10 Worst Star Trek Moments In 2024
Which Star Trek Moments failed more than the hyperspace physics test this year?
Thank the god of the Edo or otherwise for small blessings (and dressings). There have been no Very Short Treks this year. The animated line must be drawn here. This far, no further fart jokes. On the whole, 2024 has been another great year for Star Trek content (see our upcoming 'Greatest Moments…' list for that). However, like the assimilation policy of the Borg, there's always room for improvement.
History might judge 2024 as the Age of Endings. Never before have two Star Trek series had their finale in the same year. Star Trek: Discovery aired its final episode in May. Star Trek: Lower Decks will do the same in December. Sadly, with no news looking more and more like bad news for Star Trek: Prodigy, that number might also be three.
From ending to never-ending, we had lengthy real-world, high-stakes mergers this year. We were also tantalised by a fantasy coupling with another franchise that may not come to fruition. Elsewhere, we were more than just teased. We were completely spoilt by spoilers.
And in the end, if we are finding fault, it's only because we're having so much fun. As The Doctor once said to 7 of 9, "This journey certainly hasn't lacked excitement. I can't complain about being bored". Bad for Star Trek isn't the worst thing in the world!
10. Five Is An Odd Caterpillar
Star Trek: Discovery's cancellation was last year's news — Star Trek: Enterprise (+1) all over again. This year saw its fifth and final season hit the upload. Caught off-guard as much as the rest of us by the premature end, producers and actors had hurried to wrap up with a coda to Life, Itself. It wasn't These Are the Voyages…, far from it, but it was over.
As on Ferenginar, when it rains, it pours. On 12 April came the announcement that Star Trek: Lower Decks would also be airing its final episode this year. "Five seasons of any series these days seems like a miracle," noted Mike McMahan and Alex Kurtzman in their message to the fans. With the way of the streaming world, and everything over at Paramount, we'd be lucky to ever get back to seven.
Lower Decks might yet beat the odds with a movie, in live-action, or by finding a home elsewhere. At least 'end' seems to be a partial synonym for 'metamorphosis'. One series simply mutates into another, like Star Trek: Starfleet Academy and the Tawny Newsome/Justin Simien comedy spin-off. In any case, great news for the new is still a shame for those of us who weren't done admiring the caterpillar.
9. Epiphanies Interrupted
The end of Star Trek: Discovery had some unintended side effects. As a doctor, Culber should have at least been used to those. His season five arc was arguably ill-handled in the first place. It was clearly destined for more exploration. Culber's epiphany interrupted post-Jinaal was emblematic of a series cancelled before its time.
Like others around him, Hugh wasn't the only one left hanging on the edge of something more by the end of Life, Itself. Husband Stamets had the spore drive pulled from beneath him in favour of pathway. He didn't even get to play around with the Progenitors. Speaking of marriages, we did get to witness one wedding, but what happened next for the newlyweds? We might never know.
That's not to forget Kovich, newly revealed as Daniels all along. And Moll, sorry L'ak! There was the Coda for Burnham and Booker, but a lot had to be skipped in between. Wilson Cruz couldn't be there in person for the epilogue. Fully understandable, but a little uncanny.
Some of those who already can, will teach, at Starfleet Academy. Tilly, Vance, and Reno are confirmed to re-appear (to teach or otherwise). As for the rest, whatever grander realisations were around the corner might be lost to us. In Culber's case, perhaps Jinaal decided to stick around for more than just subspace resonance frequencies. You certainly have the makings of one hell of a professor. Just sayin'! Maybe the interruption is merely a sabbatical.
8. World Ampersand Day
8th September is World Ampersand Day, honouring that curious little character you'll probably find above the 7, if you have a QWERTY keyboard. 8th September also happens to be Star Trek Day, marking the date of the US premiere of The Man Trap in 1966.
Star Trek Day was only given Paramount officialdom in 2020. Since then, it has typically been celebrated with pomp (pandemic permitting), reveals, teasers, tributes, livestreams, and charitable efforts via the #StarTrekUnitedGives campaign. This year, the ampersand was more directly on display. Like an improv. comic seeking a reply, we were left asking, 'Yes, and…?'
Laudable but lacklustre, 2024's "Take the Chair, Make an Impact" was essentially left up to the fans. "What would I do if I were setting the course to the future?" we were asked. Probably plan this day with a little more effort! Star Trek: Prodigy was also largely ignored (again), so the writers had a pizza party instead!
If you were anywhere near Chicago on 8th September, you could actually sit in a captain's chair, which at least looked like the real OG Enterprise thing. Those set-up in Berlin and Vancouver were promoted as being "crafted from sustainable materials". That, however, was a woefully fancy way of saying 'cardboard'!! Don't worry, you could still get a "limited edition enamel pin".
