10 Super Disappointing Netflix Original Series

Netflix has increased original programming, seemingly embracing quantity over quality.

By Audrey Fox /

For a long time now, Netflix has been regarded as the heir to the crown of network television. Younger, fresher, and more willing to take chances, it represented everything good about the changes facing television.

Advertisement

Over the past few years, the streaming service has shifted its focus from acquiring television properties to creating their own original series, and for the most part it has been met with success. Hit after massive hit made Netflix seem like the creatively innovative leader of the pack.

And then they got cocky.

On a certain level, it's easy to produce two or even five high quality television shows. It gets harder when you're trying to make dozens, and you've got a hand in everything from comedy to drama to documentary.

Sure, there were and are still some absolute top quality shows being produced by Netflix, but there are a few losers here and then as well. But increasingly it would seem that they're not infallible, nor are they immune to the occasional bouts of poor decision-making, lazy rebooting, and overly heightened expectations that plague every other network.

10. Marseille

Marseille sort of feels like Netflix took elements of other original shows that had worked well in the past, but put all together it doesn't really work.

Advertisement

House of Cards has been a big hit for Netflix, so it stands to reason that a political drama would be a good move for the streaming service. And they've had some success with bringing foreign language shows to English-speaking audiences. What could go wrong with combining these two elements into one program? Should be equally successful, right? Well, not really.

To be totally fair, Marseille isn't terrible. It's the gritty story of politics in the crime-ridden, seedy underbelly of Marseille, and it has Gerard Depardieu in it, which is something.

But the production is just ever so slightly underwhelming, and for Netflix, which relies on people being enthralled enough to binge watch the entire series, tepid enjoyment isn't exactly the recipe for long-standing success.

9. Haters Back Off

There's this pervasive idea that the people who make YouTube videos are endlessly fascinating characters who deserve to have television shows made about them. This idea is wrong.

Advertisement

Haters Back Off is a comedy about a real life YouTube personality who parodies the concept of the talentless wannabe celebrity in her show Miranda Sings. This feels like a clever idea, if one that could easily be considered punching down in its choice of targets to ridicule.

But the problem is that the whole thing rides on the charm and likability of a YouTube performer (in this case, star Colleen Balinger). The show 100% doesn't work if you find her annoying, which it's almost impossible not to do.

And it seems like Haters Back Off falls into the same trap that often plagues Saturday Night Live stars when attempting to take a popular sketch and turn it into a feature length film -- what works in two minutes can't sustain a longer format and quickly grows tiresome.

8. The Ranch

The Ranch is a Netflix sitcom that is filmed live in front of a studio audience in Burbank, California. That sentence alone is enough to explain why it makes this list.

Advertisement

If we wanted to watch formulaic sitcoms, we would all still be paying for a cable subscription. Yes, it's cool that we get a little mini-reunion of That 70s Show with Ashton Kutcher and Danny Masterson, but is that enough to sustain this show?

Well, it's gotten two seasons so far, so maybe. But it's still sad to see Netflix go down this path, when they've always been known for their boldness, funding the kind of shows that wouldn't get a chance on network television.

This is a reversion to the same old tedious nonsense that we've been watching for the past twenty years, one that appeals to the lowest common denominator of television viewer and is creatively bankrupt. Simply put, it takes no risks and wins no hearts.

7. Fuller House

"Whatever happened to predictability?" Nothing. Nothing happened to predictability. It's still right there where you left it.

Advertisement

There is a world in which Fuller House could have been decent. It would have involved recognizing the changing sensibilities of television audiences and taking risks, but it could have been done.

Instead, Fuller House went into this whole reboot thing knowing that all it needed to do to get viewers was exist, and was happy to coast along the bottom, taking no chances and spitting out a carbon copy of the original show.

The end result is a television program that is both soulless and unimaginative, taking every old catchphrase and cute memory of the show and frog-marching them into the new one.

A typical episode involves a grown adult repeating a once beloved catchphrase that they said ad naseum as a child, waiting for applause and laughter, then carrying on with the scene.

It's charmless, and Mary Kate and Ashley Olsen were wise to steer clear of it. And not to be rude to its cast members, but the show is proof that just because someone had a modicum of screen presence as a child and teenager does not mean that they can act as adults.

6. Marco Polo

If you're going to be this transparent about wanting to capitalize on the success of Game of Thrones, it would probably help if you were actually good.

Advertisement

Marco Polo is the story of the famous explorer who traveled throughout Asia and told a lot of tall tales about his various exploits. This version is incredibly stylized, hip, and tries to be sexy, as though daring you to think that it's the sort of thing that would be on HBO.

