10 Things Wrong With American Horror Story: Coven

Examining the issues that filter throughout the season and in their wake have made ten glaring problems.

By Thomas Stewart /

American Horror Story, an anthology series, created by Ryan Murphy and Brad Falchuk came to us in 2011 with its first season, Murder House. We raved about the performances - especially Jessica Lange - and we fell in love with its dark undertones, traditional horror quirks and our favourite actors and actresses running around killing one another. We loved it. We did. And because we loved it, we ignored its glaring problems: its plot holes and inconsistencies. We continued to ignore this in its second season, Asylum where Lily Rabe stole the show as the devil possessed nun. Now, with Coven, its third season, we expect more. Coven has indeed learnt from the first season's mistakes - the fact that ghosts one minute can leave the house and the next can't, the problematic patient story-line which indicated a murder and was never returned to - but Coven continues to fall short in some capacity. With Coven introducing real life characters, for example, Murphy and Falchuk have set themselves a difficult task. Although we expect it to be gory and funny and wicked, we expect the duo to approach said characters with some caution. Have they? Sort of. In addition, Murphy and Falchuk gave us the best first episode of a season so far, to keep the bar that high would be difficult, yes, but not impossible. Coven sets up some great story-lines in its first epsiodes: Fiona's (Lange) cancer, the introduction of Patti LuPone's crazy religious character, Sarah Paulson's desire to be a mother, the introduction of the Minotour and so on. The fact that these story-lines are given to us in the first couple of episodes of the season, tells us that it's important. American Horror Story is a mini series so there only needs to be a concentration on a certain number of plots. Before the credits role, for example, our last shot is of a human made Minotour by the sadistic serial killer, Delphine LaLaurie, played by Kathy Bates. Important? We think so. Is it? No. These issues filter throughout the season and in their wake have made ten glaring problems for us. Here, in no particular order, they stand:

10. Everyone's A Murderer But That's OK

American Horror Story is not afraid to have their characters commit murder. That's fine. We're happy to watch murderers in the act but with Coven every character is a murderer. Here's a little list just to keep you in check: Fiona murders Madison, Madison murders Kyle, Kyle murders his mother, Zoe murders Spalding, Myrtle murders the other council members, Misty Day awakes crocodiles to murder two men, Delphine murders, well, lots of people, Queenie murders a homeless man, Joan murders his husband and son, Marie helps murder Nan, Nan murders Joan, you get the picture. So the question that comes into play is - who are we rooting for? Morals are always on the border with American Horror Story, we know that. In Murder House, Constance (Lange) was a murderer but we still loved her. Coven, however, gives us only murderers, in fact the only character that isn't a murderer is Cordelia (Paulson) but we'll get to her later. It begins to border on the ridiculous that every character would have the capacity to murder someone so easily and without guilt. By doing this, it makes all of the characters seem on par, that there's no-one more dangerous, they're all equally as dangerous as the other. In addition, it makes all of them think the same therefore makes them all the same. Why would we prefer one killer over the other? What makes them different? Why? There personality, of course. Sure. But there doesn't seem to be many layers to them. If this was the intention, well done Murphy and Falchuk, but even if it was, it makes all of the characters blur and become more like a cult than a coven.

9. Queenie Has Sex With A Minotour And It's Never Discussed Again

Halloween is when American Horror Story goes all out. They give us a two part mash-up. This year it involved zombies, an Evil Dead homage and, most importantly, Queenie seducing a Minotaur and having sex with him. Now with this we are forgiving because we believe it to have a purpose. We're not completely sure why Queenie has decided to become aroused by this Minotaur but we get on board, it's American Horror Story, we trust them, they've learnt from their mistakes. In addition, we know that American Horrror Story always relates - in some form or another - to the Devil and any Greek mythology buffs will now that when a human lays with a Minotaur it produces the Devil's spawn. Will Queenie, therefore, give birth to the Devil's child? No. In fact not only does this event not having any repercussions - besides Queenie being bed-ridden for an episode - it never comes up again. "Oh Queenie, remember that time when you slept with the Minotaur?" "Oh, Queenie, how are you after that event with the Minotaur?" Nothing. Not even a "I miss that Minotaur" slipping past Queenie's lips. It is never discussed. It, quite frankly, never happened. Which brings us back to the point made on the introductory page in which the writers have set up yet another great possible story-line - we're forgiving that it's mid season because it's such a good idea - and, it flops. The potential and the intrigue gets us excited and then we're told to not think about it. It never happened. What never happened? The possibility of a great story, that's what.

