10 Questionable Creative Decisions Made On Doctor Who
Every creator can make good decisions and bad decisions. Other times they're just questionable.
Throughout Doctor Who's fifty seven year reign on television, there have been many creators and many writers who've left their various marks on the show. A lot of those creative decisions have helped shape the series, and even aided in its continuation, deepening the lore of the Doctor.
Unfortunately, like all positives, there's always a negative element. Bad creative decisions come at the cost of gaining good creative decisions. Sometimes they can be harmless. Other times they can be downright questionable. To the point where fans, and audience members alike, are left baffled as to how these creators came to making such bold calculations within their creativity.
This has led to bizarre choices from characters, plot holes that render a narrative unwatchable, or even retroactively dampen other creator's positive work on the show. Sometimes creator's have even shot themselves in the foot.
It's a crazy experience witnessing these strange outcomes first hand. They either lead to you falling to the floor with laughter, because of how dumb it is, or results in you screaming out in rage. Nevertheless, it's always fun pointing out these questionable choices.
10. The First Doctor Breaking The Fourth Wall
During the height of Dalek Mania, original producer Verity Lambert decided to set things into motion for a twelve part epic featuring the Doctor's bitter adversary. In turn, this became one of the Time Lord's darkest battles, with the Daleks attempting to control the universe through the means of the Time Destructor, a device that can age planets in an instance.
In the process of keeping reality safe from the Daleks, the First Doctor loses two of his companions, and faces many deadly traps, and fierce encounters with sadistic foes. It's fair to say that this adventure was grim. Naturally, when it was discovered that a segment of The Daleks' Master Plan would air on Christmas Day, it was felt by the creators that this particular set piece should be lighter in tone.
So it was decided that The Feast of Steven would be a filler episode, devoid of the Daleks and the more chilling themes featured within the rest of the serial. However, William Hartnell felt it was a good idea to wish the audience a Merry Christmas during the final scene. In any other show, this would've been deemed acceptable.
Here, it implies that the Doctor is able to see the viewers at home watching his adventures, which is far too meta, and strange in both its execution, and concept. It completely takes the audience out of the narrative, and dampens their overall experience, through being reminded you're simply watching a television show. Perhaps it's a good thing that this episode is missing from the archives.
9. Making The Key To Time Arc Completely Pointless
Season 16 allowed Graham Williams to get really stuck in with his version of Doctor Who, pushing him to try out something different. Until the revived era, the show wasn't particularly known for having story-arcs that drove the season's narrative.
The Key to Time arc was unique in binding each serial together, forcing the Fourth Doctor on a singular quest throughout this particular run of stories, before it all concluded for the finale. At least that was the intention.
Given the Fourth Doctor, alongside new companion Romana, had spent five serials searching tirelessly for the various segments to the Key to Time, you would've hoped that this journey held some merits come its resolution. After all, the White Guardian made it clear that the search was urgent, and would prevent the collapse of the universe, due to it requiring a rebalancing because of the increase in evil spreading across reality.
In a disappointing turn of events, the Fourth Doctor separates the Key to Time at the final hurdle, and scatters it once more across space and time. Nothing gets concluded. The universe remains unbalanced, and in danger of destruction. But it's fine. The Black Guardian didn't get hold of the mystical device. In turn, this makes the entire season feel absolutely pointless
8. The Reality Bomb
Given The Stolen Earth/Journey's End reintroduced us to Davros, the deranged creator of the Daleks, things were sure to escalate in terms of the Daleks' twisted schemes for universal domination.
Although, it was a bit of a leap for them to want to annihilate every single living creature, and form of matter, in the known universe. It somewhat goes against their basic nature, and programming, considering the Daleks were conceived to become the dominant lifeform, upon all over life being suppressed, allowing for universal peace.
Here, they straight up wanted to murder everything, ensuring they were the only element left existing. And then what? Once they're just sat in their little bubble in the Medusa Cascade, what do they intend to do then? Maybe Davros had just completely lost his mind by that point, but this whole strategy is just dumb, and depletes his overall desire of becoming the supreme being.
If that wasn't questionable enough on the part of Russell T Davies' writing, then having the Reality Bomb reach ever corner of existence is even more puzzling. This implied that if the Dalek device was activated, then everything in every dimension, and reality, would be lost.
That means that reality should've been wiped out regardless, given that there must be a parallel universe out there in which The Doctor failed to stop Davros. Sometimes being too ambitious, and bold, can lead to some serious plot holes.
