10 Roles That Showed Doctor Who Actors In A Completely Different Light

Because nothing breaks the illusion more than Matt Smith and Billie Piper rutting like a pair of stags on a show about prostitution.

By Mark White /

Doctor Who may have been one of the last roles he ever took on, but William Hartnell will forever be remembered primarily, as the first man to fly the TARDIS. And in a timey-wimey way, his three years as the Doctor created so much more of a legacy than if he'd have stayed for five, or ten; one of Hartnell's greatest gifts to the show was, inadvertently, the fact that he gave it up for another actor. That last role turned out to be his biggest, and he's not alone; there have been thirteen men cast in the part of the Doctor, and it's the arguably the most notable character any of them have played. It's a show that defines a career like no other, and if you take on a role in Doctor Who €“ whether it's as the Doctor, a companion, or even a villain €“ it's a job you have for life. The public will always see you as that character. It might surprise you then, to see some of these actors in other roles. Because believe it or not, Matt Smith doesn't wear a bow tie in every show he's in, and David Tennant isn't always cast as the cheeky cockney chap in a striped suit. Here are ten examples of when Doctor Who actors took on completely different roles, showing us a totally different side to their acting skills.

10. Christopher Eccleston €“ The League Of Gentlemen

Despite delivering some of the funniest lines of the revived series €“ "Lots of planets have a north!"€“ Christopher Eccleston will probably always be the grumpy Doctor to many. He's done a lot of serious TV, thought-provoking stagework and even appeared in Heroes as a grumpy Mancunian disillusioned with the human race (sound familiar?). In Mark Gatiss comedy The League of Gentlemen though, Eccleston had a chance to show his lighter side. Gatiss played Kenny Harris, the owner of a dog cinema. In direct competition to him was Eccleston, playing Dougal Sieppe, a stereotypically posh villain who'd opened a cat theatre. Eccleston had specifically asked Gatiss and co. if he could appear, because he never got much of a chance to do comedy; it's a surprise really, given that this was a fantastic performance that highlighted his deadpan delivery and camp undertones wonderfully. Eccleston has constantly said that he doesn't want to be "put in a box" as an actor, and for audiences and casting directors to typecast him. Appearing in The League of Gentlemen was a certainly a bold move to show this, but it's one that definitely showcased a side of him we rarely see.

9. Jon Pertwee €“ Worzel Gummidge

Jon Pertwee is so many people's Doctor; he turned the character into a stately action hero, defending Earth alongside Sarah Jane and the Brigadier. In the process, he helped shaped the show's next forty years; without Pertwee, the Doctors since might not have been such sharply-dressed authority figures. It's bizarre to consider then, that Jon Pertwee played a scarecrow after leaving Doctor Who. Worzel Gummidge was a kids' show, starring Pertwee in the lead role, and Mrs Hudson herself, Una Stubbs as Aunt Sally, a life-size fairground doll. Worzel was a far cry from the Third Doctor, speaking with a higher register and a typically rural accent, and dressing in raggedy hand-me-downs. He wasn't a particularly bright character, but Pertwee was immersive in the role; Billy Connolly and Barbara Windsor guest-starred the show, and Pertwee even released a single off the back of it, entitled 'Worzel's Song'. Tom Baker's first role after Who was a similar position as Sherlock Holmes, but Pertwee truly reinvented himself when played Worzel. It might sound like a mid-career crisis for a big actor these days, but Gummidge was immensely popular; it was a show that gave Pertwee a lead role totally unlike the Doctor.

