10 TV Shows That Got Better After The Main Character's Death
Sometimes a main character's death can be the start of greatness for a TV show.
It takes a bold, bold TV series to kill off one of its true star attractions and still continue on for several more seasons. Even more so, it takes an extremely smart and impressive show to do that and somehow manage to only improve on the project's quality levels.
Many small screen offerings have opted to kill off their lead or another headline act in order to drum up some buzz, yet so many of those decisions have backfired by making that series distinctly worse in the fallout of these major character death. Misfits and Skins are a pair of shows who made a habit of rotating their key cast, yet the vast majority of those deaths sadly only hindered the two series.
Making any such call is always a risky one, but there are some great examples of shows that did that very thing and managed to thrive in the aftermath of such demises. Whether that's introducing new characters or merely allowing existing characters to step up and have more time in the sun, it's been proven that it's far from impossible to use a big-name death as a launching pad for a better overall product.
With that in mind, then, here are ten times a TV show managed to only get better after killing off one of its main players.
10. Charmed - Prue Halliwell
For Charmed's first three seasons, the magical trio of Prue, Piper and Phoebe Halliwell were our main protagonists, with Shannen Doherty, Holly Marie Combs and Alyssa Milano in those respective roles.
While all was going relatively well on-screen for these three, things were falling apart behind the scenes. Most notably, Doherty and Milano were forever at loggerheads, to the extent the Prue character was killed off as Shannen was fired (or quit - depending on who you believe).
The (off-screen) end for Prue came at the close of the series' third season, with a battle against the demon Shaxx enough to leave her with wounds that she was unable to recover from.
How did Charmed cope with the loss of likely its biggest name? Why, it simply brought in Rose McGowan as the Halliwells' long-lost half-sister Paige to fill that void.
Not just did Paige act as a more than suitable replacement for Prue, but the show itself remained successful enough to warrant another five seasons. Sure, the direction maybe drifted a little too much towards more traditional soap opera tropes in later seasons, yet Charmed still proved an entertaining beast whose passionate fan base continued to grow as the years went on.
9. DC's Legends Of Tomorrow - Rip Hunter
The man who formed the Legends team, so much of DC's Legends of Tomorrow's debut season had Rip Hunter (Arthur Darvill) taking centre-stage as he led this ragtag group through time in their mission to stop the nefarious Vandal Savage.
Season Two of Legends saw Rip battle, then join, then battle once more the Legion of Doom, and he'd then create the Time Bureau before eventually sacrificing himself to help stop Mallus in the show's third year. Since then, Legends of Tomorrow has largely improved with each passing season.
While Arrow became all doom 'n' gloom, and The Flash has become too reliant on paint-by-numbers villains, Legends and Supergirl have continued to impress when it comes to The CW's Arrowverse. For Legends, a big part of that is how the show has embraced the insanity of time travel and the limitless possibilities that throws up, whilst all of the team - despite Sara being the actual leader - feel like they're equals in terms of responsibilities and screen time.
Since Hunter's death, the Legends have added several new faces to their ranks, have battled brilliantly fun rogues like Neron and Astra Logue, and the show continues to balance serious real-world themes with outrageous, dumb entertainment.
8. Boardwalk Empire - Jimmy Darmody
When Boardwalk Empire began in 2010, the two lead characters of this latest HBO spectacle were Steve Buscemi's Nucky Thompson and Michael Pitt's Jimmy Darmody. For so much of the series' first two seasons, the focus was often on the father/son relationship of Nucky and Jimmy, with Darmody becoming more and more troubled and erratic as the show went on.
That behaviour would eventually lead to Jimmy's death at the end of Season Two, with him shot dead by Nucky after embarking on a dark, destructive spiral fuelled by booze and heroin.
A World War I veteran who, as he himself put it, never mentally made it home from the war, Darmody's death was both inevitable and surprising at the same time. It seemed destined to happen, yet Nucky surely wouldn't really pull the trigger on his protégé?
