10 Things That Would Make Doctor Who Better

There's always room for improvement.

By Sara Habein /

Much like Saturday Night Live, for as long as Doctor Who has been on the air, there are viewers who say, €œIt used to be better". Whether that is indeed the case is up to the individual fan, but even the very best of shows have room for improvement. After 50 years, Doctor Who has been an ever evolving piece of pop culture and storytelling and in the modern era, viewers are able to frequently re-watch and dissect the series, thereby making any perceived flaws more noticeable. However, improving a show isn't merely a case of making sure the script has no holes and continuity errors. Although that's still important. it should accurately reflect the world in which it exists. When there's a show that is supposed to encompass just about anything in the universe and sometimes parallel universes, the complexity of all those possibilities should be acknowledged. Yes, the Doctor is the star of the show but there are also a whole lot of other people along the way who need to be more than cardboard cut-outs at whom the Doctor expounds. So let's toss around some basic-yet-essential ideas about how Doctor Who can become an even better show. First up...

10. Incorporate Big Finish Stories

Since Big Finish is now considered canon, after The Night of the Doctor named the Eighth Doctor's companions, the show could make a further effort to incorporate the audio adventure details. Those stories have a wealth of characters and locales that would work well in a visual medium. The Doctor's granddaughter Susan, for example, has made a few returns with her own children, including adventures with the Eighth Doctor, and First Doctor companion Sara Kingdom has been given extended life through the same sort of timey-wimey writing that the regular show loves. Recently, the BBC and Big Finish announced that they would pair up with the release of UNIT: Extinction, starring Jemma Redgrave as Kate Stewart. It's the first time that a modern Who character has carried over officially to the audio adventures and there's no reason why they cannot do that in the reverse. Yes, the Big Finish stories are less well known but the writers could do it. Have Bernice Summerfield or Charlie Pollard turn up, all out of order a la River Song. Have older Sara Kingdom briefly join the Doctor, beginning where her last audio story, The Guardian of the Solar System, left off. There are so many possibilities and surely there is a licensing agreement that can accommodate them?

9. Symbiotic Doctor/Companion Relationships

With Clara, the show has had an unusual turn in the Doctor-companion relationship in that she's been written as almost the entire reason for the Doctor's existence. In Listen, for example, she's the one who tells him as a child that fear is a superpower, while in The Name of The Doctor she saves his history from being rewritten by the Great Intelligence. She's even partially responsible for his increased number of regenerations. While that makes for an interesting turn of events, it also negates some of the Doctor's strengths. The Doctor just flails around being "an idiot", as he says, as Clara stumbles in and fixes everything. While companions should certainly be capable people, it's when they and the Doctor do not have a balanced relationship that the storylines lose their potential emotional heft. The Doctor and Donna had one of the most symbiotic relationships compared to his other companions. When the Doctor is alone, the Doctor gets himself into more trouble. Without someone to reign in his more merciless side, he can sometimes overreact, like he did with the Racnoss in The Runaway Bride before Donna told him to move on. She was also not one to immediately swoon over his charm. What she liked about him was that he made her feel important, something she desperately wanted in life, and when that importance was combined with the spirit of adventure, it was essential to her that she carry on travelling with him. She's one of the few companions who didn't choose to leave.

8. Give the Doctor a companion who isn't straight.

In the Russell T Davies years of the show, there were more one-off characters who mentioned same-sex partners - like Sky Sylvestry in Midnight - and there is, of course, the magnificent Captain Jack Harkness who is a flirt with everyone. In the Steven Moffat years, however, same-sex couples are used as a punchline. Just look at Madame Vastra and Jenny, for example. In a way, they are less like companions and more like co-conspirators, in the way the UNIT and the occasional run-in with Torchwood are. They're already doing their own thing but they are available whenever the Doctor needs help. Yes, Madame Vastra and Jenny are a couple, and yes, they had the touching moment in Deep Breath where Jenny talks about her love for Vastra but generally their relationship isn't written as seriously as other couples on the show. While it's fantastic that an inter-species relationship exists, jokes like €œI'm a lizard from the dawn of time, and this is my wife" should be less frequent than they are. If the Doctor had a full-time companion who was either gay or bisexual, it wouldn't function as some check on an imaginary Diversity List, it would better depict the population as it exists. Representation is important and how likely is it really that all these people the Doctor comes across over his 2,000 are entirely about the opposite sex?

7. Get Away From Earth More Often

Speaking of diversity, Doctor, everyone knows that you love the Earth and all, but surely the rest of the universe needs exploring too? How convenient that a forest pops up in modern day London during Clara and Danny's field trip. Same for the aliens turning up at Coal Hill School over the years. While it's good to occasionally incorporate the time and location from which the current companion hails, now that the Doctor actually knows how to work his TARDIS (unlike some of his earlier regenerations), these returns happen perhaps a touch too often than they should. Yes, yes, there are practical concerns like the show budget and set design, but some Doctors get away from Earth more often than others. They have all of time and space to explore and as such the viewers should be able to see the wonders that exist away from the planet they know. And now with the Doctor knowing that Gallifrey still exists out there, somewhere, wouldn't it make sense for him to explore further afield?

6. Stop Putting Clara Down

Establishing that he is not her boyfriend is fine. After the loss of Rose and River, it definitely makes sense that the Doctor is back to his less romantic self - even if he can't resist snogging Missy/The Master after so many years of dancing around it. Lines directed towards Clara like, €œHave you had a wash?€, however, are entirely unnecessary. The Doctor's personality can be newly abrasive, compared to his Tenth and Eleventh selves, without commenting on her body. If you had a friend, even a best friend, who called you short, €œkind of roundish,€ and made fun of the clothes and make up you wore, how good of a friend would you think that person was? How indulgent would you be? If the Doctor and Clara really are as close and intertwined as the show has written them to be, there's no need for him to act this way. It's the writers thinking they are making a clever "joke" but instead it comes across as not taking Clara seriously as a person. And speaking of the women...

