The American Pie films were a cult phenomenon back around the turn of the millennium, but after three films, the franchise looked to be over until 2005 when the first of four straight-to-DVD spin offs were released. Behrs starred in the last of the spinoffs 'American Pie Presents: The Book Of Love' as Heidi, with Eugene Levy reprising his role as Noah Levenstein yet again. The film flopped, with its IMDb ranking currently sitting at a miserable 4.7/10, the lowest score of all eight American Pie films, though the exposure led to more opportunities for Behrs.