Steven Moffat is a man famed for the rippling repetitions in his work; recurring themes bubble beneath stories, surfacing for air at crucial plot points. From the timey-wimey to the woman who beat Sherlock, there are always clues to resolutions. His stories are nearly musical in the way that they relate back to something that was mentioned earlier, like returning to a chorus for the ease of familiarity. But do these repeated themes stay in their respected shows? No, of course they don't. Moffat's Doctor Who is more similar to his Sherlock adaptation than you think. Sure, he cast dark-haired, white, British men in a leading role, and gave them companions. But the similarities run so much deeper than that. And that's not a grand Moff masterplan to colonise all of British television with his ideas of what relationships should be, and what heroes should be: the original writers of Doctor Who tried to steer their lead character away from the "anti-hero" tag, and onto a more Holmes-like path. Sherlock and the Doctor are intrinsically similar characters, with huge differences of course, but I'm here to talk about the Moffat eras. I'm here to show you similarities between Who and Holmes that the Moff enjoys bringing out in his work. Here are ten examples of the more in-depth similarities between Moffat's - and Mark Gatiss's - big two characters, the Doctor and Sherlock Holmes. And for ease of writing, when I talk about Moffat's input on Gatiss episodes and vice versa, I am assuming that they work closely together. What else have you noticed that connects the two? Comment below!
10. Irene Adler/River Song
It doesn't take Sherlock Holmes or even a viewer of both shows to draw a parallel between Lara Pulver's performance in Sherlock as Irene Adler, and Alex Kingston's in Who as River Song. Both act as the woman who's equal to the main man; if you actually watch either show, you know that they both have an extremely complicated relationship where the woman's love is clearer than the man's. And I hope you do watch either, or both, shows. Or most of this article will be lost on you. Talking though of complicated relationships, Sherlock enjoys to berate Irene: "You cater to the whims of the pathetic and take your clothes off to make an impression: stop boring me and think," he spits at her. And it's fairly similar to, if not somewhat harsher than, the Doctor telling River that she embarrasses him, or that he doesn't trust her. These are two men regarded by fans as asexual; the chemistry with women is there obviously in the flirting but Moffat chooses to spike their relationships with insults. But while both Irene and River are confident, apparently bisexual, well-dressed, dangerous and possibly out to kill the men they love, we really don't know whether to trust them most the way through their stories their depictions are perhaps best viewed through the minds of Sherlock and the Doctor. Only the Doctor could see River in 'The Name of the Doctor', and as Moffat brought a probable end to that arc, the Doctor claimed, "You're always here to me... and I can always see you." Likewise, in 'The Sign of Three', Sherlock realised he was dreaming about Irene in his mind palace, and before telling her to get out of his head, as he was busy. And that really tells you all you need to know. That despite the girls' psychopathic tendencies that Moffat's so keen to show us, both the Doctor and Sherlock really do think about the women an awful lot.
9. Deduction and Mystery
The creators of Sherlock would probably tell you that their show, the show that's captured hearts both sides of the Atlantic on Tumblr and beyond, isn't really a detective show. It's just a show about a detective. And actually, that's pretty much what Steven Moffat has made Doctor Who. Under Russell T Davies the Doctor got caught up in adventure, but under Moffat, the Doctor looks for adventure. You only have to look at why the Doctor lets Clara or Amy on board the TARDIS: there's a mystery there. He found the cracks in time, and he had to investigate. He received a message from River to come to the Library, so he went there to investigate too. It's the same with the time windows in 'The Girl in the Fireplace', the Pandorica and it's why he always picks inquisitive young people to travel with. The Doctor is as much the detective as Sherlock Holmes is. The difference between Moffat's Doctor and Davies's, is that Moffat's knows where he's going, he just doesn't know what he'll find when he gets there. And it's the same with Sherlock; he loves to uncover a mystery, he lives for the crime scene, and it's solving the cases that drives him.
8. Repeated Lines And Accidental References
Imagine, if you will, a graph plotted with Eleventh Doctor phrases. You'd start with "Geronimo". Then the saying about everything being "cool". Slope down to "imagine something that isn't anything like what I'm describing", and then end at "I hate you"/"No you don't". We all know the Matt Smith-era catchphrases, perhaps more than we think we do, as this graph would suggest. But what about the lines that Sherlock shares with the Oncoming Storm? There's a line in 'The Hungry Earth' about eliminating the impossible, to which the Doctor smiles. There's the "Shut up" when the cogs are ticking for both the Doctor and Sherlock. There's insulting inferior species when he's angst-ridden (that's both of them, by the way). The oh-ful glee with which they both stumble upon eureka moments. Both the Doctor and Sherlock claim they don't have time for dinner with River and Irene, respectively. And there's the Cumberbatchian manner with which the Doctor deduces how Sardick is different from his father. The scene where Sherlock first confronts Moriarty could almost be a reference to the Tenth Doctor facing the Krillitane in 'School Reunion', as both are set in swimming pools. While this could be mistaken for coincidence, but there's no denying the similarities between both encounters; Sherlock and Ten are cool, composed and quietly dark, and their enemies are god-complexed lunatics.
