10 Things We Learned From Twin Peaks: The Return Part 12
An hour more strange than wonderful.
If Twin Peaks: The Return is in part a gruelling exercise in expectations, social media reflected this theme in something of a misguided manner.
Cast member David Dastmalchian (the little-seen Pit Boss Warrick) tweeted a picture of himself in the Red Room, captioned "Take a [fire] walk on the wild side...things will never...be...the same." This promise of an earth-shaker akin to the surrealist smorgasbord of Part 8, a hallucinogenic bridge between Las Vegas and the Black Lodge, was retweeted by series co-creator and co-writer Mark Frost, adding fuel to this "different sort of fire."
The description of Part 12 itself fanned those flames. "Let's Rock" were the words uttered by the Little Man From Another Place at the onset of Episode 2's iconic Red Room sequence and scrawled onto the windshield of the departed Special Agent Chet Desmond in Fire Walk With Me. The words carry a certain connotative meaning - a harbinger of supernatural phenomena. Bluntly, this tweet led viewers to expect a total mindf*ck. They weren't wrong, necessarily. Perhaps Warrick was a week or so premature. He would not be the only character disoriented by the timeline; Nadine Hurley has managed to run a store front business while remaining seated at the altar of Dr. Amp for days.
In any event, that promise was delivered on...
10. The Origin Of The Blue Rose
Albert, before formally drafting Tammie into the secret elite ranks of the FBI, discloses what we already inferred of the Blue Rose cases; they are proto X-Files before X-Files were X-Files - investigations into "troubling abstractions", so named after the dying words of a woman uttered before she met her mysterious end. In their quest for elusive answers, Albert, Phillip Jeffries, Cooper and Chet Desmond have travelled an "alternative path."
From Part 12 onwards, the sole remaining agent will be joined in the task force by Agent Preston.
Also: Chrysta Bell can act. She sells her acceptance of the offer with excitement and, given the fates of her predecessors, apprehension. The expression is so ambiguous that the audience has no idea how to receive this news, nor any idea if she is courageous enough to walk this path. In another incredible use of sound, the music cue gives us no clues, either; Badalamenti's swelling string arrangement is at once hopeful and foreboding.
Whether it's Bell's professed on-set nervousness or evidence that she is far better in the role than conventional wisdom has it is immaterial, really: Bell makes you care about Preston's fate. If she was as bad as an unforgiving pocket of the fandom has it, the scene would not resonate.
9. The Tragic Ballad Of Sarah Palmer
Sarah Palmer has been reduced by the horrors of her life to an alcohol-dependent shell. She roams a supermarket aisle for Bloody Mary mix, cigarettes and vodka. If there weren't a mere three bottles left, you wonder how many would have found themselves in her trolley.
She is disturbed by the unfamiliar presence of Turkey Jerky. "Is it smoked?" she asked. "Were you here when they first came?" she asks. The subtext is brutal. She talks strange talk of the room seeming different, and of "men coming" (smoked, charred woodsmen?). She then dissolves into an OCD self-reprimand, instructing herself to "leave this place" and find her "godd*mned car keys". The looming history hovering above her head is as terrifying as her breakdown.
Hawk then pulls up to her house to check in on her. We hear a commotion in the background; she's not alone. The dreaded ceiling fan whirs. "It's certainly a godd*mned bad story, isn't it, Hawk?" she says, veering from terrified to terrifying, channelling her performance in Inland Empire with a weird, subtextual menace.
Until now, the genre stylings of the skull-crushing woodsmen have a lacked a certain human agency. These scenes, masterfully acted by Grace Zabriskie, reconcile with gut-punching dramatic depth the extreme, harrowing influence of the supernatural on the material world.
8. The Return Requires A Cooper Anchor
You could argue that this was the weakest Part yet; unlike the previous three post-nuclear fallouts, this seemed to have no structural or thematic conceit. It was very much a return to the fragmented 18 hour movie structure.
We see only ten seconds of Kyle MacLachlan. His Dougie Jones/displaced Dale Cooper, divorced as ever from reality, is escorted into his garden to play catch with Sonny Jim, who bonks him on the head with a baseball. End scene. It's the only time we spend in Las Vegas, a vignette sandwiched between Peaks scenes and the ongoing Blue Rose investigation. The scene is a sort of subverted domestic bliss (you could generously read it as relevant, given the manner in which we check into the residents of the Pacific Northwest) but really, it seems arbitrary - a means of maintaining MacLachlan's lead credit.
Elsewhere, Part 8 is a loose, unconnected reel of scenes of varying quality and relevance.
