10 Revived TV Shows That Should've Stayed Cancelled
Sometimes, less is more.
The world of TV is a cruel one, beholden to the almighty dollar. If a show isn’t cutting the mustard, then more often than not, no matter how adoring its small but faithful audience, no matter how much of a critical darling it is, it’ll be axed by a ruthless exec.
Sometimes that’s the end of that - it’ll live on as a cult classic if you’re lucky, or be forgotten altogether. Other times, the tides will turn, the planets will align, a Kickstarter will be kickstarted, and the sacrificial show shall rise again.
On occasion, this can be a good thing. Deadwood was off the air for 13 years before its feature length revival which wrapped up David Milch’s vision in the most perfect way imaginable. And love it or hate it, time has proved that Family Guy was pulled way before its time.
Then there are the shows that come back when they really shouldn’t. Too many years have passed, the magic isn’t the same, the ideas have run dry. It happens: the revival can sound like a great idea, but in practise, it might be anything but. These are the shows that should have stayed dead.
10. Scrubs
Bill Lawrence’s hospital sitcom inspired a devoted fandom, with loyal viewers charmed by the gently surreal humour, occasional moments of genuinely poignant high drama, and star Zach Braff, here at his most bearable.
It had a solid eight season run, and while the quality had dipped sharply towards the end, the show geared itself up for an eighth and final run that was as good as it had been in years, closing on a beautiful episode celebrating the show’s history in an affecting way.
Like a problem gambler, though, they didn’t know when to quit. Cancelled after a fitting crescendo, ABC revived Scrubs for a ninth season focussing on a new crop of medical students, clearly with the intention of keeping the show going on indefinitely.
It didn’t work, for a simple reason: no one liked the new direction. The characters and actors were perfectly fine, but after eight years, no one was too interested in starting again afresh. They retained some players from the old show, but it wasn’t to be. It just ruined a nice ending, basically.
9. Spitting Image
The original Spitting Image, ITV’s grotesque puppet-led satire show, was the perfect programme for its day. 1984 saw Reganomics and Maggie Thatcher running riot, with an ever widening political divide and an incident-packed few years for the British monarchy. The show kept up steam through the John Major years and the dawn of New Labour before being axed in 1996.
After a couple of efforts to bring it back, it was finally revived in 2020, with more of a transatlantic flavour, though currently airing only on BritBox. It would seem like the wild and crazy days would provide more than enough fodder for any keen satirist.
Thus far, that has proved not to be the case. The sketches are toothless, the jokes as lazy as comedy gets, the establishment left very much unflustered. The original Spitting Image was wild and surreal; this version is what Have I Got News For You leaves on the cutting room floor.
Its one stab at controversy came in its unflattering puppet depiction of Greta Thunberg, with many suggesting that a minor shouldn’t be the subject of acerbic satire. They really needn’t have worried - this is as limp as old lettuce.
8. Prison Break
A show with a killer concept that was simultaneously its greatest strength and weakness, Prison Break should have ended once the key characters, you know, broke out of the prison. Instead, it creaked along for another three seasons, with the protagonists bouncing in and out of incarceration for reasons ever more ridiculous.
It ended in 2009, and while it was good, trashy fun throughout, the time had come to pull the plug. It was genuinely surprising, then, that it returned eight years after this. Prison Break came back with a bang in 2017, and it had brought fresh new ideas with it. There were faked deaths, middle Eastern conflicts, a shady paramilitary organisation, as well as all the usual prison breakery.
Only, there was too much of it. Packed into nine episodes, Prison Break season five was overwhelmingly stupid, with globe trotting, double crossing, and dozens of intense staredowns in every single episode.
It wasn’t Prison Break at its worst: it was focussed, for the most part, and mercifully brief. It couldn’t be more clear that the idea had been rinsed for all it was worth, though - and some years ago at that.
7. Red Dwarf
One of the more out-there, concept driven sitcoms to find success in Britain, Red Dwarf was a charmingly cheap sci fi comedy that produced eight strong seasons between 1988 and 1999. The hapless crew, comprising the last man on earth, a robot, a humanoid cat, and a hologram, enjoyed capers across the universe, before the show came to a fittingly weary end.
Rerun specialist network Dave gained the rights to Red Dwarf, and the repeats proved popular. It’s a cosy show, great nostalgia. Then, someone had the bright idea to bring it back.
The revived Red Dwarf has run sporadically since 2009, and each new iteration is increasingly depressing. The cast (who, with love, haven’t had much on since the show was cancelled) look ever more embarrassed to be sat in the same seats doing the same thing after all these years. Attempts to spice matters up with a little more cursing and sauciness have done nothing to improve the show.
Ratings were reasonable at first, but the fondness for the revamped series has steadily trickled away over 11 years. Put simply: we didn’t, and don’t, need any more Red Dwarf.
6. Community
Six seasons and a movie almost came to pass (and still could if Dan Harmon’s sitcom ever makes the jump to the big screen), but it probably shouldn’t have. The pop culture-savvy sitcom was cult dynamite from the off, with deep allusions to film and TV offset by heartfelt character arcs, brilliant performances, and a focus on tightly structured, wonderfully plotted episodes.
