10 Most Disappointing TV Shows Of 2018
Jessica Jones, Westworld, and more 2018 TV shows that didn't live up to the hype.
It used to be that a TV show would creep up on you, with just a few adverts ahead of time and word of mouth really helping to spread the word of the next big thing.
That's still the case with some series, but a lot of shows now arrive with a lot of pre-release hype that's more in line with what we're used to from the movies. It's why fans spent 15 months excitedly waiting for the second season of Stranger Things and are having an even more agonising wait for Season 3, and why Game of Thrones viewers live in a permanent state of hype and desire to see the next season.
Sometimes shows can soar despite the weight placed on them, as happened with, say, Daredevil Season 3 this year. Other times, though, it can prove too much. Last year The Defenders failed to live up to the lofty expectations placed on it after two years and five seasons of build-up, but even something like Game of Thrones was a bit of a let-down in comparison to the high bar it's set for itself, and 2018 has been no exception with regards to shows not quite making the grade.
This doesn't mean the shows featured are worst of the year or even bad at all - at least one of them is pretty good - but none capitalised on the promise, potential, or sheer hype they came with.
10. Camping
Coming from the creators of Girls, and starring David Tennant and Jennifer Garner, hopes were high for this HBO comedy, which is based upon a UK series of the same name. Girls had some ups and downs, but it was a strong, unique voice, while Tennant's almost always great and this is something of a comeback year for Garner, after her great performance in Love, Simon.
In translating the series to America, Camping has lost the biting, satirical humour that helped make the original stand out. The characters are still largely horrible, but this version tries to make them a little likeable, and it's in doing that it ends up not really doing anything, and you just end up wondering why they're behaving as they are. It's not outright terrible, but it can come off as irritating, and the laughs are too few and far between.
9. Westworld
After over a year away, and with no Game of Thrones in 2018, there was added pressure on Westworld to deliver as HBO's big-budget, tentpole series this year. Unfortunately, it didn't quite achieve it.
While the production values were once again stunning and it had the performances to match, there's something so frustrating in the way Westworld cannot reach its full potential. It's quite telling that the best episode of Season 2, Kiksuya, was something of a standalone. It was able to really focus on character, allowing us to fully understand his motivations and arc, and layering in emotion through that.
For the rest of the show, while it still offers up some thrilling entertainment, it's bogged down in Jonathan Nolan's apparent obsession with baiting Reddit. The majority of the season, like with the first, feels designed to obfuscate viewers from the truth so that they can shock with a plot twist. However, that means most of the twists don't feel organic or earned, and the show's insistence on playing around with multiple timelines are again more designed to generate theories than they aid the plot. The tools for a great show are there, but rather than complex characters and tackling the bigger ideas, it too-often seems like it's made up along the way to keep people guessing.
8. Rise
Mid-season network shows can often be very hit-and-miss, but there was good reason to suspect Rise would make the grade. A new high school series from the creator of Friday Night Lights sounds like an easy win, and gets better when you add in a musical spin, the producer of Hamilton, and a cast including Josh Radnor and Moana's Auliʻi Cravalho.
The series is very much pitching itself as Friday Night Lights crossed with Glee, but sadly it can't capture the emotional storytelling and character work of the former, nor the glorious fun of the latter.
It works best when it focuses on the teenagers, with Cravalho excellent, but it's nowhere near as moving as it thinks it is. The bigger problem, though, is Radnor's Lou, a self-serious, endlessly-monologuing irritant, and the fact he's the main character is a flaw the show couldn't overcome.
7. The First
After a decade of misfires and controversies, it felt like a turn to prestige TV could be just what was needed for Sean Penn's career. With Hulu's backing and House of Cards' Beau Willimon creating the series, The First should have been the beginning of the Pennaissance.
Instead, the actor's stagnation continued in this plodding series about a manned mission to Mars. There's something exciting about the premise, with the promise of going into the unknown and the dangers and adventure that come with it.
The First, however, decides to focus more on the family drama in the life of Tom Hagerty (Penn), rather than the drive to go to space and the difficulties and wonders within. It's here that it's in overly familiar territory, the sorts of familial issues we've seen countless times with little new to say. Penn himself is good, if not spectacular in the way that would truly give his career liftoff again, but it's the show's poor choice of which aspect to focus on that results in its failure to launch.
6. The Romanoffs
Matthew Weiner's first TV series since Mad Men ended, with an all-star cast including John Slattery, Christina Hendricks, Aaron Eckhart, Diane Lane, and many, many more. That alone was enough of a hook, while its premise - an anthology series focusing on global stories of people who believe themselves to be descendants of the Russian Royal Family - was slightly odd but intriguing, especially given who was doing it.
As you'd expect, the series looks great and is well-acted, with Weiner putting his bigger budget to use. But with that opulence also comes an incredible amount of indulgence. Weiner here is allowed free rein to do as he pleases, and that's not actually a good thing.
