10 Star Trek Adventures That Went Full Fantasy

Grab your favourite sword, dust off the spellbook and roll for initiative!

By Katherine Lewington /

Once upon a time, there was a galaxy full of scientists and starships on a mission to seek out the answers of the cosmos...until one day, they decided it was much more fun to dress up and play Dungeons & Dragons instead.

Advertisement

Star Trek may be science fiction (with one or two toes dipped in space opera), but it's never been afraid to dabble in fantasy. In fact, Starfleet loves to insist there's a scientific explanation for almost everything...right before taking a sharp turn into a fairytale.

When your day job involves strange new worlds and alien civilisations, who's going to say no to the occasional enchanted castle, unscrupulous wizard or suspiciously horny ghost? Especially when you have an all-powerful stalker that can just snap his fingers and drop you into any tall tale he desires.

Of course, there's already something quite whimsical about the whole thing. A found family journeying on a quest, discovering new lands, fighting for all that is fair and just. Well, most of the time.

It doesn't take much to push the merry fleeters over the edge and into a world of flight and fancy. So put away the tricorder, abandon logic and embrace Middle-earth chic as we celebrate ten Star Trek adventures that gave us magic and dragons and swords, oh my!

10. Beowulf, M.D.

When Harry Kim goes missing playing Beowulf in the Holodeck, it's down to The Doctor to search for the hero inside himself and come to the damsel's rescue. Yes, somehow, Heroes and Demons manages to take a proto-fantasy masterpiece and turn it into a missing crew member investigation.

Advertisement

This epic has everything a good fantasy adventure needs. Shield maiden? Check. Mysterious monster? Check. Viking feasting hall? Check. A reluctant hero that's so over it all before the quest has even begun? Well, that's just The Doctor's default setting.

The Doctor's crusade doesn't exactly follow the usual 'hero's journey'. On the contrary, he ditches his sword and uses his holographic nature to avoid battle entirely. The tales of his exploits, meant to impress his new warrior friends, boil down to medical anecdotes that would make even Tuvok yawn. And his very first skirmish with the monster ends with him losing an arm. But he does get to enjoy a sweet little romance along the way...albeit with a tragic ending.

In all, Heroes and Demons is a fun, if somewhat random, twist on the Holodeck malfunction trope. Our takeaway? It's hard not to envy The Doctor's ability to instantly access and digest a literary classic along with annotations and commentaries. It would have made school so much easier.

9. Space Elves

We'd love to know who looked at the proposed outline for Star Trek: Picard and said, 'I know what this needs...space elves.'

Advertisement

Because there's no getting away from it, that's pretty much what Elnor reminds us of. Don't get us wrong, we love the Romulan ninja for it, but we're all friends here and it's best to be honest about these things.

The hair, the clothes, the sword, not to mention the fighting style. Put Elnor alongside Legolas and he'd look like an Elf from another shelf. The secluded, spiritual sect he was raised in, with its dedication to absolute candour, gives him that otherworldly way of speaking. It makes him feel like a wide-eyed youth discovering the world of Men. And aliens.

Even his name bears a passing resemblance to the elven lord Elrond. And it's not just us imagining things. Showrunner Michael Chabon addressed Elnor's name in a Q&A:

...it may be possible to translate it from the Elvish in an interesting way.

Which had fans reaching for their detective deerstalkers to deduce that Elnor could be roughly translated as El, meaning 'star', and Nor, meaning 'to run'. Or in other words...star trek.

Even actor Evan Evagora seemed to embrace the Legolas comparison when speaking with Wil Wheaton in The Ready Room:

It's the greatest thing, I couldn't have thought of a higher compliment. Except I'd say I'm cooler than Legolas. You'll see.

We rest our case.

8. Unsympathetic Magic

Catspaw opens like a Dungeon Master doing their absolute best to set the scene in a Dungeons & Dragons campaign.

Advertisement

'A dead man tells you there's a curse on your ship. You explore a fog-filled ravine and hear ghostly moans on the wind. The faces of three witches appear in the mist, wailing your name. What do you do?'

And Spock's response is to throw shade and remain unimpressed.

Still, Kirk, Spock and McCoy press on, discovering a spooky old castle where they're greeted by a black cat. Ignoring the foreboding atmosphere, they follow the surly kitty...until someone in the party clearly rolls a 1 and the floor collapses beneath them, rendering the trio unconscious.

When they awake, they're chained in a dungeon, because no castle adventure is complete without one. But the dungeon crawl is unexpectedly skipped when they're transported to meet their host, Korob, who is dressed like a wizard from an old D&D book.

He even has some conjuring tricks to match and is seemingly able to talk to the cat. Only, she turns out to be his shapeshifting companion, Sylvia, with enough power to control Kirk's ship and crew alike. While our scientifically minded officers suspect telepathy, she calls it sympathetic magic...a horribly ironic name given the havoc she wreaks.

Sylvia does have a weakness though. Her sorcery is nothing compared to Kirk's charisma check, and he weaves a magic all of his own to subdue her. Alas, his romantic ruse is rumbled and it falls to Korob to rescue the away team from Sylvia's claws.

