10 TV Shows That Were Saved By One Genius Tweak
Lost would've never been the same if Jack died in the pilot as originally planned.
The blood, sweat, and tears that go into creating a successful TV show which entertains its fans for years is basically unfathomable - it requires hundreds of artists and technicians working together on the same page to execute the showrunner's vision.
And there are so, so many things that can wrong when putting a show out: perhaps a major character isn't cast right, maybe a slight aspect of the story doesn't work, or it's just lacking the special sauce that truly grips audiences from the very first episode.
We've all seen promising shows fail because they couldn't quickly cultivate an audience, and in many cases even hugely successful shows very nearly suffered the same fate.
Yet because someone involved with the production - whether a writer, showrunner, or executive - recommended a tweak to the proposed format, these 10 shows secured their futures, providing each series with the secret ingredient they so desperately needed.
While we can't say for sure that these shows all would've failed without these late-in-the-day changes, knowing what we do about how TV works, it's difficult to accept they would've been nearly as successful...
10. Adding Danny DeVito In Season 2 - It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia
Though It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia was well-received by critics in its first season, that wasn't reflected in its ratings, and network FX effectively offered creator Rob McElhenney an ultimatum - add a name cast member for season two, or the show would be cancelled.
In a 2015 interview with The Nerdist podcast, McElhenney explained:
"So, John Landgraf, who's the president of FX, he called me in for a meeting and was like, 'Hey, no one's watching the show, but we love it, we wanna keep it on, but we don't have any money for marketing, and we need to add somebody with some panache that we can hopefully parlay into some public relations story, just so we can get people talking.'
It's not that we were reticent to the idea of adding Danny [DeVito] to the show... it's that we were reticent to add a name to the show. You know, because we kinda liked that we were no-names and it was this weird, small thing, you know."
McElhenney initially rejected the notion of adding a famous actor to the ensemble, but after it became clear the show wouldn't be returning without one, he relented.
And as great as the show's rough-around-the-edges first season was, bringing Danny DeVito aboard as Dennis (Glenn Howerton) and Dee's (Kaitlin Olson) father Frank Reynolds was an absolute masterstroke.
DeVito remains responsible for many of the series' most hilarious and unforgettable moments, effectively serving as the glue that holds the main cast together, all while keeping the network happy.
Given that It's Always Sunny was recently renewed up to its 18th season, it was absolutely the right call.
9. Not Casting Steven Van Zandt As Tony Soprano - The Sopranos
It's basically impossible to imagine anyone but the late, great James Gandolfini portraying The Sopranos' iconic mobster protagonist Tony Soprano, yet if creator David Chase got his way, things would've gone quite differently.
According to Steven Van Zandt, who went on to play Tony's right-hand man Silvio Dante, he was Chase's original choice to play Tony.
Despite having no acting experience and being best known as a member of Bruce Springsteen's E Street Band, Chase handpicked him for the part. In Van Zandt's own words:
"It was one of those weird things. [Chase] wanted unusual, new faces, and he really thought I could do it, and out of pure ignorance naiveté I thought I could do it. Luckily HBO wouldn't let him, so we ended up with one of the greatest actors of all-time, Jimmy G [Gandolfini]."
Needless to say, it was the right call. Chase then ended up writing the Silvio role specifically for Van Zandt, and as perfect as he was in that role, his lack of acting experience and on-screen demeanour would've made him so, so wrong for Tony.
By switching him out for James Gandolfini, the show's greatness was ensured. Had HBO allowed Van Zandt front and center, it's tough to imagine The Sopranos being quite the same show - or being nearly as captivating out of the gate.
8. Rewriting NoHo Hank's Fate - Barry
It took just a single episode of Bill Hader's incredible black comedy series Barry for viewers to realise that Chechen mobster NoHo Hank (Anthony Carrigan) was an attention-grabbing breakout character.
Throughout the show's three seasons to date, Hank has been a show-stealing fan favourite, his quirky demeanour and hilarious interactions with Barry (Hader) ingeniously subverting the far-flung mobster archetype.
