10 Reasons Why Arrow Needs To Kill Off Oliver Queen

With Crisis on Infinite Earths looming, here's why Arrow HAS to kill off the Emerald Archer.

By Andrew Pollard /

After over a year of build, Crisis on Infinite Earths is edging ever closer. Due to commence with December 8th's episode of Supergirl, this five-episode, five-show crossover event is going to change the landscape of DC TV as we know it.

Advertisement

Not just will Crisis play out across Supergirl, Batwoman, The Flash, Arrow, and DC's Legends of Tomorrow, but this game-changing story arc will also feature stars from Smallville, Black Lightning, Batman: The Animated Series, and more as The CW looks to somehow streamline any and all DC Comics-driven series into one standard timeline.

It's bold, it's brave, and it's going to be an utter treat for longtime fans of any of these shows. But it's not going to be all sunshine and rainbows, mind, for there are some very real costs on the line in Crisis.

Adapted from the legendary 1985 comic book tale, Crisis will see The Anti-Monitor step out of the shadows and look to destroy the entire multiverse. In said comic book arc, DC's finest heroes eventually managed to save the day - although several huge names died in the process.

With Arrow due to come to a close in January after eight fantastic seasons, then, here are ten reasons why the series must kill off Stephen Amell's Green Arrow before all is said and done.

10. To Show That There Are Very Real Consequences

Without consequences, what's the point in anything?

Advertisement

If the very existence of the multiverse is at stake, there simply has to be some consequences to that all-encompassing, all-powerful threat. And what better way to drill home the point that major consequences exist, than by killing off the character who started this shared world of heroes.

In previous crossover events or larger story arcs, the Arrowverse has often killed off supporting players or heroes from alternative Earths. With a threat as ominous as The Anti-Monitor and the potential wiping out of the entire multiverse, there can be no punches pulled when it comes to the severity of this situation and the huge costs that have to be paid to avert disaster.

No longer can an Arrowverse crossover get by without killing off one of this shared TV world's top, top players. For better or for worse for Arrow fans, there are no names as big as the Green Arrow. As such, the death of Oliver Queen is needed in order to really strike a chord that there are some very real, very tragic consequences to threats like The Anti-Monitor and his crazed plan.

9. To Fuel The Other Heroes

While Arrow as a show is coming to a close in the aftermath of Crisis on Infinite Earths, the rest of the Arrowverse will continue on. And what better way to fuel this shared universe's other heroes than the death of Oliver Queen.

Advertisement

Not to say that the likes of Supergirl, The Flash, Batwoman, and Sara Lance and her ragtag team of Legends particularly need any motivation to continue on as heroes, but Oliver's sacrificial demise would serve as a reminder why these heroes need to continue fighting the good fight.

By Oliver doing the ultimate heroic act of giving up his own life in order to save so many billions of others, that presents the ideal template of heroism for those left behind.

It's all well and good for somebody to talk the talk about being willing to do whatever it takes to get the job done, yet it's a completely different thing to see somebody do just that. And in seeing Oliver Queen make that final sacrifice, that is enough to hammer home to the Arrowverse's other heroes just what they themselves may have to do further down the line should such a situation arise again.

8. You've Already Fooled The Audience Before

Back during Season 3, Arrow introduced the nefarious Ra's al Ghul into the fold. Played by Matt Nable, this incarnation of Ra's was perfect for the long-form storytelling of Arrow.

Advertisement

That third season's mid-season finale was a true shocker, with Ra's defeating Oliver Queen, running him through with a blade, and then kicking him off a mountain top to his inevitable death. Of course, the mid-season premiere several months later would conveniently see Katana turn up to make sure that Ollie wasn't quite as dead as we were led to believe.

The point here, is that Arrow has already promised the Emerald Archer's death before, only to pull the rug out from under its audience and see Oliver alive and well just one episode later. To do so again - as in, to talk up Green Arrow's death, only to ultimately fail to pull the trigger - would be a slap in the face for those who have stuck with Arrow for its eight-season run.

As the old saying goes, fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice, shame on me.

7. The Emotion Of The Past Season Would Be Lost

Not just this season, but the final few episodes of last season were dripping in genuine heartbreak over what was coming with Crisis on Infinite Earths.

Advertisement

Arrow has most certainly had its ups and downs over its run to date, yet the past season or two has seen the series get back on track. And key to that has been the Oliver Queen character and his transformation from ranting figurehead to reflective, appreciative mentor who knows his number's up.

The first two seasons of Arrow were overflowing with goosebumps-inducing moments - the second season standing out as a true highlight of modern genre television - yet the series has often struggled to hit those emotional highs. In its most recent season, however, Arrow has had fans getting teary-eyed with the heartfelt moments we've seen play out on screen.

Whether it was Felicity's reaction to The Monitor's arrival to take Oliver to his inevitable death, Ollie's farewell conversation with sister Thea, or just the overall solemness of fate that looms large over Star City, it would be criminal of Arrow to tarnish all of the emotion that the show has managed to drum up recently.

6. Death Becomes Irrelevant

In the world of comic books, death has now become completely irrelevant. It's sad, but it's true.

Advertisement

The notion of death in comics was largely taken seriously until a certain point towards the end of 1993. That point? Why, that would be the culmination of the famed Death of Superman arc. Until that point, death in comics was a permanent arrangement. By October '93, less than a year after being killed off, Superman was brought back from the dead - and the Grim Reaper now wasn't as scary a figure as he once was.

From that point on, death in comic books became an afterthought, an inconvenience, and something that fans knew wasn't going to last. And that, well, that is something that the Arrowverse has to do its best to avoid.