7. Having A Regeneration At The Start Of The TV Movie
As a fan, I'm very grateful that the creators behind The TV Movie acknowledged Sylvester McCoy's incarnation in such a big way. They knew he was still the current Doctor, and wished to bridge the gap between the previous era, and theirs. Not only was it a move that ensured good will with existing fans, but it also helped to establish the Americanised version of Doctor Who as canon, and a complete continuation of the Classic run.
On the other hand, it was a questionable decision, considering The TV Movie was meant to be a backdoor pilot for an American network. This opening story had to win over an American audience, who weren't as well-versed with Doctor Who. They needed to be eased into the complicated world of the show, which British audiences had become well accustomed to.
By having Paul McGann's incarnation narrate the opening (which, in itself, was a lot to swallow for a newcomer), and then have Sylvester McCoy appear as The Doctor, must have been rather confusing. Before the American audience could get to know this mysterious protagonist, he suddenly dies, before later returning to life with a new face and persona.
Fundamentally, the creators should've been more pre-occupied with their target audience, instead of trying to please past fans. By making something that's very faithful to what's come before, it ultimately alienated any newcomer because they simply couldn't keep up with the already existing mythology that was being rammed down their throats.
6. The Sixth Doctor's Introduction
John Nathan-Turner had established himself as quite a successful producer, through managing to conclude Tom Baker's seven year run, as well as keeping the show going through Peter Davison's much younger, and relatable incarnation. However, when it came to introducing his second Doctor, played by Colin Baker, things didn't go so smoothly.
The first mistake was introducing the Sixth Doctor at the end of the Fifth Doctor's final season (particularly after his popular outing, The Caves of Androzani). John Nathan-Turner feared that he may lose audience interest by not having an established Doctor before the season ended. This seemed quite strange, considering this had been done before with three other actors, and Doctor Who managed to continue without any major repercussions.
Secondly, it was decided that the Sixth Doctor would be a complete contrast to the Fifth Doctor, meaning he would be less kind, understanding, and a lot more questionable in their behaviour and actions. More salt was rubbed into the wound by having the post-regeneration period go incredibly wrong, resulting in the infamous scene of Peri being strangled.
Needless to say, all these decisions must have left the audience feeling concerned about the future of the show. It's actually a miracle anybody tuned in when Season 22 eventually rolled around, especially after the Sixth Doctor portentously forced them to accept him.
5. Wasting Gallifrey's Return
Steven Moffat did a daring thing when he retroactively saved Gallifrey from its destruction during the events of The Day of the Doctor. A lot of people were upset by this, as it took away from The Doctor's journey up until that point. However, there was hope on the horizon that Gallifrey's return meant it gave The Doctor something to live for, with his new purpose in life being to return home, the long way round.
This could've been a neat replacement for the depressing arc established since Series 1, where The Doctor was bitter over his actions during the Time War, and what it led to. No longer did he have to feel ashamed, but proud that he remained The Doctor, even during his darkest days.
Frustratingly, all of these positives outcomes were thrown away. Hell Bent promised us the return of Gallifrey. The Doctor could finally go home after everything that happened. Granted, it was a bit too soon, with The Doctor's search being non- existent throughout Series 8 and 9, but regardless, this event was what fans welcomed above all else.
Instead, it was all shoved aside to allow the painfully written Clara arc to continue for an unnecessary epilogue, ultimately spoiling this monumental occasion. Even The Doctor casting Rassilon off the planet was rushed, and quickly glossed over for events that fans didn't want the episode to be focused on.
Everything is made a billion times worse when Gallifrey's next appearance would see its complete destruction once again. Talk about mishandling a great concept, especially when two show-runners got it so wrong with questionable creative decisions.
4. Not Including The Eighth Doctor In The Day Of The Doctor
One of the biggest crimes committed by The Day of the Doctor was its lack of representation towards the Classic Series. There were no prominent roles for any of the Classic Doctors, with their only major appearance (which was evidently minor) rendered to only archive footage. Sure, Tom Baker was brought back, but he was playing an entirely different character, rather than reprising the Fourth Doctor.
The big argument at the time was the Classic era actors were far too old to return in a convincing way. However, Paul McGann was the exception, and could've easily slipped back into the role (something that was later proven with The Night of the Doctor).
Sadly, Steven Moffat intended for the 50th Anniversary to be a New Who reunion, wishing to bring back only Christopher Eccleston and David Tennant. Meaning there was no intention on their being a place for Classic Who. It's made even worse when Christopher Eccleston turned down the opportunity to come back, forcing Steven Moffat to invent a brand new incarnation (i.e. the War Doctor played by John Hurt).