It seems the campaign needed to be wrapped up quickly at this point, because the story descends into a frenzied escape run that involves a giant cat, mind-controlled crew and a magic wand. Absolutely bonkers.

7. Seduction By Candlelight

In the era of romantasy, what's a fantasy story list without a spicy mystical romance?

Advertisement

For those unfamiliar with The Next Generation's Sub Rosa, it's usually referred to as 'the one where Beverly Crusher bangs a ghost'. And, admittedly, that's a pretty succinct description.

Beverly travels to her late grandmother's home on the Caldos colony. It's meant to be based on Scotland...if it were reimagined by a theme park. But it does give the whole episode that eerie Highlands feeling. Ghosts on the moors and voices on the wind, that kind of thing.

After attending the funeral, Beverly seeks solace in her grandmother's quaint home. But she gets a little more than she bargained for.

Lighting a candle that's been a family heirloom for generations, she settles down to read her Nana's journal, only to discover that the minx had a much younger lover called Ronin. And that's when things start to get weird.

Turns out, Ronin's an anaphasic lifeform masquerading as a ghost that lives in a candle, 'merging' with women from Beverly's family line. And now it's her turn. It's just that this joining happens to be unapologetically sensual, leaving the doctor writhing in ecstasy.

A burly, handsome stranger claiming to be a ghost? Whispering 'I love you' into the female lead's ear, and making her go weak at the knees as he promises to become part of her forever? It's straight out of the pages of a dark romantasy. And it helps that when we finally see Ronin, he looks like he could easily grace the cover of a paperback.

Add to that the atmospheric sets, rustic costumes and an over-the-top climax set in a graveyard, and this gothic fantasy has bones. Sub Rosa gets a lot of hate, but let's face it, if it had been made post-Outlander by Hallmark and set at Christmas, it would be getting views.

6. A Royal Proclamation

We always knew there was more to mild-mannered engineer Andy Billups than meets the eye.

Advertisement

And in Where Pleasant Fountains Lie, we discover his big secret...he's the Prince of Hysperia who renounced his claim to the throne so he could fix warp cores in Starfleet. Only, his mother, Queen Paolana, has other ideas. Ever noticed how often mothers get a bad rap in Star Trek?

Hysperians perfected the art of fantasy in space. Their ship boasts a royal entourage of colourful courtiers, glistening chambers full of elaborate décor, epic portraits of the prince himself, a bard capable of playing the ultimate power chord and a stable with a horse in it.

It even looks like a glimmering jewel in space, powered by dragonbreath engines and dragonsblood flame. And that would be because their homeworld has actual dragons on it. It doesn't come more fantasy than that.

Still, Andy gave it all up for his life in Starfleet. But that doesn't stop his mother from continuously trying to trick him into losing his virginity, which would force him to return home and take the throne. Not to worry, though. Rutherford has his back and saves him in the nick of time.

Oh, heavy is the head that wears the crown. Or, in this case, doesn't...

5. The Clash Of The Titans

Admittedly, there can be a very fine line between fantasy and sci-fi. Just because a story takes place in the stars, it doesn't mean it follows all the conventions of science fiction. Star Wars is a great example, with many people considering it a fantasy that happens to be set in space.

Advertisement

Star Trek clearly enjoyed flirting with that line. And the introduction of the Prophets nudged Deep Space Nine a little closer to it. Mostly, the writers maintained enough ambiguity for both the characters and audience to see them as either gods or just unique wormhole aliens. Not the most flattering description, granted.

But then, the reveal of the Prophets' nemesis, the Pah-wraiths, finally pushed the saga well and truly over the line. When an ancient tablet is broken in The Reckoning, a Prophet and a Pah-wraith are let loose on the station, and a classic battle of good versus evil begins...a cornerstone of traditional fantasy.

And gone was the show's usual gritty realism and political manoeuvring. No, these mythical forces clashed in an epic showdown. Possessing Kira Nerys and Jake Sisko, the entities just blasted beams of light at each other, until their hosts were left bleeding and exhausted.

And if there was any doubt about the moral allegory, the beams were helpfully colour coded red and blue. Thanks for that.

4. Sympathy For The Devil

The charm of The Animated Series is that it could drop Kirk and friends into any adventure, any time, any place. And a fantasy realm of magic and mayhem was no exception.

Advertisement

In The Magicks of Megas-Tu, the Enterprise is pulled into a matter-energy whirlwind where the crew meet the incredibly buff and cheerful Lucien. Who has horns. Not suspicious at all.

Lucien appears to be a powerful magic wielder, only his spellcraft mostly involves psychedelic colours, crazy music and disconcerting transportation. When he takes them for a tour of his enchanted kingdom, what follows can only be described as a non-stop rollercoaster of whimsy.

Ladies buying love potions, sorcerer-contractors plying their trade, Spock learning magic, Sulu conjuring a girlfriend, the crew on trial in Salem, and Kirk defending Lucifer...it's like a malfunctioning fantasy generator.