There may have been a handful of moments across the Arrowverse shows where a death may not have stuck, but this shared TV realm has largely done its best to make sure that death is indeed a permanent arrangement. If this long-promised death of Oliver Queen doesn't happen or is somehow reversed, then that opens up the very real possibility of deaths in the Arrowverse becoming meaningless.

5. It Again Shows That Barry Can't Save Everybody

He's getting there, but still Barry Allen struggles to accept that he cannot save everybody.

Advertisement

This all began, of course, when Grant Gustin's Sultan of Speed had the harsh realisation that he couldn't simply go back in time to save his beloved mother, Nora. Since then, Barry's had a tough time of it as he's lost several of those close to him, and even had to go through the emotional shockwave of seeing his future daughter wiped out of all existence.

Even now, Barry has a glint in his eye to suggest that he can still save anybody who's in trouble. Well, apart from himself, for he's accepting of the prospect of him vanishing post-Crisis. But away from his own fate, The Flash needs to still learn that, even despite his well-meaning efforts, it's impossible to always save the day.

Since Barry Allen debuted in a second season episode of Arrow, Barry and Oliver have had a solid bond and have become bestest buds (even if Ollie doesn't appreciate hugs!). What better way to cause even further anguish for The Flash, then, than by killing off his BFF?

4. Because That's What Oliver Would Do

After his initial resurfacing in Starling City back in Arrow's very first season, Oliver Queen has continued to step up and prove himself worthy of being called a hero. Sure, there may have been some excessive brutality in that first season, but the progression of Ollie from rogue vigilante to bona fide superhero has been a joy to watch unravel for eight years.

Advertisement

Part of Oliver's journey to heroic icon, of course, is the fact that he learnt to put the fate of the greater good on a pedestal far above the fate of himself. And that's arguably the biggest reason why anything other than Oliver Queen's death would feel like a complete and utter cop out by the minds behind Arrow.

With audiences having watch Ollie's journey for eight seasons now, we all know that this character is somebody who wouldn't think twice about sacrificing himself, who has prepped himself to do just that, and who has even said his emotional goodbyes to those closest to him.

Whether he realises it or not, Oliver Queen wants this death. For him, the Green Arrow's story is over, Oliver Queen's story is over. This is his final chapter, and he'd have it no other way.

3. Makes A Mockery Of The God-Like Monitor

For over a year now, The Monitor has been making his presence felt across the entire Arrowverse of shows. This God-like being has been turning up to warn our heroes about an ominous, universe-destroying threat that's on the way. That being The Anti-Monitor.

Advertisement

What The Monitor has made clear, is that some serious sh*t is going down and that billions of lives are at stake. Not just that, but this omnipotent being has long made a deal with Oliver Queen that, when the time comes, Ollie will be giving up his life as a sacrifice.

Should Oliver not be killed off during Crisis on Infinite Earths, that basically makes a mockery out of what The Monitor has said, about the threat he's been chillingly warning about for a year, and about the stakes that really are on the line for Crisis.

If any otherworldly being in the Arrowverse is to be taken seriously going forward, The Monitor's words of Oliver's demise have to come true by the time that Crisis on Infinite Earths comes to its game-changing close.

2. For Somebody Else To Pick Up The Mantle

We've already been teased with an alternative DC's Legends of Tomorrow future in which John Diggle Jr. picked up the Green Arrow moniker, but that future 2046 has seemingly been erased from existence. But still, the idea of somebody else picking up the mantle of the Green Arrow is a massively intriguing one.

Advertisement

If anybody is to do just that, it's a far easier prospect should Oliver Queen have been killed off by the time Crisis on Infinite Earths comes to a close.

For that 2046 Legends trip, actor Joseph David-Jones played John Diggle Jr. - the son of John and Lyla Diggle - who adopted the name of Connor Hawke and became the Green Arrow. These days, within a different timeline, the same actor is playing a different character called Connor Hawke. Still with us? We hope so.

In the current Arrow landscape, Charlie Barnett plays John Diggle Jr. - the leader of the villainous Deathstroke Gang - while David-Jones plays a straight-up Connor Hawke who is the son of Ben Turner and Sandra Hawke. If anyone in the Arrowverse is to pick up the bow and become the next Emerald Archer, that again pushes the narrative that Oliver Queen sadly has to perish.

Given that a future-set spin-off series titled Green Arrow and the Canaries is in development, and that Stephen Amell will not be a part of that show, expect a new Master Bowman to arise sooner rather than later.

1. It Can't Be Any Of The Other Major Heroes

In the comic book Crisis on Infinite Earths saga, Supergirl and the Barry Allen incarnation of The Flash are two of the main heroes who are sadly collateral in preventing the destruction of the multi-verse.

Advertisement

The sight of Superman holding the limp body of his deceased cousin was one of the most shocking images to come out of Crisis, yet even more impactful was the fact that Barry Allen literally ran himself to death. It was hard-hitting, it was crushing, and it was one of the most well constructed story arcs DC Comics has ever put together.

By this point in The CW's shared Arrowverse, it would be far too soon to kill off Melissa Benoist's Maid of Might, and it would realistically be a tad too soon to do something similar to Grant Gustin's Scarlet Speedster - not to mention, Barry Allen and death has already been overplayed in The Flash - so that means that a major head needs to fall during Crisis, and that major head has to be that of Oliver Queen.

Much like the Golden Age version of Green Arrow was one of those who perished during the iconic 1985 comic book Crisis on Infinite Earths, Stephen Amell's Emerald Archer has to face that same fate in the upcoming TV take on Crisis.

Advertisement