This made little sense, and mocks Paul McGann even further, especially when he would've been the perfect, and most logical replacement. It would've been a great way to bridge the two eras together, whilst also granting Paul McGann some long overdue limelight, and perhaps a regeneration to send him off too. Basically, imagine the thrills we got from The Night of the Doctor, but as an hour long episode. And he gets to interact with the Tenth and Eleventh Doctors on top. Missed opportunity.
3. The Sixth Doctor's Conclusion
The Sixth Doctor was given a rough ride when it came to creative decisions. From giving him a costume that felt like an acid trip. Making his personality downright unlikeable. To finally cancelling his incarnation all together.
Originally, his incarnation was meant to undergo a multi season arc, which gradually saw his persona mellow out, eventually finding his inner self, and generally becoming a much gentler, caring character. This was ultimately rushed, given the hiatus between Season 22 and 23, forcing in a radical shift in his character's portrayal, particularly when it came to his relationship with companion Peri.
This cemented the beginning of the Sixth Doctor's downfall. Having gone from a full season, to a mere mini-series, things didn't look up for this conflicting persona, especially with the ratings depleting, and the BBC executives losing faith. After all, it was they who ended up restricting the Sixth Doctor's tenure during Season 23, which nearly resulted in a complete cancellation of the show.
Sadly, they refused to continue the Sixth Doctor's run afterwards, and opted to end it prematurely. Despite desperate pleas from actor Colin Baker to stay on for one more run, BBC executives (namely the evil Michael Grade) shut down communications completely, deciding to move on with Doctor Who without even bothering to get Colin Baker back for the regeneration. Luckily, Big Finish eventually came along to pick up the pieces.
2. Altering The First Doctor's Character
Steven Moffat made many strange decisions over the course of his tenure as show-runner, but none so bizarre as making the First Doctor appear sexist. It was initially planned to conclude the Twelfth Doctor's era with The Doctor Falls, but circumstances regarding Chris Chibnall's start date pushed Peter Capaldi's run back to Christmas 2017.
This resulted in Steven Moffat coming up with an epilogue on the fly, to which David Bradley was brought in to portray the First Doctor (as originally played by William Hartnell). He'd already paid tribute to the original incarnation during Mark Gatiss' docudrama, An Adventure in Space and Time, so he wasn't a stranger to the role.
Frustratingly, Steven Moffat decided to make unnecessary alterations to the First Doctor's persona, particularly when it came to him not wanting to regenerate, retroactively changing the events of The Tenth Planet. Sure, there were originally intentions to insert dialogue eluding the First Doctor being hesitant towards the change, but since this never happened it feels forced in, like Steven Moffat felt the need to reinstate this passed on idea.
That, and Steven Moffat crafted a running joke that the First Doctor was sexist, making fans of the original incarnation cringe in both embarrassment, and disgust. It's a true shame really because David Bradley did such a marvellous job at capturing the spirit of William Hartnell, but sadly his legacy was disrespected by the show-runner inserting an ill-advised parody routine that ultimately spoilt the experience.
1. Making The Doctor The Timeless Child
When it comes to the Chris Chibnall era, the fandom is split right down the middle. Many decisions made by the latest show-runner sealed fans decisions as to whether or not they wanted to continue. The final nail in the coffin came with the reveal of the Timeless Child.
This element was first hinted at back in The Ghost Monument, but seemingly got dropped as it was never mentioned again in Series 11. Come Series 12, this idea was brought back out of nowhere, and determined the fate of both Gallifrey, and The Doctor's journey moving forward.
The Master became utterly disgusted when he discovered what the Timeless Child meant, dangling the notion that it's secrets would change our entire perception of Doctor Who forever. Naturally, this was a bold claim, and made people anxious as to what Chris Chibnall intended. Unfortunately, nobody was quite prepared for how far he was willing to go to make his mark on the show, incorporating a retroactive element that literally changed everything.
Taking inspiration from 'the Cartmel Masterplan', Chris Chibnall has made The Doctor a mythological wonder, as well as a key establishment for the foundation of the Time Lords. The revelation itself isn't a particular problem, and sticks nicely with the concept of the Time Lords being corrupt to the core, but by having The Doctor at the heart of everything takes away many important elements from their character.
They're no longer just a simple wanderer in space and time, instead an all important figure that holds the foundations of the show together. On top of this, William Hartnell is no longer the First Doctor, as there are now countless other incarnations that came before him, including Jo Martin's Fugitive Doctor, and even the controversial Morbius Doctors. It's certainly a lot to take in, and something that leaves one's head aching with confusion.