10 Reasons Angel Is Better Than Buffy

Spin-offs are always inferior to the original? That wasn't the case with Angel and Buffy.

By Percival Constantine /

Let's get one thing straight right off the batt: Buffy the Vampire Slayer was an incredible, groundbreaking TV series and may have been the first time when a TV adaptation of a movie actually surpassed the original film. Joss Whedon's series of a teenage girl who is chosen to be the principle warrior against the forces of darkness managed to wow viewers week after week with incredible characters, great storytelling, and some of the best dialogue on TV at the time.

Advertisement

From the beginning of the series, one character really captured viewers' imaginations - Angel, the vampire who had been cursed with a soul to suffer for his violent actions. The tragic romance between Buffy and Angel has become legendary in the world of television. And following the third season, Whedon made the decision to break the couple up and give Angel his own spin-off.

Whenever a TV show spins off one of its popular characters, it's a risky move and it doesn't always go well. Even the best spin-offs never really reach the heights of the original series.

But Angel was the exception to the rule. While Buffy tended to flounder a bit after the third season and never really seemed to find its footing after leaving behind Sunnydale High School, Angel managed to be an amazing mix of drama, horror, characterization, and humor.

10. A Better Lead

Angel was never the most dynamic character when he was on Buffy. If anything he could be a bit one-note: a stoic, dark, brooding love interest. And that was fine when he was a supporting character. But once the decision was made to give him his own show, it was clear some changes had to be made.

Advertisement

Whedon has said that Angel was the hardest character to write, which is probably why there was more depth added to him when his solo series began. The writers introduced some more personality for him. The premiere episode shows an Angel who was increasingly disconnected from the humanity he was supposed to save.

Over the course of five seasons, Angel developed in interesting - and sometimes surprising - ways. In many ways, this is thanks to the great performance of David Boreanaz. He was able to inject a sense of humor into the brooding vampire and even gave him a sense of self-consciousness.

While Angel became more dynamic and interesting in his show, as Buffy's series went on, she seemed to go in the opposite direction. Buffy became a more rigid character, even bordering on annoyance in the later seasons. Towards the end of BTVS, Buffy was actually one of the least interesting characters.

9. Angel At Its Worst Is Better Than Buffy At Its Worst

Neither Buffy nor Angel were without low moments. When both shows were at the top of their game, it was some of the best TV ever. But when they were bad...oooh boy, were they bad.

Advertisement

For Buffy, this trend really began in the fourth season. The college setting didn't seem like a good fit, which may be why the writers more or less abandoned it in the fifth season. Except they never really found a replacement that worked as well as the Sunnydale High library. And the fifth season found a really big albatross in the form of Buffy's teenage sister, Dawn.

For Angel, it was the fourth season when the show went off the rails. Not only was there far too much focus on Angel's irritating teenage son, Connor, but the direction the writers took Cordelia in pretty much ruined her character.

However, despite the low points of season four, it also had some things that kept it from completely jumping the shark. One of these was the character growth of Wesley (more on this later). Another was the return of Angelus, Angel's soulless dark side. And the decision to bring in both Willow and Faith to help contain him.

But Buffy increasingly seemed to feel directionless, with storylines that felt like the writers were running short on ideas.

8. Death Means Something

Joss Whedon is always accused of killing off your favorite characters, but some of that is pretty exaggerated. In Buffy, most of the character deaths were actually fairly safe. In fact, with the exception of Buffy's mother, Joyce, none of the deaths in Buffy felt like they happened to beloved characters (sorry, Tara fans, she always annoyed me). They were supporting characters whose deaths were mostly to spur other characters to action.

Advertisement

True, Whedon did kill Buffy, Angel, and Spike, but he also reversed those deaths as soon as he could.

But Angel handled the deaths of major characters with far more significance. About midway into the first season of Angel, Doyle heroically sacrifices himself to save Angel and innocent half-demons. The ramifications of that death were felt throughout the series, particularly in regards to Cordelia.