8. Murphy Kills A Character And Always Brings Them Back To Life

We're used to ghosts, ghosts are fine, ghosts were a huge part of Murder House. We're even fine with angels that featured in Asylum. Now, with Coven, we're used to people coming back from the dead. It was an interesting idea - in the first couple of episodes we worried that Madison was dead but the sassy girl we loved to hate was back and sassier than ever. But then more people died and more people came back and not just as ghosts but as real, alive people and this is when the idea was drained and done to death. Let's have another connective explanation: Misty Day died and brought herself back to life, Kyle died and Misty Day brought him back to life, Myrtle died and Misty Day brought her back to life, Joan died - good old Misty, Madison - Misty again, you get the picture. It was fun in the beginning, it was interesting and intense, new even, but now it's become the norm. Now, we don't care if someone dies because we think - no, we know - that they'll come back again. There's no fear that we'll lose our favourite characters. Perhaps the only one to die and stay dead - so far - is Nan but her story-line was up anyway. The question of horror extends to how to horrify us as an audience. In horror, to really scare us is to make us care about the people walking around. What if this character died? Are we scared? We should be. Because we care. But when we're told that they're going to come back anyway, why should we be scared? As well as this, it stops the show from developing. We thought Queenie was dead for an episode and then she's back and her story-line now? Well, it doesn't exist. Madison died and we were glad to have her back but could her return have been the only return? What did Myrtle's resurrection, for example, actually accomplish? As a reward to this addictive audience it's a good thing to bring the characters back but to live up to its title - to be "horror" as it says - it takes away that punch.

7. Patti LuPone Is Wasted As A Character

When Patti LuPone (Nora) strolled out of the moving van and into the house next door to the witches we were all ecstatic. Not just because it was her but because she was playing a manipulative religious nut who would rage hell on these witches. We were expecting a war, we were expecting the Salem Witch Trials being brought to the 21st century, we were expecting all kinds of gruesomely delicious things. What did we get? A seemingly redundant story that Nora had killed her husband and then her son and, in a rage, Nan kills her. So what, exactly, was Nora's purpose? Why was she in the show? You have to call into question the possibility that Ryan Murphy admires so many people and when he has his anthology show - which offers new parts each season - he has the luxury of inviting them on board. But should he do this? Is this good television? Bringing in a big name to act in a minor, unsatisfactory role? The problem with Patti LuPone coming is is that she was brought in with such promise. She brings a bible into the witch's house, she has a stare that could make you shiver, she has a cold voice. She's perfect for the show and they do nothing with her. We were shocked - disappointed more so - that she murdered her son but we were forgiving, we thought maybe she would go and be the witch's enemy, maybe she would even be a witch. These are interesting opportunities to take a character we've watched from the beginning. Instead, the show - doing this more so in Coven - realises that it's close to the end of the season and they need to wrap up these character's stories. If they hadn't opened up so many possibilities - so many story-lines - then they wouldn't have to. They have, therefore, shot themselves in the foot and Patti LuPone's along the way.

6. Everyone Gets Over The Fact That Fiona Is A Murderer

When Fiona (Lange) killed Madison (Roberts) we were shocked. We weren't just shocked because we were loosing Madison as a character - although we weren't, as we now know - we were shocked because Fiona was a killer. The episode in question - The Replacements - showed a young Fiona killing her mentor a few years back in the same way. We were brought closer to this character, we realised how ruthless - almost evil - she was. Then, when the body of Madison was lying there, she demanded the butler, Spalding, get rid of it so no-one would know what she did. But they do. They find out that Fiona did, indeed, kill their fellow witch and the rule is a witch killing another witch shall be burnt at the stake. Instead of this, they stage a night of interventions to make Fiona kill herself. They almost succeed, alas Fiona fights back. And then? Nothing. They all just get over it. Madison doesn't mind sharing a house with the woman who killed her. The witches don't mind sleeping next door to a woman who may do the same to them. A daughter doesn't care her mother is a murderer. Nobody cares. So we have to bring into question - is this realistic? Of course, this a show about horror and magic but with character's emotions we need to be realistic. Would Madison feel safe around this woman? No. Would any of the other witches? No. Would those who disliked Fiona say she should pay for what she did? Yes. Do they? No. Why? We don't know. It's never explained. It's never discussed. Much like Queenie's rendezvous with the Minotour, we never understand why everyone just gets over it. There's a half-explanation in which Fiona and Cordelia reconcile and say they need to work together but we're there, screaming at the TV "But she's a murderer! She went against the witches' oath!" And yet, nothing.

5. Stevie Nicks Wonders In For No Good Reason

We love her. She's Stevie Nicks! She's the white witch. She suits this season perfectly. But why exactly did she show up? The synopsis said that Fiona brought her old friend, Stevie Nicks to the coven in order to cox Misty Day into being the supreme. Fiona does this because she wants to know if Misty Day is the supreme and if she is, kill her. But in the world of black and white, Stevie Nicks walks in, says the line "Hi, I'm Stevie Nicks", which results in Misty fainting, she then does two duos and that's it. Nothing comes of it. Sure, the last duo - her rendition of 'Has Anyone Ever Written Anything For You?' - was amazing and brought us all to tears but why was she there? This goes back to the point of bringing Patti LuPone in - it's because Murphy has a huge sense of respect for Nicks and a want to work with her. So much, that he wrote her into an episode, forgetting about the plot and forgetting about its consistency. Did having Nicks in the show move the plot along? No. Did it have any bearing on the story? No. In a mini series it's evident that everything counts, every person, every story, every line has to matter. A mini series doesn't have the luxury of having a flop episode - they have thirteen episodes, each one matters. So to have this tribute to Stevie Nicks episode seems a waste. She brought tears to our eyes, she made us rush through our old records to play on repeat but she did nothing to the show. It's sad because she could have had a crucial role in the season - admittedly she was introduced close to the end, meaning they would have another case of needing to wrap up a story-line quickly again but if they were slower and smarter and had given themselves more room, it could have worked.

