10 TV Shows That Killed Off Unhappy Actors

Not everyone gets a happy ending, on screen or off...

By Aidan Whatman /

Many fans like to imagine that the casts and crews of our favourite shows are like family behind the scenes. Unfortunately, this is not always the case. Feuds, fall outs and character direction can often get in the way of a seemingly good thing, as is the case with the following entries.

Advertisement

The shows on this list comprise of comedies, dramas and sit-coms, and many are often regarded as some of the best shows in the world. It's sad to see some of them on here, especially the fan favourites, but sometimes it was necessary and almost always handled with great care.

For the following list we're steering as clear from the obvious ones as possible (that's you, Charlie Sheen) and focusing on the characters who were killed off because of reasons you may have missed.

Beware: SPOILERS within!

10. Jeffrey DeMunn - The Walking Dead

Jeffrey DeMunn was a great moral presence on The Walking Dead. A fantastic actor with a strong and varied filmography, he was a brilliant choice to play Dale Horvath. Dale was righteous and human, and contrasted the darkening personas around him - primarily those of the ambiguous Shane Walsh and the rough Daryl Dixon.

Advertisement

In the comics, Dale survives for a long time, far past the prison he doesn't even get to see on the show. So when his death came along, fans were shocked and confused. Although his death was handled well and helped the group come together over the issues with their captive, Randall, it wasn't actually the idea of the writers to take him out.

In fact, DeMunn was very vocal about his anger toward AMC, who had recently fired show-runner Frank Darabont over creative differences. DeMunn, who had worked with Darabont on a number of classic Stephen King adaptations, including The Green Mile, The Shawshank Redemption, and The Mist, felt as though the director was being ill-treated and didn't want to be part of the show if his friend was gone.

According to DeMunn himself, once Darabont was confirmed as leaving, he went to AMC and said, simply: "Kill me."

Dale loss was felt at the time, and it would have been nice to see DeMunn carry his story further into the show. Luckily for fans, his moral attitude was filled by the great Scott Wilson's Hershel Greene. The Walking Dead is in its tenth season as of this writing, but DeMunn (and now Wilson) is still a greatly missed presence.

9. Chevy Chase - Community

Despite only some good reviews for its first season, Community has gone on to become one of the most celebrated and popular sit-coms of all time. Characters such as the childish Jeff Winger, over-achiever Annie Edison and intelligent but emotionally reserved Abed Nadir have become pop culture icons thanks to their presence on the show.

Advertisement

On the show, Chevy Chase plays Pierce Hawthorne. Pierce is an old millionaire who finds life boring so enrols in some classes at the community college. Chevy Chase is great as Pierce, who at his core is a horrible and old fashioned guy with some offensive views on gender and race. Chase brings a likeability to the role, however, and remains a fan favourite to this day.

Unfortunately, Chase didn't make it to the end of the show. Behind the scenes, he had a tough time playing the outspoken Pierce and often clashed with showrunner Dan Harmon. Chase found his character too offensive and unlikable, and wanted some character development. After a particularly bad day he went into a tirade against Harmon which saw him use a racial slur in front of the cast and crew.

Afterwards, Chase only appeared in a handful of episodes and was abruptly killed off near the end of Season Four, as per an agreement made between Chase and the producers.

It was sad to see and his presence was missed in the final seasons, and to top off the escapade, Chase doesn't take part in reunions and its mostly unknown how his former cast mates - all of whom are still said to be close - feel about him and the events leading to his abrupt departure. All the same, he is missed by Community's legions of fans, and his character will forever live on.

8. Shannen Doherty - Charmed

Shannen Doherty has a reputation in Hollywood as an actress who loved to party and drink and would often arrive late to set. She also had some feuds with major cast mates, which caused rifts behind the scenes. She worked on Beverly Hills, 90210, for four seasons before taking an early and sudden exit. Some time later, with her next TV project, history repeated itself.

Advertisement

In 1998, Doherty was cast as Prue Halliwell, one of the three original sisters of the show, alongside Alyssa Milano's Phoebe Halliwell and Holly Combs' Piper Halliwell. Despite initially being on friendly terms, Doherty and Milano didn't get on during filming the show. The rift in the pair grew so bad that Milano demanded her on-screen sister be fired.

Doherty realised she was being turned on, and quit before producers could fire her. Although the Season Three left Prue and Piper's fate ambiguous after being attacked by a demon, Season Four revealed that only Piper survived her injuries. Her absence was filled by Rose McGowan in subsequent seasons, who went on to play half-sister Paige Matthews.