You could make that argument. That said, even with its mundane domestic set-ups and agonising pace, an hour devoid of otherworldly dream logic still manages to furrows its way into the subconscious - largely through a bizarre and surely unprecedented writing technique deployed as the hour drew to a close...
7. The Horne Brothers Are In Different Places
Chekhov's hotel room key finally reappears in an expository (but no less powerful) sequence between Ben Horne and Frank Truman.
In it, Ben fills in the few remaining blanks of Richard's backstory and Frank does so with his crime spree. Richard grew up without a father, precipitating a downward spiral of criminality and sociopathy. Richard Beymer's acting is phenomenal here; his eyes clenched shut realisation masks resignation, sympathy, and perhaps even guilt. Much was theorised about "which" Ben we would see: the campy villain of season one, or the reformed force for good of season two. In The Return, Ben Horne has never been portrayed as richly. He is not black nor white but grey; a rounded human being. Ben returns the hotel key to Truman as a memento for the other Truman. Again, the grave nature of the conversation is such that one can only also "hope for the best" for the absent Michael Ontkean. A cameo seems the least of our worries.
Jerry, meanwhile, might literally be out of the woods; he is seen tumbling through a field, running away from the mountains. He falls flat on his face.
It is impossible to determine what this subplot means, if anything, at this point. If it is just a slice of physical stoner comedy, it's brilliant - even if, like much of Part 12, it is swollen with trolling overtones.
6. Coordinates Destination
Diane retreats to the hotel bar, lighting up a cigarette. It's closed, but the bartender hands her a drink regardless. She recites the coordinates lifted from Ruth Davenport's from memory and inputs them into her phone, revealing the location:
Twin Peaks, WA.
Like all of the Diane scenes, its success hinges entirely on the outcome. If Albert determined them before she did - and wasn't in the midst of a trademark sardonic revelation - wouldn't he have reacted more to the fact that they lead to Twin Peaks? If she is colluding with Mr. C, a theory furthered in this Part, doesn't that rid one of the best scenes in the series of its power, instead substituting it for manipulation, and thus risking an empty re-watch? The other theory circulating is that Diane is in cahoots with Jeffries. Until we know for whose benefit Diane is attempting to corrupt the FBI, there is no real way of determining if it makes any sort of dramatic sense. Was the South Dakota prison meeting a display designed to fool the FBI, or ha Mr. C engaged in some form of mind control?
What we know is that the FBI are about to enter the town of Twin Peaks. Possibly by way of Las Vegas, Nevada. As effective as the weekly schedule is - these hours become better, richer, when they percolate in the mind - the wait is maddening. Even a lesser hour, such as this, is a success in that respect.
5. "Every Day, Once A Day, Give Yourself A Present..."
So said Special Agent Dale Cooper during the original series. The Return - the prospect of which Lynch was considered "dead as a doornail" - feels like a gift wrapped by a man who previously never expressed a prior interest in returning to his own oeuvre. The man besotted with the continuing story has until now never really told one.
That man has also given himself a present in the way of Berenice Marlohe - a classically beautiful French actress with whom Cole shares a bottle of Bordeaux and over whom he slobbers. "Would you please ask your friend to wait downstairs?" Albert requests. The act of leaving Cole's hotel room becomes a protracted exercise in subverted seduction. 'French Woman', beaming, puts on her cardigan. Cole's face lights up. Albert, audience surrogate, looks on with a detached sneer. French Woman performs a sort of couch-bound can-can to show off her pumps. "Tres chic!" remarks Cole (not for the first time in this paragraph, your writer had to delete and replace the letters L-Y-N-C-H). She then applies her lip stick, as Cole juts out his own, part emulation, part wish fulfilment.
It's a strange scene - a sexualised shaggy dog story ending in a delightful vegetable-based joke - one that shouldn't work. It's a near-octogenarian indulging his renowned love of beautiful women, but Colynch elevates it from sleazy to warm with his hilarious reaction shots.
4. A Lesson Of Pacing
Part 12 moves at a glacial pace, even by the standards of The Return. The pace is so unnatural that the capper to Lynch's love letter to the female form - he tells Albert that he worries about him, apropos of not much - can be read either as punchline or portent. His knack for the uncanny remains as intact as his sex drive.
By far the quickest scene is also the most gruesome; we cut suddenly to Tim Roth's Hutch, applying a silencer to his gun in an act of near-masturbation. In the front of their van, Chantal elects not to torture their imminent victim. There's a Wendy's down the road. She's hungry. Human life is nothing to her. The act of ending it is a mere inconvenience. Hutch shoots Warden Murphy first in the back, and then in the back of the head. In a brutal sequence, his young son opens the door of his house to find his daddy's brain pooling out of him. Lynch's camera doesn't linger on the image, like it does with French Woman's legs. He cuts immediately to Hutch, who says "Next stop: Wendy's" dispassionately. What is Lynch trying to tell us?