7. The Subversion of Icons
"Icons?" I hear you query. Yes, all good fiction has its icons, from the Millenium Falcon, to the girl in red from Schindler's List. What Steven Moffat especially does though, is not just use the icons of both Sherlock and Who, but poke fun at them for the amusement of the viewers. An example of this would be the irony with which Cumberbatch's Holmes dislikes his deerstalker hat. The relationship between Sherlock and John, a very Victorian, crime-solving duo is made to seem like a gay relationship. The idea that Sherlock that should smoke a pipe is replaced by the notion that he's giving up, as is the modern world. Compare that to the Doctor's icons. Clara claims that the TARDIS is "smaller on the outside", and like the subversion of Sherlock's big icons, that's as much a reference in-show, as in the real world. There's the joke about the sonic screwdriver not "doing wood" it was Moffat that brought that joke in on 'Silence in the Library', concluding with a punchline in 'The Doctor, the Widow and the Wardrobe'. He uses the psychic paper for a gag about responsible adults in 'A Christmas Carol'. And Moffat's more than happy to explode the TARDIS ('The Big Bang'), set off an explosion at 221B Baker Street ('The Great Game'), and roughen up the door of both these locations to suggest darkness on the inside ('The Snowmen' when the Doctor wallows in loneliness, 'A Scandal in Belgravia' when Sherlock tortures the CIA agent).
6. The "Anti-Sitcom-Hero" Elements
Before the TARDIS, Scotland Yard, Trenzalore, Tintin, both Jekyll and Hyde, quitting Twitter and being asked in every interview, "How did Sherlock live?", Steven Moffat was a sitcom writer. He wrote about the flaws and annoyances between the sexes in Coupling something he'd explore more in Who and Sherlock and it's a very British trait to write comedy characters as anti-heroes. Just look at Blackadder, constantly belittling Baldrick, or Arkwright, always mean and stingy to his nephew Granville. Moffat plays the Doctor in this way, too. "Plus, she's a woman," Eleven says, explaining River's mood swings in 'Let's Kill Hitler', before replying "Oh, shut up, I'm dying!" to Amy's unimpressed expression. A joke considered extremely misogynistic by some, the joke is actually on the Doctor: he's rude, then excuses himself for it because he's dying. That's pretty dark, but a similar joke is made in 'The Bells of Saint John' when a monk crosses his chest at the mention of a woman: the joke is on the monk's inexperience with girls. The joke is on ignorance. You can see it in Sherlock, every time he undermines John: the joke is on how rude and unsociable someone so clever can be. We don't laugh at Sherlock insulting Anderson because we don't like Anderson we have no reason to dislike Anderson we laugh because Sherlock's being childish in an investigation. And this sort of humour can rub people up the wrong way when it's used in drama. People assume that Moffat and Gatiss are sending out a message that it's okay to be rude if their lead characters do it. What they're trying to show is that their heroes are people we can laugh at. It's a very British trait in comedy, to laugh at heroes and not with them just look David Brent from the Office.
5. The Imagery
I've talked before about Handles, that Cyberman head from 'The Time of the Doctor' that was in fact a reference to Yorick's skull (Hamlet). Skulls are representative of death that's about to follow, but also on the meaninglessness of life. I'll try not to get too morbid on you, but it's understandable for Sherlock Holmes and the Doctor to both contemplate how unavoidable death is; they're two characters who meet death an awful lot, as the Doctor's constantly fighting it, and Sherlock's looking for its causes. Staying with the deathly imagery, Sherlock in 'The Reichenbach Fall' and the Doctor in 'The Time of the Doctor' face death at dawn: could that be a reference to execution perhaps? There's so much more imagery though; there's a carved apple that surfaces in both shows, which maybe represents temptation to solve a mystery, as both Moriarty and Amelia give Sherlock and the Doctor a puzzle to solve. There's the imagery of the almost-celebrity Doctor talking to Sally through a screen, almost mirrored by Sherlock minisode 'Many Happy Returns'. And then there's the imagery of the Doctor facing the Atraxi, the man who makes people better, standing on a hospital roof, above all the other people who make people better, banishing demons from the sky; and it rings true of Sherlock, playing mind games until Moriarty kills himself. Sometimes, these things are accidental, but hopefully not always.