5. Women Should Be Well-Rounded Characters

Yes, the Doctor likes to show off and be the man in charge, and that's fine. However, his companions should be more capable in that they have skill sets that can solve their predicaments along with the Doctor, rather than just looking at him to have a plan. As the 2005-era of the show has progressed, it seems that the female characters have become less complex. When viewers met Rose, they also learned of her job, her family, her friends... Martha, meanwhile, was training to be a doctor and she had a somewhat turbulent relationship with her family. Donna's life played a similarly significant role and each of the women had their own problem-solving skills that assisted the Doctor in ways he could not have (or would have more slowly) accomplished. Then there was Amy Pond with her absent family, ever changing jobs that are barely even mentioned and her whole life centring around what Rory and the Doctor wanted. While her loyalty and love were admirable, she seemed to lack something compared to previous companions. If her lack of family compounded her need to create one with Rory and the Doctor, that loneliness should have been better explored, not to mention the devastation of never being able to raise her own baby. Clara, while given a job and an occasionally appearing family, was only a slight improvement. Just when fans saw her move beyond lying about her life with the Doctor, and just when she wanted to dedicate herself to properly balancing her life with Danny, the show decided to kill him off. She's written as a Doctor-saviour with quirks, always looking at the Doctor for a plan, and that isn't always enough.

4. Cast More People Of Colour

Series 8 had more people of colour compared to the Matt Smith episodes, but there is always room for improvement. Again, with all of time and space, different cultures should be consistently represented. Having Danny Pink as a recurring character was a start but when looking over the history of the show, the Ninth and Tenth Doctor episodes did a better job at diverse characters. That's not to say the casting was some ideal, but the show would improve if it more accurately depicted the Earth. London alone, as the show is fond of visiting, is one of the most culturally diverse cities in the world. In the new Doctor Who comics, published by Titan, the Tenth Doctor's companion is a Latina woman named Gabriela and the Eleventh Doctor travels with a black woman named Alice. These characters are not presented in a €œLook how inclusive and different we're being!€ sort of way, either. The comics are not asking for a diversity cookie or gold star - Gabriela and Alice are complex, well-written characters who exist just as they are, and there is no reason why the show can't do the same.

3. Take Advantage Of Excellent Guest Writers

Doctor Who has a long running and rich history so it's not as though guest writers can do whatever they like, but some new blood is occasionally necessary. It keeps the show fresh and less bogged down in grand mysteries that have yet to be solved, and also allows for a bit of fun along the way. Of course, writing a Doctor Who episode that fits in with the overall arc of the show takes time and lots of consultation. Not every writer would enjoy the gig, but as Neil Gaiman's episodes have demonstrated, it's entirely possible to bring new people into the fold when they are available. In addition to Gaiman, perhaps writers like Warren Ellis, Kelly Link or Maureen Johnson would come up with some fascinating adventures? Some of the Big Finish writers could be incorporated, too, and while they are not necessarily €œknown€ names, they are already well-versed in the show's €œrules". Collaborations between the show's usual writers and writers from the show's other properties might generate new ideas that make the show even more exciting.

2. Let Peter Capaldi Be His Dramatic Self

In the opening monologue to Listen, Peter Capaldi really commits to the Doctor's manner of talking to himself. Capaldi is a very expressive, dramatic actor who is willing to try all sorts of things to make a scene the best that it can be. This monologue is a prime example of that, as are his frustrated slams against the TARDIS console in Death in Heaven. As such, he should be given more opportunities to stretch his performance-wings, so to speak. Peter Capaldi is also quite capable of being funny, without resorting to the aforementioned cheap shots towards Clara. He can be baffled by human habits and he can be goofy like his predecessors, but his seriousness has thus far been underrated. Seriousness can equal grumpy, but it does not always have to be so. Finally, the best thing the show could do for itself is...

1. Stop Writing Itself Into A Corner

Deus ex machina literally translates as €œgod from the machine" but it has evolved into also representing a plot device that takes a seemingly unsolvable problem and suddenly and abruptly resolves it through the intervention of some newly introduced character, ability or object. That's got Doctor Who written all over it, hasn't it? In Doctor Who, long-running story arcs should not be solved by a deus ex machina, though that has not stopped Moffat and company from doing exactly that when they've written themselves into a corner. During the World Tour for Series 8, Moffat said that he thinks of the Doctor as €œthrowing himself out a window€ and figuring out how he'll land on the way down. Unfortunately, the writing in episodes like The Big Bang use this device to conveniently wrap up a €œmystery€ that has occurred over that particular series. Hey, the TARDIS has exploded and no one remembers anything, but suddenly there's a wisp of River Song and suddenly Amy remembers everything. Crises averted. It can be tremendously unsatisfying, and not to mention intentionally vague about answering any questions asked in earlier episodes. Because of time constraints, sometimes episodes wrap up a little too neatly in this manner. In Closing Time, for example, all of the sudden a Cybermen invasion is averted because of the power of love? That's it. Seriously?! Moffat has mentioned the return of two part stories in Series 9 and, if done correctly, this might give some concepts more room to breathe. Perhaps it's unrealistic to wish for a showrunner's entire writing style to change but Doctor Who is about hope. Fans can hope that their favourite show will become even more outstanding, despite the hurdles it may encounter along the way. What did you think of this list? Do you agree that these changes would make Doctor Who better, and are there any other things that should have been included? Join the conversation in the comments section below.