8. John Hurt €“ Indiana Jones And The Kingdom Of The Crystal Skull

After it was leaked that John Hurt was to play the Doctor, we all guessed that his incarnation would be gravelly-toned, wise, with a streak of darkness, and that he would probably die (or at least get badly hurt) at some point. That's the image we all have of Hurt, from Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy to Harry Potter, and every supporting role he's had in between. Indiana Jones And The Kingdom Of The Crystal Skull gives Hurt much the same basis; he's a very British archaeology professor, capable of epic speeches according to Indy. Unlike many of Hurt's roles though, he's presumed to be mad for most of the film; the titular skull hypnotises Hurt's character, Harold Oxley, leaving him dumbed down, and somewhat comically simple. Hurt's colossal screen presence and magisterial wisdom is abandoned in favour of a childlike, wide-eyed character who actually slows the gang down more than he helps them. Though it looks like a car crash on paper, Hurt plays the role fantastically. It's a rare glimpse into a lighter side of his persona not nearly showcased enough.

7. Derek Jacobi €“ Vicious

Derek Jacobi's Master may have only realised who he was for less than ten minutes, but it's still one of the most seething, frightening incarnations of the Time Lord. When the switch flicks, and Professor Yana remembers his real life, we all gasped, as the gentle exterior melted into a bubbling rage; the Master was reborn, ready to regenerate into a psychotic new body. It's probably a surprise for anyone engrossed by that unbelievable guest appearance, to see Jacobi in ITV comedy Vicious, a show that centres around him and Sir Ian McKellen, who play a gay couple in a long-term relationship. Jacobi's character is a million miles away from his portrayal of both Yana and the Master: he's a former bar manager living in the shadow of his former-actor boyfriend, who enjoys catty arguments in his relationship. It's a similar left-turn for co-star McKellen, but at least he manages to retain his Gandalf-like majesty to play the theatrical Freddie. Jacobi's another actor held in high esteem for his serious drama work, and the Master was a perfect part for him. His imperious command of the screen is reduced to a double act in Vicious though, a comedy that tows the line between silly and rude; it's more like the chemistry he'd enjoy with Captain Jack than the Doctor.

6. Colin Baker €“ The Brothers

Outside of Doctor Who, Colin Baker will perhaps be best known for Blake's 7, a show in which he played a flamboyant and egotistical villain. It's this smarmy, outlandish side of his acting that became the crux of the Sixth Doctor; Baker claims he's taken a bullet for the other Doctors by being the arrogant, unlikeable incarnation. Before either sci-fi giants though, Colin Baker was Paul Merroney in The Brothers, a snide, young professional and the villain of the show. Rather than playing the role with his trademark bombastic bravado, Baker was often subtle, relying on his facial expressions more than his booming voice, and looking bored with his counterparts, rather than livid with them; it was a performance that was to open doors for him, and it was only later that he became such a dazzling personality on television. Kate O'Mara, who would go on to play the Rani, also appeared in The Brothers; it's a show that Doctor Who has more to thank than most.

5. Jenna Coleman €“ Room At The Top

Aside from a flirtatious turn in 'Asylum of the Daleks', Jenna Coleman's Clara has been a mild-mannered and close friend to the Doctor. It makes perfect sense for her to play both a nanny and teacher; she has an older-sister quality in the presence of children, and a warm humanness that would appeal to Eleven. Room At The Top however, showcases a very different side of Coleman. Shortly after lead character Joe arrives in Warley, he meets the rich Susan (Coleman), and the pair begin a relationship; the drama shows Susan's and Joe's lust for each other in explicit sex scenes, as he juggles dating her with an older, unhappily married woman Alice. It's a mature, no-holds-barred performance, and one that doesn't have a lot in common with Clara Oswald. In fact, Coleman's other big role on British TV, a stint in Emmerdale as Jasmine Thomas, wasn't a lot like Clara either; she started off as a suspended school pupil, before killing a man, falling in love with a woman and being sent to prison. The Doctor would disapprove.