Yet Hank was very nearly a single-episode character who died in the pilot, as it wasn't until that episode had been filmed that Hader and co-creator Alec Berg truly appreciated just how much of an asset he could be. Hader said in a 2019 Uproxx interview:
"Initially, in the pilot, he died... When I shoot up the car, he was dead. And then Alec [Berg] and I said, 'We'd be insane to kill that guy. He's so funny.' That's why in episode two, his arm's in a sling and everything."
Hank is such an integral, outstanding component of the ensemble cast that it's tough to imagine the show hitting the same highs without him. And for his efforts, Carrigan has received two Outstanding Supporting Actor Emmy nominations.
7. Spending $10 Million To Reshoot The Terrible Pilot Episode - Game Of Thrones
Though it quickly became a global phenomenon, Game of Thrones very nearly faltered before it even got going. HBO originally commissioned a pilot episode to be shot in 2009, which during an initial preview screening was poorly received by the cast, crew, and executives in attendance.
Series co-creator D. B. Weiss called watching the pilot "a deeply humiliating, painful experience," after which HBO waited four months to decide the show's fate.
Ultimately they agreed to greenlight an entire season's worth of episodes, but only if the pilot was re-shot, resulting in some changes in the cast and crew.
Factoring in the reshoots, HBO ended up spending an estimated, eye-watering $10 million on the first episode alone, accounting for approximately 20% of the first season's budget.
The unaired pilot has since taken on a mythic status in Thrones fandom, while franchise creator George R.R. Martin has joked that he's "under penalty of death" if he ever shows it to anyone.
Given that Game of Thrones' pilot was pivotal in the show's future success and the creation of a wider media empire, HBO were smart to invest more money in getting things right straight away, rather than hoping they could smooth the pilot's problems out in subsequent episodes.
First impressions count for a lot, after all.
6. Making Sheldon Asexual - The Big Bang Theory
Not entirely unlike Game of Thrones, The Big Bang Theory went through a tricky development period, whereby creators Chuck Lorre and Bill Prady had their first attempt at a pilot - which eventually found its way online - rejected by CBS.
And yet, the network saw enough promise in the concept to give them a second chance.
The second, ultimately successful pilot was markedly different - including introducing Penny (Kaley Cuoco) to the group dynamic - but perhaps the single smartest change was drastically reworking the character of Sheldon Cooper (Jim Parsons).
In the first pilot, Sheldon was basically a horndog - sexually active, frequently discussing his masturbatory habits and fetishes, and also a relatively social human being.
But Sheldon was made into the near-opposite in the second pilot - basically asexual and socially awkward, as ultimately made him such an endearing and eventually iconic character.
It's easy to imagine how Horny Sheldon could've been incredibly grating in the long run, and potentially have ensured the show didn't age too well also.
5. HBO Telling Alan Ball To "Make It More F**ked Up" - Six Feet Under
TV networks are notoriously risk-averse where challenging content is concerned, and even a company as seemingly permissive as HBO has its limits.
Yet when Alan Ball, fresh off an Oscar win for writing American Beauty, submitted the script for Six Feet Under's pilot episode to the network, he got a surprising response. In Ball's own words, from a 2005 interview with Movieweb:
"Certainly one of the most memorable moments was when I went to HBO and they had read my first draft and Carolyn Strauss said, 'You know, this is really, really good. I love these characters, I love these situations, but it feels a little safe. Could you just make it just a little more f**ked up?,' which is not a note that you get in Hollywood very often. And I though, 'Wow!' And that gave me free range to go a little deeper, go a little darker, go a little more complicated, and that was certainly one of the most memorable moments."
Needless to say, from its very first episode few would ever dare call Six Feet Under "safe" - its thoughtful confrontation of mortality, spiced with lashings of surrealism and black comedy, ensured it frequently lurched into "f**ked up" territory, and was all the better for it.
4. Changing The Oldest Belcher Child's Gender - Bob's Burgers
Loren Bouchard's original demo pilot of Bob's Burgers differed from the show proper in a number of ways, such as hinting that the Belcher family were cannibals - which Fox convinced Bouchard to nix - and assigning the oldest Belcher child a different gender.
