10 Most Controversial British TV Films
These are some of the most shocking broadcasts in British TV history.
Until fairly recently, television plays and films were a regular part of the broadcasting schedules of British channels, especially the three major terrestrial ones: BBC, ITV, and Channel 4.
And rather than the sort of tired, trite Hallmark Channel fare you might expect, these films were often some of their most radical, challenging programmes - the one-off nature allowing for experimentation that would otherwise have gone by the wayside if the broadcaster had to commit to a series order.
With such opportunity to push the boundaries, it is no surprise that these films often represented the more controversial end of broadcast material.
Violence, sex, horror: all of these were pushed to previously inconceivable limits, whether in more hypothetical contexts or in terms of documentary realism depicting these difficult issues. And as TV matured as a medium, growing bolder with each year, these one-off films only grew more daring, more risqué, and, yes, far more controversial.
From social realism to the supernatural, nuclear Holocaust to lustful devils, these are undoubtedly some of the most shocking pieces of British TV. Be warned: these films referred to mental illness, sexual assault, graphic violence, and nuclear atrocity.
10. Cathy Come Home
Cathy Come Home was one of Ken Loach's earliest directorial efforts, blending documentary and drama to tell a devastating story of homelessness. Originally airing as part of the BBC's Wednesday Play strand, the film has subsequently come to be recognised as one of the best plays broadcast. Subsequent recognition of its quality, however, does not distract from its hard hitting content.
The play demonstrates how a typical young couple, Cathy (Carol White) and Reg (Ray Brooks), slip into poverty and eventual homelessness, powerfully depicting the inadequacy of the era's social security measures. So unfamiliar with the blend of documentary realism and drama were the British public at the time that, for years after, people would give actress Carol White money in the streets, assuming she was homeless still.
The raw deception of the circumstances that can lead people into homelessness, especially the final scene where the social services take Cathy's children from her, provoked a huge response at the time, even leading to the show being discussed in Parliament. One contemporary viewer described it as 'an ice pick in the brain.' Today, the drama is just as affecting.
9. Walter
For their debut broadcast in 1982, Channel 4 opted to launch themselves with this exquisite and shocking drama about a young man with a learning disability and his cruel treatment at the hands of society.
Written by David Cook, directed by Stephen Frears, and starring Ian McKellan, Walter was a sobering examination of the maltreatment of the vulnerable in society. With excellent supporting performances from Barbara Jefford, Keith Allan, and Jim Broadbent, the calibre of the talent here should make it clear that Channel 4 was determined to make a lasting impression with their debut.
Aside from the quality cast and production crew, the broadcast was also pitched to be shocking whilst not exploitative. The film was considered particularly shocking upon broadcast for its depiction of same-sex sexual assault and violent scenes within the institution to which Walter is sent. And yet, the excellence of the drama was more than enough to ensure that Walter was given the due it deserved.
The decision to create and air Walter as their premiere drama was one that cemented Channel 4 as a stable of British Television, courting controversy from the off.
8. The War Game
Peter Watkins’ unflinchingly realistic portrayal of a nuclear strike on Britain was thought so horrifying that it was effectively suppressed, only being broadcast nearly two decades after its creation.
The War Game blends fiction and documentary style to depict the events leading up to, during, and immediately after a Soviet nuclear strike on Britain, with particular scorn heaped upon authority figures who argue in favour of nuclear deterrent, showing them to be out of touch with reality by conveying the horrors of the effects of these weapons on the populace.
Originally slated to air on October 6, 1965, The War Game in fact made its first UK TV broadcast on 31 July 1985, nearly twenty years late. A report on the prospect of broadcasting the film in 1965 stated 'the effect of the film has been judged by the BBC to be too horrifying for the medium of broadcasting.'
The War Game remains distressing viewing to this day. Despite this, it managed to win an Academy Award, after having been screened as a film when broadcasting was barred. It is a truly important piece of television history, and remains controversial.
7. The Firm
With a stunning central performance from Gary Oldman, The Firm is not just one of the best examinations of football hooliganism there is, it's one of the best British films of the 80s and it was a television film to boot.
Depicting the pointless cycles of mindless football hooligan violence, and intersections with class, status, and other social factors, The Firm is another staggering piece of social realism from director Alan Clarke, who will appear again on this list.
From the off, The Firm aroused two main responses, often at the same: shock and controversy surrounding the intense graphic violence of the film, and universal praise of the quality of the filmmaking, especially Gary Oldman's towering performance as head hooligan Bexy. It would perhaps shock some more to discover that the controversial broadcast was actually a somewhat censored version, with for instance a blinding scene receiving extensive cuts.
The Firm is another of the films on this list notable for courting massive outrage which was largely tempered by acknowledgments that the work was daring and of the utmost quality. The consensus upon broadcast was an uncomfortable recognition of both horror and art.
6. Brimstone & Treacle
This Dennis Potter penned 1976 play was declared by the then BBC Director of Television Programmes to be 'nauseating' though 'brilliantly made,' and so the Beeb shelved it for over a decade.
Brimstone & Treacle tells of a middle-class couple in middle age who, after a tragic hit and run, must care for their former-undergraduate daughter. And then, one day, a mysterious young man walks into their lives.
