10 Most Ridiculous Doctor Who Rumours Ever

Amy Pond has sex with a Dalek? Seems legit.

By Danny Meegan /

When roaming the dark depths of the internet, it's hard to know what to believe. There are so many websites and YouTubers telling us stuff that it's always best to adopt a "false until proven true" mentality, waiting until official sources like movie studios have confirmed the validity (or lack of validity) of a particular piece of news.

Advertisement

But then again, there are times when an official source isn't really needed, because it's usually quite easy to tell when a story you're reading consists of nothing more than a ridiculous, outlandish rumour.

Now, to be fair, Doctor Who is quite a ridiculous show (in a good way) so you could argue that even the most bonkers rumour has at least a slim chance of coming true, but we'd like to rebut this standpoint by talking about rumours that are so stupid, so wild, so nutty... that there's no way they'd ever make it onto the screen.

Sex-mad alien clones? We've got those. Pop stars abducting Agatha Christie? We've got that too. Humans and Daleks having babies together? True nightmare fuel, and unfortunately, that's also here. Enjoy!

10. Clara's Parents Are Rose And The Metacrisis Doctor

Back when Jenna Coleman first popped up in the 2012 episode Asylum Of The Daleks, there were all sorts of theories and rumours about the true nature of her character.

Advertisement

We knew that she'd be playing a post-Ponds companion, but we'd also been told that she wouldn't be debuting until Christmas special The Snowmen, which aired several months after Asylum Of The Daleks did - and her surprise early appearance sent the rumour mill into overdrive.

It took until 2013's The Name Of The Doctor for us to learn exactly what was going on with Clara, and until then, bizarre rumours were plentiful, including an odd one which claimed that she was the daughter of Rose Tyler, and the Metacrisis Tenth Doctor.

BBC

The "evidence" was slim - the biggest things that fans pointed out were some roses in the foreground of a shot in Asylum Of The Daleks, and a pub in The Snowmen called "The Rose & Crown" - and, of course, it was all complete rubbish in the end.

9. The First Doctor Is Inside The Vault

The big mystery at the heart of Series 10 revolved around an enormous underground vault that the Doctor was guarding. The actual contents of this vault were kept a secret until the episode Extremis, which revealed that it contained Missy. But up until we learned this truth, all kinds of rumours spread within the fanbase.

Advertisement

Some people speculated that the vault held Captain Jack, Susan Foreman, or even the Thirteenth Doctor, however, one rumour that actually had some evidence backing it up was the idea that the vault contained the First Doctor, as played by David Bradley.

This partly stemmed from an interview with the actor - which took place months before he was confirmed to appear in the 2017 Christmas special - in which he strongly hinted that he was about to appear in Doctor Who.

The Doctor definitely has shades of darkness about him (especially Peter Capaldi's grumpier Twelfth Doctor) but the idea of him locking up a past incarnation of himself just sounds completely implausible, and a little bit insane to boot.

8. Britney Spears And The Sex-Mad Clones

It's not unprecedented for pop stars and other "non-actor" celebrities to appear in Doctor Who. Singer Katherine Jenkins was in the 2010 Christmas special, and Kylie Minogue was in the 2007 Christmas special, to name just two examples.

Advertisement

So, around ten years ago, it wouldn't have been total bonkers to hear the rumour that Britney Spears was being considered for a role, but it would have been total bonkers to hear that this role was "a raunchy bunch of sex-mad aliens".

And that's exactly what The Daily Star reported back in January 2007, adding that then-showrunner Russell T Davies was a "huge fan" of Spears, and that he wanted her to play "an entire race of lusty cloned creatures who all look identical".

While this would've been highly entertaining to witness, it didn't actually happen, and to date, the closest that Spears has ever been to Doctor Who is the "Toxic" scene in the Ninth Doctor episode The End Of The World. Absolute classic.

7. Rory Is The Master

Every single time a new series is about to air, there are always a load of rumours about how the Master, the Valeyard, or even the Rani could return - rumours that are false most of the time, or all of the time, in the case of those last two.

Advertisement

One of the most normal and unassuming characters who's been subjected to these rumours over the years is Rory, a companion who the Doctor Who fanbase was quite suspicious of after his first episode - The Eleventh Hour - aired back in 2010.

This was all down to a mistake on Rory's hospital ID badge, which states that it was issued in 1990. It's an easy-to-miss detail, but this date made zero sense considering Rory's age, as well as the year in which the episode was set.

BBC

But this couldn't just be a production error, could it? Oh no - it had to mean that Rory wasn't the normal bloke he seemed to be.

From here, Rory was rumoured to be the Master, an evil time-traveller, Rassilon, or even a fugitive from the Time War. These "Rory isn't Rory" rumours then persisted for a few more years, and while it would've been hilarious to learn that this bumbling nurse was actually the Doctor's arch-nemesis... he wasn't.

6. Slipknot Will Record The Doctor Who Theme

The Doctor Who title sequence is an iconic and important part of the show. Even casual TV viewers and non-Doctor Who fans are familiar with that time vortex and that famous music beat - at this point, it's just a part of the British consciousness.

Advertisement

As a result, it's always exciting when a brand-new Doctor is about to debut, because most of the time, they'll bring a brand-new title sequence along with them.

This was the case back in the early 2000s, and in the run-up to the Ninth Doctor's much-anticipated revival series, there was a lot of discussion about what his title sequence might look - and sound - like.

This led to a downright weird rumour that heavy metal band Slipknot was "in talks" to record that all-important theme tune. Apparently, the members of the band were big Doctor Who fans, and they even dedicated a song from their then-upcoming album (Vol. 3: The Subliminal Verses) to the show.