In the original series, in the unrecoverable Twin Peaks, every life had meaning. Now that the evil is seeping from earth, that is no longer the case.
3. The Fate Of Audrey Horne
Part 12 sees the return of Audrey Horne, finally, to Twin Peaks.
This isn't the impetuous, curious 18 year-old sex siren; Audrey is a scornful and scorned figure, trapped in a loveless arranged marriage to the diminutive Charlie. They exchange looks of palpable hatred. Audrey wants to find her lover Billy, presumably the same Billy mentioned at the coda of Part 7. "What kind of sh*t are you?" Audrey asks, as Charlie expresses a desire to postpone the search. He's an oddly childlike "sh*t," despite voicing concerns over completing his "allotted duties in life." The actor portraying him, Clark Middleton, is short in stature and speaks with an innocent verbiage. He isn't "tired", he's "sleepy." Much like her presumed son Richard, her presumed unknown rapist Mr. C, and her perpetually horny father Ben, the tragic Audrey has lived a life failed by men with a distorted grasp of masculinity. The thematic echoes reverberating around the men in her life are almost shattering in their emotional weight.
Much like the object of her desires, Audrey is living a double life in plain sight. Again, it's shattering; in her own way, she has paralleled Mr. C's arc from inquisitive force of good to doomed doppelgänger of a distant past.
At its core, Twin Peaks is a story of the corruption of innocence. Audrey's story is another sad one.
2. "God D*mn, You People Are Confusing."
During Audrey's depressing reintroduction, she makes reference to a "Paul", a peripheral figure she threatens her husband with. This, and another threat to break their contract, compels Charlie to join her search for Billy. "I'm so sleepy, but I'll go," he says. Theirs is a strange Oedipal arrangement.
Charlie himself makes a call to an as-yet-unseen "Tina", "supposedly" the last person to see Billy. "Chuck" told Audrey that Tina was the last person to see Billy. Talk of a truck connects Audrey and Billy to the hit and run incident of Part 6, but that is as far as the viewer is permitted to make sense of this random stream of names. Only one side of the phone call, Charlie's, is heard. Audrey hurries him along with frantic gestures; Charlie, at the close of the call, refuses to divulge to Audrey its contents.
We then cut to the Roadhouse and meet two new characters - Natalie (Ana De La Reguera) and Abbie (Elizabeth Anweis) occupying the same booth as Part 9's (one-and-done?) Chloe and Ella. A reference is made to an Angela. And a Clark. And a Mary. Another new character, Scott Coffey's Trick, makes hilarious reference to some "as*-eater" who nearly runs him off the road. Like the best Lynch material, the effect is unsettling in the most mundane manner imaginable. All we're learning is a list of faceless names. Who are these people? Will we even see or hear from the again? Why are we learning about so many of them in quick succession? Why is a rapid-fire burst of pure exposition so discomforting?
Is it the unseen presence of a secret Twin Peaks, one even more elusive than the one we are slowly familiarising ourselves with? A major theme of The Return has been alienation. This was explored to jarring effect here. By the time the credits rolled, much of the audience must have felt as stupefied as Dougie Jones.
Given the overall theme of the series, it is exceptional writing...I think.
1. A Strange Note On Recycling
It's impossible to determine, without the full context, the point (or lack thereof) in recycling the Dr. Amp sequence of Part 5.
So much - virtually all - has been seen before. The same scene-setting insert of Jacoby's trailer, shrouded in darkness. The same gong of the golden shovel. The same music. The exact same dialogue. The same outfit. The same glowing reaction shot of Nadine Hurley. The same sh*t-shovelling advert. The same (purposefully) cheap graphic. The only new dialogue is ostensibly the same - Dr. Amp rants about "f*cking politicians". Nadine says "It's working for me," and it's ironic; this, along with Lucy's slapstick stylings in Part 4, is one of few scenes that certainly don't work. Theories abound about warped timelines, and the on-the-nose deja vu could be read as a take on the wider themes of memory permeating the series - but it's impossible to escape the feeling that the recycling is just that: filler.
There's no suggestion that the lack of quality control, designed to safeguard the secrets of the series, has given rise to a mistaken beat-for-beat retread - a gaffe.
But still, what this serves is enough to trigger suspicion, at least.