And that wasn't the only significant death in Angel. Cordelia, Fred, and Wesley all faced Whedon's wrath in Angel's final season, and each one was an emotional gut-punch. Even the deaths of recurring villains like Darla and Lilah were handled exceptionally well.

Also, of all the characters Whedon should have killed in Buffy, the fact that Dawn never ended up on the chopping block was a grave sin.

7. Never Stop Fighting

One of the central aspects of Angel has always been the idea that redemption isn't something you can ever stop fighting for. Even despite the introduction of the Shanshu Prophecy at the end of the first season, which states Angel will become human after fulfilling his destiny, the theme of redemption as ongoing always remained prominent.

Advertisement

Every single member of the Fang Gang had something they wanted redemption for. Wasn't always on the same level as "being a murderous vampire for a century or so," but redemption is the one thing that bonded this ragtag group together.

That common theme continued to bond the characters and served as a useful shorthand for why they stayed together. In contrast, several members of the Scooby Gang felt like they were just fighting evil with Buffy because they had nothing better to do.

Nowhere was the redemption theme on better display in Angel than the final (and finest) season. A lot of people have criticized Angel's series finale, but it's actually one of the greatest finales in TV history.

The entire finale is all about fighting against insurmountable odds. The final image of the Fang Gang facing down against the demonic hordes of Wolfram & Hart with no chance of success, and Angel just saying, "Let's go to work" perfectly encapsulates the show.

6. Angel and Spike

Spike may have been the most popular character on BTVS by the time the show ended, so it was no surprise that Joss Whedon made the decision to bring Spike over to Angel once Buffy concluded. On the surface, it might seem like a ratings ploy. But it also made for some wonderful character moments and story potential.

Advertisement

Whedon himself has said that Spike and Angel were his perfect couple. The antagonistic friendship between the two of them, which we first got a taste of in Buffy's second season when both characters were evil, fully exploded in Angel's fifth season.

Spike himself had gone through some difficult moments in the final two seasons of Buffy. After the "what were the writers thinking" attempted rape of Buffy in season six, Spike fought to regain his soul, but in Buffy's final season, he felt like a broken character who had been dulled.

But going over to Angel, it felt like Spike regained his edge. The fact that he fought to regain his soul as opposed to Angel who was cursed with a soul also provided a very interesting dichotomy to their relationship.

And of course, that's without even mentioning all the entertaining banter between the two. The astronauts vs cavemen argument is still the funniest thing on either show.

5. Character Growth

There is no doubt that Buffy had some extremely memorable characters. Obviously Buffy herself, but also Spike, Giles, Willow, Faith, Xander, Oz, and on and on. But the show also gave us some extremely irritating characters. Riley, Tara, Andrew, and especially Dawn were all painful to watch in virtually every scene. Others, like Anya, alternated from annoying to mildly amusing.

Advertisement

Angel didn't always have the best character introductions. Fred and Lorne come to mind as two characters who seemed like they wouldn't work with the show at all. But over time—and pretty quickly—they became wonderful to watch.

In five seasons, Angel even managed to redeem some of the irritating characters from Buffy. Cordelia went from a shallow, self-centered bully and became a true warrior and hero. Even Harmony, an even more vapid version of Cordelia, became a real bright spot in Angel's final season.

Angel even managed to do the impossible in the final season. As mentioned, season four went off the rails and took some characters with them—particularly Cordelia and Connor. But in the final season, Angel managed to turn the clock back and in a few guest appearances (only one in Cordy's case), both those characters ended up redeemed and went out on a high note.

4. Wesley Wyndam-Pryce

Some keen readers may have noticed that there was no mention of Wesley Wynham-Pryce in the entry on characters, and there's a reason for that—because Wesley deserves his own entry.

Advertisement

When Wesley first appeared, it was on Buffy as Giles' replacement. Wesley was an intelligent yet extremely arrogant and cowardly young Watcher who could barely handle himself in a fight. As described in the script for his first appearance in BTVS, "Young, not bad-looking, but a bit full of himself. Thinks he's Sean Connery when he's pretty much George Lazenby."