Community was ditched by NBC after season five, then swiftly grabbed up by Yahoo for a final run. It was dragging itself along by this point. Half the original cast had gone, the well had run dry, Dan Harmon had quite clearly lost his interest.The whole tone was off, and the episodes, given the freedom of online streaming, ballooned past the tight network TV runtime. This freedom helped precisely none; the previously sharp scripts were now flabby, and often downright weird.
The show was on its last legs before the switch, but the final series is particularly unbecoming of the once-great show.
5. Futurama
It’s not hard to see why fans so fervently fought for Futurama to remain on our screens after its 2003 death. It was messed about something fierce my Fox, bounced around the schedule, meaning fans couldn’t even find it so as to boost its ratings. It seemed doomed to become a cult affair, fizzling out quietly.
In its downtime it found favour on DVD and Comedy Central repeats, and there was much joy when the Double C picked up Matt Groening’s show for a rebooted series. Four straight-to-DVD movies followed, then another two seasons.
They were… fine! They were fine. There are some great moments in the revived ‘rama, but let’s face it: the Comedy Central era doesn’t come close to the first four seasons, which started strong and only got better as the show became funnier, wilder, deeper, and more emotional.
The creative team evidently wanted another bash at the ending, and it does come to a great finish, but the original ending was pretty great, too. Perhaps everything wasn’t wrapped up all neat, but it worked wonderfully for the show. It never sank to the depths of The Simpsons, but the returns were diminishing by the end.
4. Roseanne
The original, late-eighties to early-nineties run of Roseanne, was something special. Important TV giving visibility to an ordinary working class household, it was warm, and beautifully acted by star Roseanne Barr and her TV husband, the great John Goodman. It ran nine seasons, probably a couple too many, as the latter years saw Roseanne win the lottery, then reveal that the entire series was just fabricated by the lead character.
Ending on such a sour note, it’s easy to see why ABC would want to revive the show, and for a couple of years they had a fun nostalgia act on their hands, but they would soon come to regret the idea.
Roseanne Barr, a vocal supporter of Donald Trump, tweeted some deeply hateful, racist material about former Obama administration official Valerie Jarrett, and soon enough the new Roseanne was scrapped.
They tried once more with a Goodman-led spinoff called The Conners (for which they killed off TV Roseanne), but the ship had sailed by this point. Looking back, the volatile, Twitter-happy Barr was pretty much a disaster waiting to happen.
3. Veronica Mars
The Kristen Bell-starring teen detective show took equal cues from classic noir and the works of Joss Whedon - surprisingly hard edged, long running detective cases couched in rapid fire, pop culture saturated banter and glossy romantic plots. The first two seasons were dynamite, so distinctive and smart, superbly acted by Bell and co (especially Enrico Colantoni as Veronica’s father Keith - it’s one of the best parent/child relationships ever depicted).
The third season saw the show jump networks, send Veronica off to college, and lose a bit of quality, though the vibe was still great. Then, it was cancelled. This wasn’t a huge surprise - ratings were never great - but it ends on a downer, and an inconclusive one at that.
Fans clamoured for more, and eventually a film was made, followed by a fourth season. Unfortunately the reboot shows that you should never go back. Out of high school, Veronica feels a little directionless; its USP is gone, and the film and latter series are powered heavily by the fumes of nostalgia.
The cast and crew’s love for the concept is palpable, but that alone sadly doesn’t make for an engaging product.
2. Heroes
A show that promised so much and ultimately delivered so little, Heroes stands as a great wasted opportunity. Its first season was a revelation, superheroics on the small screen like we had never seen before, with great characters, plots intertwining, a complex mythology, and an amazing baddie in Zachary Quinto’s Sylar.
Then, it dragged on for another three seasons. The second was the worst, blighted by the writers’ strike and some angles that went nowhere, but three and four never threatened to recapture the magic of the first. It ended, more neatly than we might have expected, and we assumed that was that. No one was clamouring for more Heroes (less, if anything).
So it’s hard to figure out just what NBC expected out of revival series Heroes Reborn, airing five years after the show went off the air. The superhero world had changed in the meantime, with the all-conquering MCU changing expectations.
The mini-series was received with ambivalence at best, and Heroes Reborn shuffled off our screens shortly after, with no talk of any more episodes. And quite right too!
1. Arrested Development
A sitcom that eschewed the schmaltz in favour of kinetic plots, ceaseless gags, and one of the most delightfully unlikable casts of characters ever seen on TV outside of an Apprentice boardroom, Arrested Development never stood a chance. A critical fave from the off, ratings started low and slumped further. Few were surprised when the axe fell in 2006.
Netflix brought it back in 2013, and in the lead up there was joy, but also concern. It had been a while, seven years in which many of the cast had moved up in the world, and new shows had come along - many of which were influenced heavily by Mitchell Hurwitz’s blunderbuss style - and changed the landscape.
The concern was merited, partially anyway. The magic was still there - Netflix A.D was zippy and weird, with a crazy sprawling plot that was, in theory, able to be watched in any order. The problem was that the ensemble cast - the key to the show’s success - rarely shared a scene due to budgetary issues.
The two Netflix runs were fun but sometimes felt more like a tribute than a revamped show. Not a Gob Bluth-style huge mistake, but not great.