4. William Hartnell €“ The Army Game

It's hard to believe that William Hartnell was 55 when he took on the role of the Doctor. With his slicked-back, white wig and longing gazes into the far distance, he had a grandfatherly aura about him; this was a Time Lord who had been around a fair bit, even before the TARDIS landed in Totter's Lane. The Army Game was the show that showed Hartnell was perfect in as an authoritative lead; his performance as Sgt Major Percy Bullimore was snappy, no-nonsense and powerful, but it also showed sides of Hartnell that Doctor Who never could. Bullimore had a cockney twang, treated the boys like he would his children, and had an everyman quality that the otherworldly Doctor didn't. He was more of a father than a grandfather in The Army Game, evoking Captain Mainwaring from Dad's Army; it was a huge transformation to see Hartnell mature in quite the way he did to play the Doctor. Hartnell was reportedly fed up of playing hardmen, and that's why he agreed to do Doctor Who. It's a casting that could have so easily fallen flat, and he's not given nearly enough credit for pulling such a superb performance €“ totally unlike anything he'd done before €“ out of the bag.

3. David Tennant €“ Harry Potter And The Goblet Of Fire

David Tennant's Tenth Doctor is the most human of them all; so human in fact, he became a mere Earthling in 'Human Nature'. He's renowned for his smile and his cheeky wink, called a romantic Doctor, and is probably the incarnation you'd feel most safe with. In just a few short scenes in Harry Potter though, Tennant showed absolutely none of the beguiling loveliness he would bestow the Doctor with. Barty Crouch Jr. was a Death Eater, posing as Mad Eye Moody, to try and steer Harry into the path of Voldemort. Tennant was only unveiled as the culprit at the end; gone was his customary charm, replaced by a sneer as he stuck his tongue out like a snake. He was creepy, extremely sinister and though he spoke in a Doctor-like, English accent, he delivered his lines with a haughty smugness. Tennant's performance was deliciously evil, but ended abruptly when Crouch ended up in Azkaban. Bad things happen to wizards who mess with time, after all.

2. Patrick Troughton - Richard III

Patrick Troughton was a gifted character actor who brought a cheeky, avuncular spirit to Doctor Who, turning it into the show it is today. Matt Smith and Peter Davison have both drawn influence from Troughton's jovial but shrewd incarnation; it was a performance that in the hands of anyone else, could have ended the series. Laurence Olivier's Richard III is another example of a Troughton masterclass, but it's a polar opposite to his take on the Doctor. Tyrrel was a scheming murderer, eager to prove his worth, that Troughton played with nimble restraint: he was quietly deadly and a genuinely dangerous threat in the story. Troughton always had a strong presence on screen but gave one of the most understated performances of his career in Richard III; it was fascinating to see such subtlety and malevolence from a Doctor often labelled a clown. Rather like Eccleston, Troughton was an actor renowned for his work in drama, but unlike Nine, the Second Doctor let go an awful lot more, allowing the character to be fun and childish. It's a surprise watching Troughton in early work that he wasn't always like this, and it's a reminder of what a fantastic actor he was.

1. Matt Smith & Billie Piper - Secret Diary Of A Call Girl

They were one of the most loved Doctor-companion duos of all time; Ten and Rose Tyler took the dynamic to places that it barely been explored before, and when they were separated, it was heartbreaking. The Tenth Doctor mourned his best friend, and nearly-girlfriend, for two whole series, never quite getting over losing Rose. Imagine how heartbroken he'd be if he realised Eleven slept with her. Before he was cast as the Eleventh Doctor, Matt Smith appeared sporadically across TV, appearing opposite (and in bed with) Billie Piper in Secret Diary of a Call Girl. Piper famously played an escort in that series and Smith made a quick appearance as a client; and looking back on that particular episode, it's somewhat surreal to see Rose and Eleven in bed together. Luckily, the two characters are nothing like their Who counterparts, or it could have got a bit weird; Piper is eloquent, well-educated and enjoys living her double life, whilst Smith is nonchalant about his shop job, latching onto Piper's character Belle after their one-night stand. Commenting on which Doctor was the better kisser though, Piper claimed that it was definitely the passionate Tennant, as Matt was "Just sex." That's got to be a knock to his confidence. What's your favourite performance by a Doctor Who actor? Comment below!