10 Most Underrated Buffy The Vampire Slayer Characters

Sunnydale's most underappreciated stars.

By Aidan Whatman /

Buffy the Vampire Slayer aired for seven seasons and 144 episodes, and during that time introduced countless great characters, from sinister big bads to conflicted anti-heroes, world-saving warriors and sarcastic sidekicks.

Advertisement

Prominent characters such as reformed vampires Spike and Angel, Willow, Faith and Buffy herself have all become pop culture icons over the years, and frequently rank amongst the best figures the series ever created.

But for every beloved character, there are two behind them who never quite got the love they deserved. Whether this was a fault of the writing, a lack of screentime, or the fact that the character was a disgusting villain everyone just wanted to see gone, the following characters have their fans, but not as many as they really should.

With that in mind, from lovable demons to doomed Slayers, over-hated supporting players and antagonists who are far better than they've been given credit for, here are the 10 most underrated characters from Buffy the Vampire Slayer.

This article will contain major spoilers.

10. Clem

Though Buffy was often quite low on memorable demon characters, save for Anya Jenkins, it did have one underappreciated gem in the loose-skinned demon Clem.

Advertisement

Introduced in the season six episode Life Serial, Clem was initially portrayed as slightly antagonistic, but following his debut became nothing more than a big cuddly teddy bear who everyone around him loved.

A frequent poker buddy of Spike and good friends with Buffy, he appeared sparingly through the show's last leg, often found looking after Spike's crypt, keeping an eye on Dawn in times of trouble, or hilariously scaring potential Slayers.

Given his infectiously happy persona and the fact that he was one of the very few characters Spike was ever seen confiding it, it's a shame we didn't get to see more of Clem, even if the time we did get with him was enough to make him stand-out.

9. Willy The Snitch

Willy the Snitch was a minor character with unlimited narrative potential before he disappeared from the show without warning.

Advertisement

Played with awkward sleaziness by Saverio Guerra, he debuted in the second season as the human owner of an underground demon-friendly bar. Because of his clientele, his knowledge of the demon world made him a reluctant but important ally of Buffy.

Turning up sporadically until season four, Willy was equal parts endearing loser and sometime antagonist, willing to betray the Scooby Gang if it meant getting paid or keeping his business out of trouble.

Considering that Guerra is such a terrific character actor and Willy added a great amount of depth to Buffy's worldbuilding, it's a shame he didn't stick around, but even so the time we got with him made him in need of much more fan appreciation.

8. Halfrek

Halfrek was introduced as a vengeance demon and the oldest friend of Anya in season six. She was outwardly cheery, but that only made her destructive, torturous powers all the more terrifying.

Advertisement

During her tenure on the show, she acted as both Anya's manipulative confidant, occasionally clashed with the Scooby Gang, and in the final season died a fiery death when Anya decided to officially leave her demon past behind her.

Of course, the most interesting part of Halfrek's existence is that she's played by Kali Rocha, the same actress who played Spike's unrequited love interest Cecily before he became a vampire. Though this is briefly alluded to when the pair cross paths in season six, the narrative potential of the casting is annoyingly left unexplored.

A great addition to the show's worldbuilding and a darkly funny supporting player, Halfrek was great to have around, but is tragically rarely talked about within the fandom.

7. Kendra Young

If you can get past the atrocious accent, which actress Bianca Lawson was told to use on the day of shooting, for some reason, Kendra Young is a great character who never really got her dues on the show.

Advertisement

At the end of season one, Buffy faces off against The Master and is briefly killed, in which time a new Slayer was called to take her place. In season two, Kendra arrives in Sunnydale and announces herself as the new Chosen One.

Teaming up with Buffy with take on big bads Spike and Drusilla, Kendra had a tough relationship with Buffy since they were such different people, but ended up working together brilliantly whilst Kendra was in town.

Unfortunately, this pairing didn't last, since Drusilla kills her at the end of the season. In death, though, she's the reason Faith was introduced to the show, and her very existence brought added focus to the complexity of Slayer lore.

6. Jenny Calendar

Jenny Calendar is often remembered for two specific things: Her gypsy heritage, which was directly linked to Angel being cursed with a soul; and her horrific death at the hands of an enraged Angelus.

