People love The Walking Dead. It's one of the highest-rated shows in cable TV history, and it does so well for AMC that the network has recently commissioned a spin-off series that will air alongside the main one. The comic book has its following but Robert Kirkman, Tony Moore and Charlie Adlard's creation has found an even wider audience on the small screen, with an obsessive fan following unlike any other. Which is impressive, because it's not a perfect show. Is there such thing as a perfect show? No, but even so, The Walking Dead often struggles to reach that platonic ideal. Its second season was a mess of pacing and plots, there has been some truly dire dialogue over the years, and every so often the usually exemplary special effects will look a bit cheap. Still, the fact that the show works in spite of those issues is a testament to how great everything else is. It's strongly plotted, there are some career-making performances in there, and some truly memorable characters. Sometimes, though, those characters don't stick in the mind for a good reason. For every Daryl Dixon or Michonne, it seems, there are a handful of irritating, useless, or otherwise infuriating so-and-sos you're just rooting for to get devoured by zombies. From the truly abhorrent to the simply annoying, these are the ten worst characters in the history of The Walking Dead.
Advertisement
10. Lori Grimes
The Walking Dead does not do well with its female characters. That can partly be attributed to creator Robert Kirkman's less-than-progressive views on a woman's role in the world (namely: they're weaker and should probably be in the kitchen, because he is in fact a time traveller from two hundred years ago), but also because that tends to be what happens to women on TV dramas. It's even happened on AMC before. Skyler White was the one blip amidst the otherwise flawless Breaking Bad. Walt's long-suffering wife was put in the unenviable position of having to be the reasonable one, who didn't think the meth business was the best thing for her cancer-stricken Chemistry teacher husband to be messed up in. To the audience she represented something else. Namely, stalling the story. The exact same thing happened to Lori Grimes. She was the impetus for the Rick-Shane-Lori love triangle nobody asked for, she stopped anyone from ever having fun, and then the writers screwed with us by putting her in a car crash in season two...only to survive and then be killed of unceremoniously in season three.
9. Bob Stookey
The Walking Dead has something of an obsession with The Wire. Now granted, the majority of your high falutin' TV fans will also have an obsession with HBO's ground breaking, peerless drama about the Baltimore drug, police, journalism and political game, but it's a show that's about as far away from zombies and silly sub-plots as its possible to get. Excluding maybe all that union shipyard nonsense form the second season nobody likes. Seth Gilliam (Father Gabriel), Chad Coleman (Tyreese) and Lawrence Gilliard Jr (Bob Stookey) are all veterans of The Wire, and the explanation for all why all of them have cast is simple: I love The Wire, says Robert Kirkman. I think that every actor thats been on The Wire is absolutely fantastic. But the problem is, The Walking Dead is not The Wire. Tonally, creatively, genre-wise, it's totally different. All of which conspired against Gilliard's Bob Stookey from the off. A former army medic with a dark past (is there any other sort on this show?), Bob was introduced during the fourth season premiere and...didn't get much further than that. Dying before the season was out, he never got chance to develop much from being a bit of a crybaby. Bit of a waste of an actor.
8. Andrea
The TV series Andrea was very different from comic book Andrea. In the source material she manages to become toughened up pretty quickly, and ended up shacking up with Rick after Lori and Dale had popped their clogs. She since remained one of the key members of the group, one of the few remaining original cast members and a fan favourite. Her translation to the screen managed to lose...pretty much all that. Much as was the case with Bob, Laurie Holden is a good actress, but in Andrea she did not have a good character. To be honest, with Robert Kirkman's old-fashioned approach to gender politics, it's a surprise she was ever allowed to be such a strong character in the comics. But he made sure to nerf the heck out of any abilities she had on screen. Andrea spent the first three seasons constantly trying to prove that she was the tough person she becomes in the comics, but never quite managing it. She talked the talk but never walked the walked, and her posturing was kinda pathetic and annoying. Then she shacked up with The Governor for some reason, and sealed her fate.
7. Eugene Porter
A relatively recent addition to the main cast, Eugene first appeared in the season four episode Inmates and has since been one of the main players on the show. Which is a shame, because he's uniquely irritating in a way that no other character on The Walking Dead has ever been, and in almost every single way. It's not just the character in isolation, or his actions that rankle. It's both, and so much more. From a plot perspective Eugene is frustrating because he's a huge coward and a massive liability for the group, so far having gotten multiple people killed for first lying and saying there was a cure he was working on with some other scientists in Washington DC (he isn't and there wasn't), and then by mucking up a supply trip in this week's episode. Then there's just the character himself. Despite rocking the mullet and strong Southern accent Eugene's cowardice and intelligence are meant to be in stark contrast to those hillbilly signifiers, but his speech patterns are actually a million times more annoying than if he was a slack-jawed yokel. Instead, he sounds like a 14-year-old with an encyclopedia trying to be eloquent on an atheism forum.
6. Otis
Before the events of The Walking Dead, Otis didn't do nothing to nobody. And that's precisely the problem. He went from a bumbling milquetoast foreman on the Greene Family Farm to an almost-murderer who was hunting deer, shot one right through the face and ended up also catching the young Carl Grimes in the crossfire, leading to that interminable sub-plot where the kid sat in bed looking pale and wearing his dad's way-too-big cowboy hat. Which isn't really the fault of Otis, but how he dealt with it was a bit naff. He decided to just run away, essentially, volunteering to take Shane on a supply run to a nearby former high school, now a FEMA command post, to scavenge for medical supplies. In the process he revealed just how bloody useless he was, with Shane having to take the lead when they got cornered by walkers. Now, granted, Otis perhaps didn't deserve the untimely death afforded him when Shane decided to just shoot him in the leg and have the zombies chow down on his corpse whilst the younger, fitter man made his getaway. But then again, Otis was a nothing character who shot a kid and then refuses to let Shane have a rest, having injured himself in a leap Otis forced him to make. When he wasn't ineffectual, he was actively bad for the group.