Though things may not have ended well for her tenure on Charmed, however, Doherty and Milano have put their feud far behind them now and all is right with the world again.

Still, it's interesting to think where the show would be had Prue been made it to the end.

7. T. R. Knight - Grey's Anatomy

This is still a sore one for Grey's Anatomy fans, despite all the wonderful characters we've seen come and go over the years. T R Knight was a main cast member for the first five seasons of the medical drama, playing Dr. George O'Malley, and fans were shocked when it was announced he wouldn't return to the show for Season Six.

Advertisement

Behind the scenes, fellow actor Isaiah Washington got into a fight with Patrick Dempsey and used a homophobic slur during the confrontation. The controversy led to Washington having his contract terminated, and Knight took the opportunity to come out as gay, a fact he said the cast and crew were aware of.

This could have been the end of it, but unfortunately Knight also had issues within the show, primarily in regards to his lack of character development and limited screen time. He had disagreements with show-runner Shonda Rhimes about the way his character was being portrayed, and he felt as though O'Malley was fading further and further into the background. After some talks, he was given the chance to leave his contract early and took it.

George O'Malley was killed in a bus accident at the beginning of Season Six which left him disfigured and identified as a John Doe. His friends and colleagues realised who he was too late, however, and he died before they could save him. It was an unceremonious end for many fans, but a necessary one, as Knight was done with the show and wanted to put his focus elsewhere.

6. Jay Thomas - Cheers

Cheers is a television landmark. A fantastic sit-com, featuring some truly unforgettable characters, such as Sam Malone, Carla Tortelli and Woody Boyd, Cheers helped shape television in the 80s and 90s, and remains to date one of the most beloved and imitated shows on TV. But, like the others on this list, there were issues behind the scenes which threatened to harm the show's image and popularity.

Advertisement

The late Jay Thomas appeared in only nine episodes during his run on Cheers, but his character was a major plot point throughout his tenure. He played Eddie LeBec, a hockey player who enters a relationship with Rhea Perlman's Carla. She gets pregnant and they get married. LeBec was a relatively solid character with a good arc despite his low episode count, but Thomas himself was much less happy with the role.

On his radio station one day, he was asked by a caller what it was like playing Eddie, and Thomas said it was "brutal" because he had to kiss Rhea Perlman. Perlman and the writers heard this and Jay Thomas' fate was sealed. Despite appearing in Seasons Five, Six and Seven, he didn't return to Season Eight and Eddie LeBec was killed off-screen in a Zamboni accident.

At the funeral, it was revealed LeBec was a polygamist who was also married to a woman who looked just like Carla. Although this added a few laughs to proceedings, it was a brutal kick for Thomas and his legacy on the show.

His departure is part of television lore, and Jay Thomas has become a part of TV legend. He went on to have success elsewhere, but it seems as though his name will mostly followed up by the story of what happened to him on Cheers.

5. Adewale Akkinuoye-Agbaje - Lost

This one still really sucks. Lost is an iconic show full to the brim of characters and relationships and bizarre mysteries, but Adewale Akinnuoye-Agbaje's Mr Eko remains one of the series' most original and intriguing personalities.

Advertisement

Introduced in Season Two, Eko was a captivating character who Akinnuoye-Agbaje played with great power and relish. Instantly a fan favourite, it seemed as though Eko was destined for the success of a long arc and increased screen time. And, of course, popularity. But this didn't happen as expected, as Eko was killed by the infamous smoke monster in Season Three, and was never seen again.

Unlike most actors on this list, no feuds or clashes led up to Akinnuoye-Agbaje's departure. He didn't like living in Hawaii and wanted to return home. Despite show-runners Damon Lindelof and Carlton Cuse wanted to keep Eko around for a long, four season arc, Akinnuoye-Agbaje requested to be killed in Season Two and was reluctant to sign a long contract. Lindelof and Carlton kept him around for a bit longer, but eventually caved to the actor's demands and let Eko go.

His death may have been well executed, but fans weren't quite ready to say goodbye and his presence was missed from there. It would have been nice to see Mr Eko get his full storyline, and it's fun to consider where the show would have ended up had he stayed around, but we suppose we can settle with the knowledge that some of his arc went on to characters like John Locke and still made it to screen.

4. Isaac Hayes - South Park

Isaac Hayes' departure from South Park has gone down in television legend and has been referenced in everything from other TV shows and music. It's a bizarre tale and Chef's death remains one of the cartoon's most polarising and graphic moments.

