There are over 3 billion comedy shows currently being made in America (rough estimate) and a lot of them are no good at all. There's only so often you can take 22 full minutes out of your busy day to give a new, disappointing comedy a go before you decide to just stick with what you know (and if ratings are anything to go by, then "what you know" is usually The Big Bang Theory. You idiots). Brooklyn Nine-Nine, a sitcom set in a police precinct in Brooklyn, shouldn't be a hard sell - it's enjoyed critical success, even winning the Golden Globe for best comedy in its first season. But it hasn't gained the traction it deserves within the zeitgeist and now, at the start of the third season, seems as good a time as any to try to correct that. So here are 10 of the 3 billion reasons you should be watching Brooklyn Nine-Nine (also a rough estimate).
10. It Shares DNA With Parks & Recreation
Brookylyn Nine-Nine's creators and executive producers, Dan Goor and Michael Schur, have an impressive shared CV. Schur co-created the beloved, recently retired sitcom Parks & Recreation, which Goor also wrote for. They've (together and separately) worked on Saturday Night Live, Curb Your Enthusiasm, The Office and many, many more of America's elite comedies. They've honed their skills to such an extent that Brooklyn Nine-Nine works right from the first episode and just gets stronger as is goes along. They've also brought in some of the brilliant people they've worked with on other shows, such as Chelsea Peretti who was a writer on Parks (but more on her later).
9. It's Made Andy Samberg Likeable
Before landing the lead in Brooklyn Nine-Nine, Andy Samberg had a pretty mixed back-catalogue. He was most famous for his work with comedy group The Lonely Island but hadn't hit mainstream success as a solo performer. His movie roles and bit parts in shows could almost exclusively be characterised as "loud". As Detective Jake Peralta, Samberg has hit a sweet balance between obnoxiously goofy and genuinely endearing. He's the Leslie Knope of this workplace comedy- seemingly a complete mess but, at the end of the day, damn good at his job and passionate about his work. Such is the quality of the performance that he's already won a Golden Globe for the role and parlayed his success into hosting the 2015 Emmys.
8. It's Got An Accurately Diverse Cast
You'd think it'd be a no-brainer that a show set in New York, one of the most multicultural cities in America, would feature a reasonably racially diverse cast. Similarly, you'd think a show set on the planet earth, with a roughly 50/50 gender split among the human population, would feature a decent number of women. However, television generally remains a mostly white, male domain. Brooklyn Nine-Nine has casually subverted this outdated trend by casting people of colour and women in multiple leading roles. Further, the show doesn't go around patting itself on the back for daring to have a group of people roughly reflective of the general population (albeit slightly more attractive). They just did it and it adds to the sense of the show's world as a lived in and recognisable place.
7. It Also Has Accurately Diverse Characters
In addition to diversity in casting, Brooklyn Nine-Nine has made an effort to feature characters who are not necessarily typical of a network sitcom. Captain Holt, played by Andre Braugher, is the head of the precinct and has risen through the ranks of the police force despite facing discrimination due to him being both African American and openly gay. The show handles the character of Holt, and issues of race and sexuality in the show generally, with a light touch, never shying away from the reality of the situation while also not making them the sole focus of the characters. It is refreshing to see a show in 2015 which treats a diverse workplace as a fact of life rather than an anomaly without making that diversity a perpetual storyline.
6. Terry Crews' Arms... And Performance, Of Course
Terry Crews may be the ultimate 2015 renaissance man. He started his career as an NFL player, during which time he apparently painted portraits of his teammates because... sure, very typical NFL behaviour right there. After retiring from football, he began to pursue an entertainment career, starring in ad campaigns, hosting a game show and taking cameo roles in comedy. In 2014, he wrote a book called Manhood: How To Be A Better Man- Or Just Live With One, detailing, among other things, his feelings on women's rights (spoilers: he's pro). His character in the show, also called Terry, shares a lot in common with the actor. He's a physically imposing man in an alpha-type job who is actually soft-hearted and sensitive. It's a lovely change of pace from the majority of male archetypes we see on TV. Oh and his arms are huge. They're huge.
5. It Gets Relationships Right
Much like its older sibling Parks & Recreation, Brooklyn Nine-Nine excels at presenting a variety of romantic relationships in both hilarious and moving ways. They have the long-term couples (both Holt and Terry are happily married), crushes, flings and an excellently played will-they-won't-they. Characters fall in and out of love in ways that feel organic and real even in such a heightened setting. One of the best moves the show made was back in the first season when they realised that Boyle- Jake's best friend and partner- was lusting after Diaz- another cop- in a creepy way that undermined the likability of his character. The writers had him move on and become simply a good friend to Diaz, subverting the audience's expectations that he would either "get the girl" or continue to pine forever.
4. Chelsea Peretti Is Finally Getting Noticed
Chelsea Peretti has been paying her comedy dues for quite some time. She's worked as a stand-up comedian for years and has multiple acclaimed specials under her belt. She wrote on Parks & Recreation and a few other lesser known comedies. She's a darling of the LA comedy crowd and has appeared in bit parts in several TV shows, including The Kroll Show and The Sarah Silverman Show. But it took the role of Gina Linetti, Captain Holt's insubordinate assistant, for the general public to take notice of Peretti. She's unendingly hilarious in Brooklyn Nine-Nine and has displayed a willingness to do absolutely anything for a laugh, including extended contemporary dance sequences. Also, her character is a childhood friend of Samberg's character and the two actors actually knew each other as kids so that is just about the most adorable piece of TV trivia ever.
3. Everyone Likes Each Other
Larry David, the creator of Seinfeld and Curb Your Enthusiasm, famously believed his shows should contain "no hugging, no learning". He pioneered a particularly cynical type of comedy, which has inspired countless other shows in which the characters are not particularly great people and often don't get along. While a lot of those shows are brilliant, there's something wonderful about a programme like Brooklyn Nine-Nine in which all of the characters, despite the occasional dispute, fundamentally like each other. The respect and friendship shown between them is often a source of comedy, particularly in the case of the extraordinarily loyal Detective Boyle. But even when there are no jokes involved, the precinct feels like a place where friends hang out and that's a nice world to visit once a week.
2. The Guest Stars Are Absurdly Great
In addition to a stellar main cast, the guest stars on this show are just ridiculous. Bradley Whitford of West Wing fame shows up as Jake's deadbeat dad. Sandra Bernhard, comedy and cabaret legend, is perfect casting as Gina's equally eccentric mother. Patton Oswalt appears as do half the hot young things in American stand-up including Moshe Kasher and Jenny Slate. Hardly an episode goes by without someone wonderful popping in. Perhaps most spectacular is Kyra Sedgwick, who has built her career largely as a dramatic actor. In Brooklyn Nine-Nine she plays the closest thing the show has to a villain as a higher-up in the police department hellbent on ruining Holt's career. She is icy and absurd and just absolutely perfect.
1. It's Laugh Out Loud Funny
Of course, none of these good qualities would matter if the show wasn't funny. Fortunately it is really, really, extremely, consistently, laugh-til-you-cry-actual-tears funny. Though a lot of the humour comes from the characters themselves, the writers and actors are also not afraid to mix things up with incredibly stupid wordplay or classic slapstick. It's a show that's hilarious without ever resorting to meanness or talking down to its audience. Every single performer on the show is gifted with brilliant comic timing and the writers have been careful to highlight each of them at different times, so it feels like an equally-matched ensemble cast. After the highs of seasons one and two, season three is already firing on all cylinders. If you're not watching yet, get binging.