Over 50 years and nearly 800 stories, Doctor Who has consistently delivered some of the best science fiction on television, and is currently the most popular sci-fi TV show on the planet. Let that sink in, people like me who have loved the series since back in the olden days. But it hasn't been all raisins and glory, oh, no. There's been some pretty bad mis-steps over the course of those fifty years. Let's have a look at ten times when the series...well, wasn't all it could have been.
10. The Master Race (The End of Time Parts 1 and 2, 2009)
Yeah, the Master, decides to clone himself and turn everyone on the Earth into him for t3h evulz! At least I think thats the reason. Its really not very clear, and frankly, its very stupid. Stupid enough that it muscled out the also very dumb, bringing the Master back to life using his horcrux scene, and thats saying something.
9. The Ballad of the Last Chance Saloon (The Gunfighters, 1966)
Ok, so the episode itself isnt great. Sci-fi western stories seldom are (Im looking at you, Firefly!). For some reason almost everyone seems to think theyre two great tastes that should taste great together, but with the exception of the Red Dwarf episode, Gunmen of the Apocalypse, theyve all pretty much sucked (looking very hard at you, Firefly!). But silly and bizarre though the plot is (a plot which, mind you, has the Doctor seeking the dental technology of the late 1800s when he has all of time and space to pick from), its not nearly as bad as the song. Yes, for some reason, someone decided what this episode really needed was an old West-style ballad. Even that isnt really horrible, per se, but it plays on and on and on and on, and like every two minutes you get a line from it. ItjustwontEND! Kind of like my dislike for Firelfy.
8. The Eric Roberts Version of the Master (Doctor Who, 1996)
So Im not bashing on Eric Roberts here. I think hes a fine actor, and he clearly did the best given what he was working with. But, oh, dear lord, what a mess. There is really nothing even remotely good about this version of the Master. He makes the Ainley version look understated and the Simms version look straight. Hes campy, overly evil in that Im so deliciously EVIL! kind of way, seems to have a thing for the Asian child, and really is just horrible and awful and lets move on before I lose my will to live.
7. The Death of the Seventh Doctor (Doctor Who, 1996)
Oh, look. Were here again. I could write an entire article about how horrible this movie was (and I have). Its bad from start to finish, with very few good moments. One of the worst is the way the Seventh Doctor (you know, the chess master, the one who was always a few steps ahead of everyone), dies. First, he lands in an unfamiliar place. He hears the rattle of bullets striking the TARDIS. He doesnt check the monitor (we assume), and steps out into the gunfire, only to be shot. Even thats survivable, but then the surgeon who works on him winds up killing him since shes not used to a binary circulatory system, though I will say the use of the opera in the background almost makes this scene cool. So, yeah. Really bad. In fact, the only thing that could be worse would be if hed died by, say, hitting his head on the console.
6. The Sixth Doctor Dies By Hitting His Head on the Console (Time and the Rani, 1987)
To be fair, we arent 100% sure exactly what killed ole Sixie. All we know is that the TARDIS gets shot at by the Ranis beam, everyone inside gets knocked around, and when the Rani and her minions get inside, we see the Doctor has already started to regenerate. This was made all the worse by the fact that Colin Baker didn't want to come back to film the scene after being fired (and who can blame him?), so the role of the Sixth Doctor is played by...well, the Seventh. There really is nothing good about this scene. Im entirely in agreement with an interview I saw where someone said they should have just gone with showing the Doctor having already regenerated, like they did in the launch of the 2005 series. But that wasnt acceptable back in the day, so instead we gotthis. *sigh* Lets move on.
5. Roses Character Erosion (Season two, 2006)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JvkjthzlyV8&feature=related One of my friends has been re-watching the Eccleston episodes and he said to me the other day, You know, Rose is actually a really good, likeable character in season one! He said this in tones of great amazement, and I dont much blame him. She was really good in season one. But sadly, along came season two. Its hard to pinpoint exactly when Rose jumped the shark. I think it was when she decided she really wanted to jump the Doctor. This was explored a bit in season one, but it wasnt until Captain Gorgeous (aka: David Tennant), popped up that it became a major focus for her character. I have a theory as to why this is (look up mary sue and apply it to Russell T. Davies), but regardless of why it happened, it did, and it was not to the characters benefit.
4. The Sixth Doctors Outfit (his entire eye-watering run)
Dont get me wrong, I like the Sixth Doctor. In fact, the Sixth and the Eighth are two of my favorites, and this is due almost entirely to the audio adventures. With the Eighth (and also here), its because, well, otherwise we have only the movie appearance for him. With the Sixthits not entirely because I cant see his outfit, but, frankly, it helps. What can I say about it, really? Just look at the damn thing. Look at it! Then keep looking at it! Now keep looking at it across two seasons of stories! Argh, its awful. Baker hated the hell out of it, and by virtue of that alone, the fanboys should give him a break. His idea was that the Doctor should wear a black suit and a tie. I dont know if that would have helped the ratings, but it sure couldnt have hurt.
3. The Slitheen (Aliens of London/World War Three, Boom Town and some The Sarah Jane Adventures episodes)
If you want a great example of what was wrong with the RTD era of Doctor Who, take a look at these guys. They, along with the following two items, all go to prove something Ive often said about Davies; hes a great writer, but he cant take science fiction seriously. The Slitheen are a great example of this. They came to Earth with a very stupid plan, but no stupider than some (see: The Dalek Invasion of Earth), and are, at times, actually menacing. But then any air of menace is destroyed when they start farting. Which they do. A lot. Im sure all the junior high school kids out there loved it, though possibly Im not giving them the credit they deserve. The characters work marginally better in SJA, but thats like saying youd rather eat ten servings of Mexican food instead of ten servings of Indian food. At the end of the experience, youre still left with a lot of crap. (note to Mexicans and Indians: I apologize for comparing your fine cooking to the Slitheen)
2. The Paving Stone Bit (Love and Monsters, 2006)
So as I was saying, Davies cant take sci-fi seriously. Here he created a potentially wonderful story about people coming together because of their experiences with the Doctor, and a young man and woman finding love. We then see some touching scenes of the young man, as a boy, saying goodbye to his dead mother, killed by an alien the Doctor couldnt stop in time. Its a really heart-wrenching scene thats only slightly spoiled by an oral sex joke only seconds later. Yeah, Im not kidding about that. To Mister Davies, should he read this, please look up the word tone in the context of films and TV shows and then apply it to this scene where the heros girlfriend has been reduced to a sentient face in a paving stone, with whom he has an active sex life, and then defend what youve done. Thank you.
1. Clap If You Believe in Fairies! (The Last of the Time Lords, 2007)
The Doctor has been captured by the Master and turned into a house elf. Yes, the Master aged the Doctor so hardcore that apparently he changed species. The Doctor is trapped and cant do anything to save the day, but dont worry! Martha Jones has been on Earth, telling everyone all about the Doctor and at the end, they all essentially pray/clap for the fairies and he comes back to life! Please bear in mind that this actually happened in a science fiction show in 2007. Words fail me, they really do. At the time I remember I wasnt even angry; I was just confused and mildly stunned. The anger set in later. What a stupid, stupid, stupid way to resolve the plot! It just made no sense and derailed any affection that I had toward the series until, well, frankly until Donna Noble came along, and what was done to her in the end, ohjust wait, Davies. I have more poison in my pen. Just wait until I do a sequel to this.