It may seem churlish to suggest ways to save a TV show that has already turned a corner of late, but no matter how good a show is theres always room for improvement. When The Walking Dead first graced our screens it was clear early on that Frank Darabonts version of the Robert Kirkman comics was going to be something special. Through Season 2 (aka the farm series) and even the Governor stories there were dips and the show was bogged down for a while. Season 5 took a definite turn for the better and has been a belter so far. Well-liked characters have been killed off (it's one of the joys of the show); when the tension mounts, no one is safe. Beyond Hannibal, there are few other shows that can have the audience find themselves holding their breath involuntarily, or instinctively cringing back in their seats. The recent return of after the mid-season five break took fans on another rollercoaster - a brilliant character was lost and there were some excellent set pieces. But there are still rumblings among the fans that its all a bit samey, and there are some things that irk. So lets take a look at 10 ways to make this improving show even better.
10. Hold A Mirror To Society
One thing the Walking Dead hasnt done so far that other zombie stories have tried to do is hold a mirror to society as it is now. Instead it concentrates on how previously cosseted humans react in a survival setting. Audience you are often challenged to think how you would react in a given situation. Could you put a bullet in the head of a loved one if they had turned? Could you leave a friend to be taken if it meant you could survive? How far would you go in order to stay alive? Stealing? Beating? Murder? Survival horror is all well and good, but the whole idea of zombies came from unthinking humans and their obsessions with consumerism - it would be good to spend at least a little while being more introspective. Maybe the writers could take the opportunity to give the characters a wash and a change of clothes, using a shopping trip as a challenge to our modern day consumerism. The question of what makes us human and what keeps us above the level of savages is an interesting one. Investigating that in the context of the show could give it a new angle.
9. Let Go Of The Comics
There have been many changes from the Robert Kirkman stories, with characters being handed different roles and various stories invented that are completely alien to the books. Some have died that shouldnt have, others are still alive who shouldnt be - some events have even been moved around the timeline. But as with any TV adaptation of a well-loved book or comic, it shouldnt be afraid to take its own direction. In shedding the need to hold to the plot points of the source material, writers are free to think more broadly and audiences can be surprised with unexpected twists. This is not to say that the show should risk 'jumping the shark', but being able to introduce completely different ideas is important if the show is to continue long term. Certainly some of the upcoming stories in terms of the graphic novels are less than appealing for a TV setting and would risk the show getting bogged down again.
8. Get Out Of The Countryside
America is an extremely large country. People in the UK refuse to visit friends if theyre more than an hour away in a car; in the US, thats a next door neighbour. Its also fair to say that the areas around the North of Atlanta have a lot of woodland. But theres only so much the audience can take of wandering through trees and happening upon some little village. Seeing semi-sustained law enforcement and health services gave a teasing glimpse of what other directions the show could take. Seeing the desolation of the aftermath in a metropolitan setting could bring new challenges and new opportunities. Supplies, fuel, vehicles, even food would all would be more readily available in a larger city (as well as competition). Perhaps there could be an homage to George Romeros seminal Dawn Of The Dead with a visit to a mall for the aforementioned shopping trip, a trip down to the docks to search through shipping containers, or maybe a trip to an army barracks in search of weapons. There are certainly more options than "watch out for that tree.
7. Show Some Other Parts Of The World
As far as the audience knows, this outbreak, or whatever it is, could be limited to a few parts of the USA. It would be interesting to see some other parts of the country, or even some other countries. Is this something that only happened to the USA and the rest of the world managed to avoid it? Is this a worldwide problem, with very few humans left alive? Broadening the canvas and making the show about slightly more than just one rag-tag group should increase the potential for new characters, new plot threads and new opportunities for tension, not to mention a few more gruesome deaths. This wouldnt have to be some Resident Evil-style trip around the world, but seeing some other countries and how they cope could leave little breadcrumbs for where the show will go. Besides, this is a programme shown in 120 countries, so having some chance of spotting local landmarks will widen the scale of the show as well as let worldwide audiences see a piece of home. Albeit, a piece of home that's utterly desolate and covered in the undead, of course.