But the biggest issue with the show is exactly that: it's trying too hard. Nothing cool about that. It spends so much time trying to emulate the type of show that it perceives itself as, but it never fully convinces itself or anyone else.

The poor thing stumbled along for two seasons before Netflix had to admit defeat and issue a cancellation notice. This sort of show does not come cheaply, and Netflix couldn't afford to spend any more capital on what was their first real taste of failure.

5. Chasing Cameron

Much like Haters Back Off, Chasing Cameron revolves around a YouTube personality (why is Netflix obsessed with these people and can they please stop?). But in this case, it's a reality show about the rise to fame (debatable) of one Cameron Dallas, who became an overnight sensation through his success with the dearly departed Vine social media outlet.

Advertisement

The main problem here is...what is this show's audience? How does one craft a show about a so-called celebrity who has little name recognition and expect people to actually care about it?

And not to paint with too broad a brush, but whenever a network or streaming platform takes a step away from doing what they do best (bold, creative original programming, in this case) in favor of the lure of cheap, easy reality television, it never bodes well. Be better than that, Netflix. Don't make the same mistakes as MTV and VH1.

4. Richie Rich

Richie Rich is yet another attempt to capitalize on nostalgia, taking its cues from not only the original comic strip, but the film adaptation that came out in the early 90s.

Advertisement

It stars Jake Brennan, who is terrible. You think you can just walk into Macaulay Culkin's shoes like that, bro? You haven't earned what he's earned. There are a lot of issues with this show. It's made for kids, but it treats all of its pint-sized viewers like idiots. There is no subtlety, and every single one of the jokes is tired and lame beyond belief.

Also, a huge part of the original film's charm was that even though Richie had everything in terms of material goods, he was still super lonely and wanted to hang out with regular kids.

This version gives him two best friends, so he's just a kid who has literally everything going for him, and what's interesting about that? Also, it's kind of gross that he has a French maid robot. Just throwing it out there. That one came out of left field and it's hard to tell exactly who amongst the show's viewers that was supposed to appeal to.

3. Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life

Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life is the revival of a beloved television series that everyone thought they wanted, but then when it actually aired they were all like, "Oh yeah never mind this isn't that good."

Advertisement

Has it aged badly? Sure, the fast talking "wit" shown by the two Gilmore girls doesn't feel like the kind of humor that's popular at the moment, more of a relic of the early 2000s. It's actually crazy how fast styles of humor can become dated.

But more than anything, it doesn't feel like the kind of show that matches the public mood, for the most part. Times have changed since this show was first on the air, and watching two privileged white women talk about themselves as they swan around their quirky yet idyllic New England hometown isn't as entertaining as it might have been fifteen years ago.

Add to that the shaky writing that succeeds only in making its main characters unlikable and you've a show that, if left to its own devices, might actually curb the tide against the constant rebooting of television programs.

2. Iron Fist

Iron Fist sort of went into this whole Netflix thing with a few strikes against it. First of all, every other one of the Defenders series was uncommonly good. The second season of Daredevil was a little hit or miss and Jessica Jones didn't vibe with everyone, but on the whole, they were some of the best programming that Netflix has come out with.

Advertisement

And being the last to be released, Iron Fist had a lot to live up to. There were a lot of questions about the role of race and representation in the show from the very beginning, and the casting of Finn Jones, who is charming but in way over his head here, didn't help matters.

The general plotline of rich boy who ends up stranded somewhere in Asia/Oceania and learns crazy impressive fighting skills, only to return to his home city and vow to make it a better place, has been done before. And better. By a show that's also available to stream on Netflix. Maybe Iron Fist will function better as one fourth of the Defenders, but as it stands now, it probably doesn't need a second solo series.

1. 13 Reasons Why

There are so many layers of why 13 Reasons Why is a terrible show. For one, it does the societal disservice of glamorizing suicide and promoting it as a way for misunderstood and bullied teenagers to get back at their classmates.

Advertisement

Even if you killing yourself would, like, make people feel bad about the way they treated you, you would get exactly zero enjoyment out of it because you'd be dead. And while it isn't the job of entertainment to provide a moral compass for impressionable youth, this does feel particularly irresponsible.

But even worse, at the end of the day the series isn't well done. There's a mass of cliches, questionable acting, and a characterization problem which results in about 30 young white teenage males who look fairly similar and are more or less impossible to differentiate.

Simply put, if you're going to make a, for lack of a better word, morally problematic television show, it had better at least be good. This one isn't. Not that it matters, though -- people watched it out of interest or outrage, and it has been renewed for a second season.

Agree with this list? Want to come to the defence of any of these shows, or have your own disappointment to mention? Share your thoughts down in the comments.

Advertisement