10 Most Messed Up Deaths In Star Trek: Deep Space Nine

Serving on the front lines can be a truly dark fate in Star Trek - as these deaths show

By Sean Ferrick /

Star Trek: Deep Space Nine often finds itself labelled as the darkest Star Trek series, which has a fair amount of truth to it. The characters who popped up throughout the show's seven years often faced trials and challenges that would break the majority of us all.

Advertisement

There was often a cruelty in some of the fates faced by these people. There were those who were inches from freedom, only to have that freedom snatched away. Others admitted to transgressions only to be brutally murdered for their honesty.

This list, by its very nature, outlines the sometimes shocking deaths that appeared in Deep Space Nine, so a full spoiler warning is in effect. This is not the happy and feel good list you may be looking for today. For that, we suggest playing with a puppy, or dancing in the rain. 

On this list, that puppy will probably try and eat you. 

10. Vargas - The Siege Of AR-558

Vargas was stationed on AR-558, tasked with holding the defences in place as Starfleet tried to crack an important Dominion communications relay. What should have been a relatively short, albeit certainly bleak, posting became hell. Vargas, along with the rest of his squad, were stuck in place for months.

Advertisement

They fended off repeated attacks from Jem'hadar columns, while also battling the constant fear of the Houdinis - deadly mines that popped up from subspace with no warning. 

The arrival of Captain Sisko and several of the Defiant's crew did little to raise Vargas's spirits, so thoroughly downtrodden as they were. The trauma that he carried was enough for a small army to deal with, while he shouldered it all. Then, in the final days of his posting (though he wasn't to know that) another assault by Jem'hadar soldiers saw the man brutally stabbed in the back, killing him before he could have any hope of rescue. 

This, truly, was one of the most messed up deaths in Star Trek - just how cruel did the writers need to be? Thus is the hell of war, depicted so perfectly in The Siege Of AR-558.

9. Kai Winn - What You Leave Behind

How best to remember Kai Winn, one of the purest examples of 'love to hate them' in Star Trek? Louise Fletcher brought an intensity to her depiction of the ultimate Space Karen that saved her from being so unpleasant as to avoid her at all costs - but one could understand Sisko running a mile when she arrived on the station.

Advertisement

Her descent into evil in her final days was not entirely shocking, so consumed as she was by the drive for power. Time after time, she had demonstrated that the only thing that mattered to her was rising to the top. What manner of rising that may take, well, that was for lesser folks to worry about. 

Her death, quick as it was, came as she did her very best to try and save face, once again, though this time she bit off far more than she could chew. Bitter at the discovery that her beloved Pah Wraiths would choose Dukat to be their emissary, she switched sides, warning Sisko to destroy their book, 

With a casual acknowledgment, Dukat caused the fires in the cave to lift, surround, and rapidly dissolve her. A thoroughly unpleasant way to go for a thoroughly unpleasant person.

8. Kai Opaka - Battle Lines

This entry could, perhaps, be labelled as both messed up, and fitting for the character herself. Kai Opaka kept the Bajoran people together for much of the Occupation, rallying them to faith, saving lives in the process.

Advertisement

She was not without failings. She gave the location of a group of hiding Bajorans in an attempt to save her son, thus condemning others to die. Perhaps, then, her fate in Battle Lines serves as her penance.

Travelling through the Gamma Quadrant, she is killed in a Runabout crash, only then miraculously return to life. There is a catch - this rejuvination only works on the planet's surface. She is not alone. Two warring factions battle and kill each other repeatedly around her, trapped in a seemingly eternal struggle for control, though neither side is able to gain dominance while that life saving energy remains in place.

Opaka elects to remain alive, dedicating her existence to helping these people find peace. It may not be the final rest that follows a life dedicated to service, though it still somehow feels like fate for her. Whatever sins in her past led her to her death, in her afterlife, she could find atonement.

7. Jadzia Dax - Tears Of The Prophets

Killed by a disgruntled producer, or by a possessed supervillain - we shall leave that for history to decide. Either way, Jadzia Dax received one of the cruelest, most brutal deaths in Deep Space Nine.

Advertisement

The signs were there. She had just received the news that she and Worf were capable of conceiving, which is akin to any soldier in a war film showing a picture of their honey back home. You know the second the photo comes out, that poor bugger is marked for death.

Mid-prayer to the Prophets, or Wormhole Aliens as she preferred to label them, Dax is struck down by Dukat. Despite his best efforts, Bashir is unable to save Jadzia, though he manages to save the symbiont. There is a little comfort in knowing that her memories live on through Ezri, but this was a truly unfair, messed up death. 

6. Chu'lak's Victims - Field Of Fire

Lieutenant Hector Ilario, Science Officer Greta Vanderweg, and Petty Officer Zim Brott all became victims of the deranged Vulcan Chu'lak. Using a TR-116 rifle, with a micro-transporter attached to help the bullets travel through bulkheads, these three poor people were killed from afar. 