And, if anyone remembers what happened on First Contact Day this year, send your answers on a postcard to that place in Montana!
7. The Skydance Dance
Will they, won't they? Will they, won't they? The paso doble between Paramount Global and Skydance Media this year was definitely not tens across the board from the judges. The boards of directors weren't giving high marks either at times. And we, well, we were just bored.
Talks were had, deals were made, terms agreed upon, reneged upon, renegotiated. Bob Bakish, CEO of Paramount Global stepped down. Rival bidders like Warner Bros. Discovery, Apollo Global Management, and Sony Pictures dropped in and out of the race. Paramount and Skydance have now settled on a definitive agreement to merge, although we've heard that before. From the press release, dated 7 July 2024, atop the starry mountain itself:
Ellison Family and RedBird Capital Partners to invest over $8 billion in New Paramount and to acquire National Amusements, Inc.
It's not over until the two have shared warp fields. Even then, it's still a bumpy ride. The 45-day "go-shop" period in the agreement that allowed Paramount to seek out other offers is over, but the Skydance deal is not expected to close, if it does, until sometime during the first six months of 2025.
It's worth noting that Star Trek is not mentioned once in Paramount's July press release. Star Wars is mentioned twice! Nevertheless, Skydance has a vested interest in Trek, having co-produced Star Trek Into Darkness and Star Trek Beyond. That's not to forget the ever-elusive Star Trek 4.
6. Time Bugs For All
If you barge your way onto the bridge from the future, you'd better have a damn good explanation. Chakotay did in Shattered and was promptly arrested. In Face the Strange, Captain Burnham had to fight her former self before she could step back on and off the turbolift. Unlike Captain Janeway, it didn't take much to convince Airiam, back from the not-yet-dead, to play along. The truth of her impending demise was inexplicably easier to believe than a good old-fashioned lie.
That Krenim chronophage has been buggy for everyone. 'Face the Strange' might as well be the leitmotif of this entire year. The episode itself feels like it aired ages ago. Cancelled after the fact, Star Trek: Discovery's fifth and final season was, at times, impossibly prescient. Then, there were those other faces missing, not knowing that time was running out.
After Mirrors, Commanders Owosekun and Detmer took the very long way round to Fed HQ storage with the ISS Enterprise. As showrunner Michelle Paradise noted on Twitter in May, both Oyin Oladejo and Emily Coutts "had other projects during that time so we got them when we could". Saru was also absent from several episodes of season five. As Doug Jones revealed to CinemaBlend's Mick Joest, he had "asked if there was a way to lessen the load" after season four so he could spend more time with his wife.
5. 'Snot Happening
Don't adjust your ocular implants, we've not reverted back to Bev and Riker in Worst Contact, the Very Short Trek. Snot was still the theme, however. The first episode of this year's new Doctor Who — Space Babies — was full of it. The Bogeyman was bogies. Very clever and very gross, Mr Davies! Before the sheer mavity of mucus kicked in, there was a direct mention of Star Trek from companion Ruby Sunday.
"We've got to visit them [i.e. the Star Trek lot] one day," the Doctor replied, implying that Trekverse and Whoniverse occupied some sort of similar space-time. We'd better keep throwing salt over our shoulder at the end of the universe for good luck. In spite of tantalising nods and whispered promises, the two franchises have yet to merge into anything of substance (snot or otherwise).
Going into the 'Intergalactic Friendship Panel: Star Trek X Doctor Who' at San Diego Comic-Con in July, we still had cause to get our hopes up. We shouldn't have. The conversation between Russel T. and Alex Kurtzman was lovely — very amicable, in fact. What it wasn't was the crossover news we were looking for, but a limited-time, free-to-play mobile video game event spanning Star Trek: Lower Decks — The Badgey Directive and Doctor Who: Lost in Time. Allons-y, Alons-no.
4. Una All Over Again
*Warning! Spoiler alert for this and the next entry*
Paramount has a curious history of releasing clips for Star Trek: Strange New Worlds which tell us more than we really should, or should want, to know. The official trailer for season two showed Una in uniform on the bridge and on Krulmuth-B, that is to say, not in prison. The first look clip for season three featured a healthy, happy (ish) La'an, that is to say, not gorged on by Gorn.
Naturally, there's a lot of pressure to keep fans interested. The wait between seasons has also been longer than normal this time. However, and not to phaser ourselves in the foot, or look a gift replicator in the gel pack, are we so avid for content that we have to have the plot plundered in advance? Is patience just a virtue to be scrolled through?