Wesley was intended to be an irritating foil for Giles, so when he came over to Angel to replace Doyle, it first seemed like a step down. However, over the course of the seasons, Wesley evolved from this incompetent pain in the ass into a mild-mannered, intelligent man. Then to a dangerous badass.

If you've never watched the show, this may seem like a ridiculous transformation. But the writing - and Alexis Denisof's amazing performance - makes the whole thing completely believable. It's hard to think of another character in either series who went through more growth and transformation than Wesley, who became one of the best characters in the Buffyverse.

3. The Big Bad?

One of the characteristics of Buffy was the presence of the "Big Bad," a season-long villain who would lurk in the background, manipulating things from behind the scenes, before an inevitable confrontation with Buffy at the season's end.

Advertisement

Angel took an opposite move. Instead of each season having a separate Big Bad, Angel gave the entire series a Big Bad—the interdimensional law firm, Wolfram & Hart. Run by a trio of ancient demons, the Wolf, the Ram, and the Hart (known as the Senior Partners), the law firm defends the worst of the worst.

The use of Wolfram & Hart allowed for a lot of interesting concepts to be developed over the course of Angel's run. In the first season, Angel expresses frustration at the fact that he can't fight for mankind because Wolfram & Hart can use the laws to bend the rules in their favor.

One of the most chilling moments of the series came in the second season when Angel finds a way to Wolfram & Hart's Home Office. Thinking he's going to go to Hell, Angel is told by Holland Manners that Wolfram & Hart exists because of the evil within humanity, so he'll never be able to destroy them.

With Wolfram & Hart, Whedon created a villain Angel could never defeat, could never even punch.

2. Shades of Gray

The world of Buffy was always very straightforward. From the first season, the world was presented in a very stark black and white. Demons were soulless, evil things that had to be killed or else they'll destroy the world. Angel was considered the exception because of his soul. Yes, as Buffy went on more nuance was added, but overall it was more black and white.

Advertisement

Right from the first episode, Angel took a different route. He's paired up with Doyle, a half-demon who receives visions from the Powers That Be to help Angel save people. The episode "Bachelor Party" introduced the idea of demons who had assimilated into humanity.

Angel and his allies helped, worked with, and even employed numerous demons over the course of the series. But some of the show's greatest villains, such as Lindsey McDonald and Lilah Morgan, were 100% human.

The shades of gray used in Angel portrayed a world that wasn't always black and white. Which made doing the right thing much harder, because it wasn't always clear what the right thing was.

The final season dealt heavily with this ambiguity when the Fang Gang was given control over Wolfram & Hart's LA offices. It forced Angel to make compromises, never knowing if the action he took was something that would lead to the Apocalypse or further taint his soul.

1. Choice Vs Chosen

Buffy was chosen to be the Slayer. She had the life of a hero thrust upon her. And though Angel had a soul forced upon him, we learned through flashbacks that it took him nearly a century before he finally became the champion we all know and love. He had to make the choice to be a hero.

Advertisement

Buffy was about dealing with the life that had been thrust upon you and coping with the hand you're dealt. But Angel was about making hard choices and dealing with the consequences of those choices. And that concept didn't stop with Angel. All the characters had to continuously make the choice to be a hero.

There was never any question if Buffy and her friends would remain on the righteous path. But with Angel, it was a harder choice. Angel walked on the dark side several times, particularly in the second and fifth seasons. It happened to Wesley in the third and fourth seasons, Gunn and Fred/Illyria in the fifth season, and Connor in the fourth season, to name a few notable examples.

The entire final season of Angel was all about the consequences of choices made. As mentioned before, when taking over Wolfram & Hart, everyone in the Fang Gang had consequences associated with the choices they made.

Which show do you prefer? Share your thoughts down in the comments.

Advertisement