For all its eccentricities, it's still a fun caper that would have been a nightmare to pull off in the live-action series. But if you can get more than halfway through without thinking 'what the heck is going on?', you're made of sturdy stuff.

We're also not entirely sure that Star Trek would have gotten away with Kirk having a lark with Lucifer in any other format.

3. A Wish Upon A Star

The Elysian Kingdom begins with the story of a princess. Dr. M'Benga's little princess, Rukiya. With his daughter suffering from an incurable disease, he's resorted to suspending her in the transporter buffer while he researches a cure.

Advertisement

When the Enterprise comes into contact with a nebula, a consciousness within it senses her plight and turns the ship into the fairytale realm from one of her favourite books, The Kingdom of Elysian.

Every magical kingdom needs some flamboyant subjects, and in this case, the unaware crew become the enchanting characters. And oh my, does it make for an entertaining fantasy.

Our usually fearless leader, Pike, becomes the cowardly crawler Sir Amand Rauth. Thankfully, the valiant Sir Adya, better known as ace pilot Ortegas, makes up for his cowering. And we have to say, she makes that knight aesthetic look good.

But Adya's already spoken for, if their chemistry with the dark and brooding archer Z'ymira, aka Una, is anything to go by. Meanwhile, Spock is masquerading as the nefarious wizard Pollux, and Chapel has found her calling as the healer Lady Audrey. La'An delights as the precious Princess Thalia, and Uhura becomes a worryingly convincing Evil Queen.

Every good fairytale comes with a happy ending, but this one has a bittersweet note when M'Benga's daughter awakens from her endless sleep in the transporter buffer and embraces a new lease of life with the nebula.

And they all lived happily ever...actually, hold that thought...

2. The Never Ending Story

Elysian wasn't finished with the Enterprise crew. Beaming down to an unlikely-shaped world in Once La'An a Time, the away team find themselves back in the fairytale kingdom. But it soon becomes apparent that M'Benga didn't tell them about their previous impromptu LARPing session. The lengths to which he'll go to avoid paperwork is impressive.

Advertisement

This time, the script is flipped, and Pike, Spock and La'An have to convincingly play their former alter egos. La'An isn't exactly thrilled about having to act like a pampered princess, especially when she sees her outfit (and no one could blame her, it's outrageous). She's even less impressed when Pelia points out that all she has to do is cry whenever she doesn't get her own way.

Regardless, La'An is dragged into the escapade when she meets her counterpart's love interest, the dashing prince...no, wait...that should be Prince Dashing. Conveniently, he comes in the form of Kirk, her not-so-secret crush.

Chaos inevitably ensues as the story unfolds. Dashing tells La'An that 'she' has accepted him for all that he is. Which is a werewolf, by the way. Huntress Z'ymira and Sir Adya are going through a messy break-up, but thankfully, there's also a heart-pounding make-up. Just as well, or there may have been riots. Spock and Pike's storybook doppelgängers, Sir Amand and the wizard Pollux, manage to board the Enterprise and do a hilariously bad job at fitting in.

And the spectacular finale? La'An literally fighting herself with a sword while the Evil Queen turns into a dragon to do battle with the Enterprise.

Then finally, they all lived happily ever after...until that look on future Kirk's face when La'An is mentioned...

1. Stupid Qpid

Qpid is the notorious Q adventure that throws the intrepid Next Generation crew into the world of Robin Hood. And this is by no means an earnest, historically accurate retelling of the myth. It's a full-blown swashbuckling fantasy adventure, complete with camp characters, spirited swordplay and audacious costumes.

Advertisement

Picard's one-time girlfriend, Vash, is back, and Q decides to teach him a lesson about love. And naturally, the best way to do that is to cast Picard as Robin Hood, Vash as Maid Marian, and the rest of the motley crew as the Merry Men. And women.

Qpid might be a little much when taken as a whole, but it's filled to the brim with unmissable moments.

The so-called damsel in distress running rings around the unscrupulous Sheriff of Nottingham (played by Q himself). The crew decrying the ridiculous roleplay while conspicuously remaining in full costume, props and all. Troi trying to wrangle her bow and arrow only to shoot Friar Tuck, aka Data, in the chest. And the absolute gem of Worf smashing Geordi's mandolin like a parent sick of their kid's noisy toy five minutes into a cross-country drive.

Of course, no Robin Hood story would be complete without a chaotic castle rescue at the end. Even if it is a little eye-roll inducing, given the men get to test their mettle in battle while the women are relegated to smashing pots over heads...because girls clearly aren't allowed real weapons. Although, Dr. Crusher looks suspiciously excited when it's her turn.

The key to Qpid is to just go with it. Don't overthink it, treat it like a holiday special, and just sit back and have a blast. In that context, it may well be one of the most fun renditions of the Robin Hood legend, beaten only by the dashing Disney fox.

More importantly, it gave us one of Worf's best lines:

Sir, I protest! I am not a Merry Man!
Advertisement