10 Most Shocking Catfish Reveals

Catfishing your cousin for calling you a fat Kelly Price isn't even the wildest reveal for Catfish.

By Danni Scott /

In 2010, Nev and Max released a documentary that changed not only their lives but the landscape of social media interactions. Catfish: The Movie, documented Nev's confrontation with his own catfish; from this he began receiving messages from other people experiencing similar things across the USA.

Advertisement

And so Catfish: The TV Show was born.

10 years, 8 seasons, and over 100 episodes later, 'catfish' is a common term that has even been added to the dictionary. Known for shocking reveals and memorable stories, Catfish has so many wild episodes to choose from. No matter which one you end up watching, you're in for an adventure spanning across the whole of North America and even to England.

Over the years there have been many different reasons people begin to catfish others, the most common being that they are seeking some sort of human interaction. That being said, some of the most surprising reveals come from a place of anger or extreme lack of empathy.

If you don't have time to binge watch the series, here are the top 10 most shocking episodes of Catfish the TV Show.

10. Jennifer And Skylar

Poor Jennifer was only 18 when she sought the help of Nev and Max. She had fallen for Skylar, a male model, who she met through an online gaming site. The pair quickly began flirting and Jen was ready to take the relationship to the next level, despite never having video chatted or seen anything more than a few photos of him.

Advertisement

There was a brief suspicion that the catfish was secretly the show's sound mixer Tyler Faison due to the names rhyming and Skylar having previously claimed to be an audio technician. This was obviously proven wrong and the catfish was revealed to be a man named Bryan who was using the Skylar profile to practice flirting with women.

This was so shocking due to Bryan's complete lack of emotion towards Jen and his denial that he was doing anything wrong. He explained he was speaking to many girls and said he was "just hoping to brush up on his game". His emotionless response and refusal to admit he had hurt Jennifer riled up the hosts and fans alike. They left him and Nev and Max instructed him never to contact Jennifer again.

9. Craig And Zoe

Craig had fallen for a girl named Zoe online and she had not only connected with him but also made friends with his sister and lots of girls in his hometown. Having spoken to the girls, Nev and Max discovered that Zoe had been messing with the whole town in an attempt to cause drama.

Advertisement

She had sent a girl's nudes to the girl's friend and tried to instigate arguments between them. The catfish had told the girl she also had other girl's explicit photos with their full names and threatened to leak them.

The catfish was exposed as a lady called Sandra who had no real excuse. She initially explained that she just wanted to "mess with people" and like many catfishes had no real feelings for Craig. She claimed she didn't care about what she had done. However, when Nev and Max spoke to her the following day, she broke down and revealed a much deeper issue.

Zoe/Sandra showed that not everyone catfishes from a malicious place. A catfish might simply be a damaged person who is trying to connect with others but is too scared to be themselves - admittedly Sandra may have taken it too far.

8. John And Kelsey

John contacted Catfish as he'd met a girl called Kelsey on a chat room. Despite having spoken online all the time, they had never video chatted; she used body dysmorphia as an excuse for this. John admitted he hadn't been so shy and had sent her explicit photos.

Advertisement

On further investigation the hosts discovered that multiple people in the chatroom spoke to Kelsey and went on to speak to a young girl named Ellie who considered Kelsey a good friend. Ellie was dating another member of the chat named Adam, and had confided in Kelsey a lot about this.

They convinced the catfish to meet up at a casino and when they arrived a young man approached them. It was Adam, who revealed he had used the Kelsey account to seduce Ellie and then started the relationship with John to stop him pursuing Ellie. He didn't feel much remorse for his actions until they discussed Ellie.

The hosts made him video chat with Ellie to admit to her what he had done and she was understandably upset. Ellie ended the relationship with him there and then.

7. Lucille And Kidd Cole

Lucille began communicating with recording artist Kidd Cole and his record label, which was supposedly affiliated with Kanye West. After a string of events which involved a lot of money and unpaid bills, Miguel, Cole's manager, bolted and left Lucille to pick up a large cheque.

Advertisement

During the investigation, the hosts discovered the music on SoundCloud was not even Kidd Cole's and got in touch with another victim of the catfish. Loretta, the victim, revealed Cole had a criminal record for felony and fraud.

Finally Cole agreed to meet them and throughout the interaction was clearly dismissive and uninterested, texting on his phone the whole time. This infuriated Nev who took the phone from Kidd Cole and tossed it into the nearby water.

In the follow-up interview Cole stuck to his story but was revealed once more to be lying when his friend confessed to the producer that the entire thing was a farce. Afterwards, Lucille never contacted him again and Cole refused to speak to Catfish but was believed to be up to his old tricks.

Lies and large sums of money aside, this episode will always be remembered for Nev's iconic phone toss.

6. Lucas And Jayme

Having met on a dating site, becoming close, and sending explicit photos, Jayme got a message telling her not to speak to Lucas as he wasn't who he said he was. Upon investigation the hosts discovered more girls who had been catfished by the Lucas profile.

Advertisement

There seemed to be a massive number of girls he had manipulated and got explicit photos from which led to Urzsula joining the team. The hosts then baited the catfish with a girl on the crew - which he fell for.

They discovered it was a man named Zack and went to confront him with three of the girls he had catfished. Jayme asked what he did with all the photos he had amassed, to which he replied he deleted them. They asked to look at his phone and he started deleting things before giving the phone over.