5. Father Gabriel Stokes
Man, Father Gabriel is just the worst. Another character who's turned up this past season, Stokes is a priest that had barricaded himself inside his rural church during the zombie uprising, and had been doing just fine until Rick and his posse showed up. Even then he didn't do too bad, not having to lift a finger to keep his church well-fortified from the masses of monsters outside who wanted to literally pick his brain. But his shelter left him a little...well, sheltered. In the mid-season finale Stokes freaked out when the pews started being cut up for further defences, worried about the immortal soul of himself and his new flock, and then ran into the woods to have the least interesting side-plot since that time Carl Grimes sat on a roof eating a whole can of pudding. Before Stokes was simply ineffectual, a nothing character who was a bit annoying whenever he was on screen. In recent weeks he's become a full-blown irritant, dramatically tearing up his Bible and then babbling about Rick and co being literal demons in an awfully hammy, scenery-chewing performance from Seth Gilliam. Urgh.
4. Randall
This little snot didn't exactly ingratiate himself with the audience or the other characters during his debut. When the makers of The Walking Dead realised they should probably have something happen in the second season/found some extra money down the back of the writers room sofa they decided to send Rick and pals into a new side of town, where they came a cropper of some other survivors. One of whom was Randall, who apparently had some history with Hershel's daughter Maggie and tried to ring that connection for all it was worth. Which turned out to be...not a lot, considering before that he was on a roof trying to shoot Rick, Hershel and Glenn and then expected they save his life after he fell off said roof and impaled his leg on a spike. His Alan Partridge-style entrance didn't exactly pick up from there, with Randall exhibiting the level of charm and grace you'd expect out of Radio Norfolk's premier late-night disc jockey, revealing that he's part of a bigger group that routinely rapes and kills other survivors whilst managing to never thank Rick for saving his life. An odious little man.
3. Ed Peletier
In terms of the truly abhorrent characters The Walking Dead has provided over the years, Randall is second only to one. And that one is Ed Peletier, your friendly neighbourhood wife beater and probable paedophile who was part of the main cast during the first season. For the most part those disturbing revelations about Ed were played close to the chest, with initially shy-and-retiring Carol not wanting to make anything of it. A lot of Ed's awfulness came in retrospect, his abusive relationship with his young daughter Sophia alluded to long after he died, with Carol praying for him to be punished not only for the way he treated her not only beating Carol, but making her dress in dowdy clothes and keeping her hair short but also for looking at his own daughter, whatever sickness was growing in his soul. It was ambiguous, but given the generally off-putting demeanour Ed had during his brief time on The Walking Dead, quite believable. Actor Adam Minarovich actually did a bang-up job with the character; it's just that he was so irredeemably awful that he couldn't have stayed on the show any longer, and so his quick zombification followed by death-by-pick-axe at the hands of his wife was more than necessary.
2. Milton Mamet
Some of the most hated characters on The Walking Dead sort of stumbled into being awful. Either from poor character development, performances, or just not having much to do, audiences can cook up a negative association with everything from core cast members to guest appearances. Then there's Milton Mamet, who was simply a straight-up d*ck from the moment he first showed up on screen to the moment he was gloriously slaughtered. Now far be it from anyone to condone the insane actions of The Governor, but you can't really blame him (and Andrea!) from doing in Milton. The guy was a class act, in the worst possible way. He's a slimy little guy who does experiments on walkers, which are only second in inhumanity to all those heads in jars his boss kept. Milton had a smug look about him whenever he was on screen, and whenever he did, you just wanted him to stop. Nobody wanted him to be happy. He didn't deserve it. He was a nasty little weasel, the Grima Wormtongue of The Walking Dead, sycophantic and conniving and ooo doesn't he just make your blood boil still?
1. Dale Horvath
Ah, Dale. How do people hate thee? Let us count the ways. For some the elder statesman was not only a staple of the original group of survivors in the show, but the very heart and soul of that group. Others would suggest that he was a nosy bugger who couldn't help but interfere in everyone's affairs, not matter how welcome his contributions were, which came to a fever pitch when he emotionally blackmailed Andrea out of killing herself. From that season one finale it was only downhill from there for the supposed moral compass who spent most of his time sh*t stirring, eavesdropping and generally making a nuisance of himself whilst the rest of the group were trying not to be devoured by flesh-eating undead hordes, with his gormless face only adding to the desire most of the audience felt to punch him. Very hard. So hard that, perhaps, he might tumble off the top of his ever-present RV and break his neck. Or at least to knock that stupid hat off of his head. Urgh, that hat. Dale was nothing more than a roadblock, a plot device the writers would employ every so often if things were going too swimmingly in the group. Or sometimes, paradoxically, when the warring factions were managing to built up to an interesting conflict, which is another moment that apparently called for a Hovarth special of spreading gossip and acting like he was the most important person in the group. A moral compass? Maybe. But in the world of The Walking Dead, when all past rules and laws have been thrown out, you don't need a moral compass. You need one of those pointy one you use to draw circles. And to stab Dale with it.