10 Things We Learned From Twin Peaks: The Return Part 8
Twin Peaks: Origins.
Just one dependable (but not entirely reassuring) pattern has emerged in Twin Peaks: The Return; the episode description for each Part is lifted from dialogue spoken within it.
The description for Parts 1 and 2 - "My log has a message for you," "The stars turn and a time presents itself" - were both uttered by the Log Lady. Part 3 - "Call for help" - was spoken by Dale Cooper, but not in the context you might have guessed two months ago. This was the catatonic parrot version of our spiritually adrift Special Agent. Part 4 - "Brings back some memories" - restored a sense of familiarity.
Part 5 - Case files - referred to insurance documents, not archived police reports. Part 6 - "Don't die" - was distressingly ironic, given the fate of the young child who met his end. Part 7 - "There's a body all right" - was simple enough to decode. It was spoken by Detective Dave Macklay in reference to the beheaded corpse of Garland Briggs.
The expositional Part 7, generally, restored us to the familiar. We spent more time in Twin Peaks. Several narrative threads propelled us forwards. For the first time, it felt as if we had a firm grasp on where we were headed. Part 8 unravelled that in what might be The Return's equivalent to that first hallucinatory Red Room sequence.
The words in the description - "Gotta light?" - very much were not spoken by a returning Audrey Horne...
10. In An Utter Surrealist Mindf*ck...
...there was room for a traditional soap opera twist.
Part 8 begins with the doppelgänger split half of Dale Cooper, referred to by associate Ray as "Mr. Cooper" - like his demon-in-collaboration, BOB, it seems he delights in skirting the line of infamy - in the passenger seat of the prison breakout car. This staging might be important, suggesting that Cooper is but a vessel for BOB, not acting "with" him as Part 5's CGI face-bleed indicated.
Ray seemed doomed, his goofy smile during the prison breakout sequence acting as a portent of his unwitting end. Here, in a gut-punching sequence, it is revealed that he has somehow removed the bullets from Mr. Cooper's gun, thereby tricking him into apparent death. He shoots him in the stomach, a la the season one cliffhanger - again, echoing the original Dale Cooper.
The two split halves have been linked via appearance (obviously), dialogue, and now action, creating the unsettling (and dramatically satisfying) notion that the doppelgänger is not some black and white sci-fi construct, but an ugly manifestation of Dale's dark side.
9. Is Jeffries Now With BOB?
After Ray shoots Dale Cooper in the gut, a series of figures slowly materialise - multiple versions of the blackened entities haunting the prisons and morgues of South Dakota.
"That f*cker Ray" acts as audience surrogate, sinking to the floor with an expression of terror plastered across his face. The spectres fade in and out of the picture, performing a shamanistic ritual. They spring up and down on their haunches, circling him, smearing his blood across his stomach, and, in an echo of the two-hour premiere, using it as lotion to massage his face.
It's a grisly, almost upsetting sequence. This bastardised version of Cooper is a being of unspeakable awfulness for reasons both evident and implied. Still, whether it is the faint recollection of the split half - or, simply and more likely, the absolute brilliance that is Kyle MacLachlan's portrayal of the character - this is not the end we want for him. He deserves to be destroyed or subsumed by the man he has supplanted in the material world.
The leering visage of BOB, peering from within an amniotic sac, is then removed from Mr. Cooper's bowels. It isn't the end of Mr. Cooper - he rises from the dead - but BOB is no longer "with" him, which might - might - indicate that these woodsmen are acting as agents for Philip Jeffries, with whom Mr. C is seemingly at war for.
8. We Have Witnessed The Creation Of A World
We encounter a vast desert scape after Mr Cooper reawakens. A graphic - JULY 16, 1945 WHITE SANDS, NEW MEXICO 5:29 AM (MWT) - appears on the screen.
We hear a countdown from ten and then: a nuclear test explosion, soundtracked, notably, by Penderecki's Threnody for the Victims of Hiroshima. The mushroom cloud swells in parallel with the strings. Lynch takes us inside of it. We see grainy film. White dots elongating into daggers dance in a black void, like weaponised stars. Black, sperm-like organisms shake in the inverse to that image. More doubling. Actual intercourse between worlds. Those stars/daggers then flicker furiously, as if powered and illuminated by electricity. We then enter a cosmological wormhole, firing through nebula of blue, orange, purple.