4. Fan Representation
There's been a lot of talk recently of Sherlock self-parodying. It's something that's considered extremely original by some, for a show to take its expectations and laugh at them on-screen almost like a fourth wall wink, but at the whole of Tumblr and Twitter combined. But NewWho did it way back in 'Love and Monsters', when the group LINDA were actually based on the real Whovians out there, who dedicate their lives to following the Doctor. More recently though, it's become clear quite how much fans are represented in Sherlock and Doctor Who. Anderson is one of us, it would seem, founding the Empty Hearse and imagining crazed theories: even imagining a kiss between Sherlock and Molly, or Sherlolly if you have Tumblr. He's really not that much different though from Osgood; a scientist from 'The Day of the Doctor' who's star-struck by him, cosplaying in a Tom Baker scarf and knowing that the Doctor would save her from any danger that lurks around the corner. Moffat, Gatiss et al seem to be catering to the fans in a huge way these days. Which may alienate casual viewers, but it's certainly rewarding to know that us die-hard obsessives are a big part of the shows we care about. It's like a footballer scoring, and celebrating in front of his fans. (Check out the alleged TARDIS that snuck into 'The Empty Hearse, by the way, as seen above in the picture!)
3. The (Really) Scary Villains
Some people will tell you that Doctor Who's a show they grew up cowering behind the sofa from. And some people will tell you that the ludicrous, man-in-a-suit monsters weren't scary, and only indicative of bad production values. But in the 21st Century, Steven Moffat's perhaps contributed more scary monsters to the Who wall of fame than anyone else. It's really quite a simple trick that Moffat uses though: he plays on primal fears of children. A noise under your bed or something moving when you can't see it is frightening to a child. So is the idea that something could be living in shadows, or that you've forgotten an alien incursion: even when the Moff took on the Daleks and visited their asylum, he turned them into crazed relics prepared to suck out your humanity like dementors. Hell, he even tried to make wi-fi scary. He's determined to turn every ordinary thing in the world into something to terrify your kids. The first villain he wrote about in Sherlock was a taxi driver. An ordinary thing, someone you trust. He played on the primal fears of anyone who's ever wandered home alone. He introduced a villain who knew every tiny, secure detail about his hero. And he wrote about a woman that his hero (sort of) fell in love with, only for her to be dangerous, too. He's not just intent on terrifying your kids. He wants you frightened of the ordinary too; he'll prey on anyone's primal fears.
2. The Companion
It's an obvious comparison to draw between Sherlock and Doctor Who. Both are frighteningly powerful beings who travel with a more human sidekick. But the comparisons really don't end there. John Watson has post-traumatic stress syndrome at the start of Sherlock, and his therapist labels him as having "trust issues". Amy Pond is abandoned by a mysterious hero, which also leads to trust issues, and Moffat hints at psychiatric help during 'The Eleventh Hour'. Both Amy and John choose to travel with their heroes because they crave adventure away from a boring life, and as Moffat's progressed with both shows, he's chosen to depict John and current companion Clara as having a lot of admiration for their heroes that's often unspoken until the situation calls for it. You get the feeling a lot of the time that neither Clara nor John want the Doctor and Sherlock to know how much they care about them. And as both shows have progressed, the living situations have changed. John used to live at 221B, as Amy did the TARDIS (a bedroom's mentioned several times). And though Clara does have a room too, she doesn't travel with the Doctor full-time, just as John's moved out from Sherlock's home.
1. ...And the Lonely Angel
What, have I not mentioned the similarities between Sherlock Holmes and the Doctor? Let's reel this off, Sherlock-style, deducing the similarities between these two fictional Goliaths... Both Eleven and Sherlock hate to be bored, and both are hugely detached from humanity. The Doctor has always loved humanity and has always been full of wonder for them, but Sherlock isn't romantic enough to see that; well, he's starting to warm in Series 3. Both the Doctor and Sherlock are often rude, often witty, and tread a line between self-awareness and naivety. Neither realise their image, but both know how intelligent they are. They're also both very quick talkers; they think out loud and reel off their ideas in a stream of consciousness, and they both curse themselves for not working out a mystery quickly enough. They both take pleasure from being the quickest person in the room, but they both believe that their friends are the best of them. And they both lie Sherlock lies to John about faking his death, as the Doctor lies to Amy and Rory about it. Both lie because they feel they can protect their friends, and then both turn up, unexpected, assuming that everything can go back to normal now they're here again. The big similarity though, is that they both understand how humans work, but they don't have the social skills to fit in with them. Or, as Steven Moffat says, "The Doctor is an angel who aspires to be human... Sherlock Holmes is a human who aspires to be a god." I couldn't have put it better myself.