In its haste, Paramount then re-offended at New York Comic Con. The second season of Strange New Worlds had ended on a cliffhanger, the apparent indecision of Captain Pike faced with a Cornelian dilemma. Should he stay to rescue his crew, or follow orders and go?
In the NYCC exclusive clip, we found out what Pike did immediately next after the end of Hegemony. It didn't give the whole Gorn game away, and it was certainly thrilling. Just now, like a Gorn hatching from its parasitic egg, the tension has been broken from the start.
3. Real McCoys
For all of its post-Gorn spoilers, the first look clip for Strange New Worlds season three was already an odd choice to release in advance. Now, we must address the Vulcans in the room. The effects of the Kerkhovian serum were funny at first as the transformations kicked in. Carol Kane's Pelia was as hilarious as we've come to expect. Unlike the serum, however, the joke soon wore pretty thin.
Let's all bully Spock like in the 'good old days' that haven't happened yet! Down the line, Doctor McCoy would get away with insulting the half-Vulcan, half-human every which way to 40 Eridani A. In the first look clip, the newly 'real' deals had barely stood up from toes to "ears […] so pointy" than they were laying on the verbal lashings (and the lirpa).
With Pike, Uhura, Chapel, and La'an fully Vulcanised — hair like hardened rubber — the Spock-bashing came thick and fast:
Spock is only half Vulcan, whereas the four of us… Are fully Vulcan.
Oh, go hug a wild Sehlat! Of course, the point was, we'd hope, to point it out — the bullying and xenophobia, that is. Ultimately, it might be wrong to glaze over that unfortunate fact from The Original Series.
It's also already par for the course being set in Strange New Worlds. In season two, for example, Spock was pulled apart by mother-in-law-to-be(-or-not), T'Pril, for not being Vulcan enough. When it came to getting crap from his transformed crewmates, though, 4.5 from 0.5 was exactly 9 times too much.
2. Leaving A Legacy
The buzz that followed The Next Generation's The Last Generation was electric. Fans clamoured for a continuation on the Enterprise-G in the form of Star Trek: Legacy. Well over a year later, that buzz has become a little electro-static (although that might just be the carpet). The lack of Legacy featured on 2023's version of this list. Back on it in 2024, the absence is turning into an unfortunate yearly tradition.
The concept hasn't lost its appeal amongst the cast of Star Trek: Picard. In October this year, LeVar Burton told TV Line that they were "just as interested in the idea of Legacy as when Picard was just airing". At Spacecon 2024 (viaTrekMovie), Jeri Ryan surprised us all by revealing that she had turned down a pitch for a "Captain Seven show," in part because it wasn't Legacy. "Never say never," she added.
At the same event, Michelle Hurd noted that, "Jeri and I both want Legacy so badly". Earlier this year, the "Spock dead" Todd Stashwick told TrekMovie that he was "hopeful because [he] would love to keep telling stories".
In the TV Line interview, Burton did admit that Legacy was unlikely whilst focus was elsewhere on other shows in the franchise. Meanwhile, as production lingers for Star Trek: Starfleet Academy, OTOY have demonstrated how misguided it was to pass up on a Legacy project. 765874: Unification has now surpassed 3,500,000 views on YouTube, without Paramount's marketing machine behind it.
Behind the scenes, the creatives — like Terry Matalas and Dave Blass — have also moved on to other projects. They'd surely return in a Bolian hearts' beat. After all, we'd rather like to switch Legacy to 'Greatest Moments…' next year!
1. How Many Planes Does It Take (Admiral)?
"Don’t be eejits, here!" Kate Mulgrew noted to CinemaBlend's Mick Joest at San Diego Comic-Con in July. That was her broad, but decidedly accurate, summary of the banner flown over the Netflix offices in Los Angeles in August 2023. No fools the first time, the streaming giant picked up Star Trek: Prodigy for season two.
Yet, in spite of everyone's best efforts — a second plane in particular — and one of the best outings of contemporary Star Trek, we're still suffering the lack of season three news un-gladly. Nothing from Netflix this time. More fool them! Does the Admiral need to send in a whole fleet of light aircraft followed by a squadron of shuttles?
"It is unquestionably superior," Mulgrew went on to add to Joest. You'd have a hard time convincing us otherwise. Critical and fan praise for Prodigy's second season was overwhelming. At time of writing, season two has 100% on the famous tomatometer, and 96% on the popcornmeter. Even its IMDB score never drops below 7.6, which is more than can be said for the second seasons of some other Star Trek shows.
Art is seemingly little more than an excuse for viewing figures. It has been like that for some time, but when everything is measured, the immeasurable is lost. How many planes will it really take? Infinite and none. All we can do now is hope — pie instead in the sky — that hope is not a foolish thing. We'll all need a lot of it in 2025, anyway!