10 TV Shows That REALLY Shouldn't Have Worked
Against all the odds, these TV shows pulled it off.
Research has suggested that it is a matter of milliseconds within which a first impression is made. In that time people are able to surmise almost everything they need to know about someone, which can often be their lasting impression. The same can be said of TV shows, with seconds of a trailer, a glimpse of the first episode or even a quick Google of the show’s synopsis enough to know whether you think the show is worthy of watching.
The initial contact made with a show can tell us that the show’s premise is bad, the quality looks sub-par or simply that the show doesn’t look up to much at all. And often these split-second analyses made whilst simultaneously scanning Twitter and eating Doritos are correct. However, every now and then a show defies expectations, the odds and even the boundaries set by the shows themselves.
Whilst no show is ever guaranteed to be a success, shows like Game Of Thrones, The Wire and Friends followed well worked formulas that made critical acclaim and positive audience reception highly likely. Some shows however seemed less likely to be the successes they turned out to be.
The lesson? Never judge a TV show by its IMDB synopsis.
10. Jane The Virgin
Whilst shows are never a guaranteed success, good
quality source materials or experienced writers with a solid pedigree make it
more likely that a show will be successful. It’s fair to say that amongst the
pantheon of great TV shows very few are inspired by, or based on a Venezuelan
telenovela.
This however is the case with Jane the Virgin. Based on the telenovela Juana la Virgen, Jane the Virgin is perhaps the archetypical ‘don’t judge a book by its cover’ TV series. Critics and fans alike questioned the premise, with the story following the life of a 23-year-old devout Latina virgin who is accidentally impregnated through artificial insemination.
The idea sounded limited and fairly cheap, however the shows acting, clever writing and parodying of common Latin telenovela tropes and themes garnered critical acclaim and a loyal fan base.
Jane the Virgin’s awareness of its silly premise added to the laughs, and with plans of a spin-off shelved in 2019, it could be a while until we see another Venezuelan telenovela inspired comedy on our screens.
9. BoJack Horseman
Whilst online streaming services have enabled TV’s weirder and wackier creators to express themselves, in 2014 there can’t have been many tougher pitches than Bojack Horseman. A depressed anthropomorphic horse who was the star of a hit sitcom, now living with an oddball squatter called Todd in a version of Hollywood where humans and animals co-exist. Wrap your head around that one.
Despite its interesting premise, early on it appeared unclear what BoJack really was, which this was reflected in reviews of the opening series. The gags were there but they lacked the deeper insight, moral ambiguity and juxtaposition of light and dark that would define the show in later series.
Fortunately, the second half of the first season picked up and was rewarded by further seasons. What followed was an era defining comedy that contributed massively to the sadcom format. Bojack was never afraid to confront the darkness of show business and life in general, tackling issues such as anxiety, mental health and drug addiction whilst making animal based puns and having a whale of time doing so.
The insane premise and troublesome start for BoJack Horseman could have led to Netflix’s first animated show being put down with a broken leg. But instead BoJack now resides in the stable of great TV shows, with a legacy of being one of the smartest comedies of all time.
Thankfully the show’s creators stopped all the Horsin’ Around and turned BoJack into what it is today.
8. Westworld
Despite
Westworld’s stellar casting, impressive visuals and inexplicably complex and
intricate storytelling, it must be remembered that dystopian sci-fi/Western
mashups have a long and troubled history. From Deadly Reactor to Solo: A Star
Wars Story, sci-fi and Westerns have often mixed like oil and water.
Based on the 1973 film of the same name, Westworld has however garnered universal acclaim, largely overcoming the difficulty of pairing the Wild West with advanced robotics. For many the two genres were deemed incompatible but Westworld’s stellar cast and ingenious writing has led to the show’s massive success.
Whilst the show has been criticized for its overly complex storylines and sometimes insane complexity, it’s fair to say that Westworld is in another universe to Cowboys vs Aliens…or Wild Wild West.
7. Sleepy Hollow
It’s fair to say that the best TV shows are complex, with multiple threads running concurrently, giving shows depth whilst building towards something bigger. However, with Sleepy Hollow the phrase “a hat on a hat” initially seemed more than apt.
Sleepy Hollow’s premise has more mythical cross-overs than a Lord of the Rings edition of Dungeons and Dragons. The show loosely follows Washington Irving’s short story ‘The Legend of Sleepy Hollow’, with further inspiration from his other tale ‘Rip Van Winkle’.
However, within the pilot alone viewers meet Ichabod Crane (a double agent for George Washington), who wakes up in the present day because someone has raised the Headless Horseman (one of two Horseman in this list). This Horseman however is one of the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse, with the pilot also introducing viewers to George Washington’s magic Bible, multiple dimensions, Biblical Witnesses (see Book of evelations for more details) and yes all this is in the pilot episode.
But it’s fair to say that despite its cluttered premise fans really took to Sleepy Hollow, with its well-produced visuals and action packed storylines making the show a firm fan favourite, despite the show never truly being sensational.
Perhaps a hat on a hat could become the fashion. It worked for Sleep Hollow after all.
6. Mad Men
Certain ideas, tropes and settings come around time and time again in the world of television. Comedies are often set in bars, the hero gets the girl and dramas are often centred on criminals, police officers or lawyers.
In 2007, it would have been fair to dismiss a TV drama that focussed on the lives and work of Advertising Executives. But 7 seasons, 16 Emmys and 5 Golden Globes later, Mad Men certainly proved that Advertising Agencies were as interesting as any Law Firm.
