11 Simple Fixes That Would Have Saved Marvel's Iron Fist
Iron Fist vs an immortal dragon? Yes please!
By now, most people will have made their way through Marvel's Iron Fist (or, seeing the reaction, decided not to bother). The dust from all those knocked down walls (which is about the only thing the Iron Fist is used for) has started to settle, and what's left behind is a bit of a mess.
Iron Fist has been the first major critical failure for the Netflix Marvel Universe, lambasted for everything from its decision to cast a white actor in the lead role to the terrible writing, and referred to as "laughably bad".
Since then, the people involved in the show have went on the defensive. Finn Jones blamed Donald Trump, the original creator of the character made some old-white-man-is-racist remarks, and the 'fan v critic' debate (long the defender of the DCEU) has came over to Marvel, despite the fact the two things are very much *not* exclusive.
Behind all this, though, is a semblance of a potentially solid show. After all, Daredevil, Jessica Jones, and Luke Cage were all hits, so why not Iron Fist? My review has already covered the things it did well and got wrong, but with a few relatively simple tweaks, it might not necessarily have been great, but it certainly could've avoided the disaster it's become.
11. Cut Out Most Of The Boardroom Drama
One of the problems with Iron Fist, especially in the earlier episodes, is just how much it invests in the boardroom struggles of Danny, the Meachums, and Rand Enterprises.
While it does bring Jeri Hogarth into the show, which is definitely welcome, it means that the plot - if you can call it that - is extremely boring and difficult to really care about.
Here we have this show, promised to be the most mystical of the bunch, and instead we're watching boardroom meeting after boardroom meeting, with an endless array of stock corporate types muttering about finances and how they can make themselves more money.
Cut a lot, if not all, of that out, and you can focus on telling a more interesting story.
10. Pick A Villain
One thing the Netflix Marvel shows have done very well, even better than most of the movies, is introduce an array of complex, charismatic, and terrifying villains.
Daredevil has Vincent D'onofrio's Wilson Fisk, Jessica Jones had David Tennant's Kilgrave, and Luke Cage had Mahershala Ali's Cornell Stokes. It's no surprise that Daredevil Season 2 was weaker without Fisk, or that Cage got worse after killing off Cottonmouth.
It's an area Iron Fist struggles with a lot. The main problem is that there's a lack of clear villain: it's Joy and Ward, then it's Gao, then Bakuto, then Harold - who's been twirling his moustache in the background all this time - then sets up Davos and Joy (with Gao back in the mix too) for the future).
The show would've been stronger had it picked a villain and stuck with it. There's no guarantee any of them would've been strong enough, but it would've given them a better chance to carry the main villain arc and develop across the course of the show. Based on performance Davos may have been the best suited, because Sacha Dhawan is excellent (but doesn't come into it early enough), but there's enough in David Wenham's performance to suggest he could've handled it too with some different material and a lot more focus, rather than just sitting around pretending not to be dead and killing people over ice cream.
9. Cut Back On The Hand
Yeah, ok, the Iron Fist is "the sworn enemy of the Hand" and all that jazz, but once again the MCU's resident evil ninja organisation make for incredibly dull viewing.
Despite the fact that they're an evil ninja death cult, there's very little personality to them, nor much interesting in their motivations. We constantly see them defeated en masse, the leaders are incredibly vague, and even though they're supposedly really powerful, they've essentially been turned into a drug cartel.
This might not be such an issue if they weren't such a big part of things, but the Iron Fist's existence is to fight against the Hand, and they dominate the latter half of the season. Having a different villain, or even just some different storylines, to take attention away from the Hand would've been welcome. As it is, they remain a major concern ahead of The Defenders.
8. Practice The Choreography
While the show's bigger failings come on a writing level, there's also a major problem with the action scenes, which are pretty laughable.
Even though this is about the martial artist of the MCU, the scenes that we see come off far worse than those in Daredevil (I certainly know which one I'd back in a fight), often far too slow moving, and absolutely horribly edited, with more cuts than Pop's Barbershop.
One of the reasons for that is that Danny Rand isn't in his costume, meaning it's harder to disguise the stuntman filling in for Finn Jones, a problem not shared by something like Daredevil.
So, one fix would be to have him wear the costume, if you can find a way of doing it that isn't overly goofy (and to be honest, there's an argument this show could benefit from leaning into that aspect more). However, an even easier fix would be to have Finn Jones actually practice the choreography ahead of time, with the show's action issues explained in this quote from the actor (via Metro):
"But really, I was learning the fight scenes 15 minutes before we actually shot them because the schedule was so tight. So 15 minutes before the stunt director would talk me through the choreography and I’d just jump straight into it."
Unfortunately, you can really tell.
7. Don't Have Colleen Fall In Love With Danny
Colleen Wing is one of Iron Fist's saving graces, the best of the show's characters with an excellent performance from Jessica Henwick, proving bad Game of Thrones actors can convince in the MCU.
She's strong, brave, more convincing in the action department, has relatable struggles while everyone else is complaining about their billion dollar company, and generally a badass.
And yet, even she can't escape the show's writing issues. Making her a member of the Hand could've been an effective twist (even if it wouldn't make the group too much more interesting overall), but the show undercuts it by having her turn against her 'family' for Danny, a man she couldn't stand a few episodes ago. As well as this, she readily goes along with all of his ideas, despite the fact they make little sense.
She's an excellent supporting character, and would've made an even better lead, but by having her become Danny's love interest and go along with whatever he wants, it completely undermines her character.
6. Introduce Davos Earlier
Another of the show's stronger characters is Davos, Danny's friend from K'un-Lun who witnessed him become the Iron Fist.