6. Include Some Hope For Humanity
It seems so far that the average post-apocalyptic human is either selfish, stupid or psychopathic. It would be nice to find a group of humans who were a bit more, well, human. There are likely groups of humanitarians, nurses, doctors, military, even local government busy-bodies who would have been trying to create something. Techies, network engineers, hackers, professors, teachers - surely there would be more left of our once great civilisations than a cop, some crazies and a few random joes? Arriving at Terminus, there just seemed something off from the start, but cannibalism and treating humans like cattle was more than a little troubling. The sense of hopelessness towards the end of that story arc was palpable and the idea that humanity wasnt worth saving has started to take hold. What is needed is a group of people who arent too good to be true. People who have been through just as much hardship, but who have come out with their empathy intact. This doesnt have to be a bunch of tree-huggers or even a fully fledged society, just people who arent only out to kill you and steal your stuff.
5. The Show Needs A Goal
When Eugene was brought in with his dodgy mullet and a promise of a cure, many who were unaware of the plotline of the comics must have whooped with delight. Not that there is any need to rush the successful show to a conclusion, but having a light to aim for is crucial to avoid the drudgery of getting through each day alive. This wasnt to be, however, and Eugene turned out to a chancer, but that kind of plot point is exactly what the show needs. Heading towards something rather than just blindly bumbling about gives the audience something to talk about and the characters somewhere to go. How will they react with yet another sliver of hope handed to them? Will they be too battle-weary to trust? Will they grab it with both hands? Will some be reluctant to rejoin society, feeling that they have a place in this new world that was better than where they were? The show may have plenty of tension, but it does lack direction. Knowing where you are going, even if you dont know how youre going to get there, gives added drive and determination.
4. A Whole New Set Of Characters
Obviously this would be pointless unless there was some link to the existing group and would have to be used sparing and carefully, but weaving two plot threads together leaves room for a more intriguing tale. So far the story has been about losing humanity, or trying to hold on to some semblance of it - doing that without hope is likely difficult, and one of the most basic human needs is contact. There have been hints of this before, and other groups have of course melded with the original set of characters, but this is a call for a completely different story arc. New characters would give the writers the opportunity to imagine what might be going on elsewhere in the country and show the struggles of different types of society. There would be other survivors, other survivalists, as well as the rich and powerful who would have taken precautions. Perhaps some wealthy gun nut with a safe house and a helicopter, perhaps some border patrol style clean-up teams determined to get rid of the walkers, or a make-shift government calling out to citizens for help. There is a whole universe of characters and events that could be used to build on the established group.
3. Flashbacks
With new characters comes the opportunity to start stretching out the backstories of our well-known friends, as well as the new ones. The initial outbreak was more than a little glossed over and, as was seen from the events at the CDC in Season 1, would be a gold mine for stories and gore. Perhaps the producers are reluctant to have their show likened to Lost, but used properly this particular story telling technique can add to the understanding of a characters motivation, as well as give hints of tales yet to come. Who wouldnt want to see some footage of when things first started to go awry? The logical thing would be to follow a team of scientists working on the virus and show the initial outbreak. This could involve our old friend from the CDC, even if only via a video call, to provide a link to Ricks group. This could be juxtaposed with the current state of whatever facility the team are working in, desperately trying to find a cure.
2. Up The Threat Level
Along with a new hope must come a new threat. Despite the call for a complete parting of the ways from the graphic novels, there are still hints there of a potential enemy: The Whisperers. In the comics, these are people who wear the skins of the undead so as to live among them. This may be creepy, but ultimately its a dude in a suit; what would be far more interesting would be to take the idea and run with it. What could be creepier than finding that not all of the undead are equal? What if some of them did actually retain something of themselves? Imagine seeing one of the group attacked by a walker thats pleading kill me. The virology of the infection is entirely unclear and its almost certain that Robert Kirkman is no biologist. Quite why a bite from someone else infected with the same virus should act as a catalyst is unclear, but it also leaves the potential for someone with a natural immunity that leaves them either impervious to the deeper form or in some way retaining consciousness. Being more creative with the virus and what it does could provide just the difference between the show and comics thats needed.
1. Promise Of A Cure For The Recently Turned
The nature of a zombie means there is unlikely to be a cure per se. Outside of the wonderful Warm Bodies, there has never been any suggestion of a cure for a zombie that didnt involve blowing their head off. One of the obvious conclusions from the other suggestions made here is to find a way of bringing people back from their undead state. It is highly unlikely, even in a fictional setting where zombies are accepted as a possibility, that any cure would work on those who are barely skeletons. But there is no reason an antigen could not be found to save those who have been recently bitten. The quest to find such a holy grail would certainly give the characters impetus and a goal, as well as having them question who they could have saved had it been available previously. A race against time to find the correct solution could prove an excellent cliffhanger to a season and offer some semblance of hope that normality could be resumed. What fixes do you think would improve on The Walking Dead? Let us know in the comments below.