Advertisement

They were the victims of a man who had lost so much in his life that, repressed as his emotions were anyway thanks to his Vulcan discipline, found himself enraged by the joy of others. They had next to nothing in common, save for photos of their happiest moments adorning their quarters. 

They, sadly, were punished (despite being totally innocent) by a man who felt that all joy was mocking, and must be destroyed. It took the mind of a killer to bring this man down, as both Ezri and Joran Dax worked to get inside his head. In a near miss, Dax dodges Chu'lak's bullets while firing one of her own, incapacitating him. 

5. Crewman Muniz - The Ship

Crewman Muniz became an early victim in the slow build up to the Dominion War. Deep Space Nine rarely shied away from showing the horrors of war, though in The Ship, the show opted to depict a slow, painful death, inflicted on a poor man who happened to be in the wrong place at the wrong time.

Advertisement

Muniz was part of the away team that was tasked with salvaging a downed Jem'hadar fighter. He was shot by one of their weapons, which then consigned him to a slow death - something Worf found particularly grating.

He butted heads with Chief O'Brien, advising to kill the man quick and save his dignity. O'Brien vehemently objected, refusing to give up hope. Would that the show have opted to go with the Chief's outlook, rather than later proving Worf, at least in part, to have been correct. Muniz slowly bleeds to death, finally passing away mere hours before the rescue party comes to collect them all.

4. Mila - What You Leave Behind

Mila was guilty of nothing more than association, though this did little to spare her an ignoble death at the hands of the Dominion in What You Leave Behind. She had been the housekeeper for Enabran Tain for years and, most likely, was Garak's mother - though this was never confirmed on screen.

Advertisement

When Garak, Damar, and Colonel Kira found themselves stranded on Cardassia Prime, she sheltered them, allowing them to use her home as their base while they rebuilt the Cardassian resistance movement. 

This came crashing to an end when she was discovered, and murdered, by several Jem'hadar soldiers. She was thrown down her own stairs, followed by a grenade, which surely finished the job that the soldiers had started. She was avenged, not just by the Cardassian soldiers who accompanied those Jem'hadar, but by those who she saved. She may not have lived to see it but Cardassia was liberated mere hours after her death. 

3. Torah Ziyal - Sacrifice Of Angels

Meeting her father was the beginning of the end for Torah Ziyal, even if that meeting did, for a while, see a dramatic improvement in her situation. When she was discovered, she was labouring as a Breen prisoner, then quickly found herself (after a brief moment of potential murder by her father) free and travelling the stars.

Advertisement

Dukat even went to bat for her, declaring her as his legitimate daughter, losing his status in society by doing so. Not that this did Ziyal many favours as she then was forced to serve with him, first on the freighter Groumall, then later as part of his one man war against the Klingons.

She eventually settled on Deep Space Nine, developing a relationship with Garak, much to her father's disgust. Despite a brief period of blindness to the crimes of the Dominion, she joined Major Kira's resistance movement. Upon learning this, Damar killed her in an instant, firing his phaser over her father's shoulder. She died in Dukat's arms, looking shocked at her fate right through the last moment. 

2. Amin Maritza - Duet

Amin Maritza is a name that will rarely appear in the great annals of Cardassian history, though he was emblamatic of the collective guilt felt by so many survivors of the Occupation. 

Advertisement

His final days were marred in a misguided attempt to bring Gul Darheel, the long dead Butcher Of Gallitep, to justice. His plan, to play the part right through until execution, was noble, though as Kira put it, simply condemning another innocent person to death.

He felt bitter that his attempt was thwarted, believing Kira to have robbed a chance for healing. He was cut short, and cut down, by a random Bajoran man on the promenade. With no warning, nor motive other than 'he's a Cardassian', the man stabbed Maritza in the back. He died believing that Cardassia could never heal from the wounds of its guilt, even if he did receive the forgiveness of a single Bajoran - Kira herself - before he slipped away.

1. Vedek Bareil - Life Support

Bareil died slowly, piece by piece, carved away by the need to keep him around long enough to conclude peace talks. It was an ignoble death, despite the nobility of what he was trying to do. Watching him go through it was painful, not just for Kira, who loved him, but for Bashir, who was forced to do the carving.

Advertisement

The episode Life Support sees the death of this once great contender for Kai, locked into his fate. Though there are moments of humanity, so to speak, from Kai Winn as he suffers, she wastes no time in claiming credit for his achievements when the talks finally conclude.

By the time the end arrives, it is hard to say how much of the man Kira loved remained to actually die, or if he was mostly gone already. It was a slow, sad ending, one that Kira would never truly recover from. 

Advertisement