Advertisement

Though often talked about negatively in the fandom because of the secrets she kept from Buffy and love interest Giles, Jenny was actually responsible for the show's earliest redemption arcs, and was actually very compelling.

After the gang found out about her true identity, Jenny spent much of the second season trying to redeem herself by finding a way to give Angel his soul back. This ended in tragedy, as she was killed and left for Giles to find, but her work was directly responsible for saving Angel (briefly) at the end of the season.

Like most characters on the show, Jenny was flawed, but her mistakes and attempts to right her wrongs made her a genuinely effective, underrated creation.

5. Chanterelle/Lily/Anne

One of the most intriguing characters to ever grace Buffy or Angel was Anne Steele, a woman first introduced in the show's second season episode Lie to Me as a vampire wannabee called Chanterelle.

Advertisement

A teen runaway constantly conflicted about her identity and place in the world, she returns to the series in the season three episode Anne when she encounters a missing Buffy and helps her fight the dangerous demon cult that killed her fiancé.

When she reappeared on Angel, she'd adopted the name Anne (Buffy's middle name and former alias) and had started a homeless shelter for runaway youths, and even turned up in the spin-off's finale.

Anne's development took years to achieve, but was nonetheless one of the most satisfying and underappreciated arcs of either show.

4. The Master

Ask anyone to name a villain from Buffy the Vampire Slayer, chances are they'll name Angelus, Spike, Mayor Wilkins, Faith and maybe Adam (if only as a reminder of how terrible he was).

Advertisement

But then there's The Master, a big bad who often gets left behind, mainly because he was the show's first villain and wasn't quite as charismatic or well-developed as his successors.

A vampire so ancient he had become deformed in his old age, The Master dwelled under Sunnydale and intended to open the Hellmouth. He managed to kill Buffy in combat, setting in motion the existence of Kendra and Faith, and he also sired Darla, a decision which led to the siring of Angel, Drusilla and Spike.

Many of the series' key characters only existed because of The Master, a big bad who set the blueprint for all the villains to come Buffy's way, and a perfect representation of the evil she would have to face.

3. Darla

The first scene of Buffy the Vampire Slayer perfectly exemplifies just how unpredictable the series would be.

Advertisement

It starts with a high school couple breaking into the school at night, only with the girl getting scared that something's in there with them. It looks like the boy's going to kill her, but then - shock horror - it's the girl who turns out to be the vampire.

It's a great rug-pull, and introduces Darla in the best way possible. She causes some trouble in the first half of the show's debut season, before being killed by Angel to prove his loyalty to Buffy.

Like The Master, Darla was a character whose existence put many of the show's biggest developments in motion, and in both life and death she was just as compelling as the depth she added to Angel's harrowing backstory.

2. Warren Mears

The Trio are often cited as perhaps the worst villains in Buffy the Vampire Slayer. Made up of super-geeks Jonathan, Andrew and Warren, the awkward, painfully unthreatening group caused some trouble for Buffy, but were ultimately forgettable.

Advertisement

But that all changed later in season six, when Warren Mears became the focal villain and began to show his true colours. First, he tricks Buffy into thinking she's killed someone; then he shoots her and kills Tara.

A vile misogynist with no redeeming qualities, Warren went from bland bad guy to excellent big bad who caused more trouble and heartbreak than almost any other major villain on the show.

Played with detestable anger by Adam Busch, he was incredibly easy to hate, but still made for one of the series' most effective, horrifying, and damaging antagonists.

1. Dawn Summers

Dawn Summers' inclusion on the top of this list isn't so much that she's underrated, but has more to do with the fact that she's over-hated.

Advertisement

Admittedly, she's not without her flaws; she's shrill, naïve, occasionally selfish, and her kleptomania phase is somewhat annoying.

But even so, think about what she went through. She had an emotionally distant sister, she learned she wasn't real and only existed to open a demon hell dimension on earth, and her mom died, all in the space of a season, which also concludes with Buffy dying to save the world.

Considering all this hardship, Dawn's worst habits are very understandable. The amount of development she achieves after this is also fantastic, since she grows into one of the show's most dependable and brave fighters.

Nearly twenty years after the Buffy's final episode, it's about time Dawn got some of the respect and support she deserves, and that's why she has to be the show's most undervalued character.

Advertisement