He arrives to try and convince Danny to return to K'un-Lun, because he's shirking his duties, helps him fight the Hand, tries pizza for the first time and doesn't hate it, and then makes a big heel at the end.
Ok, so it's essentially the same arc as Mordo in Doctor Strange (but with added cheese), yet thanks to the performance of Sacha Dhawan and the lacklustre writing of Danny, it still manages to stand out, even if it is a little rushed.
He doesn't appear until episode 9, by which time the chance for him to develop and have a major impact is diminished. They could've brought him in a lot earlier, which in turn would've helped sell some inner conflict within Danny about his role as the Iron Fist (not something it bothers with too much until the end), painted an interesting contrast between the duo, and better established the animosity between them.
5. Go To K'un-Lun
The show leans very heavily on a 'tell, don't show' method of storytelling, which leads to a number of problems, the biggest of which is the fact that we hardly ever go the mystical city of K'un-Lun.
We get a couple of establishing shots of the place, we see it at the very end of Danny's trial (but really that could be anywhere), and then by the end of the season it's disappeared, leaving us with a literal cliffhanger.
K'un-Lun is one of the Seven Cities of Heaven, and it's where Danny went missing, grew up, and became the Iron Fist. It's an intrinsic part of the Iron Fist character, and it should've been an intrinsic part of this show too. We hear about the place's importance, yet it's hard to buy that when we never actually see it.
If the show wanted to convince us of the Iron Fist's status and power, make itself more diverse, help us understand its lead character, and explore the mystical side of things, then actually spending time in K'un-Lun was an easy way to achieve that.
4. Show The Trial
Much like not showing much of K'un-Lun, the show definitely suffers by telling us about Danny's trial to become the Iron Fist, and yet not putting any of the darn thing on the bloody screen.
In order to become the Iron Fist, first Danny has to prove himself as a great student, but more than that he has to take on Shou-Lao the Undying, or in other words he has to fight against an immortal dragon.
After defeating Shou-Lao, which includes him getting the dragon 'tattoo' on his chest, he enters the cave the dragon was guarding, and plunges his hand into the brazier containing Shou-Lao's molten heart that had been ripped from his body, thus becoming the Iron Fist. Sure, it might've cost a lot of money to do the dragon justice, but just imagine how great that would've been to see.
3. Actually Be About *Something*
As I've covered already, the writing is the series' biggest flaw, and within that there's an issue with the fact that there's very little actually happening in terms of plot. Going further still, the series finds itself without anything to say, which is disappointing given a) it's using a well-worn story (see: Batman Begins, Doctor Strange, Arrow etc), and b) the other Netflix Marvel shows have provided some kind of stronger message or thematic grounding.
Daredevil tackles its hero's struggle with how far he can go to protect Hell's Kitchen, and occasionally wrestles with his faith; Jessica Jones takes on PTSD, sexual abuse, and addiction, and overcoming your demons; Luke Cage what it means to be a black superhero. As well that each, each have compelling plots with real drive and purpose.
Both are sorely lacking from Iron Fist, which sees rich white people fighting over a billion dollar company (it hints at Danny wanting to use that money for good, but never really gets into it), and then the titular Iron Fist largely shirking his duties as such, but even that it doesn't examine too much, despite the fact it could've made for an interesting conflict.
There's definitely potential there for stronger, more relevant societal themes to be explored and for the show to have an interesting plot about its hero's journey and what it all means, yet the writers never get into it. They had to get Iron Fist on screen to get to The Defenders, and apparently thought that was enough.
2. Fewer Episodes
Okay, so this one is perhaps the most implausible, because it's how the Netflix model works and was the plan for these shows from the very start, with only The Defenders getting a shorter run (8 episodes).
I'd say all the Netflix Marvel shows could do with being shorter, either in terms of the number of episodes in a season or how long each episode is, because 13 hours is a lot for these shows. Daredevil Season 2 and Luke Cage both suffered from the problem, and it's even more prevalent than ever before in Iron Fist, which stretches out such little story and character development over its 13 hour-long episodes.
Had it been shorter, with fewer episodes or shorter ones, then there'd definitely be a better pace to things, the story wouldn't feel quite as thin, and the series would feel tighter as a whole.
1. Cast Lewis Tan
Even putting aside the issue of this being a problematic white saviour narrative, there's a compelling case to be made for having Danny Rand portrayed as an Asian-American character.
Yes, it does take care of some of those issues anyway, but it also leads to a more diverse Netflix Marvel Universe (there'd be something interesting and rather unique in seeing a team of heroes such as The Defenders made up of a a white actor, a white actress, a black actor, and an actor of Asian descent).
Moreover, though, you could do more with the character if he was Asian-American, exploring what it means for him to feel like an outsider in K'un-Lun, and/or trying to connect with his parents or grandparents' homeland (and even that ignores Asia being a huge and varied continent) and then coming home to America after 15 years, where again he could seem/feel like an outsider. It could tackle the notion of stereotypes, and indeed have a relevancy to the current political and societal climate.
Continuing that thread further, Marvel and Netflix even had the right actor in front of them. Lewis Tan (who comes from Manchester, with a father of Singaporean descent) steals the show as Drunken Master Zhou Cheng, once again putting the actor of Asian descent into bad guy martial artist role.
Tan, however, initially auditioned for the role of Danny Rand, and based on his performance it's very difficult to understand how he didn't get the part. Ignore stereotyping and appropriation, Tan would've solved a major problem with Finn Jones' iteration of the character: the he's an absolute charisma vacuum. He wouldn't improve the writing, but he would make for a far more likeable and charismatic hero, not to mention instantly improve the fight scenes because he's obviously brilliant in that department. The show would still have flaws, but it'd be far more interesting to watch.
How would you improve Iron Fist? Do you think it needs fixing at all? Share your thoughts down in the comments.