The series is ambitious, but it never gives you anything to invest in - and certainly not its characters. There's the potential here for an analysis of human connections, of our history, of identity. The Romanoffs is simply more concerned with being lavish, a style over substance affair that needed someone to cut it right down and focus on the meat of the story and its characters. With episodes running to 90 minutes in length, it becomes less ambitious, and more just greedy.
5. Here And Now
Here and Now was another series where there was a high level of trust in the creator - this time, Alan Ball. Having created Six Feet Under and True Blood (steering that show when it was actually still good), his track record offered hope for his latest HBO series.
Starring Tim Robbins and Holly Hunter, the show was a family drama with a slight supernatural bent, centring around a multicultural family and looking to tackle issues such as race and mental illness.
The show's issue is that in its desire - which at times almost feels like desperation - to be so well-intentioned and Important, it completely forgets to be a functioning TV series. It's a series of lectures; a checklist of topics that need to be discussed. It tries to be woke but ends up broke, with actual story arcs and character development eschewed in favour of its melting pot of ideas that it can't make up its mind about or give any authoritative voice to.
4. Legion
Legion's first season was a mind-bending trip through the head of David Haller, a mutant with schizophrenia. Although not focused too much on plot, it worked wonders as a character study of a very different kind of superhero, while still having enough of a narrative thread running through it.
Season 2 very much sticks to the same visual style, and even more of Noah Hawley's unique sensibilities. Indeed, it's those that the show lives and dies on, really. Hawley is a wonderful creator, with an imagination few can match, but that's allowed to run loose here and it means the series gets away from him in a sense.
The series simply cannot keep up with the multitude of ideas he has spinning around his head, meaning that while there are a number of WTF moments and great visuals, it doesn't really function as an actual TV show. It's like a magpie, flitting from one shiny new object to the next, rather than focusing on the one in front of it. This all culminates in an unjustified (and potentially unjustifiable) finale, but even before then, the second season was a beautiful mess.
3. Altered Carbon
At the beginning of the year, Altered Carbon looked set to become Netflix's first major sci-fi success. With a major budget, an acclaimed novel to draw from, and Miguel Sapochnik directing the first episode, the tools were there for this to be a big, buzzy series. It just didn't know how to use them.
Sapochnik and the rest of the crew did succeed in creating one key element of the show: it looked incredible. With its cyberpunk visuals, this was the kind of lived-in, futuristic feast for the eyes that wouldn't look out of place on the big screen. It was everything else that was the problem.
With uneven pacing, a wooden lead performance from Joel Kinnaman, and some bad writing (the other showrunner was Terminator Genisys' Laeta Kalogridis) the series didn't have much inside its admittedly gorgeous packaging. Although ambitious, it bashes through themes of race and sexual violence like a sledgehammer, its grand philosophical questions remain surface-deep, and more than anything the story just becomes rather dull. Still, there's greater hope for Season 2, which will have the more charismatic Anthony Mackie in the lead role.
2. Making A Murderer
Making A Murderer is one of the buzziest Netflix shows to date, with EVERYONE talking about it in that late-2015, early-2016 period. One of the reasons it worked so well, though, is that it had a real story to tell. It was filmed over the course of a decade, so there was lots of information to pack in, keeping viewers gripped as the various cases and wrongdoings came to light.
Part 2, however, has arrived just three years later, in an age where the Steven Avery case has been much more well known. Still, the first was exciting, and it's the same filmmakers, so it must have something, right? This is, after all, Making A Murderer - the show that started a true crime craze (well, alongside podcast Serial).
Sadly, no. Instead, we get a drawn-out follow up that doesn't need to exist. There's no intrigue, hardly any new material, and while the production values are infinitely better (thanks to Netflix being onboard from the get-go), it covers some similar beats without adding anything fresh.
1. Jessica Jones
The first season of Jessica Jones, which debuted Krysten Ritter in the title role, really showed what the Netflix Marvel Universe could be. It included the dark, tone of Daredevil, but used that to discuss a number of serious themes and featured an intense, incredible hero vs villain rivalry (helped in no small part by David Tennant's performance).
After two-and-a-half years away, then, there was a lot of expectation for Jessica Jones Season 2 (unlike with Luke Cage, which had already faltered in its first season anyway). Krysten Ritter was phenomenal yet again, and the show once again had a great voice, but it also fell victim to many of the now-common Netflix Marvel problems.
There was hardly any story, let alone one that could fill 13 hours of television, and a real lack of focus, while it also missed having a clear antagonist. It was an average, at times boring series, when the first had been something really special. Hopefully, Season 3 can bounce back, but then it's also likely to be cancelled as well.
Which TV shows disappointed you this year? Let us know down in the comments.