Advertisement

Isaac Hayes played Chef, who for years had been the most level-headed adults in town and a sympathiser with the kids and their antics. Stan, Kyle, Eric and Kenny often trusted him and came to him with advice, which doesn't always work in his favour. He's responsible for some of the show's funniest moments, including his conversation with Stan about God and the time he converted to Islam.

All of this and more is possible because of Isaac Hayes, whose deep voice made Chef appear wise and trusting, and helped make some of his more outrageous statements even funnier because of their almost innocent-sounding delivery. Hayes was a staple of the show, but after South Park mocked Scientology - to which Hayes belonged - in the Season Nine episode "Trapped in the Closet", he felt betrayed by the show and wanted it taken off the air. But it wasn't.

A couple weeks after the episode aired, Hayes quit and Chef was killed brutally in Season Ten's "The Return of Chef", where he is devoured by a mountain lion and a grizzly bear. It's a shocking and violent end to the beloved character, but remained in-keeping with the tone of the show.

Still, Chef is sorely missed even today, as the epic show continues to air. Isaac Hayes passed away two years later, in 2008, making Chef's end ever-more heart-breaking.

3. Jon Polito - Homicide: Life On The Street

Homicide: Life on the Streets is a cop-led drama on a level with The Wire and The Shield. Based on David Simon's book "Homicide: Life on the Killing Streets", the show's popularity has grown over time and cemented it as a cult classic praised for how well it appears to have aged.

Advertisement

On the show, Jon Polito played a cop called Steve Crosetti. In the role, Polito was fantastic and consistently believable, but there was a problem at NBC, who aired the show. They wanted more young actors and some stronger female characters before there could be a Season Three (Season Two was only four episodes long and the ratings were low), so they decided to get rid of Polito to make way for some fresh blood.

Polito, who was very passionate about his role and the show, was devastated by the news. Producer Tom Fontana promised he'd bring Polito back, but Polito didn't believe him and said to the media how little he trusted NBC and how they were ruining the show. In response, the sixth episode of Season Three saw Crosetti kill himself off-screen, and any chance of Polito coming back was crushed.

Polito admitted he had made a mistake, but of course it was too late. In Homicide: The Movie, he made a brief cameo appearance as Crosetti in a hallucination. His death shocked fans and Polito himself, but the show made went on to Season Seven without him.

2. Nicollette Sheridan - Desperate Housewives

For the first five seasons of Desperate Housewives, Nicollette Sheridan played Edie Britt, one of the many residents of Wisteria Lane. Her character was widely adored by fans and critics alike, and Sheridan's performance was often considered one of the strongest on the show. Her sudden and shocking death (pun intended) was a blow to long-time fans who loved watching her antics on the show.

Advertisement

Although Edie's death was well received by Sheridan herself, who liked the fact that she died as she lived - "the centre of attention" - the behind the scenes friction between Sheridan and creator Marc Sherry went from heated to vicious very fast. Sheridan said Cherry ignored her on set and didn't care about her character. Cherry said her death had to happen to save money.

After Edie was killed, Sheridan sued Cherry for wrongful dismissal and battery, claiming that he had hit her. It became clear that their feud was more bitter than was ever made out to the public. Unfortunately, this friction has gone away. Sheridan refused to cameo in the finale and in interviews since has remained adamant that the show let her down and killed off the wrong person.

Since the show continued through to Season Eight, it would have been interesting to see where else she would have ended up had she been allowed to stick around. It was a tragic and shocking loss, but not as sad as the behind the scenes drama that preceded and followed it.

1. John Amos - Good Times

For three seasons, John Amos delighted audiences with his portrayal of the no-nonsense family patriarch James Evan Sr. Amos said he wanted to take the role because he was interested in doing a show about a poor African-American family beating the odds. However, he didn't enjoy the humour of the show, which he said undermined the essence and themes of the show.

Advertisement

But his troubles didn't stop there. Amos argued that the writers didn't understand what life was actually like for the African-American family and disagreed with the way his on-screen son was portrayed. His disagreements with creator Norman Lear became too much for the show's success, and Lear even went as far as to say that Amos had become a "distraction", which Amos agreed with.

Because of his open objection the show and the way it was run, Amos was fired after the third season and James Sr perished in a car accident in the premier of Season Four. The show lasted three seasons without him, unchanged by his previous objections, but lacking his moral and warm presence that his fans had come to love.

Advertisement