In the demo, the oldest Belcher child is a boy named Daniel, but by the time the show went to series, Daniel had been switched out for a girl, Tina.
While superficially little actually changed about the character - she was still voiced by Dan Mintz and both looked and acted similarly - the gender swap led to Bob's Burgers ultimately offering up one of the most frank and hilarious depictions of an awkward teenage girl in sitcom history.
It's also tough to deny that the show likely couldn't have gotten away with some of Tina's more "eccentric" behaviour were she a boy - were a hormonal Daniel constantly obsessing over his female classmates' butts, it wouldn't hit quite the same way.
Given that Tina is the show's MVP in the eyes of many fans, kicking Daniel to the curb was an extremely smart call.
3. Adding Q To The Pilot At The Last Minute - Star Trek: The Next Generation
There's no denying that the first season of Star Trek: The Next Generation was quite the rocky ride indeed, but it very nearly faced even more of an uphill struggle retaining viewers if Trek creator Gene Roddenberry got his way.
Originally Roddenberry wrote an hour-long pilot for the show, but Paramount ultimately demanded a two-hour pilot, at which point Roddenberry had to find ways to pad out the story.
And so, he came up with Q (John de Lancie), the inter-dimensional being who puts humanity on trial in the episode.
Q's presence certainly helped imbue the relatively sleepy pilot with some much-needed energy, and the character proved enough of a hit that he reappeared numerous times throughout TNG's run, cementing him as an all-time fan favourite Trek character.
Had the pilot, "Encounter at Farpoint," simply been a one-hour episode without Q as Roddenberry initially intended, it's difficult to imagine it making quite the same impact with fans.
And yet, Roddenberry clearly knew what he had once he came up with Q, because though other Trek writers suggested to him that the character wouldn't work, he confidently retorted, "The fans will love it."
TNG is so much more than Q of course, but without the charismatic nudge he gave the show at the outset, who can say where it would've ended up?
2. NOT Killing Jack In The Pilot - Lost
In an all-time classic example of executives making a smart call that arguably saved a show - or at least massively improved it - J.J. Abrams' original outline for Lost's pilot had protagonist Jack Shephard (Matthew Fox) die half-way through the episode.
Initially, Abrams and company planned to hire an A-list actor in the role - Michael Keaton was interested for a time - whose death would shock the audience and layer the remainder of the season with an air of unpredictability.
However, network ABC strongly disagreed with the idea, feeling that it would simply piss invested audiences off, that a character as so easily likeable as Jack was taken off the chess board immediately.
And so, Jack was given a stay of execution, at which point Keaton departed the project - having no interest in committing to a larger part - and Matthew Fox was eventually cast as his replacement.
Given that Jack quickly established himself as one of Lost's most potent characters, and enjoyed quite the complex arc throughout the show's run, it would've been a massive mistake to kill him at the outset.
In Jack's absence, the role of the survivors' leader would've reportedly gone to Kate (Evangeline Lilly), and as great a character as she was, it just doesn't feel like a natural fit for her.
1. Toning Down The Rose's Bitterness After Season 1 - Schitt's Creek
If you recommend Schitt's Creek to any of your friends, there's a good chance you'll accompany it with the caveat, "It gets so much better after the first season."
And it's absolutely true - the riches-to-rags sitcom had some major growing pains in its uneven first volume, with many critics and viewers alike complaining that the Rose family were just too obnoxious and unlikeable for their own good.
Though the Roses were supposed to be privileged, out-of-touch a**holes to a point, the show still needed to tease out their inner humanity in small ways to convince audiences to keep watching them every week.
By season two, it became clear that creator-stars Eugene Levy and Daniel Levy had a much firmer handle on the show's tone and the personalities of the Rose family, ensuring they retained their defining traits albeit without being quite so acerbic and offputting.
Over the course of the remaining seasons, viewers fell head-over-heels for the Roses as they drifted further and further from caricatures into well-developed human beings who actually grew.
In one of the all-time great glow-up stories for a sitcom, Schitt's Creek's final season ended up performing a record-setting sweep of the Emmys.
Yet had the Levys stuck to their original vibe for that wonky first season, it's easy to imagine the show getting the chop relatively quickly.