Once Nucky did pull the trigger on his protégé, Boardwalk Empire grew as a show. With Jimmy out of the picture, other characters were afforded more time in the spotlight. Likewise, the series' third season also introduced some fantastic new faces, with Bobby Cannavale's Gyp Rosetti a particular standout addition to butt heads with Nucky.
7. Homeland - Nicholas Brody
During its first few seasons, Homeland was Brody and Carrie.
A presumed-dead marine, Damian Lewis' Sgt Nicholas Brody had made his heroic return home as Homeland started. Sceptical of Brody and his story of being held captive by terrorists, we had Claire Danes' Carrie Mathison. And with tensions often high between the two, it didn't take long for a will they/won't they romance to emerge between these two lead characters.
Following plenty of twists, turns, fall-outs and make-ups, the story of Brody came to a tragic end in Season Three as he was hanged in Iran as a watching crowd cheered for his death.
Losing a character as great and multi-layered as Brody was one major concern for Homeland fans, and likewise losing an actor as talented as Damian Lewis - who had won an Emmy Award for his role - was worrying, yet the series only improved with Brody out of the way.
Carrie became the anchor of the show, Saul Berenson became pivotal, and Homeland also developed an eerie habit of foreshadowing real-life happenings - such as President-elect Elizabeth Keane's battle with the intelligence community mirroring what was soon to come from Donald Trump and his National Security fight.
6. Roseanne - Roseanne Conner
It takes a special sort of ass to behave so atrociously that not only does your character get killed off, but the entire show in question is cancelled.
That was infamously the case with Roseanne Barr and her self-titled Roseanne show. With the series having been warmly received when it returned to air in 2018 for a tenth season after 22 years away, that return was short-lived when social media comments from Barr resulted in the show being axed.
Those comments were directed towards Valerie Jarrett, a former advisor of Barack Obama's. With these horrendous remarks causing ABC to cut ties with Barr and cancel the show, the one silver lining is that Roseanne lived on - and absolutely thrived - without its eponymous star.
While Roseanne itself was cancelled, the rest of the show's characters were able to continue on in spin-off effort, The Conners. Killing off the Conner clan's matriarch and revealing her to have had a long-standing secret drug problem, the series initially found Dan and the rest of the family grieving their loss, and The Conners and its four seasons to date have flourished when the series' characters moved on from Roseanne - to the point that the most recent episode (as of this writing) even had Dan remarry.
5. Teen Wolf - Allison Argent
The third season death of Crystal Reed's Allison Argent is viewed as the most shocking of Teen Wolf's many, many demises.
Across those three years, Allison had cemented herself as likely the most popular character on the show amongst fans. Starting life as a rather generic teenager, Reed's Allison grew into a total badass who was just as handy with a bow and arrow as any one of Green Arrow, Hawkeye, Katniss Everdeen or Robin Hood.
Unfortunately for Allison, her fate was sealed once she was stabbed with an Oni sword in the Insatiable episode. Going into that episode, fans had been told to expect a notable death, yet few could've predicted such a hugely popular character would be the one to bite the bullet.
While Teen Wolf experienced an Allison-shaped hole in the aftermath of this, the MTV series would have its best days still to come, with the next three seasons viewed by many as being superior to its three predecessors. Of course, that matter is subjective, but the point here is that Teen Wolf was still able to carry on and deliver the goods even after killing off its female lead.
4. Grey's Anatomy - Dr. George O'Malley
While Ellen Pompeo's Meredith Grey is clearly the main character of Grey's Anatomy, the early goings of this ABC show was very much an ensemble as Grey and her fellow interns got to grips with the day-to-day life of a surgeon.
For T.R. Knight's George O'Malley, he was one of the four interns who started alongside Meredith, and he was a major part of the series' formative years. So, when George brutally died, it was a genuine gut punch.