4. There's Not Enough Magic

This season is about witches and what do witches do? Magic. So when we heard that each of our favourite actors and actresses would possess such powers we expected them to be used. We weren't expecting the Harry Potter kind of magic - people blasting each other with wands - we expected voodoo, spells and potions. Coven has this, it just doesn't have enough of it. There's not a lot of magic going on to satisfy. The season seems to focus more on the murder of the characters, the constant betrayals, the battle to be the most powerful. The question of power seems to fall flat on its face. These women are fighting to be the next supreme - the Queen of the Witches - and yet they don't seem to being doing very much magic. There's one random episode where Fiona mentions putting a sleeping spell on another character and it jars. We're suddenly reminded that this is the world of magic. The beginning of the season - which seems to be the common theme with this season - there was a lot of magic. We have to call into question whether they did this to hook us and if they did it worked. The magic now, however, has gone to the extent of doors swinging shut behind people, nothing glamorous or exciting at all. If we look at the previous seasons, Murder House offered us murder and ghosts as they said they would. Asylum offered us copious amounts of madness. Coven seems to have offered us a lack of magic.

3. Fiona's Cancer Peaks When It's Convenient

As mentioned before, Fiona's character is introduced with a 'secret', this being that she has cancer. Fiona, the supreme, gets weaker and ill when one of the other witches' is advancing towards becoming the next supreme. Her cancer comes into play when she decides that she will kill each of the girls in order to stop herself from dying however her cancer goes from one extreme to the next. When she's introduced she's ill, she fears her hair may fall out. A few episodes through and she seems perfectly fine - which, we can argue, is normal with some cancer patients. Then, on the episode where the other witches torment her so she'll kill herself, she seems already on the edge of death, like the cancer is decaying her. Next episode, when she's decided to be OK again, her hair is back and she's alive and well. This secret goes back to what is completely wrong with this season which is that plot lines are introduced with a lot of potential and fall short. It seems that the writers don't know how to continue with a plot line. Fiona's cancer comes in and out when they please and peaks when it suits. When they want her to be well and swinging an ax into a man's throat, they do. When they want her hairless and crawling on the floor in pain, they do. To hell with continuity! Fiona's cancer relates back to the problem with character. She may be a witch and with that we don't need realism but she has a human disease - a life threatening disease - and with that we do need realism. To have her dying one minute and completely fine the next slants towards the ridiculous. Continuity may be something the writers don't consider but maybe they should.

2. Sarah Paulson's Character Has Become Dull

Sarah Paulson was never going to have a sassy character straight after her role as Lana Winters in Asylum. We all knew she was going to be toned down and when she was introduced as Cordelia Fox - the daughter of Fiona - we were accepting of this. Cordelia, the quiet, reserved and strict headteacher of the witches' Academy was intriguing. She spent a lot of time messing around with potions and plants, she told the girls the history of the witches, she was intelligent and we liked her for that. Then we were introduced to her human husband which added another layer to the character. Before we knew it, she had acid thrown in her face and was able to see people's secrets. Then, for some reason, the writers' pulled away this type of magic, made her healthy again but with that they made her dull. Sarah Paulson walks onto the screen as a blubbering, annoying mess and all we want is for her to disappear. In fact, last week's episode proved a heightened want for her to commit suicide. Instead, she gauged her eyes out. Did we care? No. Did this make her more interesting? No. Did it salvage her doomed, dull character? No. Why? Because it's gone back on itself, it hasn't brought her character forward in any way. If, for example, she committed suicide for the benefit of the coven or managed to produce some form of rare magic that surprised everyone she could be salvaged. Will she? With two episodes left? We doubt it. Sarah Paulson has accepted a very bland role that had - like many things with this season - the potential to be interesting. Instead, she went from interesting to blind to healthy to blubbering to desperate to blind again. Do we seen an arc? Yes. A dull one.

1. No Zackary Quinto

And the final problem of Coven: where is Zackary Quinto? Quinto played the flamboyant and angry Chad in Murder House - a minor role but an entertaining one. He then played Dr. Threddson in Asylum - the sadistic, necrophiliac, skin-obsessed serial killer - who pretends to be a caring doctor. Needless to say, Zackary Quinto is flawless, so why isn't he in Coven? Murphy has managed to write in 90% of the previous members of American Horror Story. He's even added four extra roles into this season for actresses he admires and yet there's no room for Zackary Quinto which has made the season that little bit less exciting. How fantastic would it be to have Quinto walk in as a magician? Or a dark male witch? He would have even suited the Devil character that appeared in last week's episode. Sadly not, Zackary Quinto is nowhere to be found and we fear he may not be. We have two episodes left so we live in hope but there's that doomed, bleak feeling that he won't appear. We pray Murphy will come to his senses and have Zackary Quinto in season 4 which will come to us in September of 2014 where we're sure there will be ten things wrong with that season too. Do you agree? Disagree? Hit the comments!