In the end though, this never happened, and it was composer Murray Gold who arranged the theme tune, just like he did for the Tenth, Eleventh, and Twelfth Doctors. And what a cracking job he did.

Weirdly though, Slipknot actually made a creative contribution to Doctor Who around a decade after this rumour did the rounds. For the 2015 episode Before The Flood, the band's lead singer, Corey Taylor, provided the roar sound effect for the Fisher King.

5. David Bowie Will Abduct Agatha Christie

Over the last 15 years, it's become a Doctor Who tradition for each series to feature a crop of famous faces in supporting roles.

Advertisement

From Simon Pegg in The Long Game to Maisie Williams in Series 9, it feels like Doctor Who can get pretty much anyone it likes, so it's not really surprising that there are constant rumours about who might be next in line for a TARDIS trip.

That being said, it's quite surprising when these rumours come hand-in-hand with some curiously specific and highly unusual details, which is exactly what happened in the run-up to Series 4, which aired its first episode in April 2008.

According to this rumour, singer David Bowie was set to appear in a two-part story in which he would "abduct" Agatha Christie, while facing off against David Tennant's Doctor. Apparently, Bowie was considered because of his "other-worldly looks", which, admittedly, is an assessment that's hard to disagree with. Just look at this guy.

TriStar Pictures

While Bowie is a fantastic actor (see The Prestige for proof), his Doctor Who role never came to pass, and since he died in 2016, it can't ever happen in the future, either.

Interestingly, this rumour did get the Agatha Christie part correct: the legendary writer appeared in Series 4's The Unicorn And The Wasp, although she wasn't abducted.

4. Harriet Jones Will Return As A Dalek

The return of Harriet Jones (former Prime Minister) in Series 4's The Stolen Earth was a big, delightful surprise, allowing the character to exit the Whoniverse on a high note after the Doctor had her deposed in The Christmas Invasion.

Advertisement

In the episode, it's revealed that Harriet has developed the subwave network, a communication system that allows her to contact the Doctor's allies (Martha Jones, Captain Jack, and Sarah Jane Smith), and ultimately, contact the Doctor himself.

In short, Harriet returned as the normal, heroic, human character we had always known, but a truly bonkers rumour claimed that this wouldn't be the case at all.

Back in March 2008, The Sun ran an article titled "PM is Doctor Who Dalek", stating that Harriet would become "the daddy of all Daleks" at some point in Series 4:

"In a shock moment on the BBC1 sci-fi hit, the casing of one of the metal monsters opens to reveal the ex-PM has been converted into a tyrannical pepperpot. A source said: 'It’s a stunning highlight of the series. Penelope was smuggled on to the set to try to keep the storyline a secret.'"

This rumour then spread around various fan forums, with one annoyed user joking that showrunner Russell T Davies must've been "snorting crack" when he wrote it.

Ultimately though, all of this nonsense was proven false, and we feel pretty confident in saying that Davies was never planning for Harriet to return as a Dalek.

3. Matt Smith Will Be The Thirteenth Doctor

Just like the "this new character is actually the Master!" rumours, the rumours that a current Doctor will regenerate into a past Doctor are really popular within the fanbase.

Advertisement

Pretty much every single time a regeneration is inbound, there'll be rumours that someone like David Tennant or Paul McGann might make a surprise appearance as the next incarnation of the Doctor, and as we all know, this is always total rubbish.

The most recent example of this - and possibly the biggest example, judging by how much coverage it received - was that Peter Capaldi's Twelfth Doctor would regenerate into Matt Smith as the Thirteenth Doctor, a role that hadn't been cast at the time.

Most people with two brain cells could tell that this was absolute crap, but the rumour appeared everywhere from fan forums to news sites in 2016/2017, before being dispelled with the announcement that Jodie Whittaker would succeed Peter Capaldi.

And speaking of ridiculous regeneration rumours...

2. Paris Jackson And Jason Statham Will Play The Doctor

The daughter of Michael Jackson, Paris Jackson was - according to The Daily Star - "lined up" to become the Twelfth Doctor, taking over from Matt Smith at the end of 2013.

Advertisement

This rumour circulated before Peter Capaldi ultimately won the role, and despite Paris being only 15 years old at the time (far too young to take on a role of this magnitude) and despite her having very little acting experience, this story was reposted on a surprising amount of sites - even credible ones like The Huffington Post.

This whole thing stemmed from a now-unavailable tweet in which Paris stated "OMG I wanna be the Doctor", which, clearly, we all should've taken really seriously.

According to The Daily Star, Paris' agent was going to make her a "major star" like Leonardo DiCaprio and Cameron Diaz, allowing her to step out of her father's shadow.

On a similarly ridiculous note, it was once rumoured that Jason Statham was going to take over from David Tennant. The Doctor punching a Dalek right in the eyestalk? Sign us up!

1. The Father Of Amy's Baby Will Be A Dalek, A Cyberman, Or Vincent Van Gogh

When Amy told the Doctor that she was pregnant in the Series 6 premiere The Impossible Astronaut, the conversation instantly turned to the identity of the father.

Advertisement

While the obvious candidate (and, as it transpired, the correct candidate) was Rory, Amy's flirtatious behaviour convinced many viewers that we were in for a shock reveal somewhere down the line, leading to a massive game of "who's the daddy?" within the fanbase, which spawned wave after wave of insane rumours - just like this one.

According to some extremely credible sources like The Daily Star (yes, them again) and Unreality TV, the "potential daddies" for Amy's baby included the Doctor, a Dalek, a Cyberman, and Vincent Van Gogh, who she met in Series 5.

It's hard to fathom how someone could even think this up - the thought of Amy getting it on with a Cyberman is just disturbing, and no, there isn't a scene in Vincent And The Doctor where they have a quick shag behind the TARDIS - but here we are folks.

Advertisement