And then: the convenience store alluded to in the original series (and shown, internally, in The Missing Pieces) appears. Those blackened entities dart around and within haphazardly, not adhering to known laws of physics. Through the darkened windows we see tin cans piled on top of one another.
This sequence, as politicised as it is spiritual as it is completely without precedent in television, all but confirms that the evil inherent to nuclear weaponry has created both copious amounts of garmonbozia - and a gateway allowing that evil immediate access to the pain and suffering of humankind.
7. (Maybe)
Any suggestion that this nuclear test was the origin of the second world we are now very much "between" is contradicted by co-creator Mark Frost's epistolary tie-in novel 'The Secret History Of Twin Peaks'.
In it, the explorer Meriwether Lewis stumbles upon and is temporarily frazzled by a space that is alluded to being (but not formally designated as) the Red Room/Black Lodge, with references to Venus statues and blinding lights. His visitation of the spirit world took place in the 19th century, predating the nuclear test blast by well over a century. This (might) indicate that the Red Room exists independently of the Convenience Store - that the unprecedented artificial power magnified this other presence, rather than created it outright.
Perhaps crucially, David Lynch reserved one of the few tidbits that weren't pure evasion during The Return's press rounds to dismiss the importance of the novel. He did not even read it.
It's "his" [Frost's] history, not theirs.
6. Experiment = Mother
Within that batsh*t sequence, we see the androgynous figure that eviscerated Sam and Tracy in the two-hour premiere floating in a blank void, arms outstretched (reminiscent of the manner in which Cooper was suspended in the glass box in New York City, having been plunged into "nonexistence" by the Evolution Of The Arm's doppelgänger).
We see this figure - credited, for now, as 'Experiment' eject...something. We are dealing with something literally alien, indefinable by physical concepts. To the human eye, it echoes the mushroom cloud itself, an instantly-fossilised, translucent, frozen stream of grey matter within which there are multiple small eggs (hosting the blackened, hobo-like spectres?) and a sac - unquestionably - bearing the visage of BOB.
In the original series, Philip Gerard/MIKE suggested that (by 1989) BOB had been with us for "over forty years". This sequence is self-evident - BOB's face emerges from an amniotic sac - and the math all but confirms that this is the birth of BOB, the evil that men do.
Therefore Experiment = "Mother": the unseen, door-pounding entity from which Cooper narrowly escapes in the mauve world of Part 3.
5. Have We Seen The White Lodge?
After the Mother gives birth to BOB, Lynch leads us through another cosmological wormhole, in which he uses a red and black colour palette reminiscent of the Red Room.
This image bleeds into an expanse of ocean. On the horizon, rising from the depths, is a tall rock formation at the top of which lies what might be the second implied visual representation of the fabled White Lodge. In the original series, we saw Major Garland Briggs sat on a throne in what was the first. This - if either or both were/are meant to represent it - has been retconned. This Lodge is a far less obvious presence of otherworldly benevolence.
It literally exists on an island, far removed from its own evil doppelgänger(s). It is bathed in white light, into which there are three minuscule entrances - an indictment, maybe, of the evil manifest in the human realm and a symbol of the elusiveness of all things good. In it live The Giant - or ???????, as Carel Struycken is now credited - and "Seniorita Dido", played by Joy Nash.
This almost vintage Hollywood aesthetic (with which we know Lynch in enamoured) is removed from Windom Earle's description of it. There are no gamboling fawns - but Lynch loathed the Earle character and is not beholden to it.
Aesthetically dissonant from the original notion of the White Lodge, the behaviour of its two spirits nonetheless suggest a benevolence befitting of it.
4. Laura Is The One
In the apparent White Lodge sequence, ??????? surveys, with a weary expression, the creation of the Convenience Store and the birth of BOB on a screen in the same theatre Lynch used for Club Silencio in Mulholland Drive. This fuels more fire that the memory of that never-was TV show lay as dormant in the recesses of his mind as the town of Twin Peaks did.
This suggests that ??????? is an omniscient, God-like being, lending the next sequence a certain parabolic significance. ??????? ascends to the rafters of the theatre before it is suspended horizontally. Glittering lights materialise from its head and form a constellation. A golden orb descends from it and lowers into the palms of Seniorita Dido.