Widely regarded as one of the greatest television series of all time, Mad Men follows womanizing creative director Don Draper and other characters at the fictional Sterling Cooper ad agency. The show portrays Don’s relationships with his family and co-workers, whilst also engaging with the changing social mood and issues of the US during the 1960s.
Issues such as identity, counterculture, racism and sexual politics are all part of the shows complex, brooding narrative. And whilst the suits and whiskey drinking are all somewhat cool, the show’s characters are often complex, troubled and certainly problematic.
Mad Men was ironically a show that just needed a good sales pitch. Fittingly, you come for the show’s debonair visuals, but you stay for the writing, characters and excellent performances.
5. The Great British Bake Off
The use of the word smorgasbord has never been as aptly used as to refer to the volume of cooking and baking competitions on TV. From Masterchef to Cupcake Wars, there is a cookery competition for every palate. However, with many using similar basic ingredients, shows tend to blend into the massive batter of endless cooking competitions. But like a wholemeal loaf with a kilo of yeast in it, one show rises above the rest.
In 2010, the world was introduced to The Great British Bake Off. Whilst it seemed that the last thing the world needed was another cake-centric cook off, Bake Off had a pinch of magic- something that took an innocent enough baking show and propelled it into mainstream consciousness.
Ten years later, the series has controversially changed channels, presenters and become a global phenomenon, spawning versions across the world. The shows bunting and tea towel clad combination of good honest competition, innuendo, village fete aesthetic and lovable characters has taken a run of the mill baking competition that could have lasted a series and created a global baking behemoth.
A few soggy bottoms took this dainty little baking show to the very top. A Cinderella story- if Cinderella wore a pinny and accidentally threw custard in the bin.
4. The Office (U.S)
The IT Crowd. Coupling. The Inbetweeners. What do
these shows and many others have in common? God awful American remakes.
The Office was a much beloved British series written by Ricky Gervais and Stephen Merchant and was inherently British in its portrayal of the ordinary office environment. There is an awkward, desperately uncomfortable edge to the hilarious UK original which thrived because of its stripped back, subtle approach.
So, talk of an American remake would have hardly inspired fans of the original to watch a potentially shoddy, laugh track infested remake of their beloved original.
However, despite those with an exclusively British comedy palate perhaps not taking to the US remake, The Office’s American cousin was largely regarded as a rare success for US adaptations. The show was lauded for its lovable characters, decent gags and balancing of UK/US comedy style.
Is it better than the original? Perhaps not. Was it
better than anyone expected? Absolutely.
3. The Eric Andre Show
Imagine a show that combined The Tonight Show, David Lynch and Andy Kaufmann. Now make that show look like it’s on public access television and force feed it psychedelic drugs. Et Voilà! you have The Eric Andre Show.
Created at a time when Eric Andre had no money and was working intermittently in adverts and doing stand-up, the show takes the talk show format and then plunges it into a world of surrealism and insanity. With Hannibal Burress as the co-host, the show is irrepressibly dark, twisted and yet somehow hilarious, with the show inexplicably veering off course at any given moment. No synopsis could do this show credit.
The Eric Andre Show has increasingly managed to book respectable well-known names such as Jack Black, Seth Rogen and Jimmy Kimmel. In a strange twist of fate, the talk show that isn’t really a talk show has managed to land stellar names that actual talk shows could only dream of.
Whilst it's often unclear what The Eric Andre Show actually is, it has certainly defied expectations.
2. Lovesick
Now on the surface this British sitcom following three friends living together in a flat in Glasgow and their complicated relationships seems like it would always have been a fairly safe bet.
However, after the first series, the show moved from Channel 4 to Netflix. And with this move came a change in the show’s title. In with Lovesick, out with Scrotal Recall. Yes, Scrotal Recall.
Lovesick/ Scrotal Recall is the story of Dylan Witter, who upon being diagnosed with chlamydia must contact all his previous partners. The show largely works in flashbacks and has increasingly focussed on the relationship between Dylan and his friends. Written with real heart and intelligence the show is a fairly down to earth look at growing up and relationships.
But with a name like Scrotal Recall this show should have been destined for an early cancellation. Granted it is an amazing pun, but it was hardly in keeping with the sense of the show. Lovesick has overcome its earlier title, becoming a refreshingly good comedy that is far better than many viewers expected.
Any spin off must surely be called The Sperminator before being duly retitled.
1. Buffy The Vampire Slayer
With hindsight Buffy The Vampire Slayer might seem
to have been an inevitable smash hit. Given its excellent casting, well written
storylines and its creator being Josh Whedon (whose filmography includes
co-writing Toy Story and directing multiple Avenger films), Buffy’s success
might have seemed natural.
However, the story of a seemingly ordinary girl battling vampires, demons and other creatures of the underworld, whilst also overcoming the greatest monster of them all, adolescence, divided viewers and critics before the shows arrival. The name of the show alone hardly inspired confidence. What kind of name was Buffy anyway?
However, unlike the 1992 film version that preceded the TV series, this Buffy was far from a disappointment. The show was a massive success and has even spawned an entire ‘Buffyverse’. Not to mention a seemingly bizarre area of academia. Surely academic minds could be better used on something other than Sarah Michelle Gellar fighting Vampires.
Buffy changed the way TV and films viewed monsters
and demons, bringing a level of artistic merit to the genre. But with a name
like Buffy The Vampire Slayer, it would have taken quite the premonition to see
the success the show had.