Featuring sexual assault, accused of blasphemy, and other social issues including fascism, the play is unflinching to say the least.
Speaking of his taking on the role of the mysterious young man in a later film version, Sting said he believed the young man was supposed to be the Devil. The Beeb concurred, so to speak, and decided that the play was far too horrible to air. It remained unbroadcast until 1987.
Some controversies seem ridiculous in retrospect, but not so with Brimstone & Treacle. It remains difficult, disquieting viewing. And if you are interested, they remade it as a film with Sting a few years later, for reasons best known to themselves.
5. Up The Junction
Before Cathy Come Home, Ken Loach's docudrama blend focused on the more controversial subject of illegal abortions for his first television play.
Following the lives of three working class women, and to a lesser extent their partners, Up the Junction's Rube, Sylvie, and Eileen each encounter different challenges associated with their statuses; Rube becomes present and seeks a back-street abortion, which is botched; Sylvie enters into a troubled relationship; and Eileen's partner must contend with his criminal past.
Director Ken Loach fused documentary filmmaking with the fiction to heighten the authenticity of the social, kitchen-sink realism. This was a major source of controversy, as well as the subject matter, as audiences were simply used to the technique, especially on television. Loach, however, persisted in using the technique, as noted earlier with regards to Cathy Come Home.
Given the outcry from some quarters following the play's first broadcast, the BBC rejected the proposal to repeat the programme. Regardless, the play contributed to the discussion around the Abortion Act 1967. It remains an important and challenging piece of broadcast history.
4. Threads
The second nuclear holocaust themed drama for the BBC on this list, and just as controversial as Watkins' earlier The War Game. This time, it is Sheffield that's in for the nuclear winter treatment, with arguably a more visceral and dramatic depiction than the earlier drama's documentary sobriety.
When the Director-General of the BBC happened to watch The War Game, he commissioned Threads. Depicting the horrors of radiation sickness, burning, suffocations, and other deaths related to the bombs themselves, Threads also showcases the inexorable descent of society into savage, medieval barbarism, as communities breakdown and people regress due to the effects to the attacks, from cataracts and cancers to technological regress, resource poverty, looting, fascistic responses from the desperate remnants of government and more. Threads does not let up: you must keep looking at the horror.
One contemporary review called the film 'unrelentingly graphic and grim, sobering and shattering, as it should be.' That it still retains its disturbing power should be clear from the fact that since 1985, the BBC has only ever repeated Threads once, in 2003.
3. Elephant
Perhaps no film on this list better encapsulates just how radical the television play form could be, considering that Elephant is 37 minutes with little dialogue, little plot, and unrelenting focus on realistically portrayed political violence. Suffice to say, it ruffled a few feathers and still retains its power to disturb.
Another Alan Clarke film and produced by Danny Boyle, the film is designed to represent the 'elephant in the room' of the Troubles. As mentioned, there is little in the way of traditional plot; instead, Clarke depicts a series of political killings during the Troubles by focusing solely on the act of violence itself, rather than the context and narrative justifications for such acts. The result is a masterpiece of television, but one that is relentless and difficult to swallow even today.
With a prominent use of steadicam, each of the killings follows the same grammar, so to speak: we follow the killer as the approach their victim, kill them, then leave. Repeat. Writing about watching the broadcast, filmmaker David Leland remembered thinking 'stop, Alan, you can't keep doing this,' and that one's gut reaction is that the killing must stop.
2. Ghostwatch
At one time, this supernatural documentary-style special was one of the most complained about broadcasts in British TV history, with many a viewer outraged by having been duped by its ‘this is live’ conceit. Viewed today, Ghostwatch will strike most of us as a fun supernatural horror romp with some surprisingly effective uses of the 'found footage/documentary' stylings, and yet hardly deserving the reported one million plus calls to the BBC Switchboard it prompted.
Ostensibly a live ghost hunt, with Michael Parkinson and team in a studio setting cutting to Craig Charles and Sarah Green inside the house with the poltergeist plagued family, Ghostwatch was actually a pre-recorded scripted drama featuring these aforementioned cast members, known almost entirely for factual broadcasting.
As the supernatural goings on escalated throughout the night, the show would deliberately play with those convinced it was live, by showing the ghost in some shots then having the studio team review the footage 'live' to show it wasn't there. Consequently, the show was so complained about that it has never been rebroadcast in the UK. Plus, Parkinson gets possessed; its well worth a watch.
1. Scum
Scum is one of the few pieces of drama created for British Television that were deemed to be too distressing to be broadcast, with this play completely dropped by the BBC (for whom it was made), eventually receiving its public debut courtesy of Channel 4 decades later.
An examination of the brutality of the now-reformed borstal system for young offenders, Scum features Ray Winstone (in a very early role) and Phil Daniels amongst others as they engage in the dehumanising experience of borstal life, with the 'daddy' of the wing controlling the inmates and the brutality of the guards dominating their lives.
The original 1977 television play was banned following a change in a management at the BBC, with some top dogs fearing it could be confused for documentary, given how authentic it was. Considering the extent to which Clarke's work has appeared on this list, it should be no surprise to find a piece of his on the top spot.
Clarke was undoubtedly was one of the finest and most challenging filmmakers Britain has produced and Scum is the prime example: horrifying, deftly-crafted, devastating, and truthful.