Admittedly, George had been underutilised in Season Five, but the handling of his death stands as one of the most impactful moments in Grey's Anatomy history. By this point specialising in trauma surgery, O'Malley decided he wanted to join the military. As his colleagues plan to talk him out of this career change, they find themselves dealing with a disfigured Joe Doe case, where a man was flattened by a bus as they saved someone else from being ran over.
That man, of course, would ultimately be George O'Malley.
The death of George made Grey's Anatomy more compelling due to the initial shock and subsequent fallout of this demise. As for the show as a whole, it's recently started its 18th season - showcasing just how much of a true powerhouse it has become over the years.
Of course, Grey's Anatomy would then go even more big-time in its deaths in 2011 when Patrick Dempsey's McDreamy, Derek Shephard, died after being struck by a truck.
3. The Walking Dead - Rick Grimes
Okay, okay. Sure, Rick Grimes hasn't been killed off in The Walking Dead, but it's hard to argue that the exit of Andrew Lincoln's character hasn't coincided with an upturn in quality for AMC's previously-sagging show.
Rick is still alive and out there somewhere, with him gearing up to have his story continued in a trilogy of Walking Dead movies. In his absence, the main TWD show has spun its fortunes around and become a whole lot more fun.
Rick Grimes is a modern-day great TV character, but he'd realistically done all he could do in The Walking Dead. At best, audiences needed a break from Rick; at worst, the character needed permanently removing.
This is someone who had been front 'n' centre for 120 episodes by the time he was airlifted to wherever in Season Nine's What Comes After. We'd had Determined Rick, we'd had Angry Rick, we'd had Sad Rick, we'd had Crazy Rick (complete with marvellous beard), and we'd seen this once-great character start to be one of the things dragging The Walking Dead down.
It may not have quite hit the heights of the show's prime, but the post-Rick TWD seasons have been vastly superior to the prior couple of years. The Whisperers arrived, Michonne was able to shine, Negan has become an antihero, and all the core characters feel on a way more equal footing than when Rick was the clear main attraction.
2. Game Of Thrones - Ned Stark
By the time Games of Thrones rolled to a close in 2019, the vast majority of the HBO juggernaut's headline attractions had been killed off along the way.
Taking the prestigious honour of being the first main Thrones character to die, of course, was Sean Bean's Ned Stark.
While it's become a running joke that Bean must die in whatever he appears in, Thrones felt, well, different. In how the marketing of this series was handled, Ned was the glue that held so much of the show together up until he was beheaded in Thrones' ninth episode.
The second-to-last outing for the series' debut year, Baelor shocked us all - well, bar those who'd read George R.R. Martin's source material - by killing off the person who was absolutely positioned as the show's lead figure.
Some may not have been happy with how Game of Thrones concluded, but there's no doubt the series went from strength to strength in the aftermath of Ned's death - becoming one of the most must-see TV shows of all time.
The beheading of Ned Stark not only helped to push so much of the future narrative of Thrones - particularly in how his children all grow - but it hammered home to audiences that all bets were off when it came to this burgeoning behemoth of a show.
1. Bates Motel - Norma Bates
With Bates Motel, it's not that the show was bad before the death of Norma Bates, but more that Norma's demise took the series to another level of quality for its final season.
In your writer's oft-questioned opinion, Bates Motel is the greatest TV series of the past decade and is a show that immediately set the bar high with just how damn good it was - before then maintaining a ridiculous level of high quality across its five-season run.
The death of Vera Farmiga's Norma happens in the penultimate episode of Bates Motel's penultimate season, with the cause of death being carbon monoxide poisoning. Of course, this was part of a bungled murder-suicide plan of Freddie Highmore's Norman.
Why was said plan bungled? That's because Norman himself wound up being unsuccessful with his attempt to take his own life. As a result of this, the rest of Bates Motel sees Highmore's character's descent into madness amped up to 11.
By the time Bates Motel jumps forward two years for its final season, we have a Norman who is happy to kill, who is fully in the midst of being "Mother", and who has his ma's frozen corpse hidden in the basement... as Bates Motel served up a flawless end to its five-year story.