Nev discovered a list of catfish victims on said phone with details about them and then found photos and videos sent by hundreds of unsuspecting women, including one of the girls who was there confronting him. As they turned to leave Zack showed his creepy nature by saying "miss you all", which Nev questioned.

They met up with him again and he admitted he didn't feel guilty about anything, even going as far as passing the blame onto the victims. Jayme and the other girls left, Nev and Max then took a photo of Zack and posted it to Lucas' social media, shutting the catfish account down for good.

5. Jasmine And Mike

In 2012, Catfish received an email from Jasmine. As many Catfish hopefuls before her, she had been texting Mike for two years despite the fact they had never met or spoken on the phone. The pair only lived 15 minutes away from one another but due to Mike's modelling career, had never met.

Advertisement

Nev and Max immediately spotted multiple catfish red flags and set out to help Jasmine. They eventually convinced Mike to meet them and anxiously awaited his arrival. A girl in a red dress walked towards them, to who Jasmine said "do not come over here" repeatedly.

It was revealed that Jasmine knew the girl approaching, telling Nev she was called Mhissy.

Mhissy threw a flower at Jasmine and revealed that she was Mike. Jasmine asked why she did this to her and the pair began to argue, causing the hopeful to get upset and angry. The catfish clarified that she did this for revenge as they were once friends. Mhissy explained that she created the profile to distract Jasmine from a man named Josh that they both dated.

The confrontation escalated and the two women separated with no plans to reconcile.

4. Keyonnah And Bow Wow

Catfish is no stranger to fake celebrities but this hopeful fell for supposed rapper BowWow, who she had been a fan of since she was young.

Advertisement

Keyonnah decided to take a chance on her celebrity crush and message him. To her surprise she received a response and the pair began talking. After four months, BowWow refused to video chat, although he had spoken to her on the phone.

Nev and Max began their investigation and Keyonnah revealed that BowWow had actually sent her $10,000 to ease her financial difficulties, which threw in the possibility that this was actually the rapper.

Once the catfish agreed to meet, the hosts and Keyonnah waited nervously outside his house for him to reveal himself. Much to Keyonnah's surprise, out walked a young woman named Dee. Dee revealed she was in the music industry and used the BowWow profile to seduce straight women as she "likes a challenge". Once Keyonnah had got closer to her, however, she did shut the page down.

Dee admitted that she did feel they had a connection but Keyonnah left in tears.

3. Antwane And Tony

In Season 3, Catfish introduced us to the delightful Antwane who had been talking to Tony for three years via a chat line. His cousin Carmen had contacted the show seeking the help of Nev and Max to reveal the identity of Tony. Even after speaking for so long, Antwane had never seen a photo of Tony - much less video chatted - as Tony often said he was too busy working to meet.

Advertisement

Tony's number was traced to a woman named Diana who happened to have a family member named Anthony. Unfortunately, Anthony was now serving time in prison, which would have explained why he could never meet if he was Tony.

The hosts, Antwane and Carmen travelled to multiple locations that were connected to Diana. In a shocking twist, Carmen turned around and revealed she was actually Tony and had been catfishing her cousin as revenge for him calling her a "fat Kelly Price". The entire thing had been constructed to ridicule Antwane but backfired on Carmen and destroyed the relationship between the two!

2. Artis And Jess

Artis wrote to Catfish as he was having feelings for Jess. However, both were in relationships and living with their significant others. They had kept the relationship secret the entire time. Uncomfortable with helping someone cheat, Nev and Max told Artis to come clean to his girlfriend, which he did and they broke up.

Advertisement

He told the hosts he was in love with Jess and admitted they had had some flirtatious and risqué conversations. Nev and Max asked to meet her and the catfish in return asked them to prove that the hosts were who they said they were.

She agreed to meet and the hopeful and hosts were waiting in a park for Jess to arrive when a car pulled up. A man got out and walked over to them, beginning to slow clap. In a now infamous interaction this man dismissed Nev, while Nev tried to stop him attacking Artis. Continuing to try and rile up Artis, the catfish shouted "you can still be my chocolate kiss" and admitted to being Jess.

He revealed his name to be Justin and they agreed to meet the next day. He vaguely explained his reasoning and said he didn’t care about Artis at all. He refused to explain himself any further and the hosts left without a full explanation or even an apology. However, the "you got me there" meme was born of this episode, so not all bad news.

1. Spencer And Katy

Possibly one of the most iconic episodes of all time. Spencer contacted Catfish because he had been in an online relationship with Katy for six years. The pair had met on a messenger app and had been speaking on and off ever since. He then revealed that this Katy was none other than pop sensation Katy Perry.

Advertisement

Nev and Max understandably did not believe it to be legitimately Katy Perry and they began their investigation. Spencer sent them links that Katy apparently had sent him of unreleased songs but the hosts quickly discovered that these links did not work. The hopeful then revealed he had gone so far as to make a ring for Katy from his grandmother's emerald.

They traced Katy's phone number to a Canadian phone and her email led them to a girl named Harriet who was Canadian but had moved to the UK. This took them all the way to England with Spencer still insisting that he was speaking to the real Katy Perry. They contacted a girl who was Harriet's ex-girlfriend. However, Harriet's sexual orientation only convinced Spencer further that this girl could not be his Katy.

Harriet finally confronted Spencer and admitted everything was her but did not have the exact details of their conversations - again this convinced Spencer that she was lying.

Nev and Max tried some tough love but in the catch up it was revealed that Spencer's delusion was so strong that he emailed the Katy email after the meeting saying he still believed it was her. He has since said he accepts it was Harriet.

Advertisement