure, unadulterated fun.

1. Fargo (FX)

That a television show based on The Coen Brothers' classic dark crime comedy Fargo not only avoided being a complete disaster, but in fact emerged as our favourite show of the year, is an incredible thing. The Coen's are such auteurs, with a particularly unique style and voice, that the thought of another person trying to tell stories in their universe was initially very hard to comprehend. How would anyone find that tone that they capture so well in their best work? That mix of off-kilter humour with quick flashes of violence and dark undercurrents is something that many thought only the Coen's could do. In the end it turned out that Noah Hawley, creator of the TV show, was an expert in this world as well. Who knew? The show starred Martin Freeman, Billy Bob Thornton, Allison Tollman and Colin Hanks as its four leads and each one was amazing in their role. Freeman was a revelation: his character, Lester Nygaard, allowed him to invert the hangdog, put-upon but loveable nature that he portrays so well in Sherlock, with Nygaard initially garnering audience sympathy that soon turns to disgust as it becomes clear he is a despicable human being concerned only with self-preservation. As the unfathomable Lorne Malvo, Thornton was also superb, oozing menace at every turn. Malvo was the great villain of the TV year, an unknowable killer whose true nature became more and more obscured every time the audience thought they had him figured out. Fargo has adopted the anthology approach that many shows are using currently. Similar to the likes of American Horror Story and True Detective, the second season will feature a different cast of characters and tell a completely different story in a different time period. When it was announced that it would focus on the backstory of Keith Carradine's Lou Solverson, the retired-cop father of Tolman's Deputy Molly, fans rejoiced as the hints we had been given in season one to a particular case he handled in the 1970's were extremely tantalising. Well played, Fargo. So, what shows are we missing on our countdown? Feel free to tell us why we should have included the likes of Game Of Thrones and Mad Men in the comments section below.