Laura Palmer's homecoming queen photograph shines through the sphere, which is marvelled at and then sent to Earth through a pipe. The way in which this is both framed and received by Dido suggests that Laura is not a biological product of Leland and Sarah but a saviour moonchild spirited into existence (and secluded, like the subject of TSHOTP minor character Aleister Crowley's novel, in a remote North American township) in order to combat the evils generated by Mother.
And people, in a far simpler time, speculated that Lynch would cast Sheryl Lee as a third, redheaded cousin of Laura's...
3. Who Wants A Light?
After we exit what is presumed to be the White Lodge (the only drawback to this impossibly brilliant hour of television is the need for constant, ungainly qualifiers), we return to the sand dunes of New Mexico.
There, we accelerate through eleven years, taking us to 1956. A corn kernel shaped egg gives birth to an insect/amphibian hybrid. The blackened spectres float downwards from the skies, arms outstretched. It is happening again. One figure emerges in front of a car, its herky-jerky movements soundtracked by electrical buzzing. In a totally Lynchian touch in a totally Lynchian feast of sight and sound, this otherworldly figure is in possession of a cigarette but not a lighter.
"Gotta light? Gotta light? Gotta light?" it asks, impersonating a human being with the off-kilter recording of Mr. Cooper in the FBI interrogation scenes. The wife in this middle aged couple is terrified, her anguished cries sounding like BOB's passion throes in his murder of Madeline Ferguson. This figure then walks into a radio station and kills the secretary working there by pressing its fingers into her skull. He repeats this trick with the disk jockey, whose microphone he assumes. He then seems to kill a listening mechanic and waitress with the following message:
"This is the water. And this is the well. Drink full and descend. The horse is the white of the eyes and dark within."
More frightening than the sequence in and of itself is the implication that these figures - absent both from the original series and Fire Walk With Me - have returned to "our" world in 2014.
2. In An Utter Surrealist Mindf*ck... (Reprise)
...a full Nine Inch Nails performance in the Roadhouse was the most normal thing about it.
The cast list triggered various concerns. Was Lynch's intention to stunt cast musicians in acting roles? To land his famous friends a gig? To expand upon the ethereal ambience of the Roadhouse as it existed in the original series, thus risking the idiosyncratic atmosphere of the series itself, the indelible Peaks feeling that, beyond so many of the actual, much-maligned subplots, carried the show through the wilderness years of cultural irrelevance?
The latter is the route Lynch has chosen.
On paper, very little about the performance of "The" Nine Inch Nails makes sense. They are an arena-sized act slumming it in a Pacific Northwestern vista. It should be incongruous. It isn't. Perhaps that risk is why Lynch located a doppelgänger of Little Jimmy Scott - a pinecone decorating his mic stand, a symbol of the dissonance between classic and modern Twin Peaks - to introduce them as "The" Nine Inch Nails.
"She's Gone Away" fits perfectly into this new world - doomy, menacing, discordant, punctuated by Trent Reznor's deranged cackling. Who is the subject, in this context? An earlier scene indicates that the death of Laura Palmer has far-reaching implications on the universe.
1. In A Show In Which Parentage Is A Key Theme...
...Tikaeni Faircrest's character likely plays another mother.
She is credited, obliquely and directly in that inimitably Lynchian way, as 'Girl (1956)'. Her appearance might be tangential, but the final sequence, through its placement alone, seems too significant not to have any bearing on the plot going forward.
Girl and, sure enough, 'Boy (1956)' created a sense of dread with classically Lynchian stilted delivery undermining their wholesome dialogue, in an idealised version of 1950s Americana. After timidly accepting an innocent, closed-mouth kiss, Girl retreats to her upstairs bedroom, smiling to herself before relaxing into a dream. The insect/amphibian hybrid climbs her house and enters it through the upstairs window, echoing the presence of BOB/Leland Palmer in Fire Walk With Me.
Girl, unconsciously, opens her mouth and accepts the parasite.
This sequence is timestamped 1956. Subtracting that from 1989 leaves us with 33. Even if this is a sequence of conception (which jibes with the overarching theme of Part 8), the cosmology of this new Peaks could date Laura Palmer as any given material image. Is this a young Sarah Palmer? The smoking woodsman and the horse imagery of his poetry certainly created parallels with her. 33 was also roughly the age of a preternaturally gifted FBI agent in 1989.
This might just be a tangential slice of symbolism concerning the entrance of evil into the innocent - a capper visual for the theme of the hour - but the questions burrow into the subconscious with such a similar insidiousness that you cannot help but ask.